We have always loved going to Prime Butcher in Windham -- it's one of our go-to spots, especially…read moresince my husband is a total carnivore and appreciates great quality meat. Last week, for the first time ever, we ended up with a steak that just wasn't up to their usual standard. Honestly, it's so rare for them that we didn't think much of it, but my husband stopped in today and mentioned it. What happened next is exactly why we keep going back. They didn't just acknowledge it -- they went above and beyond. They replaced it with a free NY strip steak, and on top of that gave us Prime Butcher playing cards and a big bottle of their "Everything" seasoning. Completely unexpected and absolutely appreciated. That kind of customer service is hard to find these days. They didn't have to do any of that, but they did -- and it speaks volumes about who they are. The manager and staff are always smiling, cracking jokes, and just genuinely good, down-to-earth people. And the meat? Always beyond delicious -- you won't find better anywhere else. We'll definitely continue to be regulars. If you haven't been yet, you're missing out.

Everyone was so pleasant and knowledgeable. Everything we tried was absolutely delicious. Can't…read morewait to go back! We'll definitely become regulars!

Pricey but it's a Butcher you should expect to pay for quality. Lamb tips always great not always…read moreavailable but I get it. I'm doing review as I've been a loyal reward member & frequent customer & had weird experience today. Asked for Rib Roast, bone in, guy went to see if the "have any" 10 mins later another (Mgr?) comes out; " how big a roast...?" Two ribs..." "I can't do that I'd have to open a large cut etc". Wow they didn't want to sell me a $200 roast they have on hand? Very weird. I'll cash my "Loyalty Member" points/credits & will be done. I understand holidays are upon us but I've spent THOUSAND at this place each year since open...NOPE I'll drive to be a "loyal customer". One out of five or 10 only due to location.

Grabbed some steak, twice baked potatoes, and stuffed mushrooms for dinner, last nights meal was…read moreexcellent! Also grabbed a chicken quesadilla from the lunch counter. Love going to this place, the staff has always been very friendly and helpful. The store itself is very well laid out, with a down home feel, things are easy to find and the choices are great.

Found this place by accident and stopped in for the first time this weekend. Just wanted to check…read moreit out and I was so surprised at the selection and how fresh everything looked. The staff was amazing, we only saw frozen burgers and asked if they had any fresh. They didn't however the immediately said they could make them right away and even offered to add seasoning which I absolutely said yes. We also got chili, cornbread and pulled pork. It was all AMAZING!!! So fresh and delicious. We will absolutely be back and recommend this place to everyone. I don't think I will ever buy meat at the grocery store again.

Wonderful meats, the staff are always helpful, and willing to go the extra mile. My favorite meat…read moreseller locally.

The best oven fried chicken! My family loved it!!…read moreTender chicken with a bread crumb coating that was perfection!

I love their steak and the server was so nice and it's not the first time that I've been here but…read moreevery time i come back they are so nice and the place is calm and nice to just enjoy the food and spending time together

Cock, beef and seafood is the best place to go for your seafood and beef. Everything is fresh and…read morethe service is perfect.

This place is excellent! The Ambience,The service, the food and definitely the drinksread more

Happy Sunday, I'm excited for our weekly meat run. Maine…read morelocal beef is amazing. The difference is so noticeable. I get the subs for lunch while we are there! You have to make Carls a weekly stop.

We decided to try this local butcher shop and deli since we've heard great things about it…read more We decided to try their sandwiches today but will be back to try their meat as it looked fresh and high quality. They also have a selection of ready to go meals and sides and beer. We ordered two of the cold sandwiches and they were both delicious. We also tried some of their smoked marrow bones for our dogs. Our dogs loved the bones. This place gets pretty busy so be prepared to wait. Otherwise, definitely worth the visit.

I had an excellent experience here! The server was attentive and prompt. I have three adult…read moregrandchildren that have dinner at Nana's every other Tuesday. This particular Tuesday I decided to treat all of us to a meal out at a restaurant that had recently been recommended, Tomahawk Tavern. Well, we were not disappointed. Two of us ordered steak tips, tender and tastey, my grandson had the special two for one price lobster rolls and my granddaughter buttermilk fried chicken sandwich. We were all happy with our choices and have returned several times since then.

What an amazing place this is. Great food and the best service with the nicest people…read more But please understand the people who work there are actual humans. If something is wrong let them know don't wine about it in sites like this. Restaurants would be happy to make up for it. Also don't complain when you have to wait to be sat even if you see an empty table. If know one is sitting there that section might be closed.

From SoCal and needed supplies not available in other grocery stores. I would rate this an equal to…read moremany San Diego carnicerias.

Love this place. They have pastries, a meat counter, hot sauces, produce, candy, and tortillas all…read moretraditional to Mexico. The prices are reasonable and the people are friendly. Can't recommend highly enough

Amazing cuts. Amazing sandwiches. Amazing staff. The owners are also as awesome as their…read moresandwiches. I hate that my new job is too far to come for lunch as often as I would like.

I agree with an early review that this is a social media creation. Like some NYC club, they want…read morethat line for the hype as opposed to hiring more staff on Saturdays and actually efficiently moving the line. And maybe reviewing this is like reviewing a Target ... i.e. who cares. Or maybe it's jealousy because I got there on a Saturday morning and waited in ridiculous line. After 45 minutes, I had moved 1.5 car lengths with still 50 people in front of me. I guess if you are a roast beef guru, it's for you. Funny thing, I didn't even want roast beef! I finally went across the street to Brothers and had an excellent tuna sandwich.

Love love this place! From the homemade meals to the shop , where you can get wine, soaps, gifts,…read morealmost anything. Absolutely love it here. My only request would be to be open at least ONE night during the week past 6pm! So those of us with crazy hours and make it in during the week past that time. I love to shop here and also wish they had some sort of loyalty program!!

Everything is fresh and yummy the service is impeccable, kind friendly, and helpful with questionsread more