Oh boy, this place has potential to be really great, and I really hope it makes the necessary tweaks to get there. So close!
Let's talk about: The Good, The Bad and The Beautiful.
The Good. Location, Location, Location! Situated directly on the water at a marina in Key Largo surrounded by hotels, condos and charter boats coming in and out, the views are gorgeous and the foot traffic is plentiful.
Also, the food and drinks. Mostly. I had a Killer Colada, which was strong and tasty and the fruit garnish (pineapple, orange and cherry) were fresh and delicious as well -- it matters! For dinner we shared the Island Snapper, which looked beautiful on the plate and tasted even better. The only downside here was that, at $32, the portion could have been a tad more generous. Finally, we split the key lime pie, which we make a habit to always order in South Florida in search of the best and let's just say this one was . . . unique? It came topped with an impressive layer of meringue. Okay, I like meringue. But it looked better than it tasted. And a good deal of compote came on the plate that I can only assume was blackberry by the number of seeds it contained. It was not good. Neither tart nor sweet. Just not a good flavor and the seeds were off putting with the pie. The crust, normally my favorite part, had none of the buttery goodness of a graham cracker crust. It, along with the pie filling itself, lacked flavor. Disappointing. But not "Bad" bad. My husband ate all of it. To each his own.
Now for the truly Bad. After being sat initially by the hostess, we were completely ignored for about 15 minutes even though a half dozen servers milled about at the bar nearby. I should note that they weren't that busy yet. When a manager came by to ask if everything was going well I mentioned how long we'd been sitting with no one helping us yet. He was not happy and went to get a server. From that point on, service was fine, but they never offered anything extra to compensate for the inconvenience, which would have gone a long way. And the manager never came back either.
Last but not least -- the Beautiful. Not only the views but the space. It was much nicer than expected as far as the outside bar area and the indoor space was really nice also. However, it was completely empty except for one small group. Even the restrooms were new and very nice! Not a soul at the bar or in any of the indoor booths. And maybe 20-25 people outside on a holiday weekend in season. What a shame.
One last note, the live entertainment, a man singing and playing guitar in the outdoor bar area, was very good. Too bad most patrons were watching the NFL playoff game on one of the many TVs around the bar. He was largely ignored.
All in all, I would definitely return despite the service lapse, because the ambiance and views were that good. I just won't go if I'm in a hurry. I hope they do well because they have too much going for them for it to go to waste. read more