The Mussels were our favorite appetizer. The food was delicious. Modesto and Diana made the experience enjoyable with their warming presence. The environment felt classy in a comforting, casual manner. read more

Ive been absolutely obsessed with finding the best oysters happy hour in town and downing so many dozens of oysters in the process... I wouldn't have done my neighborhood justice if I didn't pay this beautiful restaurant a visit. I walked in here on a cold and quaint Monday night after a really long and exhausting day at work for my favorite treat. I got situated at the bar and ordered two dozen oysters on the half shell. The oysters came our looking phenomenal with a presentation that made me want to dig right in. Everything about these oysters are perfection. They are fresh, shucked with care so they retain their brine, they are a good size and taste phenomenal. The accompaniments on the platter are amazing. Cocktail sauce with freshly grated horseradish, a cucumber hot sauce that adds both heat and texture, a fat, generous wedge of lemon cut with Max juiciness in mind. This is one of the best oyster happy hours in Brooklyn by a mile and I say this with absolutely no exaggeration! The interior of this restaurant is also so beautiful with soft dim lighting and a clean inviting aesthetic. It's perfect for a cozy date night, intimate dinner or just a casual dinner with a little bit of oomph. Prices on most items are very reasonable, but the happy hour menu between 5-7 PM is an absolute steal! I deeply enjoyed chatting with my bartender Diego who is part owner of the establishment and learning how they procure their catch and personally taste the oysters they serve. You can just tell how much thought and care him and his partner pour in to running a beautiful neighborhood restaurant like this. If you are in park slope, this is the spot you absolutely have to step into. I can't wait to be back for more oysters and to try other things off their menu! 10/10 read more

See all

Me and mom celebrated Mothers Day today! I chose the restaurant because I was there 2 years ago on my birthday in September! Before we ordered the Mother's Day special, I specifically asked the waitress if she would like her tip in cash and she said of course! The special was $95/person plus a 20% TIP ($38) which was $228! See photo below! We ordered some other items and the waitress gave me my bill for $252.86. We then drove 10 blocks to Chase to get out cash for her. I then noticed that I was charged $298.86. It was the $252.86 plus a TIP of $45.20! I immediately returned to discuss the discrepancies. The tip that was supposed to be $38 was now $45.20! The waitress then said she would credit my account. My question was how did this happen! All three waitresses stated it was not them and that the machine did this! How was this possible? Not one of them took responsibility for the discrepancies! Had I not looked at my bank statement then I would never have known that I would be tipping her twice! I then decided to leave to explain to my mom! Then the short Indian (I think) than sarcastically stated "Oh so now you're not going to tip us" Really! I drove 10 blocks and I NEVER ONCE STATED THAT I WAS NOT GOING TO TIP HER! I merely was going to let my mom know what happened and then TIP her! Note* I was going to give her a $100 cash TIP! Had she given me the REAL receipt with the $45 TIP then I would have given her $50 CASH but since she only produced the REAL receipt after I came back (how ironic) and told her she charged the wrong amount, she would have received $100 TIP. But since the short Indian waitress made that slick remark, she did not receive anything! After the disrespect and blaming the machine and giving me a fake receipt? I decided to leave! If this is how you conduct business then you just lost a great customer! PS! The food was great! read more

See all

A great dinner at Siren BK! We ordered two dozen oysters and they were incredibly fresh and honestly some of the best I've had in Brooklyn. The prices for the oysters and the cocktails were surprisingly good, especially for the quality. We also tried the baby lamb chops, Caesar salad, goat cheese salad, braised beef, lobster roll, branzino, and Brussels sprouts. Everything came out well-seasoned and cooked perfectly. The branzino and lamb chops were standouts. Drinks were great too--Hugo Spritz, French 76, strawberry margaritas all balanced and not overly sweet. Overall, delicious food, fresh oysters at a great price, solid cocktails, and good service. Definitely worth a visit! The highlight were the apps for sure . I liked their menu from the summertime in 2024 when they had steak . read more

See all

They have really good drinks here! I had a slightly dirty martini (was actually slightly dirty and smooth), a hibiscus margarita, the south slope gimlet, and the winter in Brooklyn ! All the drinks were great. We had some oysters from the oyster special. They were decently shucked, but a little bland. Fresh and very large but not much flavor. The mignonette was good. We will have to come back and try some of the food -not oysters! read more

The food did not disappoint but I tried the 1/2 chicken and it was juicy and flavorful. It did take a bit of time for the dish to come out but my bartender was on top of things. The chicken did have a gravy which had poured on my chicken but I do know the chicken was juicy before hand. I have to say the space is opened and inviting but the staff really make the difference. My Barton's me the best Negorini that I have had in a really long time! read more

Siren Restaurant & Bar - Chi Half Roasted Chicken - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

came for happy hour but only had 15 mins left of it so we made the best out of it. The oysters were HH pricing and you need to order a min of a dozen. The hot apps we ordered were decent, not to really rave about. Our espresso martini was good. Only complaint was that the place was really hot and we asked to be moved, the waitress said she'll take a look but never got back to us. Had a small meal but sweated most the meal. read more

See all

Had a nice dinner here- everything was fresh and tasty. The oysters were great, and we also enjoyed mushroom masala, Caesar salad, mussels, and lobster bisque soup. Drinks were really good too. Overall, a solid spot for seafood with good flavors. Friendly service! read more

See all

I'm back! Great 4 course prix fix for $65 during the week. It was too much food for me, so I took left overs home. Reheats very well. Great happy hour! Cocktails n $1.50 oysters. Mon-thurs till 7pm and Friday till 6pm. I love the French 75 cocktail. Service is great. read more

See all

We went to Siren for our anniversary after we discovered the restaurant we had originally chosen was closed. We were so glad we did! The goat cheese salad was excellent. Fresh and very tasty with the cherries and pecans. The Mushroom Marsala was rich and delicious and not overly creamy. The linguine and clams was cooked perfectly and flavored with garlic and herbs. The ginger crème brûlée was an excellent way to end the meal. We were pleasantly surprised when the waiter told us dessert was on the house because we were celebrating our anniversary. There were plenty of other things on the menu we would like to try; we will be back. read more

Small hip / sheek place with delicious food options at a decent price for park slope & delicious drinks! Can't forget the Great Vibes!!! The owner and his family are great hosts and really make you feel valued as a guest / customer! We celebrated a birthday and they prepared a special menu with a pre-chosen pre-fix menu - it was very cute, thoughtful and well put together, as well as on really good quality paper! So much so I had to mention it haha Give it a try! You won't regret it! read more

See all

I came in late. But it wasn't good. The lobster bisque was an onion soup. I've never had crunchy veggies, onions and peppers in lobster bisque without lobster. The fries and the Brussels were great. The lobster and shrimp roll tasted like they burned it on the grill but it wasn't grilled. Like the gravy that burns at the bottom of the pot. I paid $136 dollars with tip for two shots, bisque, lobster roll, and Brussels sprouts. It was not worth it. Great ambience! Thank goodness for the kind bartender that got me food last minute. I appreciate the kindness. I wish I had just ordered drinks like the waitress said in the beginning. She said the kitchen is closed. I should have taken the hint. I have great pictures! You would have thought it was Michelin Star food. I don't mind paying for good food. Unfortunately, this was not. read more

See all

Not bad, but nothing unique or spectacular! Pricy. First, I think they are very overpriced for the neighborhood, type of food, and service they offer. The whole "package" did not match the prices. Second, we were the only table on Sunday evening; I hope that's only the case for that particular Sunday (and no, that was not a holiday). FOOD We came to this spot for oysters. The oysters were okay, but half of the oyster's menu was unavailable, and the ones we tried were very salty (but that's not the restaurant's fault). The oysters were overpriced for the neighborhood. If I remember correctly, the price per oyster starts at $3,75... That's Manhattan's rate, not Brooklyn's, or you need to be a spectacular place in BK for that rate, where you pay for the location, the view, or/and how popular the place is. I was disappointed with Hamachi. The price was way too high for what it was! At least, what I have seen in other places was much better. The octopus was well made and tasted delicious, and the squid ink humus was fantastic! We loved it. The lobster roll was okay, but again, nothing outstanding that could have a wow feeling. SERVICE There is not much service to value. The one hiccup we had was that the waitresses asked us if we were Russians (none of us are), which was disturbing, given the political situation. And it was early in the evening when we just got seated. I personally have no reservations about that, but some people at the table got a bit awkward. One other thing: the waitress was also a bartender, and she messed up tequila with Mezcal. Other than that, it was okay. However, I cannot properly value service here because there is not much to value or be objective about. AMBIENCE Lovely and pleasant! But it was empty! We were the only table on Sunday night. They have a beautiful bar setting, and for a glass of wine with oysters, you will surely enjoy your night. I found this place somewhat good, but I did not have a spectacular experience. They tried to do well, and you can see attention in their dishes, but somehow, they did not get it 100% right! Maybe that was an empty night on Sunday, and that did not allow us to see the full potential of the place read more

See all

I was excited to try this place, but unfortunately it was extremely underwhelming. They call themselves an oyster bar, but only had 1 type of oyster available and they were not very good. The pasta with clams was also a miss because it lacked flavor and the sauce was watery. We also got a very small side of shoe string fries for $12. The only thing that was good was the mezcal watermelon margarita. I wish I could say more positive things, but our whole party was disappointed. read more

They cancelled our Christmas Eve dinner, reserved weeks in advance, with no explanation, the morning of Christmas Eve! Left us scrambling to find an alternative when everything was long booked. They also promised a voucher which hasn't arrived. I see others have also experienced cancelled reservations. I don't think I'd trust them in the future. read more

I can't say anything bad about this place . I was greeted with a smile - service was excellent, the ambiance was extremely date worthy . And the food was good ! I came for oysters (so we ordered twice ! Lol) but I also ordered the arancini and the lobster ravioli. Both needed salt but the flavors were there ! I also enjoyed their take on an old fashioned called the renaissance fashion. Over all I have no complaints and I cant wait to go back ! read more

See all

This team has earned my trust with their consistent quality. The plates are well-filled and the servers are helpful. The team provides good help with warmth. This restaurant creates a notable environment. I genuinely enjoyed this place and will definitely be back! read more

Absolutely perfect spot for drinks and bites lets start with the fact that this is a PROPER OYSTER BAR - pencil and paper oyster order which you dont get much of in bklyn. the oyster selection was rich. pink moon, bad boys, beau soliels were favorites. we added caviar too which was power move. oh and the mignonette slapped. really good drinks and big mezcal selection got grilled octopus (delivious) and lamb chops (with mint chimmi) which were perfect plates along with the oysters. the space is nice and def vibes // very impressive all around . read more

Siren Restaurant & Bar - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Such a great new neighborhood gem! The host and staff were so welcoming and accommodating! And for a Friday night, we were able to sit without a reservation, but it was pretty packed! We started off with 12 oysters. They provide you with a list of oysters and pencil to mark which you would like. About 5 east coast and 4 west coast. For our meals, I ordered the lobster ravioli and my fiancé got the special which was a grilled tuna with lentils and cauliflower and a side of teriyaki sauce. Honestly they should add it to the menu because it was delicious!!! The sauce was good but it didn't even need it the tuna was grilled so well and perfectly medium rare. The lobster ravioli was solid, a bit mild in flavor, but overall pretty good. Cant wait to come back and try more of the menu! read more

See all

A nice spot for happy hour oysters but that's about it. The food was a little disappointing and the prices are not cheap. Came here for dinner with some girlfriends and it was pretty empty with one server. The AC was not working properly or maybe because we came when they just opened but it was sweltering inside. As the night progressed, it became crowded, the server was overwhelmed (still just him, poor guy), and the heat was pretty unbearable with the kitchen cooking at full blast. For happy hour oysters, it's 1.50 per but you have to order a minimum of a dozen. You get 1 option for happy hour. We had the petite and it was very fresh and sweet. The drinks seemed a bit weak. I had the French 75 and it was very light. Maybe because it's happy hour? They also have a 4-course pre-fixe menu for $65 but it's a table commitment. There were enough options for a table of 4 to pick different dish to try so we ended up doing the pre-fixe menu. Apps - Crabcakes, kale ceasar and octopus was good 2nd - mushroom tagliatelle, linguine clams (they ran out of lobster ravioli) The pasta was ok but pretty salty though. 3rd - Branzino, NY Strip, Mussels. Surprised that it was the steak that turned out to be the best one for the 3rd course. The branzino was ok but wish the skin was a bit more crispy instead of the soggy, rubbery version we got. The mussels were very fishy and we did not like it at all. That was the dish leftover. The steak was cooked medium rare (how we ordered it) and was season well and tender to the taste. Dessert - peach cobbler, bread pudding. - At this point we were all pretty full but the dessert was good. For a table of 4, our bill came out to be $100 per person. The service was very slow. Normally I wouldn't care but because it was so hot inside, we were practically eating and sweating at the same time for close to 3 hours. read more

This was a random spot that we picked because we were craving for oysters and this is the closest place we found in Brooklyn. The food was good and the service was great. Highly recommend to come in here for the oyster happy hour. We will definitely come back here often. read more

Went for the first time Monday night. Insanely delicious food! Beautiful atmosphere and super talented, friendly bar tender. The cocktails were perfection! This is my new go-to in the neighborhood! read more

This is a fantastic date spot, or even just a place to treat yourself to happy hour after work. The cocktail menu is literally the most delicious and creative, since pre-recession speakeasies of 2007. Every bite here is delicious, the staff are all kind and beautiful. My favorites things are oysters (especially for their west coast selection which is rare!) and the lamb chops might be addictive. I will be back. read more

Siren Restaurant & Bar - Special friend oyster appetizer - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I wanted to love this place, but the food just isn't that good, especially for the prices. The service (besides our waitresses very strong BO), ambiance, and drinks were all very good. Food was not. We got the chefs selection of oysters - they picked 3 different kinds. Two were good but the third was the most fishy oyster I've ever had - I tasted it for the rest of the night. It overpowered everything, I was nervous I was going to be sick (I wasn't thankfully). The octopus was TINY! Plus it was also fishy, it tasted off (and I've had octopus so many times) - the hummus was good. The lobster ravioli was just okay - it was garnished with lobster in the middle that tasted old and frozen - it made me question if the ravioli were fresh. Our bill was close to $200 for three drinks (espresso martinis - very delicious), oysters, octopus, kale salad and lobster ravioli- on the high side for Brooklyn. I would return for drinks and ambiance, definitely not for the food. read more

See all

Lobster ravioli was fishy. We left some on plate and table next to us didn't eat theirs also. Waiters couldn't figure out how to split bill in half and add wine to one persons bill. So loud 2 people at one small table couldn't have a conversation. Bar patrons very loud read more

Great place! Ambience and vibe is to die for! If you like spicy, try the hibiscus margarita, you will LOVE it! The oysters one of the best I've ever tasted, fresh and it feltblike off the sea!!! . The wait staff - great! Amanda and Jenny were great! Our new hang out spot.. read more

See all

Excellent all round performance The food is delicious Great seafood dishes Great appetizers The wine list has something for everyone A must try !!! read more

I went for brunch and the food was amazing! I got the lobster roll and loved how flaky and buttery the bread was and how generous they were with the lobster meat! I also got the bloody Maria to drink which had a big shrimp in it. The food and service is 5/5 for me but the pricing is a little above my regular price range so it'll have to be a special occasion or happy hour place for me! read more

Siren Restaurant & Bar - Bloody Maria with shrimp - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great spot. We had oysters, fritto misto, octopus, squid pasta and clam pasta. The oyster, and crudo were on point, all was very good! Top shelf liquor for cocktails and super accommodating with kids. Will return for sure! read more

Amazing food, great drinks, great service. Oysters were a good choice, pasta is very nice.

The staff was so nice, we were starving after a show and came an hour before closing and they fed us the most delicious meal! The ravioli was amazing and juicy, the arancini was eaten almost instantly. And they served great drinks. 10/10 will be back! read more

Came on a Sunday night, the space is dimly lit, there was such a nice and romantic ambiance to the place. We were greeted very warmly by both the host and our server. They have a menu of oysters you can check off to order from both from east and west coast. Minimum order of 6 oysters. Prices range from around $3-$5 an oyster. We ordered 6 oysters, do not remember which ones, but they all tasted pretty fresh. We then had a salad special, potato leek soup, crab cakes, clams casino, mushroom tagliatelle, and a grilled shrimp special. Really enjoyed the potato soup, it was creamy but not too heavy. Clams were stuffed well and had a rich bacon flavor. Mushroom tagliatelle had a strong mushroom flavor and loaded with mushrooms. Pasta cooked al dente. The grilled shrimp special was on top of a tomato purée sauce? Really elevated the flavors of the shrimp. Crab cake was on the saltier side for me but that might just be me because only I thought so. My absolute favorite dish surprisingly was the salad special of the night which had cauliflower and ricotta, it was refreshing and flavorful. Our server checked in on us and refilled our waters throughout the night very often. Dishes came out two at a time and paced well. We enjoyed our meal from beginning to end. Siren seems to be like a hidden gem in that part of the neighborhood, seriously worth checking out. read more

See all

This is a new establishment and I don't they got a grip on how to run the kitchen yet. Pricey for the food they serve.

I'm somewhat on the fence with posting this review. My experience was not quite as grand as the yelp* community. I grabbed a seat at the bar, and I ordered from the restaurant week menu. I began with the Octopus. The Octopus was tasty, but the black bean concoction didn't work. My second course was Linguine with Clams. The Pasta was overcooked, and the clams were a bit sandy. My third course was Mussels ala Marinara. The Mussels were good, but could have used a bit more spice. I finished with the Key Lime mousse. It was very tasty. Would somebody please tell management that those swinging kitchen doors are a nuisance. Thank you next! read more

Food was good drinks were great. Nice little cozy spot. Oysters is always a plus will visit again.

The best dish here has to be the mushroom pasta! The wines are great. I wish the menu had a bit more variety. The staff was super friendly.

Food is not just typical everything is seasoned just right. The service is amazing, the ambiance is great. When I realized they've finally opened as I'm a local in the community my family was eager to try it out and I say this is a great new addition and satisfactorily can become a new family addiction. My kids love it, it's a tranquil spot, where you can definitely enjoy and appreciate the neighborhood while eating and drinking after a long day of work or just to sit on a date night. I definitely enjoy it every time as it's not a hit or miss it's a WIN WIN keep up the good work SIREN. read more

Service was horrible! Server didn't even ask if we wanted a second drink. (Drinks were watered down) They did not stagger our food, brought everything out at once. do not get the clams casino, the cheese tastes like chemicals. When we mentioned this to our server, he said ok and took the rest back. He didn't give an explanation or took them off our bill. Oysters were good and the caviar topping compliments the dish. Everything else was mid at best. read more

Siren has a warm ambiance, exceptionally friendly service and a cool vibe. My co-worker and I loved the fact that their is a deep wine list with stalwart wineries. We ordered the freshest Kumumato oysters and misto plate for apps and then ordered branzino and a fresh pasta dish. We paired the Oysters with Pieropan Soave and the main courses with a Grenache blend by Orin swift called Abstract. Will definitely come back for date night with my girlfriend and try their champagne with an assortment of oysters and their other Dover Sole and Crab Cakes. Welcome to the neighborhood! read more

Amazing addition to Park Slope. We went there by chance. We liked how it looked from the outside. Well, we were in for a treat. The prix fix had incredible choice. A full 4 course Christmas eve dinner to remember. The lamb chops with a mint chimichurri cooked to perfection, tender and juicy. The shrimp cocktail, in fact langoustines. The pasta with clams was light and well seasoned. The clams right on point. The Tuscan fish stew with a tomato sauce that lacked nothing (I would have asked for seconds) and the Chilean sea Bass was wow, flaky juicy. The dishes were well cooked with almost no oil or butter, which made them light and easy on the body. Chef Suarez is a genius. And the desserts..... The cheese cake was creamy and sumptuous. Both the cheesecake and the bread pudding had a perfect level of sweetness. I will come back for sure. The service is impeccable. The restaurant was full but there were no delays in service. The ambiance is cozy, elegant and very Manhattan. If in Park Slope, pay this place a visit. Enjoy!!!! read more

Siren Restaurant & Bar - Chilean bass over bock Choi and caper sauce - Seafood Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all