Our favorite pizza. Sandwiches and side salads are also great too! We love Mama Tigs!read more

We were making our way from Fort Worth to Branson, and were about to pass through Eufaula when we…read moredecided to stop for lunch. My husband showed me a photo of the pizza and said, "How's this look?" "Looks good!" Eufaula is a nice little town with restaurants, shops, and typical small town businesses. There's even a Eufaula Museum across from Mama Tigs. We sat at the window facing the street. The table was made from a slice of a tree with the bark visible, but it was shellacked, of course. There were about a dozen options for pizza or you could create your own. There were some other menu options but we were there for the pizza. We chose number 5 ("The Erin") which had sliced meatballs and fire-roasted peppers (sweet not spicy). SO GOOD!! It reminded me of pizza we get from a Brooklyn Italian family-owned restaurant in our small town of Haslet. The cheese and the crust... We also got a side salad with house made ranch. This side salad had leafy mixed greens, sliced cucumbers, radishes (which my husband loved!), shredded carrots, and grape tomatoes. We almost missed dessert but decided to get a cannoli. It was delicious as well. Everything was simple and so tasty. The owner, or who I assume was the owner, was serving another table and asked if they were passing through. They live in Northwest Arkansas and Mama Tigs is their usual lunch spot (there are a few other locations). The owner said most people are visiting the nearby lake or passing through to Branson, when I said "That's what we're doing." We chatted a bit more with the owner and discovered they had lived in DFW at one time. Small world. Great place! Friendly staff! Excellent, wood-fired pizza! Be sure to stop in. It's far better than a drive-thru burger. (I didn't think to get photos of the food. I was focused on enjoying it.)

Very good food,Italian cuisine from Italy yes from a family that's made a tradition from there…read morefamily to our plates in America

The server was nice and helpful. The free bread was really good. The side salad was decent for a…read moresimple side salad. I ordered the lobster ravioli covered in the "pink" sauce. It was 4 larger raviolis (about twice the size of an average ravioli) with sauce completely filling the plate and that's it. No veggies, no nothing else on the plate to make it look more appetizing. It tasted pretty good but not near worth the price. It was $20 for the lobster raviol meal w/salad plus one extra side salad. And we drink water.

Good place I visited, but I haven't been able to go to the place in a long time and I just want to…read morego an see what's new. All in all everything is great and employees and customers are very nice and appreciated to work with & help on by. So an so people stop on by an people knows each other by day on days or even by nights when people getting off at work to go home. I like the community from the Casey's Store they have been effective and doing pretty good on every role by opportunities to go by. Very much needed to say job well done

Food I had Habanero Hawaiian Pizza, and it was okay. It…read morewasn't spicy at all. Normally, I would think that there would be more flavor, but not as tasty as I thought it would be, especially if it's wood oven made pizza. Service The server is friendly with that sweet southern hospitality. She deserves 5 stars. Ambiance Music background, clean and spacious place. Sadly, I had to give 3 stars not because of the staff or the ambient, but because of the food.

If we are just going by price and food quality I'd give Compass 4 stars. Reasonably priced, pretty…read moresolid wood-fired pizza. The stuffed mushrooms were good too. But unfortunately I have to drop it to 3 stars as the setting is weird and the service was bad, teetering on horrible. It's located downtown at the back of a building that looked like it had a flower shop, a coffee shop and a salon to walk through before you got to the restaurant. I understand you gotta do what you gotta do as a business owner, but it was a bit strange. That didn't detract from our experience, but when we DID get into the restaurant, it's not a good sign that you feel unwelcome and frankly a burden to the staff. Which is exactly what we felt like. We were told "sit wherever". "To drink?" "We have Pepsi products but Pepsi out" as she walked away. It never got better from there. Too bad because I'd recommend the food but when coming thru town next time, I think I'll try somewhere else.

Need to update your address. 606 E. Wyandotte Ave. Phone is still the same…read more We were traveling through town in our RV and wanted to stop for pizza. No decent reviews for any spots on Yelp so we opted for one with no reviews. We got a good one! Good service, good pizza. Thin crust like we like and lots of sausage. The sausage was good and flavorful - not greasy. We ordered white sauce and it was just right. Very satisfying meal and the glasses of soda were large enough that one refill was just fine. We enjoyed the hometown environment and both the cook and the waitress (Jade) were very friendly and accommodating. If you don't want pizza there are lots of other options on the menu. They seem to do a very good business with locals.

food was fresh, hot and taste good will definitely return again in the near future. Employees were…read morecheerful and helpful

This is a dinky little drive thru but their calzones were the bomb! Service was simple and…read morefriendly. The calzones could easily be shared by 2 people, we had leftovers for the next day and they were great warmed in an air fryer.

Quick service and delicious pizza. We had the pepperoni pizza. I loved the wood fire and hand…read moretossed right there for you to see. Indoor and outdoor dining options. Lots of wi does to enjoy a view of the lake.

Pepperoni pizza is amazing! 5/5. Crispy pepperonis and a nice oven fired crust. The bruschetta is…read morealso good, the amount of tomato's makes it a little soggy. 4/5. Cheesy bread is a great appetizer, light and fresh very very good! 5/5. The gelato tasted amazing! 5/5. Nice and cold inside after a day on the lake! Bring your patience, went twice and it's 30 minutes to receive your food.

Food is good and the prices are okay. Waited for the 20 minutes while they prepared my food which…read moreis typically normal waiting time. Service The staff was cordial, professional, and of course that good old southern hospitality. Ambiance Overall, clean and pretty positive. The salad bar needed a little bit cleaning.

We had a party of 10 from our church on May 24 2026 we waited almost 1 hour. The waitress Lilly…read morewas wonderful BUT.... she and only one other person was working . she was doing everything taking orders working the window and busing tables. She deserves a raise since they DON't have enough help!!!!

Their pizza is pretty darn good. Passing through from Dallas to Mena, Arkansas, and found them on…read morethe map. Glad we stopped salad bar was well stocked. Very friendly staff. I love how they took the historic home and turned it into a cool pizza place.

Great local pizza shop! Jeff and his crew make some amazing…read morepizza! Be sure and try the Fred's for a local favorite!

Drove through at noon on a Friday and decided to stop. Had the Buffett and the pizzas were…read moreconstantly coming out. Staff was super friendly and helpful. Want or need a specific pizza? Just tell them, and they'll fix it and bring it to you. Food was hot and delicious.

Do not stop here. Service is poor. It took 20 min to get a salad. They and even longer for 5 wings…read more Not worth the time. The workers stand around and talk. There is no reason for it take this long. Will not ever stop here again. Never got my wings. People getting orders before me and they ordered after to me.