I enjoy writing reviews if I have a great experience, or if I believe others need to be warned about what they are getting themselves into, Simon's Mill falls under the latter. My boyfriend and I initially planned to relocate out of state, but plans fell through and with rising costs we decided to stay in WA for the remainder of the year. We had an appointment to visit a place near Tacoma and as we were driving I found the website for this community and decided to call.
I spoke with Assistant Manager Cookie on 2/18 and she seemed nice on the phone, but as soon as we got to the office, she appeared to have had a personality change. She gave us a sheet of paper with some info about what units were available, security deposit and other fees. When I asked what the rental requirements were, she acted as if I had said something wrong and stated, you mean the "qualification criteria, it is on the website." She obviously knew what I meant and finally told me what the requirements were, but to say they were on the website was very rude.
I had skimmed the sheet that she had given us and ended up asking a question about the holding deposit ( answer was on the sheet), she replied the answer is actually on the paper...Ok.
My boyfriend and I went to tour the unit, it was cute, we liked the Washer/ Dryer area, but didn't feel like it fit the $1600 price tag, but since that seemed to be the lowest amount that we were finding in our search we decided to apply.
We went to the office and told her that we were going to apply and asked if we could do so there, but there wasn't any computers available for use. We let her know we would apply when we returned home and she told us that if someone else comes in wanting the apt and pays their holding fee then it will go to them first since they paid the deposit, so we decided to go purchase a money order for the deposit.
When we came back to the office with the money order, I tried to hand it over, but she told me to keep it an fill it out. Mind you, I know I should have done that, but I had just worked an overnight shift and hadn't had any sleep and was tired, so I filled it out and took the receipt. When we left we talked about our interaction with her and we both agreed that if we were approved at least we wouldn't have to talk to her when picking up packages ( they have a package room).
When we returned home we applied and sent over the email with the month's worth of paystubs, as requested along with a few questions we had thought of and waited. Although she works on Saturday, there was no response to my email, we also didn't hear from her on Monday until my boyfriend called her in the afternoon to check the status, said she was waiting to hear back from our current apartment. I reached out to them and they contacted her asap.
Then on Tuesday he had to reach out again, this time to find out that on the report she received there was a late payment from an apartment that he rented 10-12 years ago. This was the first time we have heard about that as we have lived in numerous apartments together and have never previously been denied nor had any other apartment mention this "late fee." She said that now made us "risky applicants" and she would have to speak with her manager, but he was handling an emergency and would be back in an hour. That hour apparently never came, because we did not hear from her again, until my boyfriend called on the 23rd. He was told that he could reach out to his previous apartment and have them send something over stating that was an error. He called his old apartment and they sent over an extensive ledger with all his previous rent payments and the date and said there is no record of a late payment and that they would let Simon's Mills know that. My boyfriend sent over the ledger to Cookie and relayed the info and she said she would speak to her manager. When we finally spoke to her again, he was basically accused of fabricating that ledger and that the person who sent it over could be lying for my boyfriend and if we wanted to move into the apartment it would be an additional $600 deposit on top of the $500 deposit that we had paid. Cookie didn't want to reach out to the previous apartment or have them call, which led us to believe that she never wanted to let us move in anyway.
I'm African American and my boyfriend is Caucasian and the only thing we can thing of when it comes to her rude behavior, making us jump through hoops for a basic apartment, accusing him of fraud, no response to my email, etc would be because of my race. I've dealt with racist all my life, I can see the signs and she should have just told us we weren't "her kind of people" and we would have saved the $100 application fee. Applicants, if you must rent here, insist on speaking to Tammy, she is nice. Cookie, you need to change your NASTY attitude. read more