Right near our house, we go once a week or so, we love that the 2 women recognize us...our family favorite is the party size peppers and onions, pepperoni and cheese is second. We look forward to trying other pizzas and other menu items in the future. read more

A solid option. People were personable, and the price/quantity ratio was good. When Wicked Good dropped the ball they stepped up. Wouldn't hesitate to go back. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - a cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Rhode Island

Went to Silver Lake with my son after a volleyball game on Tuesday. He got chicken tenders and fries, I couldn't decide between hot weiners (which were on my mind on the way there) or a pizza, which I had not had from Silver Lake in a while, so I got two weiners and a small pepperoni, figuring I could take most of the pizza home to my daughter. What I didn't originally realize was we weren't supposed to dine in, and the booths and tables were roped off. When I expressed my surprise, the owner said it was OK and we could sit down. That was appreciated. The food was really good. The chicken tenders were large and the fries were hot and crispy, my son loved them. The hot weiners were good, there's not often a large amount of variance in this particular item, but they were hot and the mustard/meat sauce/onion ratio was on point. It what really stood out was the pizza. Medium thick, crispy, airy and a little buttery, nice tangy sauce and real cheese, it was the clear standout of our dinner. My poor daughter only had a couple of slices left when my son and I were done grazing. We kept saying, "just one more slice..." A great little neighborhood pizza place to get something good at the right price to fill you up. Support local, family owned over the chains any day. Quality and price will always win. read more

On 6/11/2021 we ordered a large pizza and large fries to pick up ; we were told 25 min it would be ready. My husband went to pick it up 30 min later and had to wait in line another 15 min only to be told they had not started the order. The woman who spoke with my husband was extremely rude and unhelpful (the woman who we usually see when we order from there who I assume is the owner was not there) The woman offered no explanation or apology ; I get it they are busy but cmon make an effort ! My husband ended up saying just forget it and cancel the order ! Silver Lake Pizza WAS our go to place for pizza but not anymore!! read more

I love this place! The food is great! Prices are very reasonable. Service is very great! One of the best family owned pizza shops around.

Most of the negative reviews are from ages ago and over the last year and a half I've ordered from this place with mostly no problem. They don't have a up to date online menu which is annoying but they're speciality party pizzas are really good. read more

I was out looking for something new to yelp about, so I drove to an area in Coventry and did my little 'near by' search and came up with Silver Lake Pizza. Not much to look at from the outside, but inside it is a pizza joint, and that is a good thing. Too many places focus on delivery these day. SL does that as well, but you can sit comfortably inside as well with friends and family and enjoy the time. So the food. I have only been here this one time and only had Pepperoni pizza. The crust was thin, crispy and favorable. They told me that they make it by hand daily. The toppings were really good as well. Did not taste like they skipped on the product. At this point, I would put on the level as Kingston Pizza (Warwick branch). They also do Cold and Hot grinders, your typical fried items, pastas and sandwiches. So for now, I am a fan and will return. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - menus on the wall - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Rhode Island

See all

Pizza Great, Food good, Service TERRIBLE. RUDE. I asked the price on a medium pizza not knowing any prices and figuring if medium was only $1 more I would just get a medium... when I asked the price and told her I just wanted to know the prices on a small med and a large... meanwhile I already ordered $40 worth of food... the lady mumbled OH GREAT! As if I was bothering her!!! I said something and she got extremely nice and said she didn't say that. I said whatever placed the order told driver how rude she was he said I know everyone complains about her... ummm ok so let's keep a witch there smh read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Rhode Island

Silver Lake Pizza is great. We buy lunchtime sandwiches there from time to time.. Hot oven grinders are always piping hot and delicious. I had foot surgery awhile back. I would order sandwiches and the great staff there would accommodate me by bringing our food out to car with a smile. A couple of reviewers gave them poor reviews because they thought the employees were a bit unfriendly.. I think they are quite friendly. They are mother and daughter..and they have been doing this a long time...They just don't smile much I guess. I suggest you try again and be friendly yourself.. perhaps a smile from you might go a long way.. you get more with sugar than salt ... BUT back to the point: The food... great food at great prices at this family run small business... ! Try them.. smile at the value you receive and you will be going back time and time again. 5 star .. without hesitation! read more

Was feeling a totally RI lunch- stopped in for wieners and fries! The cashier was extremely nice, talkative. The pricing was decent, they were quick and the fries were very crispy! My Mom kept raving over the crispiness! No complaints, it hit the spot! The location is decorated very rustic inside, if I lived closer I would love to have a meal here every so often, feels quaint. read more

Being from Connecticut, I was a skeptic about the quality of pizza in Rhode Island. Silver Lake Pizza changed the game for me! My boyfriend introduced me to Silver Lake Pizza a little over a year ago. I love the shape/size and the way they cut the pizza, as weird as that may sound. The rectangular shape provides tones of flavor-packed squares of cheesy goodness. The crust is crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. Typically, I am a thin crust kind of girl and Silver Lake won me over again with its texture and taste. There is just the right amount of sauce and toppings. Sometimes, other places will either put too much or too little, but Silver Lake has it down to a science. The service is always really great and the staff is very friendly. I have yet to sit down and eat inside, I always order my food to go. If you're looking for a pizza that will please the crowds, then Silver Lakes got it! read more

Just ordered 2 fish & chips dinners. Cost was close to $20. Two filet of fish sandwiches, per dinner, from McDonalds would have provided more fish. My daughter also placed an order and they gave her fish & chips to someone that ordered a meal and side salad. Their side salad is now fish. Poor quantities & very expensive for what you receive. read more

Waited 4 hours for delivery Thursday night. When we ordered they said 90 min but then called 30 more and called again 30 more and called again 30 more. It was too late to eat. Don't mind waiting but please be honest when we call back. read more

Would like to review the food, but, the disrespectful employee answering the phone hung up on me twice trying to order food and now wont pick up. I assume the food is just as much garbage as their service. Don't waste your time or money. read more

If you don't feel like cooking on a game night this is the place to go. Their square pizza is amazing, and it comes with plenty of slices for a family of four. There's always some left over! The delivery guy was on his way out and was kind enough to toss me a smile and "hi hawaya" on his way out, and the lady behind the counter was sweet....told me how they've been in the area for 30+ years. They must be doing something right! Love this place. read more

Ordered fish and chips to be delivered and spoke with Betsy who took the order. After an hour without them coming by or calling me back had to reorder again. Was not happy with the fish and chips that were barely warm. Having doing business for many years with Silver Lake Pizza will not be returning. This took place about 8 months ago but has not slipped my mind. Finally had a chance to review. read more

I used to love getting pizza, fries, and hot wieners from Silver Lake Pizza in Coventry, Rhode Island. As of lately, the older lady that runs the place is increasingly more and more rude on the phone. Called today (Sunday) asking for a delivery. She rudely and aggressively instructed me that they did not deliver till three pm on Sunday, which I was about to follow up and say "Oh okay, thank you. Can I place an order for pick up?" However as finished saying "can" I heard her hang up the phone. I then called back two times and was hung up on. Silver Lake has lost a lifetime customer because of their lack of courtesy. Being rude is far too common these days, and it shouldn't be the case when it comes to serving food. read more

This is our stop for our weekly pizza. The crust is crunchy and the prices are reasonable.

I've never been disappointed. Great wieners, pizza, wings and spinach pies! Chicken fingers are good too. I wish they would add buffalo fingers, instead of just a dipping sauce. read more

Honestly they dont even deserve one damn star.The older woman that runs the place is a total bitch and has no people skills.I overheard her and another worker making fun of one of her help!!! The food is greasy and cold!!! Overpriced garbage...Ill go to Santoros instead read more

My HORRIBLE experience yesterday. Walked in, went to the counter. (I was the only customer in the place), and said "Hi" to this old women with white hair. She completely ignored me, as if I wasn't there. Then she walked by me, again did not even look at me. I finally said, "Are you going to waite on me?". She finally looked at me and said, "I'm busy". Are you kidding me! Something is seriously wrong with this women. I walked out, never to return. The only reason why I went there was because my 85 year old mother likes an occasional hot weiner and I heard they had them there. Otherwise, I would have never stepped foot in that place. It's a dump. I don't know if this women is seriously ignorant or is demented. And she's the owner I heard! And she's making the food! Time to shut down the place. No customer should ever be treated so blantently rude like I was. read more

They charge you for something you didn't order. I was charged almost $20 for a large pepperoni pizza when I ordered a square pepperoni pizza. I received a normal large pizza and when I called to have the order fixed they hung up on me and then yelled at me on the phone. Never ordering from them again. read more

We ordered delivery and we were told 45 min. An hour and a half went by, no food. I called, she said our food would be here shortly. Another half hour, still no food. Tried calling a dozen times with no answer read more

First and last time ordering from here. Called in an order, was told it would be ready in 20 minutes. 50 minutes later, it was finally ready, but with one pizza completely wrong! Called them to let them know they made a mistake, put on "hold" for 5 minutes, and could hear the couple arguing if they would remake the pizza or not! Another 30 minutes later, it was finally correct. Older lady working there has terrible phone etiquette, and very rude in person. Workers look miserable and mostly unhelpful. If you can get passed all that, the food is pretty good, but I won't go back! read more

They wouldn't deliver one night, then I called the next night and they wouldn't even answer the phone. Food is not as good as it used to be either. Disappointed to say the least. read more

The lady is incredibly rude and food is trash, I can't believe this place is still open.

I like the pizza not too crazy about the weiners here but i stopped goin after so many burnt pizzas or pizzas with hair in them

Meatball grinder was very weird tasting meat seemed prossessed and old or freezer burnt. The wieners tasted funny like.. dish soap... i will not recommend this place they even make you feel... un wanted somthing i really hate as a costumer. I understand times can be tough but don't serve old pre-made or store bought meatballs, and taste your food.. it was bad. read more

When you're the only one in the place and asked to be waited on, it's not a great idea for the woman behind the counter to bark "I'm busy" and ignore you. Avoid this dump read more

The girl at the counter must hate money, because if she did like money - she wouldn't be rude to a person giving her money. So she'll be happy to not get any more of my money. And I'll get my pizza from the million other pizza restaurants in the area. (You're pizza wasn't even that good). And I noticed George F from Reading Mass., gave his own restaurant a rave review. I guess that's easier than hiring employees that are polite and professional to customers. How do I know that a George F from Reading Mass owns the restaurant? I looked up the website owner because I was curious as what kind of people hate money. Very odd people indeed. read more

Having moved recently to Coventry, RI, my family has tried a few pizza places nearby. The majority of them are pretty forgettable, however. While we often get pizza from Dave's across the street, we decided to try SLP and didn't regret it. Everyone in the family loves them, they have better hours than Dave's, and the wings are delicious as well. The owners are super nice, and Patriot fans too! read more

I order from here, because it's very close to where I live... it never fails though no matter what the order is, they somehow ALWAYS screw the order up. Last night pizza was burnt. Last month Ordered a ham and cheese grinder and they delivered me a eggplant parm. ordered a turkey club fries well done, got a turkey grinder with no fries. Not to mention these were all separate orders at different times. Only positive about this place is they will make up for it the next time you order and give it for free. All set from ordering from them anymore. read more

They don't use gloves while making any of the food.. gross and is a health hazard. They don't pay their drivers much money at all. The mother is sweet but the daughter is highly obnoxious. I worked there for a whole two days before I couldn't take it anymore. They don't chip in for gas and only pay $5 an hour. Not worth the gas you lose. Also not worth getting food poisoning by their lack of glove use. read more

Thoroughly dissapointed. I called and asked about party pizzas and generally how many people they feed. The woman on the phone simply replied it depends how hungry you are. This was not amusing. After being put on hold about three times during the call I decided just two large pizzas and a order of teriyaki wings would do. The woman told me my total was 27 and change and it would be 45 mins. I shortly later received a call back informing that they don't carry teriyaki and if buffalo or plain would serfice. I chose buffalo and decided on a ranch sauce. About an hour and ten minutes later my food showed up. The driver apologized for the wait and had my credit card slip handy to sign. The total was 38 and change and I signed off on $42. Moments after the driver left I realized the total was off and inspected the food. To my astonishment i received two party pizzas which were satisfactory but the wings were hardly luke warm and it was obvious by the appearance they had sat around a while. They screwed up my order which put a dent in my wallet seeing I was only feeding two adults and two children. (Which includes me). I didn't call back to argue because I received what I paid for even though it was much more than what I ordered.. 4 thumbs down from this guy. I won't order or recommend PERIOD. read more

Silver Lake Pizza - Not thrilled about leftovers... - Pizza Near Me - Coventry, Rhode Island

I've been ordering from this cute little town pizza place for years. I'm guessing there are new owners or they are just letting children run their business into the ground.... I placed a simple order, received my order in a timely fashion only to find the order was wrong. After 2 calls to them to try to have it fixed, they refused. Said they didn't have what I ordered! Which makes NO sense! I Wasted my money on food we didn't eat, didn't get it fixed or even an apology! It's always unfortunate to see a nice little place going under due to a lack of basic common courtesy & respectful customer relations! That was the LAST time we ever ordered from there! Make sure you have them read back your order twice! read more

Called for the first time for a delivery. The lady who took the order was extremely rude. Should of hung up an ordered somewhere else. The driver was nice who had delivered are food after a hour. So, we gave a good tip. Food sucked. You can tell it was sitting around for a while and old. It was also burned. We eat the food because are bill was almost 80.00 after tip. We had really bad indigestion from it for a couple of days. We won't order from there again. read more

Must stop on your way through RI! I have been stopping here for the past 15 years with my family on my way traveling through RI. Mouth watering Greek style pizza, fries, hot wieners and subs. I used to live nearby and go weekly for Friday pizza night, but since moving I have to settle for visiting a few times a year. Love that the owners are always there, they remember me every time! read more

Silver Lake is actually really good. I don't know if they still do the cheeseburger buy 1 get 1 free but that deal was killin it because they are so good! It's also convenient that they deliver late (past 1 or 2 I believe) so if your drinking no1 has to drive to get food. Their prices are really good and they offer a little of everything. read more

Extremely rude customer service. I called and tried to place an order for a pizza and knew the woman had taken the order wrong but she insisted she knew what I meant. I then received the wrong pizza and when I called back about it I heard the employee whispering about how difficult I was being. Only good for their hot wieners. read more

So I was on my regular lunch run and I decided to go to the daves market coventry what a bad idea. Today's selection for lunch sucked. As I was leaving I always say I wanna check out silver Lake pizza so I did. Tight parking some guy decided to take up two spaces so I went across the street to the Plaza and walked across. I like to come into the smaller pizza shops always better service and food is great. Got the 12 inch Italian grinder small fry and soda. Great food and fast service. The day I came in was busy walk up service. I recommend coming here and trying a new pizza place if you can. You won't regret it read more