This store is not limited to stocking hardware. For example, they carry an extensive selection of…read moreBBQ supplies and even Lodge cast iron skillets. There is also an adequate staff to help customers locate the items they are seeking - welcome when you're trying to find an obscure part. I needed a box in order to ship my medium Big Green Egg and saw that they stock the Big Green Eggs. I asked if they could contact me when they receive a new medium BGE, to let me come in to pick up the custom heavy duty box that the BGE is shipped in. I gave them my phone number. Sure enough, Jim from the store called a few weeks later and had saved the shipping box from a medium BGE for me. I promptly drove over and picked it up. Wow, they had kept my phone number and followed through with a phone call! Thank you and kudos!! You won't find this level of service from a big box store. They have earned our business for hardware and other needs - will be heading back for a lid for our Lodge skillet.

Sherwin Williams no longer offers "sample" sizes. The smallest you can get is a gallon. Save…read moreyourself the time and hassle and go to Lowes. I wish they would have saved me the trouble but maybe it will help you!

Slow and expensive. Go to Lowes or Home Depot that are both in the immediate area…read more I personally like Valspar paint that you can buy at Lowe's. It's the best....goes on easy and covers in 1 coat. Don't waste your time at Sherwin!

Very friendly and service focused location. Lots of color options and supplies. Parking is a bit…read moretight just drive towards Elegant Design in the same strip mall for more spaces!

Great Paint! Great service. I painted my entire interior with Ben Moore. Its the best.read more

I will never go to any Benjamin Moore Paint again. Four and half years since I purchased several…read moregallons/quarts of paint to paint all interior walls of home. Needed to do touch-up work, and did not remember the name of my paint. Went to Benjamin Moore on 12th St in Sarasota and ask if they had records of my past purchases. Yes they do. I ask for sample size in the color/finish I had bought previously. Well, I could buy the color in sample size, but not finish, but you can purchase a quart in color/finish that you need for $27.99, so I spent 5X more than I wanted and bought a quart simply because "that's what the computer said" and I guess the computer had the final word since I didn't remember what I had purchased 4 1/2 years ago. Back to paint store, clerk agrees, yes, it is flat. He flips the computer screen around for my viewing pleasure to prove his point, "computer" says you purchased the matt paint finish. I remind him again that my walls are not matt - walls are satin finish. Right color, wrong finish. Frustrated at this point, I took my $27.99 quart of paint - right color, wrong finish and informed clerk that I would go to Home Depot and get what I needed, which is what I did. Fifteen minutes later I had a sample size of cloud white in satin finish for less than $5.00. Thank you very much Home Depot. Rotten service from Benjamin Moore, clerk couldn't get past what the computer said. Couldn't hear me repeatedly telling him.... hello....my walls are satin finish. Thanks BM, stuck with paint I won't use. BTW: Home Depot can match any color paint and offers 5 finishes ! Have a great day !

Hands down the best paint store I've found in Sarasota. Always a pleasant place to shop…read more Consistently helpful and competent. Chris, the manager, indulged me in my searches for the perfect whites for both my house and my condo, even mixing custom tints. And , of course, Benjamin Moore paints themselves are terrific.

The store was clean. The sale people were awesome. I only had a paint swatch and they matched it…read moreperfectly. I was in and out in under 20 minutes paint in hand. GREAT JOB!! I will be back - Pluto Paint & Pressure Washing LLC

I bought an aerator for my kitchen sink. It did not solve my problem. Which was low water pressure…read more I went to Ace with the exact thing in my hand I needed. The one that I got did not correct the problem. I had a plumber come out and he showed me why this aerator Was not working. Basically it's cheap and poorly designed. He showed me and it made absolute sense.

I was buying tomato seeds and a worker then walked me to where they are, and then at checkout a…read moredifferent worker said he respected gardeners and paid for them for me. There was a huge variety of plant seeds and for the price is was most definitely worth it. Amazing experience.

I finally received a reply from this store. They agreed I was overcharged, and made things right. I…read morewill remain a customer.

I went to Benjamin Moore on 41 and got nine cans of quality paint, including two different yellows,…read morefrom a pair of very pleasant young men in less than a couple hours for a rational amount of money, including stirrers, a key, AND one of them cheerfully loaded it all into my vehicle. That's kinda what one might expect but this was the next day after a dreadfully opposite experience at the competition on Cortez so I'm EXUBERANTLY RECOMMENDING this Benjamin Moore store.

Help was there as soon as we entered the store. He took to exactly what we needed. Highly recommend.read more

This is a smaller "neighborhood" ace store, and so the selection might be a little more limited…read more The people who work there are knowledgeable and were very helpful when I asked question about the different types of generators that they had. Prices are more on the expensive side, but I kind of expected that with it being a smaller store.

My dog went missing on 4/30/26 and I was so nervous I wouldn't find him after checking our…read moreneighborhood. We usually take walks around the area and he is familiar with the paint store. I was so relieved to see on Facebook that Alfred had grabbed him before crossing into traffic! I am so thankful for the help of all the associates that helped my dog come back home. Thank you!!!

these guys are great! I was recently renovating a condo in the area and had some tricky paint…read morequestions. Chris and David were extremely friendly, helpful and knowledgable. they hooked me up with the right paint and tools. I would highly recommend coming here rather than going to one of the big box stores because the prices aren't really any higher so you basically get the awesome customer service for free!

Best paint store with the most knowledgeable employees very helpful guiding customers into the best…read moreproducts and colors

From the owner: Your local Sherwin-Williams Paint Store in Sarasota, FL, provides expert advice, premium coatings,…read morepaint matching, and professional-grade supplies to help bring complex urban projects to life. Connect with our team for expert recommendations, the right coatings and tools, and personalized support that helps you achieve professional results. As a convenient paint store near you, we offer online color tools, color consultation, wallpaper and application resources, brushes, and information on paint recycling, along with high-quality paints and options to order paint online. A Spanish-speaking representative is available to assist customers.