I've only ever ordered takeout from them, but every time I have it's not only good but they always show up AHEAD of schedule as opposed to late like every other restaurant that delivers. Scott was our driver tonight. He was prompt, polite, and courteous. He took the time to make sure that the order was correct 100%. You're safe ordering from here! read more

I had ordered a couple pizza pies w/ toppings to be delivered to a wonderful business the following day. Allison was not only so pleasant, but she literally helped me get a great deal on the order and had it delivered earlier than the posted time on app. Food is great, reasonably priced & staff is phenomenal!! Thanks Sergio's for a great experience, very appreciated!! read more

The food and the service is always amazing. Holly is always so sweet and remembers what I order. She's always greeting everyone with a smile. read more

The best and fastest service I know , food is great and delicious delivery was on time 5 stars

we were out here after an Apple picking day & came across this place ... let me first start by saying we were a party of 20 & we got our food/ drinks/ seats right away ... The pizza was so good! Tons of cheese !! If I am around I would definitely come back read more

See all

Absolutely perfect delivery. I ordered delivery and they said about 40 minutes. It came in 20 minutes. The pizza is super hot and fresh. I am totally impressed. The driver even brought plates and extra napkins which I didn't even ask for. Awesome service Sergio's. Keep up the good work. read more

Sergio's - Pizza Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Always sparkling clean and smells good. The food is fresh, tastes like home made and soooo delicious! Friendly staff, great deals. Catering available and dependable. read more

Sergio's - Sergios Salad: walnuts, chicken, feta, special balsamic dressing, cranberries, field greens - Pizza Near Me - Riverhead, New York

Undercooked pizza isn't a crime but not worth ordering from again. French fries I had ordered were also undercooked. Dissatisfied had high hopes looked like a nice menu read more

I was helping my parents with some errands and it was time for lunch and we stopped at Sergio's for a pizza. Their menu is extensive featuring handmade pizzas, calzones, rolls, appetizers, salads, pasta dinner platters, heros and even desserts. We ordered a cheese pizza and were told to sit down and they would bring the pizza to the table when it was ready. We got sodas and shortly after sitting down, the pizza arrived piping hot to the table. It was delicious. The staff was friendly and very accommodating. When they saw we were having trouble separating the slices of pizza, they brought over a spatula for ease plate transfer. Their restroom was clean and well maintained. I would recommend and return. read more

This is by far my favorite pizza place on LI! Unfortunately, most Italian restaurants serve pizza that is greasy and have sweet sauce as well as doughy garlic knots. This place, on the other hand, has plenty of selection, well cooked garlic knots that make you hungry just looking at them, wonderful marinara, and the smell of garlic hits your nose as soon as you walk in! The service is nice, even when the place is super crowded. Everything tastes as great as it smells and looks, and the crust is thin and crispy, as pizza should be. Like many small restaurants that are often in strip malls, this place is a gem! An absolute recommend if you're in the area and you're a huge fan of Italian food! read more

Good pizza, but the worst wings i ever had. They were so dried out, it was hard to chew the meat off the bone.

Delicious and generous portions of pizza, with a good selection. I opted for a couple of veggie ones to take out - the grandma and the vegetarian. They were both delicious. I think the herbs made them extra special. Everyone else had the buffalo chicken (spicy), meat lovers, pepperoni and gave the thumbs up. A great find for a friendly, quick meal. read more

Nice people, not great pizza. I think they survive because they deliver. Tried it once, that's enough for me.

Sergio's- service is just as important if not more important then the taste of food. In saying that your pizza is very good and being in a industry of many competitors that's very important. However, the service your providing behind the counter is sub par at best. There is no reason to get push back on how I would like the temperature of my pizza. The eye rolling along with snarky comment is unnecessary. The young lady with the blonde to reddish hair should not be dealing with your guests. I will not be returning to your location. read more

Mask on the chin and not the face of the blonde girl at the register, mask on the chin of the guy -- who was coughing up a long -- making the pizza near the window, the blonde and another worker yelling stories to one another while cursing up a storm with customers in the restaurant. Not sure what's worse, this lack of caring that we're in the middle of a pandemic or the lack of being courteous. Can I give this place 0 stars? Simply awful. read more

One of the best pizza spots on the island , the place was nice and looked liked it was recently renovated . The food was just amazing and I gotta say the staff was pretty awesome . Overall 10/10 would go to Sergio's again . I loved the philly everything read more

This place has delicious food and provides excellent customer service. I am so thankful to Sergio's for going above and beyond for our family this past weekend. My mother, who is a regular customer, decided to preorder multiple meals to feed our family after my brother's funeral service. When the manager found out what was going on, she helped put our order together, provided suggestions, and customized things to meet our needs. When we got the food and began opening everything up, it was very apparent that we probably got twice as much as we ordered and they also threw in plates, napkins, and anything else they thought we might need. It was unbelievable and so appreciated!!!! What a top notch establishment with such a caring staff!! read more

Love their pizzas. They deliver within the hour. Their prices are very reasonable and they are very pleasant over the phone. I've never had a problem with any of their food- except their grandma pie is not as good as setauket pastaria. read more

Hate to trash a local business but this is the worst pizza I've ever had in my life. I'm from the area, ordered once & it was very underwhelming to say the least. Gave another chance and it's literally the worst pie I've ever had. Chose "well done" which is an option THEY offer..it was even partially done it was practically raw - both times. They use canned mushrooms instead of fresh which ruined my pie. At $3 a topping you can't even use fresh mushrooms. The sauce is awful and there's very little on there. The slices flopped over like a limp "you know what". I don't discriminate with pizza but this was horrendous. Never again. You've been warned. read more

We often order delivery from Sergio's and really enjoy their food. The pizza is great (although it could use more sauce). The meatball heroes are delicious and never too spicy like other places. Their salads are plentiful and very good, especially the antipasti salad. We also recommend their zeppoles for dessert. Prices are reasonable and delivery is always fast and accurate. We have even ordered delivery at a local campsite and they are always very accommodating! read more

I didn't even make it through the phone call. Guy on the phone bitched me out because I gave him my phone number with the area code. He yelled at me because he didn't need the area code and said I screwed him all up. SO RUDE. I hung up before placing the order and before giving him my whole phone number! ;) read more

This pizza is SO good. So so good. Honestly I haven't gotten beyond just the classic cheese pie, but there's no reason to! It's the best. Always nice on the phone and pizza always shows up hot. I heart Sergio's. read more

Ok, they were super busy, and not overly friendly, but wait till you taste the pizza!!! Small seating area, but hey it's in a strip mall.....got the veggie slice and the meat lover slice..... Just like new york pizza is supposed to be! read more

Horrible service delivery takes them over 2 hours to make a half cooked cold pizza we will never use them again.

I went in there to pick up my order and all of a sudden and employee started yelling at the one guy telling him to hurry up with the pizzas. In front of all the customers she was yelling at him and he responded that the pizza was already in the oven that if it did not get there on time it was the delivery persons fault. I found that very rude especially since there was customers around. If she wanted the pizzas done why couldn't she just help. The whole situation made me think that they are really treating there employees bad considering it was a Hispanic man she was yelling at. read more

Was waiting for my mom to get done at the dentist and thought I'd give this place a try. Best pie I've ever had! I've been to pizza restaurants all over the east coast and I gotta say this one is #1 on my list. read more

The Buffalo Chicken Pizza is my absolute favorite. I usually don't even wait to eat it at home...I usually sit in the parking lot and eat it because it smells so good. I never had a problem with customer service but they are always busy...which is a good thing. read more

Fast, hot, and good food. The delivery man went the extra mile to deliver to my door even though it wasn't easy to find. He even brought plates and napkins just in case! read more

By far the best pizza place in town! I can always just stop by and have a slice with the family inside or have them deliver for free...YES, FREE! Fast service and great attitudes most of the time. The specials are the real deal that you won't be able to find anywhere else. read more

The pizza from Sergio's is worth mentioning as INCREDIBLY good. The dough itself is as tender as fresh baked bread inside, yet has a lovely crunch on the outside. It is (thankfully) NOT over salted, but instead has a delicious, bright flavor. No need to drink a gallon of water after this pizza. The ingredients for my toppings were sausage, and a nice, thick chopped fresh bacon. No skimping there! Both meats were very fresh, bite-sized generous portions yet thin cut enough to eat easily. You receive a mouthful of flavor with no mess down your shirt! The Mozzarella cheese is a full bodied whole milk, full of flavor and has a nice string to it. Delightful to pull a piece and see the appetizing string, but the cheese doesn't pull off your piece. It stays put! Served hot and fast. But the fun part is at Sergio's you can also buy the dough and make your own pizzas at home! We made a breakfast pizza with scrambled egg, sausage and bacon which came out beautifully. When you shape the dough it's kneaded nicely and elastic. Easy to form. No holes when you shape this dough! My family has eaten pizza from just about every shop from Virginia to New York. and today, with Sergio's, ALL of my 3 teen boys asked me where we got THIS good pizza, and asked for more. One son even begged me if we could have it again tonight! They all raved about it. Now, that's a winner. Try Sergio's. The owners aim to please and do just that. read more

GREAT food!!!!! Buffalo chicken pie my favorite! Super nice staff and the owner went out if her way to make my kids smile. Was not my first visit and definitely won't be my last. Jay from read more

I have been going to this pizzaria for a while now, there pizza is amazing i suggest the garlic know slice and buffalo slice , there cheep and amazinggggg food, the service is good by location is kinda ehhh read more

This place was once a good bet, but it has gone downhill for months. They have messed up our order 4 or 5 times now, and we are no longer going to tolerate things like undercooked pizza and missing items. When I called tonight to find out why they didn't bring my salad, they said they were busy and all the orders went out with no salad. They obviously have no concern for their customers, so they won't need to worry about us adding to their workload in the future. read more

The Pizza is alright the sauce is to sweet, and I felt like I was being rushed out of the place by the staff.

Very good pizza. I've been here twice now for lunch. The service is always friendly. The grandma slice is delicious.

I'd love to give this 4 stars as the food is worth it...however, the phone service is ridiculous. They don't understand your order, then apparently can't find our house (gps?). The order took an hour to arrive, but even the cold pizza was delicious, couldn't imagine how good it could be if it were hot! read more

Umm..LIVE ROACH in my salad!!! When I called, they said they wouldn't drive back out with a refund (the store that I was working at is 5 minutes away) Instead of being apologetic about a ROACH in my salad running around inside the container, they were rude, saying that if I wanted a refund that I would have to go another time since I would be getting out of work after they closed. I have had other situations here as well, from delivering pizza with all the cheese slid off and cold to entirely bringing the wrong order. read more