My friends were visiting me in Bay Shore and I set up a stay for them here last year and they…read moreabsolutely loved it! Liz the general manager was incredibly kind, attentive, and accommodating. The property itself is gorgeous and super cute (great Gilmore Girls/New England B&B vibes!!). The room was clean. My friends thought everything was super comfortable. Check-in was seamless. Breakfast was super tasty and fresh! Highly recommend!!

The property is professionally maintained and the room accommodations are wonderful; all nicely…read moreappointed. We have had three opportunities to stay at the Bay House and have never been disappointed by the service and hospitality. The morning breakfasts were absolutely scrumptious. They also are eager to accommodate any special food requests. Recently they hosted my sisters 70th Birthday party and it was perfectly managed and they made all her guests feel special. Eddie & Cindy

Interesting architecture in fire island, a 9 room guest house with pool…read more Our garden level room was freezing with no way to turn off the AC. Management is pretty unknowledgeable about running the place, property maintenance was almost nonexistent. Hot water failure for a day with no notice from mgr's. Pool, however, is a bright spot .

We had such an awesome weekend here. The guesthouse is so nice, neat and organized. Thank you to…read moreall the staff for your hospitality. You guys made us feel so welcome. If the management could put Netflix in all of the guest rooms that would be AWESOME!

Beautiful B&B with a very friendly inn keeper. All the rooms are beautiful and the location on Main…read moreStreet is one of the many lovely large estates lining the street. It was perfect for walking to Ye Burying Yard since that has nowhere to park. Enjoyed my room with the dial-on fireplace, the heated towel rack, and great water pressure. The room was spacious, and well appointed. Loved the four poster bed in the Dogwood suite, and bed was comfy. Also loved that I was next door to the Keeler Tavern Museum. Loved getting to look at a place my ancestors had visited. Beautiful property. Breakfast was small but nice: small quiche, small selection of pastries, coffee/ tea, some cheeses. The personalized pin key entry worked well. Hope to be back at some point. Loved it.

wonderful wedding weekend spent here. Rehearsal dinner, Welcome Drinks, wedding preparations and…read moreall photographs. Spectacular weekend. Morgan was fantastic and goes above and beyond to make your stay enjoyable. Thank u Morgan for everything xox

Listen if you're looking for a 5 star resort then go to another part of the world. This is Fire…read moreIsland and expect anything to happen. For everyone complaining about px it's a 5 month a year business. Our experience was top notch, stayed at the main house employees were excellent, they provided a cart w chairs, umbrellas a lock, towels, bikes, free kayaking, water,ice free breakfast along with other locations you can use. Room was small but it's we just used it to sleep and shower. BTW shower was awsome. Spent time in the main courtyard with our friends, employees were attentive. I can also see an issue staying at the off site locations being loud. Looking forward coming back next year.

Nice staff and great text communication. Alarms went off in hallway outside our room both nights…read more Needs coffee maker in room. The restaurant (CJs) and mini bay club affiliated need serious cleanup. Nice people but room for serious improvement.

My friend and I just spent a beautiful, relaxing weekend at Pines Bluff Overlook. Our apartment was…read moreso warm and cozy. The shared living room kitchen area is also so warm and cozy and filled with natural light. Very nice amenities with everything you need for a relaxing stay. The pool area and jacuzzi with deck are just beautiful. The best part of our stay was meeting Eva, the house manager. She was so kind and welcoming. She provided everything we needed and made sure the place was spotless upon our arrival. She provided many helpful tips and shared interesting facts and history about the island. Thank you Eva, we hope to see you next season. Martin

Beautiful B&B!!! Not far from the ferry dock. The place is spectacular with beautiful views,…read moreamazing pool, snacks and wine. The manager is super nice and welcoming! Would definitely return on my next visit.

Donna and Dave are wonderful hosts. The location is centrally located to all kind of great…read moreactivities of the North Fork. Our room was very quiet and comfortable- and Dave's breakfasts were wonderful- very hearty!! We I'll be back!

Just returned home after a 2-night mid-week stay at this beautiful and charming B&B. It was the…read moreperfect quick getaway. The house is clean, beautifully decorated, and spacious. We felt welcome as soon as we walked up to the house and met Dave. He gave us a tour and showed us to our lovely (and large) room with a view of the vineyard. Dave and Donna have thought of anything you may need. There's a bar, 24-hr access to coffee, tea and water, board games, pool table, a mini indoor golf set, spacious outdoor seating to take in the beauty of the property or have a drink by one of the fire pits, even microwave popcorn! Dave made us a fabulous breakfast each morning and was super friendly as he presented each dish and chatted with us. If you're considering checking this place out, DO IT!!! We will definitely be back to spend more time at this fantastic east end gem.

Cool for an overnight stay. Included 2 beach chairs and an umbrella. Included plenty of bikes, the…read morechains popped though. I wouldn't plan a romantic getaway here but ok for an overnight stay.

Small hotel with about 8 rooms--great location right next to the ferry (yes, beautiful boat ride to…read moreget there--about 25 minutes) and right in the heart of town near shops, markets, ice cream shops, and restaurants, 2 block walk to beautiful beach. Room closet had free beach chair, umbrella. Staff (owner) very nice and attentive to all my needs. I've been coming for 30 years and plan to keep coming back. Place neat and clean. Yes, 4 shared bathrooms but that means a couple can have 2. Never had to wait. Irving R. June 26, 2025

My girlfriend and I were staying in Brooklyn for a week and we found this place online. We found a…read morefew reviews and decided to give it a try. We stayed 3 nights, Sunday to Wednesday. Josie was great. She showed us around our floor (when you rent a room you get the entire floor) and talked about locking up and things like that. The Breakfast portion is on the lighter side. Cereal and juice are available. Josie offered to get pastries in the morning but we said we didn't need it, there are too many great places for brunch in the neighborhood. The rooms were clean, the main bathroom seemed brand new (the second bathroom in the bedroom was nice to have as well) and the location was fantastic. I'd much rather pay a little more to stay here as opposed to getting a hotel on the other side of Park Slope. If you need a place to stay in Park Slope I recommend considering this place.

Great location and super friendly staff! The Lodge is a quick walk to downtown Stowe and the Lodge…read moreitself has a very rustic feel with a great outdoor space and a fire pit to hangout by and have a drink!

We thoroughly enjoyed our stay at The Lodge tucked away in Bedford in a big cozy log house. Both…read moreAbbott and Christina were excellent and friendly hosts. The room was very comfortable with a really nice shower. Our hosts told us about all the activities in the area and made suggestions for local restaurants. Our stay was very peaceful and the wooded grounds were great for walking.

The rooms are extremely small and provide only the bare minimum. While they were clean, the…read moreaccommodations did not justify the price, especially with the added housekeeping gratuity. If an emergency comes up and you need to leave early, don't expect much flexibility. Be sure to read the cancellation policy carefully before booking. I would recommend looking at other accommodations if possible.

Big bucks for bare bones. But the staff were exceptional, especially Elaine at the front desk…read more Roof top was nice. I like that they provide bikes, chairs, towels and umbrella. Room was tiny, one lamp, nothing in the bathroom except soap, shampoo and towels. No closet. No where to put bags. Everything had to sit on the floor. But clean.