Let's just say I won the potluck with this beautiful seafood platter. Thank you for putting it…read moretogether so quickly! It was perfect and such a treat!!

I just visited Coastal Bay Seafoods for the first time and will absolutely be back!…read more I picked up a big piece of cod, some oishii shrimp, smoked whitefish & salmon dips, homemade salmon wellingtons to bake at home and a shrimp Caesar salad for lunch. All of this was just over $100 and they were super nice and helpful too. She also showed me this beautiful piece of tuna that had just arrived - definitely will get some of that next time. Check them out!

One of the best selections of fresh seafood in Chicago. The family has been in business since 1955…read more Nobody has more knowledge. Always quality .

Great selection, super cool staff, and good prices ... I will definitely be going back again.read more

Well, this is an update to the review I made 4 years ago. Today was a better experience all around…read more We arrived around 2pm and it was not crowded at all. They added an enclosed outdoor seating area, Thats lets you enjoy the breeze or sun, but protects you from the rain. It used to be a tent, so this is definitely nicer. My wife and I were seated immediately. The server quickly brought us water and garlic bread. I really like that they give you 5 fairly big pieces of garlic bread for only two people. Nice touch. We were not in a hurry and couldn't decide what we wanted so we started with the calamari salad. $29, but it's huge and chock full of those calamari guys. Lettuce is always crisp and has everything I like in it (olives, eggs, carrots, artichoke, peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, and romaine lettuce). We were almost full just from the salad alone. I ordered a grouper sandwich (not fried), and my lovely wife ordered the Scottish salmon plate, which comes with potatoes and grilled vegetables. My sandwich came with coleslaw and fresh cut fries. They switched to fresh cut since my last visit, and this was an upgrade. My sandwich was great, and huge too. Could not finish it. Wife's meal was a humongous slab of salmon. The veggies now come on a smaller plate, but that's okay, given the size of the fish. Service was a tad slow, but like I said, we weren't in any hurry. Total tab was $100, with tax and that pesky 3% service fee. I really enjoyed the food and the ambiance. It's not a place I can go every week, but when I can splurge, and have a taste for fresh seafood, this is the best around.

I drove a long way to obtain fresh quality seafood from an independent vendor. I was so put off by…read morethe extremely unfriendly, nearly mean, service. The cashier was a jerk. I don't think I'll be back bc of that. I'll drive to a further fish market just to be treated w friendliness. Get a grip on the FOH staff. She might need a day off.

I am big on seafood and vegetables. This restaurant is not far from my house, so I decided to try…read moreit out. It's in a walk-up. They do not have tables for sit-down eating. I thought they had raw seafood that you could buy for your own cooking since I wanted shrimp to put in my gumbo. That's not the case, as they cook the raw food that's on display. I was under the impression that they were also a seafood market. I ordered baked catfish that came with corn, potatoes, and broccoli. I got the cajun seasoning on it. Tasted great and the portions were nice. I must admit that I'm bigger on sauces than I am on rubs and dustings. Service was not bad. It did take time since there was a steady flow of customers. They cook to order. If ever I don't want to do my own seafood boil, I may return.

I typically visit the location on woodlawn. This CCHills location was not as seasoned, some legs…read morewere overcooked and the shrimp was undercooked. It seemed as if they reheated the crab legs. Also called several times (4x) trying to place a phone order but no answer. The staff was friendly enough but forgot to provide me with lemon and the gave me old packages of cocktail sauce that tasted horrible. Going forward I will continue to patronize the Woodlawn location.

UPDATE ON MY REVIEW: I'm not sure if this place is under new management or what, but it has been…read moretwice I purchased a seafood pan and my corn was hard, sausages lazily cut up, a crazy amount of juice at the bottom and bland. It felt like my food was rushed. Fisherman's Island used to be my #1 and I mean My GO TO...When I go I spend bank, because what I want is not cheap. I am so disappointed.

Hmm, where to start. I ordered 2lbs of snow crab legs with sausage. When I opened the tray I had 2…read moreclusters of snow crab not 2lbs and no sausage. When I went to opening the crab legs there was no meat in them. If they would've weighted it which I assumed they did, they would've realized I wasn't receiving 2lbs of snow crab more like a pound of shell. A whole leg came with a half knuckle size of meat. Maybe they overcooked it, i dont know. They also wouldn't put any of the juice or boil in a separate container for dipping the crab meat. Most establishments charge you for sauce on the side which I was willing to pay for but the lady behind the counter refused. It was a very disappointing experience, and honestly they probably got these snow crab from a Costco or wherever they sell them in stores. If people are paying money for snow crab please ensure the snow crab has meat in them.

I'm not sure why it's taking me years to do this review however I've been going to seafood city…read moresupermarket since they opened this Chicago location years ago. When it first opened, it was great to see how bright and clean it was and to see all of the incredible stacked foods and items. However, over the years it's definitely been worn down a little bit and could use a new refresh. What has been good is that they really expanded some of the seating area as well as the seafood city Grill area and the food offerings. However even this is slightly inconsistent as far as what's available when it's open, etc. It's also great that this particular location also is able to build out some of the other additional vendors like the bakery by Valerio. Again, though, I wish there was a little bit more consistency and organization throughout. Parking lot is has been quite ample except during peak times. I really wish they would open one in the suburbs as well. The only major disappointing thing was I used to carry the best Chicharron by Saint Michaels and then they absolutely abused and price gouged the bags. And eventually they stopped carrying it. I however, have gone directly to the stores to purchase.

First time here. Very large variety of shops and the grocery store part was very busy. They have a…read morelarge variety of items to purchase and I will be back, if in the area.

Love everything I picked up! (Prime tomahawk, ground buffalo, ground pork). And very clean and…read moreorganized! I was in Costco asking for smaller portions and someone overheard me and told me to come here for great quality meat. Just moved here, so I was happy to find it! Especially because the grocery store is right across the street in West Loop. Super convenient and I got my best compliments cooking the meat from here! lol

I came here after hearing about it from a relative who works a few blocks away. It was near St…read more Paddy's day but we did not want corned beef. We got steaks, and some wrapped with bacon! I like how the store is organized by protein types. The staff was helpful but not intrusive. The prices were elevated but not ridiculous. I still usu go to regular grocery stores for meat, but for a special occasion or something different, I'd go back to Wild Fork.

The fried biscuits,5 for 10 for seven Customer service was awesome. Biscuits were brought to the…read morecar. When we were waiting for the food. Black on business on business that stay on business. Good was great

First time ordering and I was a little disappointed my broccoli was jus plain nasty wasn't cooked…read morecorrectly nor my potatoes . The shrimp n crab legs were decent and my lobster tail was a lil iffy tbone steak def was tasty jus DRY! Potatoes wedges was a waste so over cooked and dried out. Baked potatoes seemed like they were good but as well dry even with the sour cream and all that liquid on the bottom . Still have to try the fried chicken I'm hoping that don't disappoint me .