We had a great trip with Captain Mike. He was very friendly and knowledgeable and had a good day…read moreoverall. Would recommend.

While there was nothing wrong with the boat or the captain, this is just a horrible company. To…read morebegin with, their prices are 2-3x equivalent boats in Mediterranean or St. Barths. Secondly, they have an absurd cancelation policy - there are no refunds regardless of weather and they're incredibly rude about it. If it rains and THEY cancel (which they won't decide til the day of), they still won't give you a refund and insist that you must rebook for a different date. I've never heard of such a thing anywhere. Not everyone lives in the Hamptons all summer. Thirdly, they have nothing on board - no towels, no sunscreen, nothing except water. Someone needs to start another boat company in the Hamptons to give this company some actual competition. It's just such an inferior boat rental product to anything we've experienced anything else.

Just finished my FIFTH trip with Sailacat and it keeps getting better every time! Capt Cal and…read moreBrian are the absolute best! My personal favorite is to take a longer afternoon sail, then catch sunset on the way back. Love all the water toys (esp the floating bar!), then just chillaxing on the deck & bean bag chairs...seems like every year there's something new! Thank you both for everything as always, and will start counting down to the next time!

We were guests on Captain Kal & Brian's catamaran recently…read morecelebrating our friend's birthday ~ and we are still glowing! We dined and celebrated on their gorgeous boat, relaxed on deck in yachting bean bags, enjoyed paddle boarding and watching the glorious sunset. Captain Cal & Brian made this such a memorable experience. We can't wait to do this again! Susan S. & Mitch

A beautiful sail on Saturday the fourth, and the chance to experience it with a wmll tuned first…read morerate crew. At first they went in search of enough wind to sail, and we ended the cruise racing it to stay clear of impending storms.

Hands down the best thing to do on the North Fork. Erick, Hannah and Christian took 8 of us out…read moresailing for several hours on the schooner Bonnie Lynn, and it made for the most memorable, vibrant and relaxing time. Bonnie Lynn is an incredible boat, with Erick and Hannah the perfect hosts. I can't think of a better way to introduce people to, and share with them, the beauty of the North Fork. We cannot wait for next time, and neither should you.

This was a very interesting and relaxing two hour cruise…read more I surprised my wife with a sunset cruise hosted by Bedell Winery. The cruise had 3 offerings of their specialty wines, a nice red, white and sparkling wine along with all you can each shrimp and freshly shucked oysters. If you couldn't consume shellfish, they offered a charcuterie box from Mamma Lombardis. Pretty nice offerings Bedell! Parking was easy peasy, the train station lot had plenty of available parking. Once we boarded, we each grabbed a wine glass and headed to the upper deck. My wife, looking so elegant in her summer dress, it was just a perfect night for a romantic cruise on Long Island. You don't have to call me late for dinner, I saw the crew carrying the oyster aft (that's the back of the boat for you non sailing Yelpers) I grabbed a plate and loaded up with a nice amount of shrimp with cocktail sauce as well as oysters. Ever try sail while trying to keep cocktail sauce off my white silk Tommy Bahama shirt? I did it because I have mad skill. I noticed the couple next to me, I made small talk with the guy. This woman, she must of eaten 2 dozen oysters! And I dig that! Enjoy yourself, don't hold back. I had about 6 oysters, a good amount of shrimp and a quite a few glasses of Bedell wines. The captain of the boat did something very cool. He brought the ship very close to lighthouse for a perfect picture spot. Could this night get any better? Here's where and I hope Bedell reads this review. You have the perfect opportunity to talk to all the guests and sell your winery! There should of been bottles of the wine we tasted for sale as well as baskets filled with wines & cheeses, raffles to come back to the vineyard for a tasting, shirts, glasses, Bedell things for sale. It sounds like you need me to take over this area of responsibility. ABC, always be closing. Wine is for closers! The guy pouring the wine was swamped with everyone at once saying: Gimme! A back up sales person, a closer would have sealed the deal. Other than that, if you see The Peconic Star offering sunset cruises, it's something I highly recommend.

My first time fishing in years. Had a great time. It's nice that they only take one half capacity…read more Captain and crew knew their stuff. Coming back soon. I wish they would add some 1/2 day trips. They wore this old timer out.

Perfect spot to rent a hobie car sailboat for an hour on Fort Pond. Remember they are cash-only!…read moreYou can leave your essentials at the front desk with he friendly staffer. We had no trouble getting one mid-day Friday, and the weather cooperates with a nice wind. $50 might seem steep, but it was worth it for the 3 of us to get out on the water and for my daughter to learn how to captain. The dude at the dock made sure my wife could control the boat and gave us a little guidance, then we were on our way to some light sailing fun. Most boat rentals in Montauk seem to be for bigger or motorized craft, so look for what suits you.

Played a game of crazy gold with the kids and then rented a hobie cat and sailed around the lake-…read moreloads of fun. What a great place! Reasonable prices.

Had a fantastic time with a last minute charter. If you are interested in having a great trip…read moreOn the Montauk waters you will Be well Served giving these guys a call.

I have been all over Montauk on trips. These guys do it right! Everyone had fish on! Mario and Joe…read moremade the experience even better! Great personalities. Thank you guys very much. See you next summer

The captain Charlie was so accommodating to my family! The mate Joe was so friendly and helpful! He…read moremade sure we all caught plenty of fish! We had a great day of fishing!

I have been on this sport fishing trip 2 times and each time was great. I have caught more than 18…read moreshark and 1 mahi mahi. Charlie the caption and Sean are very helpful and want you to enjoy every moment that you can. Everything is clean and they help 110%. Learning how to fish out there is incredible. Just keep yourself outside learning to rock with the boat is the best advice. I will always come back and fish with you guys. Thank you for the T-Shirt. You guys are very professional and you guys love what you do. I do recommend trying Alyssa Ann out. 5 STAR

Outstanding marina. Clean shop with plenty of inventory from fishing to boating supplies. Helpful…read morestaff and professionally run.

We had reservations to stay for 4 nights. On Tuesday Morning (the day we planned to arrive) we…read morechecked the weather and tropical storm Fay was approaching Long Island and the Ocean Conditions were expected to be very rough along with heavy rain on Friday and Saturday. For safety reasons we needed to cancel. I knew I would lose my Deposit from my initial reservation back from January 22 of $195. We had 4 boats traveling together. The Montauk Boat Basin charged us the full amount of the trip plus the deposit stating that the Weather was not poor enough to give a full refund. No alternatives or options were provided. Fire Island Ferry cancelled trips on Friday in the bay because of conditions Due To Tropical Storm Fay - July 10th. There were also a small craft advisory for the route home. Fire Island Inlet NY to Moriches Inlet NY out 20 nm- 4:37 AM EDT Sat Jul 11 2020 SMALL CRAFT ADVISORY IN EFFECT THROUGH MONDAY MORNING. TODAYS winds 15 to 20 kt with gusts up to 25 kt. Seas 6 to 8 ft. Slight chance of showers early this morning. I guess you would need it to be a Hurricane for the weather conditions to be considered poor enough for marine travel to be dangerous. I am sure it is a beautiful place but we needed to make a decision based on the safety of our passengers and boats. This was the response to My question via email: from Montauk Marine Basin: My policy applies to the entire stay similar a hotel stay. I have a full marina and i blocked off those slips for Four boats and turned other boats away. The weather was not poor enough to give a full refund. I am sorry that you interpreted my policy that way. You canceled the day of the start of your stay I'm sorry, but I will not be giving you a refund. If the Montauk Boat Basin is willing to work with us I would retract this review but I had made every effort to no avail at this point of time.