huge fan of this establishment. hot and cold lobster rolls are both exquisite, oysters are cold and…read morefresh, and the chowder was the best i've had in the island. service was amazing, everyone was so kind, and there is seating outside around the corner which was perfect! this is the kind of place you want to go back again and again to try everything on the menu

Best fish sandwich on the island! Delicious fresh seafood. When you visit Martha's Vineyard, make…read moresure you go to Menemsha Fish Market. You'll be glad you did!

I stopped by Larsen's Fish Market while visiting Martha's Vineyard, and had to try the lobster…read moreroll. It was loaded with big, fresh chunks of lobster meat, and I loved that the lobster was really the star of the show. No need for a bunch of extras when the seafood is this fresh. I also really enjoyed the casual experience of grabbing my food and eating outside near the water. Nothing fancy, just fresh seafood, beautiful surroundings, and a very New England/Martha's Vineyard kind of experience. Definitely worth a stop if you're in Menemsha and love lobster!

I just don't get what the hype is about. We stopped here before going to the beach. Got two hot…read moreLobster Rolls and an order of Lobster Mac and cheese. The Lobster rolls were just OK. If anything, was disappointed and the bottom of the buns were soggy before even putting on some melted butter. The Lobster mac and cheese was just awful. I would not call that mac and cheese. While I did not order anything from the fresh fish side, it did look very fresh and nice and clean. I would not get food from them again but would purchase some fresh seafood there and go home and cook it myself.

My girlfriend and I got a large cone dipped in cherry and a large hot fudge sundae and felt like it…read morewas skimp. The large sundae didn't even fill the large cup that it was in. The total for the two was around $25

As the name implies, this is a down to earth food provider. The best item is their basic lobster…read moreroll (which contains a sizable amount of fresh and tasty lobster meat. The other items are good but not exceptional. Had the crab cake side order (two cakes) which were mostly crab meat. Another good benefit is that the view from the back (dining area) is picturesque

Fried clams with bellies are some of my favorite New England foods, and I order them whenever I'm…read morein the area. Unfortunately, these were some of the worst fried clams I've had. The fried clams were $31 with no sides, and the plate contained only 3-4 actual clams. The rest was just pieces of fried batter. I've attached a photo because I couldn't believe this was considered a full order. I asked the employee at the counter if this was the normal portion size. She shrugged and said she didn't know, so I asked if there was a manager I could speak with. The manager came out, offered a refund, took the plate back, and then slammed the door behind her. I later asked another employee whether I would actually be getting the refund, and she also shrugged and said she didn't know, adding that the manager would come find me. She never did. I ended up ordering a chicken wrap instead, which was fine, but the overall experience was disappointing. I understand Martha's Vineyard is expensive, but charging $31 for what amounted to a few fried clams and a pile of batter is ridiculous.

I can't believe I haven't reviewed this restaurant before since I've been coming for a number of…read moreyears. The format has changed (regular menu, to prix fix, back to regular) so this is based on my August 2026 visit, with a few photos from 2025 thrown in. As usual, the setting is spectacular with a beautiful view of the sunset. We sat outside, and it was perfect. Service was attentive and friendly.Started with some oysters on the half-shell (delicious but expensive) and shrimp cocktail (by the piece, and so good.) I started with the green gazpacho, which a friend had before on the set menu. It is so good, refreshing and different. Loved it. Then I had the crispy skin fish, and it was amazing. SO good! My husband had the clam chowder, which he loves and the lobster salad, which was refreshing and delicious. Others had the scallops and everyone was really happy with their meal. It's a little pricey, however it is BYOB which greatly cuts down on the final bill! And the delicious cornbread is complimentary now. There is a parking lot.

Good setting but notoriously bad food and weird service. Not on the level of State Road or Chilmark…read moreTavern.

Have been here a few times over the years, and it has been re-done to be more cas,…read moreupscale-barn-esque. It still has one of the best sunset spots so reserve early to get a spot with a view during sunset. The menu seemed sparse, and nothing sounded major but let me tell you everything we had was really very good. 4 os us split 2 entrees & 3 apps. Lobster toast was amazeballs, cheeses, salad & oysters. Chicken & fish special (was it bass?) were delish perfectly cooked & bursting with flavor.

This was a great restaurant with an outdoor covered patio. Our server was personable and attentive…read more For my drink, I got the Cucumber Cosmo which was refreshing and really good and my friend enjoyed his Blueberry Mule. We both ordered the Lobster Rolls with butter which was absolutely amazing. It was a large sandwich with plenty of meat - so tasty! Great spot for delicious lobster rolls and great drinks.

OMG...we waited OVER AN HOUR for this lobster roll, and somehow I'm still going to tell you it was…read moreworth it. I typically do not believe in waiting that long for food, but Lookout Tavern got me with this one. The lobster roll was AMAZING. The lobster was juicy, fresh, and plentiful--they are not playing around with the portions. You get these huge lumps of claw meat, and the toasted bun was perfect. Honestly, this lobster roll and a nice drink are all you need for the day. I could literally eat here every day I'm on the island. They have both indoor and outdoor seating, which is nice, especially during the summer. Just know that if you're visiting Martha's Vineyard during peak season, the wait can be LONG. We waited more than an hour, so plan accordingly. Would I normally wait an hour for a lobster roll? Absolutely not. Would I do it again for this one? Yep. HIGHLY recommend.

The Net Result came highly recommended for a tasty lobster roll. It was a little busy when we…read morearrived but service was fast. Inside there is a fresh seafood market, freshly made sushi and a counter to order hot food - including burgers, fish and chips, etc. There is a cooler with drinks, ToGo food, fresh sushi desserts and other goodies. You can get a sautéed lobster roll (hot) or a chilled regular lobster roll (mayo based). I went with the sautéed version along with a cup of clam chowder. Others in my party ordered fried oysters, and fried shrimp. My lobster roll was good but the bread was a bit dry. Not sure if it was coated with butter (if so, it was a little dry but not a deal breaker.) The roll was packed with meat and was filling. The clam chowder was filled with lots of actual clams. Overall my food was good and it's worth a visit. I would recommend a visit.

Food was great, prices fair, service not great. 6 employees stood around in a circle talking to…read moreeach other while we waited to order - we were inconveniencing them for sure and I felt completely ignored. Would go back for food, but if the service was better, I'd recommend to others

No big update, just popping in to say the restaurant is still great, the service is still friendly…read moreand the chicken is still delicous!

One of our "Go To" spots. Exceptional service, personable wait staff and always delicious. Very…read moreenjoyable and the sundae is a family favorite!

Sandy's Fish & Chips is the neighborhood favorite, IYKYK…read more They have delicious fish sandwiches and in season whole softshell crab sandwiches - a must try, my favorite. The oysters, come in a lovely gold metal container, that is easy to transport to your local or to an outing or event on the island. Prices are very reasonable as well. They' share the same space with John's Fish Market. My last order was pretty large and they kindly accommodated.

The food is always fresh with large portions. The customer service is efficient and accurate. Don't…read moreconfuse the lack of a loud cheerful greetings with an unfriendly staff. The staff is usually busy and working hard. If you engage them in conversation they will reply with smiles and laughter. The owner John is usually there working in the back. There is also a small soft serve ice cream bar there.

We enjoyed great service, the outdoor seating, and the cocktails…read more Chips and guac/pico: The guacamole was really good! That was eaten almost immediately. The pico needed salt (was the consensus). Baja bowl w/ steak: This was fine, nothing very special or unique, just solid. I would have preferred bit more steak, but otherwise this was a good non fish option. Carne asada tacos: These are decent tacos but they aren't going to blow your socks off. The hot sauce helped a lot. The rest of my party really emjoyed their Poke bowls, lobster rolls, oysters, and shrimp tacos Churros: Two dipping sauces and three extra long church's were really good! I also liked the ice cream with it. Key lime pie: This was very good key lime pie! Someone in my party prefers theirs almost frozen (crazy) but this was silky and not overly sweet.

Ordered for takeout and I guess they forgot to charge me, they hung up the phone at order and sent…read moreme away at pickup... Didnt even occur to me until they left me a voicemail, then proceeded to call me SEVEN TIMES within a day *even though I already said I would come take care of it* instead if accepting their mistake as a loss. A two-appetizer order cost FIFTY DOLLARS and the harassment was priceless. Will not be coming here again