This is our local spot and it's the best! Terrific pizza and pastas. Today, I'm going for something different: Hot Dog All The Way With Fries. Yum!!! read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - March 2026 Menu - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

2/22/24 Thursday night trivia was fun. Pizza was good. Thin crust and just right on the red sauce. We ordered a 14" supreme (hold the green peppers). It came out with Pepperoni, mushrooms, onion and sausage. I think they forgot the black olives? See picture. Still tasted good though. The beers were nice and cold and they had a fair selection. Our group was able to put the two big high tops together and we could seat 10 comfortably. Service was good and friendly. Good pizza and beer joint and I do recommend. Want to try the calzone next time we come! read more

See all

Neat place right in the heart of town. Easy parking out front and friendly service inside. Ordered fried mushrooms as an appetizer (wished they offered horseradish sauce) and a calzone for lunch. Mmmmm. Food was very good, ample portions, and piping hot. Good value, too. Has my "Give 'em a whirl" meter begging me for seconds. Nom, nom, nom here! read more

See all

Arrived at 11 am, but there was no pizza ready for slices, so a 20-minute wait no matter how I went, slices or whole. Disappointed that at noon, when I was leaving, there were no cinnamon rolls ready, they weren't started until 11 am. I don't understand a pizza business that sells slices of pizza and opens at 11, but doesn't have any slices ready to go when the doors open. And I asked about cinnamon rolls when ordering shortly after 11 am, but was not told they wouldn't be ready until after lunch! Very disappointing on the service front. Here's the rest of the review. Good pizza. I got a small with pepperoni, sausage, and onion. The sausage was excellent, spicy and flavorful. The crust was thin, but not super-thin, and carried the generous portion of sauce and toppings with ease. The decor is basic, but lots of red/black as one might expect. Paper plates and styrofoam cups, but okay, cleanup is easier. I'm not sure I'd drive from Columbia again, but if I'm ever out here again, I will definitely stop for another pizza. Note: the address listed on Yelp is incorrect. They are in a new location on S Palmer Street, in view of the old building. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Small pizza with pepperoni, sausage, and onions - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

See all

Got the Miles to Race sub, toasted and "Sarah's Way" and what else can I say but WOW! They didn't skimp out on the protein, and it was great. The staff were very friendly, and answered a few questions I had politely. The music was playing loud enough to hear it, but not so loud that you have to yell to hear whomever you may bring with you. Prices were fair as well. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Miles to Race - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

I love love love their pizza! Sausage is cooked and prepared exactly the way I like it! Owners and staff are friendly and attentive to customers. read more

Good pizza! The sauce had a nice flavor, although the crust could be just a little crisper. Fast and friendly service, pleasant atmosphere, drink refills offered without even asking, and the food was ready very quickly. So glad we found this little gem in an unfamiliar town. read more

We were so excited to come back to this restaurant, but this time it was disappointing. The cheeseburger was pretty dried out and the pizza crust was very card board-y. Maybe we hit a bad day this time. :( read more

I did not care for the slice of pizza I was served when I ordered a single slice to go. Slices are not ready ahead of time they have to be made and can be ordered like a regular pizza, the price includes up to 3 toppings. I dint realize this before ordering but figured it would just come with lots of cheese. It was sparsely covered at best. I did not like the taste of the heavy handed sauce, it tasted like tomato paste from a can more than anything else. I also ordered some cinnamon rolls to bring home for the kids. Will update when I get the review from them. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Cute little store front. Looking forward to some pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

I liked the area, nice small town feel, but that was about it. The pizza was average. My service was bad. I had to go ask for refills the first time, to have my table cleared after the appetizer, threw some of my own trash away just to clear some room, and got little to no interaction from the server. It was nearly an hour before we got our food. I'm all for either fast or friendly service, at least give me one of the two, but I got neither. The owner, or who I believe was the owner, was friendly, but our server could use some training. I usually will say something like "it wasn't bad" when asked about the experience, but it was such a negative experience that I accidentally blurted out "it wasn't that great" when I got asked at the counter. Unfortunate because I love the area and wanted a good experience. read more

This pizza is soooo good!!! We have about 5 pizza places near where we live in NE Columbia but this place is totally worth the 15 min drive. Food is so delicious and the service is phenomenal. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

If you love pizza like I do and you are close to Ridgeway, SC; do yourself a favor and stop in for a slice or a pie! They make a pie for me that is called "The Michael T Special" and it is delicious. The toppings are: pepperoni (extra), sausage, meatballs, onion, black olives and mushrooms. I can honestly say that Sarah and George make one of the best pies I have ever tasted. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - "The Michael T Special" - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

I placed an advanced online order giving the restaurant one hour to prepare my order. I received a confirmation text and a text right at 5:50 (the time I requested for pick up) saying my order was ready. But when I went inside, it's clear that my order was never made because she printed my receipt and walked towards the open kitchen where orders were being made. I could not see her (the owner) but saw everyone else in the kitchen directing their attention to her. My receipt was then hung on the wall with an "R"... maybe code for rush. Then one of the kitchen staff grabbed one of four boxes out of their refrigerator that was facing the sitting area where I was waiting. Within 5-7 minutes my pizza was done. She opened the box and the cheese was nothing like their online photos. Just white and melty, not brown and bubbly. Some concerns now started going through my head. I asked if this is how their pizzas always come out of the oven, where earlier i mentioned "hey don't let them rush it too much I drove a good way for this pizza". She said yes, that she had to put some extra cheese on top because it was short on cheese. Hmmmmm....... Interesting. She offered to put it back in the oven but I declined, knowing I could heat it in the broiler when I got back home 25 min away. I put my pizza in the car, and then went back inside and raised my concerns. Was completely up front and said "so after your cheese comment that had me thinking... I saw the girl get a box out of your fridge. I sure hope this wasn't a pizza from earlier today that just had new cheese and mushrooms added on top". The owner said "oh no, we don't ever have pizzas made ahead. But I can tell that you are not happy so let me refund you." Once I got home and was pre-heating the oven, I decided to dissect my pizza a bit... and was able to peel off the obviously added on white, melted cheese on top, along with my mushrooms. AH HA! And just as I suspected, underneath was a cheese a pepperoni pizza (I did order mushrooms and pepperoni).... With nice brown and bubbly cheese. I'm honestly disgusted and could not even finish my piece because the more I thought about it the sicker I felt. Here's a photo, you be the judge.... And I know that this could happen anywhere, anytime... but I saw it with my own eyes. Luckily I have been refunded as promised within the hour. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

Sarah-N-Gio's is a nice addition to Ridgeway. The pizza and subs is good! Things I've tried and would recommend: pizza (pick your own toppings), meatball sub, and turkey sub. Call ahead so your order be ready. There is no inside seating, just picnic tables in the screened area. The staff is very polite, warm, and very friendly. read more

See all

The food is great! The supreme pizza had the perfect amount of toppings. The restaurant is clean and well maintained. The absolute best part of the visit was the people. They were extremely friendly and would go out of their way to get you whatever you wanted/need. Highly recommend this restaurant for anyone to visit. read more

We were on our way home from vacation and were hungry for a late lunch. We found Sarah and Geo's online with excellent reviews, and prefer independent restaurants over chains, so we decided to stop in. We found a restaurant that was well deserving of their very high ratings, not only for the friendly and competent service, the impeccably clean facility and restrooms, but also for the delicious food with such a wide variety of choices. I would definitely recommend trying the fried portobello mushrooms which were indescribably delicious as well as the garlic knots which would have been right at home on a table at any fine dining establishment. We also enjoyed mozzarella sticks, an exceptionally good pizza with pepperoni and sausage, and my husband's favorite of all, a sausage calzone that was well filled with delicious sausage and cheese. We took half of it home and enjoyed leftover calzone and pizza for breakfast this morning. If you are anywhere in the area, I would highly recommend you plan for an excellent meal at Sarah and Geo's and make sure you bring your appetite. Even if you aren't in the area, it's worth trip to get there. Also make sure you get a pan of their cinnamon rolls to take home with you. I can guarantee they'll be the best you've ever had. My compliments to the owners and employees, for an exceptional dining experience. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Sausage calzone - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

See all

The food was fantastic. It may take a little bit longer because it is made fresh lots of good options and the atmosphere was nice the garlic knots and white pizza are to die for a great place to stop The people were super nice. read more

I'm picky when it comes to pizza, but there are limited options where I live and we were nearby for the Alpaca Experience so we decided to order some pizza on the way home. I love pld gas stations and the building is a really neat vintage 30s gas station and it's set up well for carry out and there are a few tables to eat there. We ordered the cheese pizza and we ordered a second pizza with a bunch of toppings to include sausage onions and olives. The toppings are flavorful and they were fairly generous with them. The crust was appropriately thin and perfect for folding over. My biggest critique would be the sauce. It could've used a little bit more flavor. I think that would've really made this excellent pizza. Definitely will go back though! We ordered the garlic knots and they probably won't do that again. They were soggy and had a little too much garlic on them. It was probably just that particular order. This is definitely a fantastic place for the area. They do deliver to parts of Blythewood and Ridgeway. read more

Found this place by chance while driving through and so glad we did. I enjoyed the meatball sub while my husband revisited childhood memories with a chicken tender sub with mayo and buffalo sauce. We through in a cannoli for good measure. We enjoyed hearing Geo share car repair tips with a customer waiting for a delicious lunch, this place obviously cares about their customers. The dog friendly patio sealed the deal. read more

Our lunch group of six went here today for the first time. Nice place with good seating. We put two tables together and went up to the counter to place our order. Five of us ordered pizzas and one ordered a sub sandwich. We ordered 1 pizza with the white garlic sauce rather than the red pizza sauce, 1 order for a cheese pizza, 1 meat lover pizza and 1 medium cheese, bacon, sausage, pepperoni, mushroom and onion pizza. The pizzas all came out very hot and were good. The cheese pizza seemed to have a very thin crust, as were all of them, but it seemed thinner than the rest. Everyone thought the pizzas were good. The person ordering the white garlic sauced pizza had never seen that before and really liked it....said he'd order it again. The cheese pizza person said he liked it but had reservations on the crust. I've had better sauce, but my pizza was good. Good pull on the cheese. Crust was crisp and fine. The person ordering the sub sandwich said it was good, nothing special over any other sub sandwich he had. Service was good. Atmosphere good and had a great smell of pizza when we walked in! read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

See all

Small building with make-shift covered patio for dining. Very kind staff that guided us through local favorites. Tried garlic knots, pizza deluxe, pep pizza, and a chef salad. Everything was better than just good, and the price was right too. Would def come back if I happen to be around. read more

Sarah-N-Geo's - Garlic knots!! - Pizza Near Me - Ridgeway, South Carolina

See all

Yummy!! My 10" Meaty Pizza was very good and my wife's Italian sub was fantastic! Thanks to Yelp, we were able to find a new, nearby great place to eat at. I can't wait until the next time we visit to try something else off the menu-hopefully soon. Definitely worth the trip! read more

Best pizza in the area. Friendly people and good prices. Sarah and George have done wonders for Fairfield County eating.

Pizza was delicious!! While we were picking up our pizza I noticed they had fresh stuffed cannoli and I couldn't resist, soooo happy I ordered it because it's the best I've had that wasn't home made. 10/10 will be ordering again. read more

The best pizza! We love to go there and watch Sarah make pizza. Her Garlic pizza is my favorite. The service is excellent. Try it out

We love this little gem! They have made to order pizzas, subs, salads and calzones (our favorite!). The food is delicious and the owners are right there and are so nice. They have picnic tables outside on a screened porch when you get out of the car the whole area smells delicious! I actually think this building used to be a gas station and now it's been converted into a neighborhood pizza restaurant, what a neat atmosphere. read more

Best place to eat in the area. We love the pizza there. Always freshly made not a warehouse pizza.

This pizza parlor is very true to an old fashioned pizza parlor! The staff is exceptional, the food is delightful! No matter where you are in SC, when you are in the mood for pizza - THIS pizza place is well worth the trip! read more

Had large pizza and meatball sub for the family last night for the first time. Incredible!! Best pizza I've had in SC! You can tell it's made with the best ingredients and people who know what they're doing! Can't wait to return! God bless you all! read more