This was beyond any expectations I could have imagined for any pizzeria outside of NY. Sami's in Smithfield was AMAZING!!!! To begin I will state I received exceptional customer service! Though this is not so much a traditional restaurant they were happy to serve and wait on us. The set up is on par with any pizzeria in NY. They step it up with a small bar in the back! Though I didn't sit at the bar I'd definitely be tempted to go again and check it out. The garlic bread and marinara sauce was a pleasant appetizer that set the tone for the meal. It set my hopes up for a delightful dinner and it did not disappoint. The pizza was such a surprise. I was so excited to find a pizza that I could compare to true NY pizza! During the course of our meal, we found out Sami is from New Jersey and so understands exactly what a pizza should taste like. The delicious dinner made me decide to delight myself in a cannoli. I was remiss to share with my son. The filling was divine. The perfect mix of sugar and ricotta, sweet without being overly so to still enjoy the flavor of the ricotta. The North may have won the war but Sami may have just helped them even the score on the battle for best pizza. How do you spell pizza in North Carolina? S A M I' S An underrated little gem read more

Massimo Pizza - Garlic bread with marinara sauce - Pizza Near Me - Smithfield, North Carolina

See all

My guest and I stopped in for a drink and some "hot honey pepperoni pizza." The service was fast and friendly. I forgot her name, the young lady provided amazing service and was able to help guide us of places to visit. The ambience was inviting and quiet....as I'm sure we may have been the first customers of the day. Sorry o don't have a picture, but the hot honey pepperoni pizza was satisfying. read more

Great food great service great experience the place pizza Wolfe you would go to the pizza is the best pizza I ever ate.

Pizza by the slice or pie. A little on the expensive side, but everything is these days. Best pizza I've found in the immediate area and will return for sure. read more

Excellent pizza that is tossed and made with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Good selection of items on the menu. Pizza by the slice is an option. My family goes there weekly. The staff are friendly and helpful. The restaurant is small with a bar at the rear. read more

You'd never expect a good pie in this part of North Carolina...but this place has some terrific pizza. I have only had their pizza, but their menu boasts a number of other options that shouldn't be ignored. To me...a pizza snob...you have to have the right flavored sauce, a reasonably thin crust, pepperoni (the right way), and enough cheese...not too much cheese. This place gets it. They have a very good mix of all the integral ingredients that make pizza really good. If you are out this way and want some pizza, ded check it out read more

This is the best pizza in NC! Coming from Tri-state Area this place checks all of the boxes for absolute best local pizza shop

Samis is pretty good pizza and they make their own bread there.. The garlic bread is pretty legit and full of flavor The Chicken alfredo was ehhhhh not alot of sauce or flavor and chicken was a bit overcooked... the zitti wasnt bad but couldve been better. I think the specialty for Samis is their pizza and garlic bread... The pizza sauce was good and their crust is pretty good... So I think I will just stick with ordering the pizza and garlic bread from here... maybe will try one of their subs in the future. read more

Exceeded my expectations for being a little dive. The pizza was delicious and so was the garlic bread! read more

Massimo Pizza - Meat lovers pizza - Pizza Near Me - Smithfield, North Carolina

See all

Came in on a recommendation while venturing out for the 301 yard sale. A couple ladies I came across recommended this place and it was the perfect place to end our day! As soon as we walked in the door, we were immediately greeted! I love that about a place! It was empty when we arrived, which was great, because were starved! I ordered the Antipasto Salad with the Balsamic dressing it came with and the Pepperoni Stromboli with mushroom and onion. My sister-in-law had the garden salad and a spinach, garlic and ham Calzone. It was all absolutely delicious! The owners were so friendly and easy to talk to. I loved that the wife was so friendly! If you're venturing out to Smithfield, you have to eat here! It did not take forever at all. I would say, the portions are huge, so sharing is a great idea, unless you want to take home left overs, which I was happy to do so. I would absolutely eat here again! read more

Massimo Pizza - Antipasto Salad with Balsamic Vinaigrette - Pizza Near Me - Smithfield, North Carolina

See all

Great real Italian good , great service , clean. Just what Downtown Smithfield needed . Love this place

The service is great, the food is even better. Stopped by for a Buick dinner. Pizza is awesome

Best pizza in Smithfield just like New York style first time and more to come can't wait to try the buffalo chicken read more

Massimo Pizza - Pepperoni pizza just like back home in jersey - Pizza Near Me - Smithfield, North Carolina

Great food, friendly people. Quality & quantity at a great price! The best place to go in N.C. for Italian food. GO NOW! The lasagna is so flavorful. The pizza can't be beat. I plan on trying every single meal on the menu. read more

I've yet to be disappointed by anything I've had from here. Everything is delicious and the pizza is amazing. Big big slices,Like a New York style pizza. I stop in and get something almost every time I'm in town. They do sell by the slice. Which has gotten me in trouble a couple times when going in for lunch because the pizza looks and taste soo good I get more than I could eat. Great people who work the counter and the oven/kitchen. Overall one of my favourite places to eat and possibly the best pizza in Smithfield. read more

Recommend not going to this restaurant bad customer service issues with making simple pizzas, read more

See all

the only time they have patience for you is if your white, especially the lady who takes your order

White pizza is really good. It wasn't greasy and the cheese was perfect. I grew up with Jersey and NY pizza for what's it's worth.

They make the best pizza around. If you want a Great Italian pizza, Sami's is the place to go. I highly recommend Sami's. I would have given them a 5 star but I was a little unhappy with the last time I was in there. Week of 7/20/2020. NO ONE WAS WEARING MASKS. That is unsatisfactory. Every restaurant should be wearing a mask due to the (COVID-19) read more

Tonight was my first time ordering from Sami's Pizza & Sub's. I was definitely not disappointed. I called last week asking some questions about the food and pricing. The lady who answered the phone was very polite and very helpful. She was happy to assist me with any questions I had. Sadly we ended up going with a more familiar pizza place because I was unsure of Sami's and Angelo's was just plain rude. So pizza night came around again and I definitely called Sami's. Again the lady (sorry I don't remember your name) who answered the phone was super kind and happy to take my order. I called around 6:10pm and She told me it would be about 40-45 minutes. They arrived before 7pm. I don't believe they were busy when I placed my order. Food smelled amazing upon arrival. Just a suggestion... Maybe invest into some pizza bags that will keep the food hot. The food I received was not hot but was still satisfying. Definitely wasn't cold though. Overall customer service is a Winning! We will order for here again!! read more

Massimo Pizza - I ordered a Large pepperoni pizza. It was definitely better than Papa John's. - Pizza Near Me - Smithfield, North Carolina

See all

First place I've found in the area that serves sausage parmesan. Let me just say, I was doing a happy dance in my seat. That was my first visit. My second visit was pepperoni and sausage pizza, and a dozen wings. To die for, and yes, another happy dance. Being a northern transplant finding a place that has the NY style of pizza is a dream come true. I would also like to say, the staff is WONDERFUL! They make you feel like family. There are so many yummy things to choose, I can't wait for my next Sami's adventure. read more

Best pizza in Smithfield, but they have so much more! Great subs on house made bread, and the Philly steak is to die for. Love the atmosphere and everyone is super friendly. Excited for big things for them! read more

Massimo Pizza - Hawaiian and cheese slices - Pizza Near Me - Smithfield, North Carolina

When you use low quality ingredients on a pizza, it's very obvious. That's just a fact. They even use the tiny pepperonis like the ones you find on lunchables pizza. The crust was decent, maybe make the ovens hotter so it's crispier. And I got an "antipasto" salad which was iceberg lettuce and some very sad, stale and sparse toppings and a Pepperoncini stem, no actual pepper... looked like it had been bitten off. And they give you salad dressing in a single-serve pouch. What's even the point of having a restaurant if you don't care to feed your customers decent food? I was really hoping my side of Smithfield finally had their own nice pizza/italian place, too bad I got my hopes up. This place is awful. read more

Most delicious pizza in the area! Crust is perfect, sauce delicious and toppings are fresh... Sami's Pizza beats all others, HANDS-DOWN! Any pizza connoisseur should DEF stop by Sami's Pizza for a SLICE OF HEAVEN!!! If you've not tried it, you are MISSING OUT! read more

Smithfield has been long over due for a legitimate pizza place. After having dealt with papa johns and little caesar's mediocre pizza, it's nice to have some fresh homemade pie. I will warn you it is addictive especially during this virus lockdown. read more

Being that it's a Friday night, my husband nor I felt like cooking. So we decided to order our usual on nights like this....pizza and wings. We wanted something different, something we'd never had before, so we chose Sami's. After hearing many people say nothing but good things about this place, we decide to place an order. Apparently there was a misunderstanding about our selection of toppings because when the pizza was delivered it was just a plain cheese pizza. We ordered pepperoni and extra cheese. And again, things happen, I know this. But when I called to see what our options were, I spoke to the nice lady who originally took my order. I explained that it was probably just a misunderstanding and was placed on hold. The next voice I heard was I believe to be the owner. I was not rude, shouting or any of the sort. I then explained to him the situation, and his tone and response was truly unbelievable. I asked him a simple yes or no question and I was met with a very dry, unfriendly response in which I replied "it was just a yes or no question". Overall, the pizza was good but I don't appreciate being spoke to like that when I'm conducting business with anyone. Especially when I approach the situation in a respectful, friendly way. read more