Excellent pizza! Reminds me of pizza in NY. Excellent service and a small town vibe. We have only gotten take away.

You are supposed to be able to buy pizza by the slice. But at 6pm they had mostly empty pizza trays & just a few slices of older pizza sitting out. No common pizza either. Just some specialty kinds like mac n cheese. The customer in front of me asked if they would be putting out any more pizza, and they said no. He walked out without ordering, and so did I. read more

The pizza is awesome and the staff is also awesome. prices are pretty good too. I'll be back.

Great pizza for anyone wanting to try something with a bit of a more 'Personal Touch' in pizza menu's. The accessibility and layout of this place is top notch. Great location. Safe neighborhood. Big parking lot. Sidewalk-level entrance. I'm pleased in finding this gem of a business. read more

Ordered takeout the other day for a large 18" pizza. Huge pieces. A meal in a slice. Tasted great and reheated perfectly for an enjoyable lunch. My new favorite pizza in Hartford. read more

Best pizza in the area. Small place but there are a number of tables and booths if you want to eat there. They have large slices (yes slices as pizza should be cut) with anything from traditional pepperoni to the more unique mac and cheese pizza. The garlic knots are also very good too. The people working there have always been friendly and accommodating to what we may need. read more

My husband said since we don't have Poads any longer if anything happens to Sal's we are moving! Seriously though this is good NY style pizza. read more

Good pizza and not a bad price. Great after a day/night at Little Switzerland. Would return.

The pizza is deliciously crisp and tasty. We love it as our go-to. My son also loves their chicken Parmesan. Huge portions and good prices.

Good for a quick slice at Lunch. Was driving through town and wanted to support a local biz. Very friendly. Solid slice. Will be back for sure when I am in the area! read more

Love their pizza. Could eat it all day every day. My daughter won't normally eat pizza but she loves their Mac and cheese pizza. Garlic knots are also delish. read more

The food is so good! The service is spectacular. At first I only ordered their pizza's. Later I thought I would be adventurous and try their spaghetti. Holy guacamole, it was better than mine!!! Now I am hooked on their Philly cheesesteaks, they are a little bit on the pricey side for the size... but its worth it. The people who work there are friendly and hardworking. read more

Sal's has been our go-to place for pizza over the past few years. Through a pandemic & staffing shortage, the definitely do not disappoint. Thank you for your hard work. Your teamwork, patience and professionalism does not go unnoticed. We will be back. read more

Excellent Italian food ,new york style pizza with huge servings and delicious salads and garlic knots.relaxed atmosphere and pizza by the slice available .family friendly read more

I was sure I reviewed this place a few years ago and gave it high marks. But my old review is gone. Isn't that odd. I came back here to update my last review because a recent visit to Sal's was less than satisfying. Basically what once was a pretty good pizza here was just so so. They have a good crust but the pizza wasn't very flavorful and didn't have the quantity and size of toppings I would like. The garlic knots didn't have any garlic taste that I could notice. It was like eating plain bread dunked in bland tasting tomato sauce. So another decent pizza place has lowered their ingredient quality and become like so many other pizza places before them. read more

Don't get food from here unless you want Covid! I ordered food from them, but when I went to pick it up none of the cooks making the food we're wearing masks or gloves. They also weren't enforcing customers to wear masks either. read more

Not sure what to think of this place. I ordered online, then went over to the restaurant. I told them I ordered online and everyone was kind of just standing around and I didn't see any computers around, so I wasn't sure how they were going to see what I ordered (I now learned from the other reviewer on here that the order is faxed to them from the web site...how odd!). They found my order and said it would be about 10 minutes. I ordered some hot wings with dipping sauce and an antipasto salad. This place is small and there really isn't any good waiting area, which seems odd for a take out place. Has 2 rows of booths on 2 walls and the front door. Anyways, I got the stuff and it was just...average. The salad was stuffed with all kinds of stuff and the dressing was just kind of weird...dark oil based vinaigrette? Everyone just seemed a bit discombobulated there, like the guy asking the cashier if she swiped my credit card and I was like "whoa, I paid online! don't swipe anything!" I mean doesn't it show I paid already on the order? read more

Nice Pizza with great flavor. The front desk person seem new and little bit overwhelmed. But overall He handled the line of people fine. read more

This place is pretty much dump nothing about Italian here the pizza looked like it was bought at a cheap pizza place like 7 eleven don't waste you're money here. At least if you want to eat real pizza go else where on Main Street , if you want a taste of a pizza that you microwave come to Sals pizza read more

My favorite pizza place. Go in get a slice a garlic knot and soda for 5 bucks. They put into the oven to get it hot. They have around 10 different kinds to choose from. I usually get chicken bacon ranch. read more

One of the better pizza places in Hartford. Really surprised they don't offer a Margarita or White pizza. Husband loves the calzones. Can't wait to try the stromboli. read more

Great New York style pizzas and Italian dishes. Even nicer people. We miss you Sal's! Come to the Bay area.

I have to confess that I am addicted to Sal's Pizza. Every time I am in town I make an excuse to stop by. The pizza is great, and me and my husband can eat a full meal for $7.50. You can't beat those kind of prices. I have never had a bad slice and the people who work there are very sweet. I recommend them to everyone I know. read more

Pizza is best in town!!! Also comes w- garlic knots which are yummy! Reasonably prices too! read more

Sal's Pizza-Hartford - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hartford, Wisconsin

Can't not say enough good about this place. Roomy sit down area. Staff are quickly and friendly. And the food is always fresh and warm. Best chicken pizza! A stop we always try to make when we visit Hartford for a movie. read more

Best pizza in Hartford at reasonable prices. I have been going to Sals since the first week they opened. I always make it a point to stop in when I'm in the area. I highly recommend! read more

This place is FANTASTIC. Sal's has got to be Hartfords best kept secret, because I am always looking for a place that has great pizza and I didn't even know it was there until recently. Now I can't get enough the place ----I dream about it!!!! I have tried several of the different varieties of pizza and it's my goal to try them all. Still, I couldn't even tell you which one I liked the best ---- they were all excellent!!!! I keep wanting to try their pasta dishes, but I haven't been able to direct myself away from the pizza yet. But I will!!! I will!!!! Oh I almost forgot to mention ... THE GARLIC KNOTS!!! They are to-die- for!!!! read more

Saw this on yelp, while I was in the area for work, figure give it a shot. I was not disappointed! Very good Gawain pizza and sausage/mushroom was great. Defiantly will be coming back here. read more

I was in town for a work project. I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs. It was satisfying and I liked the knotted bread that came with the spaghetti. Nice casual place and the pizzas looked good. read more

I am a Sal's addict. I went to Taco Bell for lunch and the line was so long I saw Sal's in the back round and remembered I heard they sold pizza by the slice. Promptly drove over and have been back every week since. A slice for $3, can't be beat!!! I talked to the owner, I presumed, while I waited and he was very personable. Service has been great every time since. If I lived up here I would be so fat. Will miss them when I quit my job and will no longer be in the area but when I do I know where I will be eating!!!! read more

The pizza itself is ok at best. The people working there, subpar at best. The price, is beyond ridiculous for what you get. If it were about half the cost of what it is, it might be worth it. Try somewhere else. read more

Have been in for the lunch deal, garlic knots are fantastic! Calzones are enough for two meals. Reasonable prices.

Amazing pizza! Amazing drinks! And amazing garlic knots! I cannot think of anything bad about it!! LOVE it! I defiantly recommend it for kids! read more

Had a pizza and garlic knots delivered to our hotel across the street. On a positive note, the service was amazingly fast and the price VERY reasonable. On the downside, we just didn't like it. Not enough flavor, very bland and boring. read more

Really good pizza, really bad service! They forgot half our order and we stood in front of them for 10 minutes before they even acknowledged me. Then waited another 10 minutes to get our pizza which they were out of after they forgot it to begin with. I'd get take out only. Staff was horrible. read more

Order online for delivery. Took about an hour as they did say. Pizza was average. The sauce was too watery. And the pizza was so greasy.

We got Sal's delivered last week for the first time. Best pizza in Hartford. We had the bacon cheddar pizza and it was delicious. Can't wait to try more of their unique options read more

One of my favorite pizza places in Hartford! Garlic knots are the best! I like that you can go in for just one slice, rather than having leftover pizza. (If you are like me and don't prefer leftover pizza.) read more