Our go to place in Brownsburg, everything is fabulous. LOVE their red sauce, pizza's are a must try as well. HIGHLY recommended

It was my first visit to a Sal's. The host was super friendly and sat us immediately and offered House bread. Our server did a great job engaging us and told me some information about the restaurant. We started off with a Caprese pizza, which was woodfired and delicious. I also had spaghetti, olive oil, mushrooms and chicken. The roasted chicken was outstanding in the pasta. Maybe the Chef was a little heavy-handed with the minced garlic. But it was very good. This location is well cared for and the decor it's very pleasing. We were having dinner and the lights seemed to be up at full strength. Even though it was still pretty bright outside, maybe the lights could be dimmed. Can't wait to go to other locations. Have already told tons of my friends about this one. read more

See all

Love this place. The bread and oil at the start is sooo good. We got the Sal's Signature Pizza and it was phenomenal. Service was great. Best Italian in brownsburg. read more

Sal's has always been one of my favorite places to enjoy some delicious Italian food, and they have made it even better with their new renovations! It simply elegance only adds to their incredible food! We were pleasantly surprised by their Valentines Special Menu - it had it all! The Lemon Picante is usually my go to, but the pizza was calling my name this time! It did NOT disappoint! You definitely need to try the Tiramisu! It is absolutely delicious! The service was friendly and the price was right! read more

See all

Went for the first time in about 15 years and the pizza was incredible. Probably some of the best pizza in the greater Indianapolis area. We will be back! read more

Each time I go here the food is just amazing. Portion sizes are great and prices are reasonable! The staff is always so polite. They revamped the restaurant recently. It looks very nice! Highly recommend!! read more

Sal's Famous Pizzeria - New tables and wall decor - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Great authentic Italian food. Service is always great, and the prices are fair and moderate. The entire restaurant has been completely remodeled. Some of my favorite items are the garlic knots, chicken parmagiana, and the spaghetti with meatballs. The oven baked pizzas also make this place a one of a kind that make you come back for more. read more

Rough start when Tthe link to order food was broken. I had to add the .com to the end of it. Then I could no longer select the sauce I wanted with my garlic rolls. I could add an additional sauce for more money though. So I put in the comment section I'd like the cheese sauce. I got garlic butter and marinara. No cheese. Apparently now at the Brownsburg location you have to pay money for the soup or salad with your entree, but at Plainfield you do not. The final straw was when the door dash pickup person cut in front of the line to get his order, and when I spoke up to say something, the staff continued to look for his food while mine was sitting behind the glass. read more

My family eats here a couple times a month and we absolutely love this pizza! There are so many pizza restaurants in Brownsburg, but this is my favorite! read more

Great spot for true Italian fare. Treat yourself to a slice or two for lunch or bring your sweetheart in for an evening of classic entrees and delicious desserts. Great service and even better music (who doesn't love a little Dean Martin?) make this place a fantastic option for date night or dinner with the family. Not feeling social? Get this great food to go. Trust me and try the Margherita pizza. read more

Although they do not have a dedicated vegan menu, they do have some very tasty vegan options. The marinara sauce is delicious.

My husband was craving Italian. We ordered carry out on Saturday evening. Our order was ready at the time promised. The food was very tasty and decent sized portions. The spaghetti could have used a bit more sauce but good and not overcooked. The meatballs were very good and tasted like they had NOT been previously frozen. Inside felt like an Italian restaurant from my childhood. read more

Nice ambiance, great service, food is just ok. Decided to try the sit down experience at Sal's. They have a beautiful Italian themed room....lots of old pictures on the wall. I ordered just basic spaghetti and meatballs. The red sauce was a little too acidic and almost sour. Wasnt awful but wasnt great either. Service was prompt and friendly. read more

This Sal's is located in Brownsvurg in a strip mall with other shops close by. We have been to their Plainfield restaurant multiple times and their food tastes amazingly delicious in both the locations. Their service is great. The ambiance was good and the place was average noisy. They have dine in and carry out options. They have some vegetarian options too. Although, when we asked for vegetarian Calzone without mushrooms, they said it is prepared ahead and mushrooms go with it. That was a bummer. But the pizza and lasagna we ordered were tasty and the portion was just perfect. This is a must visit place. They have a big parking lot in this mall and is a family friendly and business casual restaurant. Also, I am unaware if all the restaurants do this but if paid with cash, the prize is different and when paid with card the prize is $2 more. I am assuming this is for the credit card fees that they have to incur. But I could be wrong. read more

Sal's Famous Pizzeria - Veggie spinach lasagna!! - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

really unfortunate to see the way management and owners treat their staff. who have had to go multiple times with paychecks being late and Roccio the owner is constantly yelling and screaming at the staff. really unfortunate to see the lack of respect and care she has as a business owner. read more

Just moved to the area and happened to discover Sal's. Ordered a simple 16" cheese wood fired pizza and some cheesecake through doordash. I would probably post a pic but I ate the whole damn thing. Cooked perfectly. Not over cheesed. Just simple & delicious. Planning on bringing the crew in for dinner next week. Sal's is my new place for pizza and probably cheesecake too. read more

Sal's Famous Pizzeria - This is all that's left. - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

Really wanted some authentic Italian! One of my favs for a date night as well and saw this little gem on Yelp and wanted to go try it with a friend! When we arrived the place seemed quaint and the atmosphere was bustling. We got sat quickly despite some slight confusion from the host stand. The staff was friendly. I ordered fettuccine Alfredo entree with a house salad and house Italian dressing. The warm bread & oil dip to start was really good too, we said yes when they offered more. My friend got the spinach lasagna entree with a Cesar salad. The only downfall was that our booth still seemed dirty with crumbs everywhere and a menu left in the seat. Overall a neat little spot for some good authentic Italian food. The food tasted great and the staff was really nice which is the reason for my rating. read more

Sal's Famous Pizzeria - Authentic tasting fettuccine Alfredo! With some warm fresh bread , Yumm - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

To me, Sal's Pizza is the best in town because of their New York style pizza. The crust is just perfect. My only complaint would be that they really need to learn to adjust pricing to reflect half topping options. If you tell them half pepperoni / half sausage, they will charge you for 2 full toppings. Im ok if they want to put a whole pizzas worth of each on their respective halves or half the price for each topping. its just short changing customers in a dishonest way. They also have very good pasta dishes that are properly cooked. This really is my favorite pizza/pasta place period. so good. read more

We've been to Sal's several times throughout the years and the food is always good. Nothing mind-blowing, but consistently good. The restaurant atmosphere is small-town downhome Italian and it can get cramped, so we usually do carryout from Sal's. The most recent time we dined in, it was packed on a Wednesday night, but the servers kept up with the hustle. I had the 4 Stagoni, which is fettucini noodles with tomatoes, capers, and artichokes, and I added shrimp. It was a large portion, so I was able to bring some home for lunch the next day. We'll continue to support this local business and are glad to have it near our home. read more

Sal's is such a great place for pizza and more! Their food is delicious and their pizza is my favorite. There's lots of space too! They're always helpful--even bringing a to go order to our car window because I had sleeping kids. They go above and beyond!! read more

Love the food. Pricey but delish. Worth visiting as dine in or carry out. Pasta and pizza are worth it.

My family loves Sal's. We drive in from Zionsville when we can to enjoy the food. The ambiance is nice with an authentic feel. You can catch some Dean Martin playing in the background. read more

Tables too crowded. Not very clean. Maybe just a busy weekend evening. Food was very salty.

Sal's Pizzeria is one of our favorite Italian restaurants whether in Brownsburg or Plainfield. We do enjoy supporting a family-owned business who serves great food, has affordable prices, good service and a diverse menu. This location was remodeled a few years ago and during the remodel a large patio was added. The patio area, even though it sits on the sidewalk, is fairly private with all the greenery and blinds they've added. It can get very warm so we usually wait till it's cooler outdoors to sit on the patio. The interior dining has two seating areas with an open dining room consisting of booths and 4 - 6 top tables as soon as you enter. The second dining room has bar seating with tables in the bar. Stop at the hostess stand as soon as you enter to be seated. Lunch is served M - F from 11a - 4p. with dinner from 4p - closing. Lunch is served with bread/oil and dinner is served with bread/oil and salad. They have several made ahead lunch options for those with time constraints. Pizza slices, pepperoni breadsticks, garlic rolls, meatballs and plain breadsticks are just a few of the items you can purchase separately. Most of the dinner menu is on the lunch menu but a smaller, still generous, portion. Sal's menu offers appetizers and antipasto, soup, salads, sandwiches (Meatball, Italian or Calabresa sub, Stromboli plus) and many types of calzones including vegetarian. I love the variety of pasta dishes for vegetarians or meat lovers. You'll find pasta with chicken, veal, trout, seafood with several sauces designed to go perfectly with each pasta dish. Pizza is extremely popular here from a single slice to 9", 12" and 16" sizes pie with several different crust to select from and check out the wood fire grilled pizza. A few of our favorites are the amazing Garlic Rolls, Meatballs (can get on pizza too), the Appetizer Sampler and Melazane Parmegiana (fried eggplant with marinara sauce). My husband always orders the Spaghetti and Meatballs and enjoys. I usually order the Capellini Pomodoro with Angel Hair Pasta sautéed with fresh tomatoes, olive oil and a blend of Italian herbs. I also enjoy the Linguine Tuttu Mare with Linguine tossed with mussels, clams, shrimp, scallops, tomatoes, garlic and white wine. Order your favorite or try a new entree but either way I think you'll enjoy. read more

See all

We tried this on a whim and it was fantastic. The garlic rolls are very cheesy, the pizza has a great amount of toppings, and overall great flavor. When it go in to pickup, the service is always friendly. read more

I almost never write a bad review. It is hard to own a restaurant and it takes a lot of work to keep things going, and I know that most locally owned places are just doing the best they can. However we went out to Sal's tonight, only been once before, and brought my mom as a thank you for a night out. We met up with some friends so we had a party of five. Once we arrived they seated us quickly but we noticed most tables were full and people looked a little anxious. After sitting for a few minutes we noticed there seem to only be two servers. We decided to wait it out and give them the benefit of the doubt. After a weight of 45 minutes we still did not have a water or bread nor had a waitress even come to the table. In the midst of our wedding we noticed many other tables were seated and were waited upon, but we still sat with no drinks or service. I'm a rather patient person but after an hour I went to the waitress and said we needed waters and at least some bread as I was starting to get dizzy. I had purposely not eaten much so that I could enjoy some of their garlic knots and their yummy food. Evidently the owners wife heard me and help the waitress get us some service. We placed our full order and began to wait again. At the one and ahalf hour mark we received our appetizers. I must admit that their garlic knots and marinara sauce are amazing. I could've made them at home in the time it took for them to bring them to the table but they are definitely delicious! We did finally receive our salads, but by this time other people who had come in after us had eaten received their food and left before we even received a main course. I told the waitress we had to leave in 20 minutes as one of our party needed to get up early to be at work. At this point we have been waiting two hours. The table behind us also had a similar problem but had complained a bit louder than us and so did receive their food. I recognize that they were very busy but we never received any explanation or attempt at an apology. I have to say in this day and age when you can go to any number of restaurants I won't ever be returning to this establishment unless they change their front of house management. When we did finally get up to leave with no food, we had asked for the manager who never came to chat with us. As we were walking out the door the manager belligerently told us the food was ready. She did not attempt to apologize or explain the situation. I honestly think if she had had a different attitude we might've explained and told her we could take the food to go and still pay for it. However after two hours we paid for our appetizers but felt we did not need to spend any more time wasting away in their restaurant. I'm sorry that this wasn't a great experience and it ended up causing a lot of anxiety for our guests. I do hope this restaurant can figure out their issues because we heard many many people complaining that they would not be back after this evening. I was half tempted to call in an order for a pizza and see if I got that before our food in the house. If you want to try out sells the food is quite good I'm sure just make sure you give yourself a lot of time and perhaps plan to work, take a nap, play a game or do something while waiting. read more

We have eaten in the restaurant and the food is usually good. Our recent orders have been pizza takeout and it can vary sometimes it's good and sometimes it's cold and like cardboard.. read more

Yummy food for a burger joint next to a gas station! Wish they had a little more room. It was very busy when they first opened.

Great food and service. We get carry out most of the time. We ate there once. When in mood for Italian this our go to.

This is definitely my favorite Italian place! The bread and oil is where it's at. Unfortunately when my friend and I went last week we had bad service but that won't stop me from coming again and again AND again!!! Most of the time, it's great service. But our waitress acted so bothered. I asked for more bread and oil and she said they were out of oil but that she would grab us bread. Then I saw her give other people oil! Wtf! Lmao. Their fettuccine Alfredo is heavenly and the best I've ever had. They are also very affordable, with the bread and oil being unlimited and getting a salad or soup with the pasta. read more

Sal's Famous Pizzeria - Fettuccine Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

We had a pick up order.. the pizza was definitely not fire baked, not much sauce or cheese, mostly raw vegetables undercooked. The Pasta e fagioli only had about 10 beans in it lit and was mostly broth or soup base. One of the pasta dishes had cold deli meat ham cut up in it. In my opinion, the food is not worth the price. There are better options for pizza in town otherwise,, the Service and Ambiance was adequate. read more

I grew up in Brownsburg and have been coming to Sal's for as long as I can remember but I hadn't been back as an adult until we moved back to the area about a month ago. My parents suggested we grab a quick lunch from Sal's the day we moved in... and let's just say that started a bit of a habit for our first week or so in our new house. The panzerotti and stroboli are both so good and I love their Caesar salad dressing. In the (too) many times we've been in in the last couple months, I haven't had something I didn't like. Don't sleep on this small Italian place and come check it out when you're in Brownsburg craving Italian! read more

Delicious pizza and nice crust! Great Italian food and the service was warm, friendly, and prompt.

Very small lasagna. Very pricey. Did not get even a half a glass of wine. Not going back.

Based on my experience tonight I probably won't return. We went because we read several reviews. And many seem to be from people in the area and who have been going there for as long as they can remember. We'll....I suggest they get out and expand their culinary experience. First off, we waited to be seated, for a long while. "We'll be right with you. We need to clean off the table." Well there were tables that were clean and good to go. "We are swamped. It's a busy night." Maybe I could believe this except the young, brunette, kid/guy, whatever, that was just standing behind the counter drinking soda from a styrofoam cup and staring out at everyone waiting to be seated while he just...well stood there. Pure laziness. Maybe the owner's kid. But that's not all. My "Mista Salad" was missing the olives, the pepperoni, and the cheese. But I paid for it. Full price but basically got...well I'm not sure what it was. The cook was obviously in a hurry and didn't care about quality control. We ordered two wood fired pizzas because as the waitress said, "they are crispier". Not true! Both were wet, rained on, limp, newspaper soggy. And in the very center, they were mushy doughy soggy. We left 3/4 of the pizzas uneaten. We boxed them and brought them home thinking we would put them on a pizza stone in the oven and cook them more for leftovers. But they were too far gone. We ended up tossing them in the trash as soon as we arrived home. They were just to soggy to salvage. We'll probably not return. We did see they have other Italian items on the menu like spaghetti, etc., but I'd fear the spaghetti would be from a Chef Boyardee can, and the lasagna would be a slice from a store bought frozen Stouffer's lasagna tray. Not good here. Not good there. The pizzeria pizza place was not good anywhere. read more

There lasagna sucks. Will never eat here again. Treated terrible by management. Couldn't cut a lasagna noodle with a fork. Was tuff stuck together over cooked nasty. Would need a steak knife to cut it. Was cold was not even offered anything else to try and make it right. Was told I had to pay for it even though you couldn't eat it. That was there policy. Only thing good was the waitress we had. It clearly wasn't her fault. Never been treated so poorly by any restaurant. TRULY SUCKS DON'T EAT HERE Couldn't even eat one bite. Our whole table's experience was terrible. Price charged for not eating horrible. Bad customer service. read more

Went here for lunch last Saturday with husband and friends from out of town. We all loved this place! Nice and clean inside and Italian music was playing. Has a really nice feel to it. We had pizza and salads and garlic rolls. Our friends really liked it and so did we! My favorite thing to get here is the chef salad and the garlic roll. Slices of pizza are humongous! read more

See all

What can I say but viva Italiano! This is the first tine my wife and have eaten here; but most certainly not the last! The food was authentic, hot and delicious. Make sure you get the chance to eat here before the rest of the community finds out about it. read more

My chicken parmesan was great! Our server was on top of everything. Everyone at my table was happy with their food. My son absolutely loved the bruschetta. Oh, and I also love the dipping sauce that comes out with warm bread. I forgot to mention we 7 people at an our table and that didn't slow any of the staff down. read more

Best pizza in the Brownsburg area hands down! The wood fired pizza is amazing! Definitely our go to when we want some pizza!!