This is our go-to chain pizza place in Brownsburg. The past few years they have been super reliable- must be good management. Pizza is always ready on time and perfectly topped and cooked. On our last order we got a Works pizza that was loaded with toppings. We also got a cheese pizza which we were told they had to remake because the first didn't meet their quality standards. We always do carry out so I can't comment on delivery, but the store staff are always friendly when we get there. read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Medium cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

See all

Not impressed. First, I was told they could not take $50 bill then after I ordered, paid for order and waited 10 minutes was then told it would be another 30 - 40 minutes. I get that it's a Friday night and they're busy. That information upfront would've helped me to decide whether or not I was going to place an order. I will say that after 50 minutes, the young man that helped me was very polite. read more

I am the recipient of two post card sized mailers advertising the grand opening of the Papa Johns store at 1521 N Green St, Ste C, Brownsburg, IN. The first mailer includes discounts for three selections. A promo code is included for each with an expiration date of February 15, 2015. However, all six promo codes are not recognized as valid. What is the point of the mailer? It seems to me to be deceptive advertising. read more

What is this?? This is not papa johns... this is the worst pizza Ive ever received from them. This is a hand tossed pizza. Gross read more

Papa Johns Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brownsburg, Indiana

Rude manager he will tell you he had to many orders and basically there to busy, just call anybody else don't waste your time or your money at this place . Oh did I mention they will also argue with you about it to? read more

Had their pizza for lunch today. We've live in New York for the past few years and had great NY pizza but this is the stuff I grew up on. Ordered two large specialty pizzas. Got a "works" and "john's favorite." It was about $29 for both after taxes and any delivery charges. The pizza was hot, fresh, and DELICIOUS. Will definitely be a regular customer from here on out! read more

See all

Just can't seem to get a good pizza here. Tried the new parmesan crust one, thin, flavorless and cold. The worst part was when they delivered the pizza, they had set it down on our cold concrete porch and left. No knock, no hit the doorbell, nothing. Why am I tipping for such worthless service? read more

Papa Johns is always my #1 choice for pizza delivery when I'm having one of those days where I have all my nephews and nieces over. They love pizza and I never get any complaints when I tell them I've ordered Papa Johns for lunch. Delivery is pretty fast and food is always hot. I gotta say it's also one of the best pizzas to eat cold with texture and flavor still there, that makes it one of the best. read more

The store is always clean and the staff friendly when I pick up my order. The pizza and breadsticks are always delicious. This is my fav pizza spot in Brownsburg. read more

The red head kid that was running the register when I picked up my carry out should be the face of Papa John's. He was absolutely polite and so pleasant. The place was busy but I got my order quickly with everything I ordered online. He even gave me some extra side peppers. The pizza was delicious and just as good left over, for your typical chain pizza place. read more

Great and delicious pizza place, unfortunately today they completely messed up our order giving us the same pizza twice, when we ordered one with pineapple and green peppers and one cheese. They gave us both pineapple and peppers and the kids aren't happy. read more

I pick the pizza up and all the toppings come off even the cheese. Papa really going down hill after the racist comment papa said. The delivery person also sat in on my Front porch without knocking on the door so all my flies are full and bugs. I also used to work at Papa John's 2016 I can totally tell a difference from when I was working there and from now. Arnies pizza is probably burgs new pizza place, not even good ol rockstar, pizza is toooooo much water on it or something. I've also made pizzas and it's probably the most easiest things too make too eat :D read more

One simple question for the management of the Brownsburg store. What are you staff unaware of what is on your menu? Subs have been an item for well over a year. They are not posted on the wall menu and staff had no clue when I requested a list of available sandwiches. One time , understandable. This was the third time in one year. Not exactly an example of quality management. If you are unable to maintain staff knowledge of menu options, try posting them with the menu on the wall. This has been proven to work in quite a few restaurants. On a positive when we clarified what was on the menu the sandwiches were really good. read more

Love this Papa Johns! I actually live closer to another one, but this one is closer to work - still a little out of the way - but they are so nice, food is on time, and always hot! I love that they show you your order before you pay (ie: open the box) the PJs closer to home does not do that... no wonder, I wouldn't want to show their "handy work" off either. But I really do like this place. Always get loads of ingredients. read more

Still the best pizza around! Great staff, great food, great prices... What more do you need? Still rather drive out to this place than trust delivery from some place closer. read more

The food quality is good at this store but when I picked up food tonight, 5 of the 8 people cooking had no mask on or their mask wasn't on their face. Half of the people had no head covering / hat either. The sign on the back wall says something like "hats and masks must be worn and masks pulled up over the nose" or something to that effect. I talked to a young man manager about it who got defensive and said that the ovens would kill any kind of germs. When I asked if Papa Johns had a basic policy of hygiene/ health protocols in the time of this pandemic, and he looked at me like I was crazy. Everyone I have talked to about this store and pizza places in general (Hotbox in Avon) say the same thing... "the kids working at these places don't wear masks / gloves / hats. No one is holding these people accountable. If people are to scared to say anything to these people and hold them accountable, nothing will change. 4000 Americas are dying every day from COVID. What is the question here? read more

Papa John's has good pizza and my family enjoys it however when I get promotional codes through my email when I try to order online I spent five minutes trying to enter an order locking up and eventually saying technical difficulties cannot complete your order please call so I called and repeated the order process and was given a total and I wait on delivery, then thinking that the price is incorrect I check the menu and the numbers and apply the discount and find out I'm over charged by $3.44 so I call the store back and they adjust the price not really saying what The problem was but they did lower the price to the accurate amount of what the order was with the correct promotional applied so I would advise to very carefully check the price of your order and verify that you received the discount that they are advertising after the pizza arrives I will add to the post the quality of the order thank you read more