This might be one of the best places in Middlefield, Ohio to stop and get donuts and fry pies. We…read morefound it out while shopping one day and have been coming back again and again ever since. The fact that one part of the store is a hardware store may throw you off, but trust me it's ok! Just stick to the grocery side if you don't need a bolt or screw! The donuts often sell out fast but if you can get there early they are more than worth it. Yeast style glazed donuts that look like small tires they are so big and the donut holes look like small softballs! I could not believe my eyes. They are so good. The fry pies are hand held glazed pies and come in many flavors. Our favorites include lemon and strawberry cream cheese. You can get fry pies at several Amish shops but these have the most filling and best all over flavor that I have found. You can also get plates of molasses cookies here that melt in your mouth. My daughter can eat them faster than I can turn around. Me, I love the whoopie pies. It's a good thing it's. 45 minute drive for me to visit this shop or I would not diabetic from all their lovely sweets! Check them out!

We head out to Eastside Amish every couple of months. We usually stop in this store. It's half…read moregrocery and half hardware store. They have a bakery that smells delicious. They also have a deli. Lunch meat and cheese to take home or they will make you a sandwich. This is a fun shop. I always find what I'm looking for.

If you like doughnuts I'm not talking about the flimsy ass Dunkin' Donuts but real heavy delicious…read moreones this is your go to. Everything is made in house super fresh and well worth the coin that you'll spend on it. They also have an incredible pretzel shop that offers a wide variety of options. Trust me, you'll thank me for the recommendation.

I visited Amish Country Market recently as I noticed they just opened. They're still under…read moreconstruction, but they're able to produce donuts, pretzels, large breakfast rolls, and other delectables. Outside, they have lawn furniture for sale. Inside, there are a bunch of Amish folks waiting to serve you. On this visit, I tasted a chicken bacon ranch breakfast roll, a hot pretzel, some strawberry cake, and maple pecan cake. By far, my favorite item was the hot pretzel. It had just a touch of sweetness to it along with the traditional salty flavor. The texture of the dough was perfect. It had the right amount of moisture, chew, and flavor. It was hot and absolutely delicious. The chicken bacon ranch roll was not balanced. It was served hot and wrapped in foil, but it was missing something, like a yummy sauce or veggie crunch. I think there was too much chicken in it, relative to the amount of other ingredients. So it felt like I was just eating a roll stuffed with chicken. While the chicken tasted good, it needed something else to balance it. The strawberry cake was just okay. I think regular strawberry cassata cake is better though. And the maple pecan cake was just meh. I'll be back to try some other items soon!

This was my first time sitting down to eat in a predominantly Amish area, despite having driven…read morethrough many times. It was a steak special Saturday, complete with TASTY steak and a generous baked potato. My husband and I chose the salad bar option. It was good, but I was a little concerned about cleanliness and many of the tongs were lying directly on top of the foods available. Sadly as a result I only grabbed a couple items. I'd like to try again, perhaps on a less busy night. The staff was wonderful and I loved their gift shop and store. Very clean bathrooms as well which is something I really appreciate these days!

This was our 4th trip to Mary Yoders. The food seems to have improved since the remodling I had…read morethe half roast beef manhattan with fries and the salad bar. The other 2 had the buffet with broasted chicken.

Ingredient changes , smaller products higher prices and never fresh donuts ( And i gave a few tries…read morealso ) It's no wonder they just recently got beat out of their location in front of Wal Mart by a amish bakery in the plaza behind where they was at and because of so ,,, moved out ,Also another amish bakery that just opened on the right going into downtown Middlefield is way better than Maggies , The kids working at Maggies when i went were clueless on when i asked what brand coffee they serve , Just goes to show why they lost a good location on what i mentioned above

Small. $8.00 per 1/2 dozen. Nothing special. Only saw One 'specialty' type donut. Mehread more

This is the first place I stop after I land to visit my parents and sister in Middlefield Ohio. My…read moresister told me about them and I've been in love since. I can't believe a place I used to live in 12 years ago, That had no vegan options, now have dairy free options! The location is absolutely adorable and the staff are always sweet and helpful. I like getting a dairy free Matcha and you can tell that it's not overly sweet like commercial places. It's cute and quiet and one of the locations ( not sure which) you can rent or reserve the rooms for book club, knit club or whatever else you can think of. I live in Las Vegas and I would adore a Ferroni's here!

I love this place it's right in middlefield. Staff is super friendly and welcoming they are quick…read moreto get your order started drinks are solid I love the mocha as well as some of the refreshers they offer. Food it top notch nothing like one of there ham and cheese panini sandwiches for a quick bite. It's trendy and casual come as your are. Great place to relax and sip a hot or cold drink. Dirty chi is my favorite drink here.

We stopped in here after visiting The Craft Cupboard across the street. We loved the artwork and…read morethe historical displays in a spacious area with clean restrooms. The shop had a nice selection of cheese, preserves, and other goodies for sale. We ordered some fresh-made deli sandwiches, and they were generous in portion and the perfect picnic lunch to take to a nearby park. The service was prompt and friendly. Definitely recommend a stop if you are in the area.

After years of driving by this place, we finally stopped in on a Saturday afternoon. It was amazing…read moreand all of my cheese dreams came true. The shop has many coolers and cases filled with all kinds of amazing cheeses. Every type of Swiss cheese imaginable. We even found a blueberry cheddar! They also offer some fresh baked goods, German breads and many dry goods. Very friendly staff, mostly Amish as it's located in the heart of Amish country. I highly recommend visiting this location.

This used to be my go-to place in the summer for produce and Amish bakery. Covid kept me away for a…read morecouple of years, but went back recently to get some peaches and watermelon this summer (used to be the only place around I could find yellow watermelon). I was shocked to find that they had expanded and doubled the size of their store, which is excellent for them. What isn't excellent is how much their prices have shot up. I know everything is going up and accept that, but this was even beyond what I consider the other "expensive" fruit stands in the area. I did a circuit of the store and left without buying anything (which has never happened before).

What a Wonderful Amish Farm Market to get Fresh, Locally Grown fruits and veggies. Very Reasonable…read morePrices, Very Friendly and Helpful Associates and a wide variety ! We go there monthly, throughout the summer. Also, a great place to purchase large quantities, like tomatoes, pickles/cucumbers, peppers, Jade Green Beans (the BEST green beans Ever !), etc. for canning/freezing/dehydrating. You can buy by the peck, half bushel and bushel. It's always good to call ahead and place your order...440-548-2676 They, also, offer flowering plants, fresh baked goods, homemade jams/jellies/pickles/etc., homemade noodles, homemade birdhouses and other wood products ! What a Great Resource to have in our area ! In response to John B. With the crazy weather here in NE Ohio, a lot of farmers can't grow what they used to and in massive quantities, so Yes, more produce has been brought in to cover the demand. Do give this wonderful farm stand a chance to prove him wrong !

I'm giving one star because I have to…read more My wife called and ordered a special cake for our 5yr old son's birthday. Madison Scholtz took our money and called a few days before the party to confirm the order. Day of the party I called her to confirm pick up ahead of time. She answered (seemed upset) but said it's ok to come pick it up. My son and I drove 30 minutes to get his special cake. Got to her house and no one answered the door. I called her, no answer. My wife called her, no answer. Needless to say my 5yr old was heartbroken and didn't understand how someone would be so mean to take our money and not provide a cake. She never even provided a reason for stealing from us. It's been a month now, we have called her a few times but she just hangs up. Do yourself a huge favor and never order anything from this person or business. Do yourself homework as well because there are similar reviews out there. Madison you suck at life and ruined a 5yr olds birthday.

NOT RECOMMENDED and BUYER BEWARE!!!! My Niece got a TEXT not a call a text 4 hours before pick up…read moretime for her 200 cupcakes and small 2 tier wedding cake that West Center Sweet Treats could not complete her order. When my family offered to pick up the cupcakes and cake and finish them we found out that the order was never done. We also found out we were not the only customers that this "business" ditched that day and we were all given different lies and excuses that changed with each text message. Imagine being a bride on your wedding day and hours before finding out you have NO cake. This is UNEXCUSABLE and UNACCEPTABLE. What this "business" did is awful. Situations arise and my family is compassionate to that, but the order was never done and we and others that ordered that day were lied to!