Fantastic locally owned seafood restaurant! Visited for the first time while in the Hamptons and…read morehad a grest experience. The place is a very chill vibe with indoor and outdoor seating, they also have a nice little bar. Food wise everything is great! We got the oysters, fritters, and steamers to start; all of which were fresh and delicious! For dinner I went with the cold lobster roll and it did not disappoint! The roll was nicely over stuffed and the lobster was so meaty and fresh. Definitely one of the best lobster rolls I've ever had! Service was super friendly and fast. Got to meet the owner who was a super nice guy. Definitely recommend if your in the area. They dont take reservations so you might have to work, but definitely worth it!

Fantastic locally owned seafood restaurant! Visited for the first time while in the Hamptons and…read morehad a grest experience. The place is a very chill vibe with indoor and outdoor seating, they also have a nice little bar. Food wise everything is great! We got the oysters, fritters, and steamers to start; all of which were fresh and delicious! For dinner I went with the cold lobster roll and it did not disappoint! The roll was nicely over stuffed and the lobster was so meaty and fresh. Definitely one of the best lobster rolls I've ever had! Service was super friendly and fast. Got to meet the owner who was a super nice guy. Definitely recommend if your in the area. They dont take reservations so you might have to work, but definitely worth it!

Fran and Susan are the best bartenders you could ever want! This place is right on the water and…read morehas amazing sunset views but they don't take reservations so make sure to get here early. They always have changing specials and fresh seafood. They did open up a new location and that menu is a little bit different. We ended up doing the macadamia crusted halibut and the sauce that it came in will live rent free in my head forever! The parking is an open rock lot so sometimes it is full and it expands into the road on the harbor.

A busy Mother's Day lead to a wait but we finally got seated at a beautiful open window area…read moreoverlooking the bay . Perfect setting for a lovely dinner . Picked a few shareable dishes Bistro calamari on a bed of Asian style noodles - unique serving style which tasted good though but acidic for my taste Tile fish with basil rice & crab meat was a pretty plate and darn tasty. Fish was silky breaking off with a slight nudge sitting in a bed of basil rice flanked by carb meat . A tumultuous mouthful knowing me off my feet . Dessert pick was Key lime pie . The custard was delicious but the crust felt a bit too thick and hard . Good food with quick service in a noisy setup with an uplifting backdrop .. it's a must at the Hamptons

There are still a few things that remain as good as before, but my favorite award winning Stuart's…read moreNew England Clam Chowder is NOT one of them. It is tasteless and watery. No creamy lusciousness. No herby clammy umami. They sell clam juice. They should use it. I bought it, tasted it, added everything I could think of to make it taste like something but nada. Didn't mention It's watery? Zero clam taste? There are clams for sure, but I doubt they are fresh. Ps I hate potatoes in my soup. It's a cheap lazy way to add bulk, but red potatoes??? After tasting it, I was so mad that I thought to go back and nicely tell them to stop cutting corners as this will only lead to the closure of yet another failed biz, but instead I threw it out. These owners own a few places out here. Why would u mess with tried and true recipes? You have to spend money to make money. Sell less junk! Keep the good stuff we loyal patrons come back for over and again! Hey guys, read the room! We r a beach community filled with local fisherman and seafood lovers. Don't mess with perfection. It won't end well!

Friends wanted to have a clam bake experience and being a novice, I got a great recommendation to…read moreuse Stuart. Krystal was great! She helped me navigate how much we would need and the best part- they cook we eat! The lobsters were delicate and not overcooked and the clams; I'm not a big clam person but I devoured more than my fair share for sure. We also got a container of their garlic butter OMG. By the end of the meal we were all doing butter shots! Thank you Stuart's for a fab experience.

Wonderful, attentive service. Great cozy vibes. Meatloaf & burger in the Tavern are a MUST!read more

Very good. Super attentive staff in a lovely historical home. The shrimp appetizer was extra…read morespecial. Loved the meal.

This place makes some top tier sauce! I won some of their sauce in a raffle and had a $100 gift…read morecertificate to try them. I was trying to find a way to go there without having to drive so far just for food. I live an hour away from them, so the travel time is what makes going there a deal breaker consistently. It's worth going to East Hampton generally, but it should be a day thing. Not just to go eat. The person who helped us was very knowledgable and asked good questions in terms of what you'd like for your platter. The food was top quality. Our platters were worth every bit of that gift certificate and I'd love to come around this place again! I also had to buy their sauce on the way back home because we use it for some dinners. My only critiques is regarding the mac and cheese. I wish it was more of a homemade baked mac and cheese with the toasted top. But definitely good mac and cheese nonetheless. The mashed sweet potatoes were definitely too seasoned with all spice. It gave it too much of a kick than I was expecting. I liked the seating inside and outside. If we didn't have bad allergies, would've probably sat outside and enjoyed our meal. Also, this place has their own parking area. So that's definitely a plus!

This place is so good! I'm generally not a big fan of BBQ because a lot of times meat is the meat…read moreis dry because it was sitting around for a while, not cooked right, not good quality, etc. I for the 3 meat platter that comes with 2 small sides and a piece of cornbread. I got ribs, brisket, BBQ chicken, mac and cheese, and mashed potatoes. I also got an order of the little gem salad. The ribs were some of the best I've had in years. Very juicy, excellent smoky flavor. Tender, perfectly cooked. Brisket was okay when it was warm, but after cooling off a little bit, it got very dry. I'm not a big fan of brisket in general because of how dry and hard the texture can get, but this is okay while fresh. The BBQ sauce on the side helped, but I probably wouldn't get it again here. The BBQ chicken was the most disappointing - just shredded chicken smothered in a ton of sauce. It was very dry, like sticks of matches drowning in sauce. Mashed potatoes were very buttery and delicious, but also retained some chunkiness and skin too, which I really liked. Very flavorful and decadent. Mac and cheese was very good as well, but not the toasty top kind. Still very cheesy and good, like they used real cheese. Cornbread was a surprise hit - very moist and soft, denser than most cornbreads, and a lot sweeter than most cornbreads I've had at BBQ places. It tasted more like a dessert corn cake, which I didn't mind at all. The little gem salad tasted very fresh. Dressing was just okay, and the salmon we got on top was very stinky and did not taste fresh. The skin had a nice crunch to it though. I wish the fish had been fresher. The greens were great, so I might just get it with chicken next time, or something else if they would allow that. Overall, really great food! I would definitely go back here again. It's been a while since I've been to a BBQ place that has really good smokey char flavor without tasting burnt, while still retaining juiciness (in the ribs anyway). I'd highly recommend the ribs, mac and cheese, mashed potatoes, salad, and cornbread. I want to try some other items as well. Very friendly service too.

Great food; Great owner! Our favourite place for seafood. Amazing lobster salad, scallop ceviche,…read moresea bass and blue fish paté!

Perhaps you've sampled the rest, but Mike's Amagansett Seafood is clearly the best. Yes there are…read morecheaper... but none I've ever encountered sells fish and seafood as fresh as what Mike offers. His blarney is a hallmark, as are his prepared seafoods, including lobster salad, both a house made coleslaw and potato salad that is light and flavorful plus one of the finest tuna fish salads that's made with just the lightest touch of mayo. It's so good I freeze it for the winter months when Mike is closed. With a couple of hours notice, Mike will also custom prepare steamed lobsters, one of the best lobster rolls on the East End or shellfish platters that are to die for. This is definitely a place to come for seafood and english sports on the telly.

Another visit to East Hampton Grill and another stellar meal and experience. Dinner at EHG last…read morenight... Service is always top notch Food quality is excellent Time from order to food being brought to table is great (quick) Highly recommended the spinach artichoke dip and chips and the spicy chicken sandwich. Consistently my go to in the Hamptons!

A classy, cozy inviting high end tavern with subdued lighting and a romantic setting. People will…read moreflock to great food and service - the East Hampton Grill has both. We started with two unusual and inexpensive appetizers- the heavenly biscuits (2 per order) for $5 served warm with Hampton's organic honey. These biscuits were delicious and I could have eaten a basket full of them. With a cold beer they had just the right amount of savory and honey sweetness. The deviled eggs (3 per order) with special relish for $12 were a perfect starter. Not to heavy - melt in your mouth. Onto the entrees: my triple cut brioche roll fried lobster po boy sandwich $48 was toasted with butter, tomato and lettuce and crispy tender lightly fried lobster pieces. With a Nice sandwich remoulade. A bit expensive, but it was a large sandwich full of lobster meat. A little hard to eat because of the height of the sandwich. My wife tasted my sandwich and thought the lobster should remain cooked but not breaded and fried. To each their own. The Nashville style hot chicken sandwich came on the same three cut brioche bread with the shiny top, perfectly toasted ($36). Here again - delicious tender chicken and a large meaty sandwich. Beer and wine service was spot on with a leisurely time pace between appetizer and entree. No room for the two offered desserts- but the key lime pie looked scrumptious.

Excellent seafood at fair prices. Good service and rough-but-clean shop. We return frequently.read more

I had the absolute best tuna salad I've ever had in my life... And I am a huge tuna salad person…read more I also had the best lobster bisque soup I've ever had there. It had chunks of the good side of the lobster. Not just the leftover crap... lol !

We walked in at 845. No one was there, they close at 900. The place was empty and the woman said…read morethey were closing. I asked if they would mine giving us an espresso. The woman at the counter said no problem. When I asked how much she said it is on us. The next day we went back for breakfast. It was great. My wife got eggs Benedict and I had a fried egg sandwich. The food was great the service was awesome.

FIX YOUR TAP WATER PLEASE!…read more It tastes like metal and sewage. God how have they not fixed this by now.

Small and cramped but you're here for good food…read more Produce, high quality and maybe about par for the area. The prepared foods are the draw here. We came here to pick up a spread for lunch and it did not disappoint. Portions are large and it does help make the prices seem more reasonable. I call it the market and buffet illusion. It looks smaller than it is but when you sit down and plate it, it'll overwhelm you. The chicken salad was highly recommended and surprisingly good. They also have ridiculous baked goods. Definitely grab some cookies and cinnamon rolls.

Been coming here for DECADES, before it was cool... and it is always fresh and delicious. I love…read morethe variety of prepared foods, so easy to grab and go and make a picnic in the park at the beach or for a road trip. My favorites are the chicken nuggets, they're like mini chicken cutlets with a great dipping sauce that is super addictive (I think it's a combo of mayo and sweet chili sauce). And their sandwiches are very generously portioned. Yes they are pricey, but you are paying for quality. There is nothing I have gotten where I said it wasn't worth the price. You are paying for good quality fresh ingredients. I have been coming to RS since the 90's, and they're great.