Fish tales is simple the best fish / seafood store in Brooklyn. They just moved down the street to…read morebigger and better location. Their fish is amazing. Prices are high but so is the quality. The service is first class. We love the guys behind the counter. They will order speciality items for you when requested. The prepared foods, sandwiches, soups, salads and even spaghetti in clam sauce -- all delicious. The place is clean well lit and we could not ask for more -- well maybe some more clams on the spaghetti! Grazie!

Wrapping up their first week in a new location, I dropped by today to buy Branzini. They didn't…read morehave to travel far--just a couple doors down on the same block, and the space is larger with seafood on ice in full display. Their prices are noticeably more expensive than other places but no one should compromise when it comes to eating seafood. As someone who has had food poisoning a few times, I like to subscribe to this mindset. From Swordfish and Tuna to Shellfish and Filets, I was told they make the trek to Fulton Fish Market (in Hunt's Point, the Bronx) daily. That's good to know. There's also a freezer packed with frozen selections such as Snow Crab legs and Calamari. I would like to see more varieties of fish ( like Skate and Monkfish) while envisioning an addition of upscale gourmet items/seafood accompaniments other than Soy and Teriyaki Sauce. If you want to be assured of eating fresh seafood knowing you're paying slightly more, check them out. (I bought two Branzini for $31).

I had brought Jumbo shrimp from this place on August.30,2023 and I tell you the Shrimp was…read moreextremely rotten to the core.This place continues to sell fish and shrimp that has expired and things that drop on the floor they just put it back and sell it to the consumers.I will be calling the health department on this place. And I hope they shut this place down because it makes no sense to sell you something they know that has expired for a while please stay far away from this fish market unless you want to get sick...1818 church ave y and s market very disgusting human beings work there please stay away.

5 stars for the really great fish. Everything is fresh here…read moreand it sells quickly 2 stars for the fact they have a couple guys behind the counter and none of them at the door. This is a high foot traffic neighborhood for Caribbean people shopping. The elderly frequent these stores way more than young people so I noticed many of them on the side walk afraid to go inside. They were outside peaking inside asking for someone else to get their fish. I actually don't like when I see the elderly timid and standing off to the side avoiding asking for what they need. It's the job of the staff to notice that they arent being assisted so they can accommodate them. It was crowded today. Like way too many people were in the store at the same time. Like a mad house. I just was frustrated with how many people didn't give the elderly first dibs on ordering their fish. As far as the prices and the quality it's a thumbs up.

this fish market has very fresh fishes and reasonable price…read more i love this place. the people is very nice and kind.

I bought fresh oysters for shucking here and some fresh flounder fillets. Found the prices to be…read morereasonable. 12 smaller oysters for $10. They were super fresh. Flounder was excellent. Quality of the fish looks high, and there were a good amount of customers to make me the think they keep their offerings refreshed. Good friendly customer service. Small place but clean and well-managed from what I could tell. The variety of fish was good too. I will go back to them for sure.

Reliable, clean, and affordable fish market. I wish they were open a bit longer. It seems as though…read morethey're also expanding or at least undergoing some type of renovation based off of my most recent visit. I literally walked right past them because I didn't recognize them at first. It's not a HUGE selection, it's very small inside but they still have plenty of options. You can get bags of frozen snow crab legs, they carry frozen Caribbean lobster tails (spiny lobster), and calamari, etc in their freezer. They have tanks for live lobsters but I've personally never seen them when I go, I usually do go later though.. so maybe that's why. I like getting whole fish from them, they have Bronzino and red snapper, tilapia, fresh shrimp, fish steaks and much more. They also have a cute little section of seasonings and things to make seafood boils or fish frys, but they're a little pricey. Owners are always extremely nice and helpful.

Inexpensive, good quality on my visits so far; I've tried their large shrimp ($9.99/lb iirc),…read morecatfish ($5 or $6/lb), and top neck clams. All excellent! Whole fish available as well. I'll try to take a few pics when I go back later today!

Was in the area and noticed a new seafood shop. I don't cook a lot of seafood, but I've been…read moremeaning to, so took the opportunity to check out what they've got. First of all, everything's fresh (unless it's frozen/prepackaged like their tuna steaks). I think almost everything ins locally sourced. They had some nice red snapper, and branzino. All different sizes, and for good prices. I picked up a small 1-pound red snapper (which they cleaned for me), as well as 2 lbs of their Connecticut mussels. They also had oysters, but they were Blue Points, which aren't my favorite. Got home and cooked everything, and it was quality all around. I now know that I can house 2 lbs of mussels in a single sitting... Cash only!

I'm so glad I finally checked this place out. I got a beautiful whole red snapper for my Lunar New…read moreYear celebrations. It was super fresh and the gentleman helping me did a very complete job of scaling it and trimming the fins. I'll be back next time for the branzino! Don't be put off by the minimalist retail space! It makes sense that they'd keep it easy to clean and hose down, ya know?

Good selection in kosher fish. Nice guys serving you as polite as can be. Also they will cut or…read moreslice you filets or stake any way YOU want them. Truly great service and selection.

This is the worst fish market in Brooklyn. They are so rude and incompetent. Every time I go there…read moreI leave disappointed and annoyed. The fish is not even fresh. They have no respect for customers. The customer service is abysmal. And to top it all of they are so expensive $$$$$$. Save your money and go somewhere else. If I could give it zero stars I would.

Best caviar I've had in New York!! Zak was so helpful with shipping everything to Florida for me…read more Can only recommend!

Be ready that expiration date of your order can be ended in 6 weeks…read more I worked with Anastasia. And when I questioned about expiration date that was at all boxes of my order, I got the answer "you still have time to the end of the month of your expiration date. Even though you can eat it after expiration date"

I like this fish market. I could have sworn I reviewed this years ago but apparently I did not!…read more I like this market because they carry catfish, which a lot of fish markets in the neighborhood dont carry. You'll find your standard fare of seafood and freshwater fish including catfish (my fav), salmon, porgy, whiting and talapia. They also have a good selection of crustaceans, such as crab, shrimp and lobster. This place isn't fancy and the fish is usually kept on ice but I've been coming here for years and have never had a problem. If you get a whole fish they will fillet it for you for free ( just tip them!)

I admit I was a little nervous about a fishmarket on Flatbush, but it seemed to be happening with…read moreregulars on my walk home so I decided to check it out. They've got a decent selection of fish and shrimp on ice, as well as a selection of fixins behind the counter. This ain't Whole Foods honey, so no descriptions about what's wild or farmed, fresh off the boat or been frozen, but it definitely felt safer than the mysterious meats and fishes in barrels at some of the nearby groceries. The fishmonger was a really sweet guy and pleasant to buy from. I'm sure if I had questions he would've been helpful, but I decided to play it safe and get two salmon steaks. Got two really nice sized portions and only paid about $7.80. If they're as good as they looked I got a great deal, if not I'll update my post! Selection is mostly local varieties (snapper, salmon, perch, tilapia etc), most are whole fish but a few are sliced or in steaks, unfortunately no sashimi grade cuts but let's face it, I wasn't expecting there to be. Solid neighborhood joint, if my salmon steaks turn out well I'll definitely be back.