This is a review based from my experience as the male counterpart. My wife and I used Dr Rosenthal for our first delivery. The office staff is horrible. They don't answer the phone, they all take a lunch break together (they close the office), which seems like a novel idea until you need them, and they are all galavanting holding hands at some bodega somewhere eating sandwiches.. Great.. Lets keep in mind this is a doctors office. The day of our delivery, my wife was having health issues that required them paging dr Rosenthal. We heard nothing. We called 5 TIMES!! Still nothing back. Finally her water broke, and we went straight to the hospital. Of course during our delivery Dr Rosenthal WAS NOT there, and did not come in till several days later to check on my wife. He's less then informative during these visits. He scheduled my wife for a 6 week check up after the delivery. 1 week before she was supposed to go in, he canceled it, and said he has a emergency surgery.. Too bad right? Hell no. That is not ok. Correct me if i'm wrong but it's not an emergency surgery if it's scheduled a week out. If I could give this guy zero stars I would, he doesn't even deserve one star. There was not a single thing that I could say about this DR. that would encourage anyone to go use him. read more