Solid pizza! We got a family meal and the pizza was solid but it was hard to separate and the cheese/toppings fall off easily. Also got a salad, cinnamon sticks, wings and Stromboli. The salad was meh, wouldn't order it individually and the Stromboli was too much dough. The wings and sticks were solid though. read more

Updating my review as the one left from 5 years ago was for what is now Johnny's. Rosatis is better than Johnny's. It's the best pizza in Oconomowoc by far. Owner is very nice and they offer some coupons and specials. They should purchase the space next door now that Badger Burger closed and make some additional dine in space. Keep up the good work and we will continue being loyal customers read more

this place is now Johnny's pizza and it replaced Rosati's. . The pizza was gross, too much bread too much cheese and flavorless.. They obviously didn't keep the Rosati's recipes. Very disappointed. Won't be going back. read more

Ready on time. Did parbake. Instructions were perfect. Pizza was delicious. Only con is they are expensive but then so is everything.

The first time we tried the pizza it was crust was crispy and cooked well. This being our second time there, it awful. The crust was soggy, it seemed like they didn't cook it long enough. When I arrived to pick it up, they were not busy. There was only my order and two others waiting to be picked up. read more

Food - I have been eating at Rosati's periodically since it opened, and the food has always been consistently good. I love that they have Chicago style and thin and medium crust options. Their garlic bread is always excellent. Their eggplant and Mac n cheese bites are good. Their beer selection is spot on. And they have a variety of options if you don't want pizza too. My go to pizza place when I visit home. Service - always really solid service! Ambiance - there's the bar area on one side if you're more there to have a pint and/or watch the game and more of a restaurant with booths and tables area on the other side (but still with a tv so you can watch the game obviously). It's a solid choice for families or just couples or groups of adults. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Cheese pizza add basil - Pizza Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

See all

Not the Rosati's of old. Lasagna had almost no cheese on top but was served with packaged powdered Parmesan. Sauce was almost non-existent and if you're Italian, as I am, you know it's all about the sauce. Because it was served in plastic containers unlike the aluminum they used to serve it in, it was lukewarm and the garlic bread wrapped in foil was soggy. Order taker was almost friendly but I didn't leave the conversation feeling warm and fuzzy. They also don't seem to have specials as they used to in their old location which is now Johnnys. Different owner, different experience. Not repeatable for us. read more

We ordered pizza and when it arrived there was hair in the pizza. It's understandable that this kind of thing happens by accident. We politely called to tell them we had hair in our pizza. The employee who answered simply said "oh ok well sorry about that" and that was all the response we received. Again I understand things like this can happen by accident but to do absolutely nothing to rectify the situation is just not great. We will not be going back. read more

We enjoyed our breadsticks and thin pizza with Italian beef as the topping. We ordered that pizza because I couldn't decide between and Italian beef sandwich or a pizza. What I ordered that pizza again? Absolutely It was delicious. As for the breadsticks, I think not. Usually breadsticks are baked but these appeared to be fried strips of dough. We thought the time to get our order was a little long considering there was barely anyone in the dining room. But apparently they have a bang-up takeout and delivery business, which is the reason for the less-than-speedy service. read more

See all

We placed an order online and the server who took our order was extremely friendly and helpful. She made aure our order was just right. Rosati's is our favorite pizza restaurant. We been ordering from them for over 10 years. Their pizzas are the best! read more

1/31/22 - 6:15 PM Very nice restaurant but very odd location as it can be very easy to miss. Started off with a Gin & Tonic ($4), very easy going. Appetizer: Mac & Cheese bites. Main: Thin Crust, 14", half Pepperoni/Cheese. Ordered at 6:35 PM, received at 6:52 PM. As a Chicago native, this pizza was amazing 9/10! The thin crust, perfect amount of sauce (glad I did not order extra), and the chewy cheese reminded me of home. Definitely has a Chicago taste, and there is nothing fake about the ingredients at this place. Bold statement: Best Pizza I've had in WI? Server boxed up our pizza for us, and was spot on the entire night with the refills. Overall, I was shocked by how great this place was & will return again with a crowd. Pros: Fast/Attentive service (Our server was amazing!) Drink/Food menu Cons: ------ Nitpicks: ------ read more

See all

Had the ribs. Full rack, top was warm bottom felt like it just got pulled out of the fridge. Sauce was good though and the beer excellent. Even for a first time visit i still would recommend as the atmosphere is enjoyable. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Cold beer - Pizza Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

Best pepperoni calzones in town! I highly recommend their ranch on the side too. Very delicious!

Not only is the pizza second to no one, but the service is great, too. The ingredient quality is top shelf, (I'm guessing they use Grande mozzarella), and the sauce is the perfect blend of rich and a little spicy. Tim, the bartender, is fantastic. Very attentive and friendly. Love this place! read more

Great pizza, truly homemade and they have green olives for a topping which most places don't have. Worth the $ when you want some good quality pizzas. read more

Cold beer and great pizza and warm family service Pretty consistent pizza over multiple franchises Reasonably impressive read more

I ordered the Eggplant Parmigiano for delivery. Person taking my order was helpful and cordial. Food was delivered quicker than expected but I did order @ 4pm. Sadly, the dish lacked much flavor.... very blah. From an Italian restaurant I was expecting a superb taste. I only ate a qua r ter of it and that was because I was so hungry. read more

Just grabbed an all meat Chicago style to go and it's Sunday. Let's just say knocked it out of the park with this deep dish, whew!!! The crust crunchy yet soft, each meat was full of flavor, sauce amazing cheese and herbs were just spot on!!! Highly recommend!!! read more

Rosati's is a fabulous pizza establishment. You can get whatever style pizza you want here and they do a great job on all of them! We have been coming in here for years. We always sit in the bar area because it's beautiful and super chill. The service is always amazing and with a smile. When we order to go it's always extremely fast and the pizza legit stays hot for ever. They let you customize your order and they cut the pies into squares, a little wisconsin detail that I just love. The deep dish is HUGE and it rivals any Chicago deep dish I've ever had. Literally one piece is like a meal in and of itself. I have never had a bad experience with anything on the menu. The only thing is that I wish they would bring back the OG inferno wings that weren't saucy but were spicy AF. Can they please bring them back?? Would recommend to a friend and would take out of towners for sure! It's not a fancy shmancy spot but they make you feel like gold. My dad travels the world and almost always wants Rosati's to be his first stop when he gets home to Oconomowoc. read more

See all

Have been going to Rosatis for years. I have been getting the fish fry on fridays quite often. Over the last few months the portions for fries have been getting smaller and smaller. Today I was extremely disappointed with what I found when I got back to work. The food is always good. Hoping they can get this corrected, otherwise the $13.00 plus dollars for a fish fry doesn't seem worth it anymore. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

We had pizza on July 3rd from Rosatis. I am visiting friends that live here and love this pizza place. We ordered two large pizzas with multiple toppings and it was so good. One of the pizzas was double dough and one of them was a thin crust. I definitely prefer and loved the thin crust but did not enjoy the double dough.. my friends hisband LOVES it and they order one of each every time. In any event, I picked this place, due to the reviews on here and then my friends agreeing with the reviews (30+years residents)... so I don't think you can go wrong here. read more

Quick overnight stay in Oconomowoc. Hotel had a menu for Rosati's. Unreal delicious. Delivery was about an hour - not bad for freshly crafted food. Beyond delicious. read more

I've seen multiple times the kitchen staff in the back go either behind the dumpsters or into the trees to pee, then walk right back in the kitchen. It's disgusting. read more

One of my favorite restaurants in Lake Country. Their deep dish pizza, Big Chief Sandwich and Fish Fries are awesome. Service is always impeccable and especially in COVID times. We even had my daughter's rehearsal dinner there. Their back room is nice for parties. read more

Food is phenomenal. Service, particularly Joe at the bar, essentially worthless unless goal is to ignore customers and refuse to refill drinks. Better off getting it to go to avoid feeling unwelcome. When confronted, brushes me off and walks away and hides back in kitchen til we leave. Mark Herdt wouldn't settle for this kind of awful staff. read more

Rosati's Pizza - Joe, hiding from customer refusing to acknowledge customer complaint. - Pizza Near Me - Oconomowoc, Wisconsin

Great pizza hands down the best in the Oconomowoc area, the Chief Italian beef is to die for

I always liked Rosati's. I have a lot of deliveries from them & the food is always hot and my order is never incorrect As I said above I have always liked the food well enough to be adventurous on the menu to try almost everything on it. But the word like is how I describe my Boring encounters that go well enough to pass by without a real complaint. Good enough to be liked. That is until the past 8-10 times... or I'd say Year to 18 months. Something happened there. I love Rosati's now. I look forward to ordering from them because it is always great !!! I just can't say how happy I am when a restaurant does my order we EVERY SINGLE TIME! It's a nice feeling though. Thanks for the great Food. read more

Catered from Rosati's for a birthday party. Ordered a selection from their menu that feeds about 20. Fresh tossed salad with assorted dressings, Italian meatballs in sauce, Mastacholi, Chicken Alfredo, Italian Beef w/Au Jus. They supplied all the silverware, plates, napkins, and condiments. Very professional and courteous delivery driver, and reasonably priced. read more

Good food I love the place of rosatis being in the middle of everywhere so it makes it very convenient

One of my favorite go tos for pizza. Absolutely love their sauce and I have yet to be disappointed.

We have our food delivered to our home. The food comes in a timely manner, hot and fresh! We love their pizza. They are generous with the toppings. Everything that we have had it has been very delicious. read more

Such great service and food delivered for an adoption celebration. Delivery was more than prompt and the pizzas were a hit with with everyone!! Great job!! Thank you!! read more

I am completely disappointed! We ordered curbside because we have at risk health issues and have been coming here for years. Previously they were very respectful of COVID-19 guidelines so we were able to support their business. Tonight not so. Too busy for curbside so asked to come in. Very few masks. Had to leave without picking up. Won't be back. Very upsetting. read more

I've been coming to this place my whole life and it has always been fantastic. And I think it still holds up to a good standard. I 100000% recommend the meatball sub or double dough pizza it's amazing. read more

It was mediocre. The deep dish was bland with a flavorless sauce. The kids pizza was described as a flatbread but ended up being French bread. read more

Outstanding! Got Mother's Day delivery after running around all day for family and friends and their deep dish loaded pizza is consistently to die for. It had been awhile, and though pricey, it can feed an army-one slice is enough for a person. Delivery was earlier than expected and it was perfect. Thank you Rosati's Oconomowoc for being such an awesome standard of consistent excellence. PS if you dine in the pastas are awesome too :). read more

Great food, well improved staff! Always a great meal and excellent service! I'm a fan and repeat customer.

Do not go to Rosati's pizza expecting pizza. Ordered pizza Saturday night..Went to pickup and they would not honor the coupons that were givenout by Rosati's. When ordered we let the person taking order that we had these coupons and said it was not a problem. Went to pickup order and the guy at the counter was very rude and said they didn't accept coupons. Told the guy keep his pizza and walked out. Went to Papa Johns. Rosati never again! read more

We needed a party room half way between Milwaukee and Madison for a college graduation party. We chose Rosati's and it did not disappoint. The buffet food was hot and tasty, the staff was friendly and attentive to our guests' needs, and the price was very reasonable. I would highly recommend Rosati's for your next small or large gathering. (We had appetizers of vegetable and dip platter, cheese and sausage platter, and warm artichoke dip with crusty bread-which was amazing. Then we had the pizza buffet with salad and added a half pan of lasagna and Penne con Pollo for added guest choices. All was delicious!). read more

Great Chicago style deep dish. We've been ordering from them for ten years. Tonight we ordered a double sausage deep dish and as always it did not disappoint! Several years ago we were transferred to NJ and learned about the chicken parm pizza. Now that we're back, we ordered a thin crust chicken parm and it was awesome!!! Highly recommend this pizza!!! read more