A great choice if you are craving Italian food with a nice ambiance. As mentioned by other…read morereviewers, it can get crowded and reservations are definitely a better idea then chancing a walk-in. All of the servers that we have ever had here have been really, really nice as well as well informed as to the menu. The lasagna here is PHENOMENAL!! My wife and I usually order different dishes so that we can try new things, but here we always both order the lasagna. A typical night for us looks like an order of the bruschetta as an app, two lasagna entrees...and maybe a few vodka sodas and captain and diets to wash things down :) I have also tried the pizza a few times, and it is good...but the heart in my stomach is in love with the lasagna.

Food: we started with some beer battered cheese curds that were unusually good. The cheese was…read moretender and warm unlike the cheese curds we have been used to. We tried a cranberry and apple salad with scallops. The scallops were the best part. The beer list was more interesting than the wine list, but they did have several wines available by the glass. 4/5 Service: Both the bartender and Andrea our server were very attentive 4.5/5 Ambience: huge parking lot surrounding the restaurant. There was apparently a birthday party for a six-year-old with some very wild children running about. Once they left, the place was much more pleasant. 3.5/5

Had a slice of pepperoni and a salad. Pizza was great and the salad was super fresh. Zach offered…read moreup great conversation as well;). I'll be back when I'm in the area again. A+

Small, local spot with delicious pizza. Come hungry and leave happy! The folks who work here are…read moresuper nice and we really enjoyed our dining in experience. The pizza is the perfect combo of thin crust and interesting flavors

Our favorite go to pizza in Oconomowoc for take out. We love it!! It's great every time and the…read morepizza is always ready on time.

Great local pizza shop. Ordered delivery for mom and I while she was staying at local assisted…read moreliving facility. Thin crust with supreme toppings was great. Delivery arrived ahead of schedule. Based upon past experience, you can rarely go wrong ordering pizza from a locally owned shop near a lake. Bonus points if they also offer boat pickup and delivery as part of their menu.

My wife and I have been coming to Johnny's (formerly Rosati's) for about 5 years, ever since her…read moreMom moved to Oconomowoc and introduced us to it. The pizza here is fantastic and has received rave reviews from anyone who has tasted it. We usually order online and pick it up since we live pretty close. You can tell that they use fresh ingredients and care about quality. The people here are super friendly and always have a smile, which is really nice since they are usually slammed with customers. I've even been offered a complimentary beverage when waiting to pick up a pizza when they weren't quite as busy--which I thought was really nice. We really need to give some of their other food a try, it's just tough when the pizza is so good!

Still peak food after the change because only the franchise name really changed at all. The pizza…read moreand Mac n cheese bites were delicious. So was the eggplant. I will always come here and only here for pizza when I visit. The service was also good, though they were pretty busy on a Tuesday. The ambiance in the bar is great - lots of locals and usually the game is on.

Awesome pizzas, baked at home in convection oven …read more.... Recommended, if you can grab one !!! Cheers from MadCity

I was looking for the perfect place to celebrate my mom's 80th birthday, and from the moment I made…read moremy first inquiry until the day of the party, Kim made the entire process incredibly easy. Whenever I had a question, she was always just a text away, and her response to every request was consistently, "We can do that." On the day of the event, Kim gave us access to the space right at noon so we could decorate without any stress. Throughout the party, she stayed on top of everything--making sure drinks and food were taken care of, and even arranging for someone to cut and serve the cake. The basement area ended up being the perfect size for our group of 30 guests. I couldn't have been happier with how the celebration turned out, and Kim played a huge role in making it such a success.

Recently celebrated a family birthday there and we'll be back. Pizza was good! Slightly soggy in…read morethe middle but nice thin crust and 2 varieties of pepperoni. They have great specials throughout the week and offer free dessert for birthdays.

We stumbled upon this place and was very happy with the meal. I'd say the eggplant fries were the…read morebest I'd ever had. The breading was light and you could actually taste the eggplant. The pizza was large and baked perfectly. The menu said it had pesto however I didn't taste much pesto. It really lacked the zing. We suggested that they have some hot sauce on hand for all those spicy eaters. The cannoli cake yummy and we plan to come back with the whole family in a few weeks.

We've only ordered takeout from here, but the inside looks to have ample seating including bar…read moreseating. The garlic bread is one of our faves along with the greek salad

Ordered through the app for in person pickup. Our order was ready on time and everything was…read morecorrect. The pizza was good and I like the customization format with unlimited options. The price point was reasonable and this is a solid option for fast casual pizza!

There was a line when I arrived and all the employees were in the back doing something. Finally…read moreafter waiting they all came out together and started slowly working, the entire time they were more involved in their conversation about complaining about their manager and scheduling. I watched my pizza sit on the rack while this employee was chatting. When she finally put my pizza in the oven, she sat on a stool while texting on her phone. When I got to the register I literally had to wait for them to finish their conversation so I could pay. Worst mod pizza ever! This was on 5/20/26 at 9pm

Best Pizza in Town, Good Service and amazing food. Buffet is a must try so much variety.read more

There was a sign outside that buffet was back. Went in side and didn't look like there was any…read morebuffet. Sad I got my hopes up for no reason.