It's very rare that I eat at a restaurant where literally everything from cocktails to appetizers and entrees to desserts is of high quality, but Riel achieved that. The place is tiny in space and has a relatively small menu, but that seems to allow them to focus on what they do offer, and do it well.
There are eight signature cocktails of various liquors, each named after a song, as well as five classic cocktails. We went with the Corpse Reviver #2, which blends gin, lilet blanc, cointreau, lemon, and absinthe, as well as the My Mind's Playing Tricks on Me, which includes tequila reposado, grand mariner, yellow chartreuse, lime, and agave. The Corpse Reviver #2 had a smooth, refreshing taste, but the My Mind's Playing Tricks on Me really knocked it out of the park, successfully combining a number of flavors into a truly excellent drink.
As already mentioned, the menu is quite small compared to other fine-dining restaurants, such that all food items fit on one page. Appetizers are divided between hot and cold selections, ranging from crudo and lobster salad to borscht and bone marrow. There are also three caviar dishes if you're in a particularly luxurious mood. The executive chef is originally from Manitoba, Canada with Ukrainian heritage, which explains the delightfully eclectic mix.
We took advantage of this by mixing and matching our order with steak tartare, gator karaage, and oysters. The steak tartare was simply delicious and perfectly complemented by the mustard sauce that accompanies it. Despite my skepticism about whether gator could possibly be good, the karaage was likewise scrumptious, with the Japanese marinade flavor really coming through amidst perfect breading. The oysters were sourced from Martha's Vineyard, and the flavor difference from gulf oysters was noticeable, in the best way. There's something about New England seafood that just tastes better than the Gulf.
As far as entrees, there are only seven options varying from hanger steak to Tamarind BBQ Snow Crab. We opted for the fishermen's stew, which combines kimchi broth, market fish, mussels, snow crab, and gulf shrimp, and also sprang for the scallops, which come with Carolina gold rice grits, brown butter breadcrumbs, gruyere cheese, and charred lemon. The fishermen's stew was delectable with all the seafood components tasting fresh and contributing to an overall flavor that was even better than the sum of its parts. The scallops were also fantastic, rounding out a night of seafood in which no dish disappointed.
For desserts, there are only three options of sticky toffee pudding, brown butter cake, and a Nanaimo bar. We selected the sticky toffee pudding, which was served with foie gras and a blood toffee sauce. It was a delicious end to several courses of fantastic food.
Through all of this, our waiter was excellent and provided wonderful guidance on our selections. As stated at the beginning of this review, there simply were no flaws to mention with our experience, whether speaking of the food, service, environment, etc. Riel just celebrated their fourth anniversary, and with this kind of quality, hopefully, they are around for many more years. read more