Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Reynolds Roost Bakery

    5.0 (3 reviews)
    Open 7:00 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Reynolds Roost Bakery Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Reynolds Roost Bakery

    Recommended Reviews - Reynolds Roost Bakery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Best gluten free brownies that I have ever tasted! Please support this small business.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Tiffany R.

    Tiffany R.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Reynolds Roost Bakery

    Ruby’s Cafe & Bakery

    Ruby’s Cafe & Bakery

    4.4(14 reviews)
    4.0 mi

    We just tried the most amazing little treats... So good!!! We are happy to support this small…read morelocal business! Just when you thought life couldn't get any sweeter... Ruby's Cafe & Bakery is featuring two new macaron flavors this week: Dark Chocolate Macaron with a Chocolate Ganache Filling! - and - Lemon Macaron with a Lemon Buttercream Filling!

    I went to Ruby's with a group of about 13 women. The historic building is beautiful! There was also…read morea shop inside called Thyme Stamp Boutique, I did not peruse the items on this day but I will get back to do so. I also met the owner on this occasion and she was delightful. My experience may be because I was part of a large group of ladies, the service was slow but friendly. It also seemed a bit chaotic. Everyone complained of the parking as well but I did not have that issue as I always get to where I am going early and I found it easy to park in the extra lot behind the building. Apparently there is a place across the street from the building where you can also park. We were there at 1pm so lunch was on the agenda. I decided to forgo a regular meal and just get the cake flight, after all they are a bakery and I should try their best! I ordered a regular iced tea (no sugar) to go along with my cake. The cake flight I chose was the C.J.'s Vanilla Almond Buttercream (Wedding Cake), Dorothy Blevin's Cake, and the Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Buttercream. It was a good choice for lunch although if I go back I will just get the cake that I really liked out of the 3. Maybe next time also I will try the chicken salad croissant and the chicken velvet soup. I think my experience will be better next time outside of a big group. My favorite cake of the 3 was the Dorothy Blevin's Cake as it was unique with a denser texture than the others and it had pecans, pineapple, and a caramel topping. I thought the almond cake was a bit cloyingly sweet and the almond tasted pretty artificial, the chocolate was not chocolate enough for me if that makes sense. Maybe needed to be a little darker chocolate and richer but if you are looking for something lighter that may be your thing. Overall I will go back and try this bakery/cafe again and hopefully will have a better experience and I will order a full lunch next time.

    Photos
    Ruby’s Cafe & Bakery - Dinning room

    Dinning room

    Ruby’s Cafe & Bakery - Pumpkin Spice macarons

    Pumpkin Spice macarons

    Ruby’s Cafe & Bakery - Capacity 110!

    See all

    Capacity 110!

    A Slice Of Heaven Cakery - looking for a cake like this

    A Slice Of Heaven Cakery

    5.0(6 reviews)
    13.3 mi
    $

    Our wedding cake was absolutely beautiful. we loved the friendly service and the time she took to…read moremake sure we were getting what we asked for. we will always recommend a slice of heaven

    Amy Hans, owner and operator of A Slice of Heaven knows where its at! After shopping high and low…read morefor a perfect cake with an affordable price for my wedding, I was referred to Amy and her fabulous delectable cakes. There are LOTS of cake places in the Indy area that CLAIM to have the best tasting cakes, and having been in about 27 flippin' weddings myself, I have tasted a lot of these so called "best cakes". Well, none of them lived up to Amy's cake, which was moist, gorgeous and even wonderful a YEAR later on my 1st anniversary. Might I also mention that she charges UNDER $2.00 a slice. This might make her SOUND cheap and therefore, might make you think that there are BETTER cakes out there b/c they are more expensive, but I beg to differ. The likes of other cakeries don't have have anything on Amy and her slices of heaven. First off, I ask her to do a chocolate drizzle on my cake. She had never done this but promised she would make it work. For months leading up to my event she would call to let me know she was "practicing". She also had other brides and grooms taste test MY cake to make sure it was progressing. Not only was my cake GREAT tasting but it was BEAUTIFUL!! I cannot say ENOUGH about this wonderful concoction that was my wedding cake. It was three layers of double chocolate and two layers of almond vanilla with white chocolate icing and dark chocolate drizzle. My (crappy florist) tossed in some pretty pink roses and we WON and award from "Real People Magazine" for Indiana's BEST cake!! For a whopping $320 total for a cake that served nearly 200 people, I could NOT have been happier. She even came the day of, cut my cake for me and put it together. It looked fantastic, tasted fantastic, was affordable and I could not have been a happier bride. I have since used her for birthday cakes, shower cakes and desserts of every sort!! Brides, do not choose those OTHER cake shops that constantly CLAIM to have the best cakes. Take yourself to small town Indiana and have a slice of heaven instead! You'll thank me later!

    Photos
    A Slice Of Heaven Cakery - Wedding cake

    See all

    Wedding cake

    Cretia Cakes Bake Shop - Coconut cupcakes (left) & Caramel cupcakes with & without caramel drizzle (right) -- Delicious!

    Cretia Cakes Bake Shop

    4.8(12 reviews)
    33.6 miSoBro

    I'd had the privilege of enjoying Cretia Cakes at Zoobilation and Museum by Moonlight and fell in…read morelove! Both times--if I remember correctly--I fell in love with the caramel cake. While I was initially bummed to find out they didn't have an always-open storefront (or perhaps not yet ), I knew that when the chance arose for a cake or cupcake order, I'd want to order directly from Cretia Cakes. In hosting family and friends recently, this was the perfect opportunity. I ordered three dozen cupcakes: caramel cupcakes with caramel flavored buttercream (some they also added caramel drizzle on) and coconut with coconut buttercream. Incredibly moist and delicious! Some cupcakes it feels the icing is the star while the cake is just average, but I truly enjoy the balance of both and I believe Cretia's offers this. The team was careful to verify my order to ensure it was right and even followed up further to ensure they followed all of my details correctly. Pro tip -- 1) Cretia has cake and much more! I also ordered three pans of yeast rolls which were so scrumptious and perfect with the rest of our dinner. 2) Be sure to check their website and social media for specials and deals. I missed the deadline for mine so don't miss out like me! Highly recommend Cretia Cakes for your next gathering -- big or small. Thanks Cretia & Team!

    Everything was delicious! I really like the dew drops and the mexican wedding cookies. Her…read morecaramel cake is divine and the homemade rolls were so buttery and soft. everything was 10/10

    Photos
    Cretia Cakes Bake Shop - Yeast rolls

    Yeast rolls

    Cretia Cakes Bake Shop - Absolutely delicious yeast rolls! Not one was left!

    Absolutely delicious yeast rolls! Not one was left!

    Cretia Cakes Bake Shop

    See all

    The Flying Cupcake - New adorable booths inside!

    The Flying Cupcake

    3.4(88 reviews)
    29.5 mi
    $$

    I have been a committed Flying Cupcake customer for over 20 years since they had just one store…read moreliving its best life in Broad Ripple. Mega. Fan. Give me all the cupcakes. The service is always so pleasant, and the staff is ready and willing to take you on a grand tour of their sweet selection without hesitation. I was in the area recently having a not-so-great day so I decided to treat myself to a little cupcake therapy. Here Comes the Bride is the G.O.AT. It's super sweet, but balanced out by being so light and fluffy. I always grab one of those and then I get a little adventurous with my second choice. I've probably tried all of them at this point, and my second favorite is the Peanut Butter Blackout. That peanut butter filling! *swoon*

    Oh wow... this place is gorgeous…read more Thanks to Too Good To Go, I finally stopped by Flying Cupcakes and not only picked up some cupcakes (which were delicious), but also got to really check out the space. It's beautiful, like the kind of place that instantly puts you in a good mood. The staff working while I was there? Absolutely the nicest. And I have to give credit when it's due, I love businesses that trust people, and you can just feel that here. The person at the counter was an absolute gem and made the experience even better. Safe to say, I'll be back... and yes, I'm already thinking about booking this place for my birthday

    Photos
    The Flying Cupcake
    The Flying Cupcake
    The Flying Cupcake - Vegan Chocolate Cupcake

    See all

    Vegan Chocolate Cupcake

    Reynolds Roost Bakery - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...