Very good ice cream so smooth. The owner's are super nice. Rootbeer floats are to die for and so is the old fashioned sodas

Waffle cones made while you wait and they are delicious!! So ma t ice cream flavors to choose from and all delicious. Vegan and sugar free available too if that's your thing. read more

Yummerful - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pendleton, Indiana

Oh my! Our new fave ice cream spot! Our old favorite went out of business in Anderson so now we're thrilled to drive another 10 minutes to cute downtown Pendleton for their awesome ice cream. They have some wonderful and unique flavors (Exhausted Parent, really? LOL) My only wish is that they can upgrade their two little outside cafe tables, kind of rickety, but there is a sturdy bench close by. There is plenty of inside seating if you go in inclement weather. read more

Good ice cream. Lots of flavors to choose from. They do have a sugar free flavor, too. Friendly staff offered sample tastings, also.

The most amazing and best ice cream shop! My best friend took me here a few years ago and I've been hooked ever since. My kids LOVE yummerful. The ice cream is always fantastic. There's so many choices for flavors, toppings, cones, etc. The waffle cones are made fresh right in front of you. They have other sweet treats, too. Cookies, pie, brownies, pudding, and many other things. The owners and staff are the nicest people. You'll get incredible service any time you go. It's such a cute little shop in a nice homely area. Our favorite thing to do is stop and get ice cream on the way home from the local park on those warm spring/summer evenings. read more

Great ice cream! Very unique flavors and delicious. Service was very friendly. If in Pendleton must stop in

We had never witnessed the making of a waffle cone until today. A fresh cone with a wonderful ice cream concoction. Impressed. Yippee Skippee !We shall return read more

Nice addition to the downtown Pendleton area for your after dinner sweet tooth needs. Decent selection of flavors along with some really impressive looking waffle cone options (cone or cup). They advertise ice cream cakes as well (24 hour notice). Tastefully decorated, spacious interior. Located next to post office right on State street. read more

Yummerful - Root beer float...yum! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Pendleton, Indiana

See all

What's not to love about hand-dipped ice cream? And Yummerful has the BEST flavors around! My favorites are "Exhausted Parent" and "This Sh&@ Just Got Serious" (salted caramel with a vein of dark chocolate running through and cashews). Oh my gosh...Two scoops please! read more

I'm not an ice cream person but this ice cream is NEXT LEVEL!! The service as amazing. I can't give enough stars!!!

Super love the delicious frozen treats here! The staff are so awesome and enhance the atmosphere amazing well! The building itself bares such a historic light that would give any history buff goosebumps! We highly recommend this place! It's a beautiful hidden gem of Indiana! Already planning on going back very soon! read more

This was a delicious and amazing evening treat that we would highly recommend! This locally owned mom and pop ice cream parlor is quaint and delicious! You will not be disappointed and you'll be supporting a great local small business. read more

Most delicious hand-scooped ice cream around! Kind and friendly staff. No public restroom. Call ahead for current hours! read more

Fun and unique names. Great ice cream. Grab a friend and come on down. It's hard to recommend just one flavor. Go more than once and try them all!! read more

See all

They have amazing Ice cream!!! People that work there are super nice too and offer you to try the ice cream before you buy it:)

Terrific local ice cream place. Super friendly staff that will always offer suggestions if you aren't sure what to get. They always have some no auger and soy options available if your diet requires that. I recommend trying one of their shakes or a waffle cone. read more

We love Yummerful! Great neighborhood ice cream shop in downtown Pendleton. They have hand dipped ice cream and the flavors rotate weekly. We love to get ours in waffle cones. They also offer shakes and sundaes. No public restroom though. read more

My family and I stopped by after the half iron man as a treat. Extremely nice staff and fantastic ice cream for the price. Their single scoop is pretty massive. Their junior scoop is a pretty good size for just one person. If we ever come back, definitely stopping by again. read more

Plenty of delicious flavors to choose from. I tried the bourbon spiked espresso and man could you taste the bourbon. I wanted to take a pint home! 3.20 for the smallest cup but it was very large. Also, several soy based flavors and sorbets. read more

What a wonderful little gem of a ice cream shop!! The ice cream was delicious and the service was excellent too! You won't regret supporting this small business. read more

Yummerful certainly lived up to it's name. The owners were so sweet and so kind when I couldn't decide which of the two flavors I wanted, so they very happily offered me a sample of each and then suggested one more for me to try based off my interest in the first two and happily doled out another sample. The smell of their fresh waffle bowls when you walk in is incredibly inviting. They have new and unique flavors that change seasonally so it's not like your run of the mill chain/franchised ice cream shop. They have adequate tables for seating and the whole time I was in there the owners were chatting away with customers. Very positive experience and a perfect way to support local business. read more

This place has some of the best ice cream! You can never go wrong when picking Yummerful as your place to buy ice cream. I highly recommend this to everyone! read more

This is the best ice cream place I have ever eaten at. I love love love all their ice cream choices. They have some regular flavors but they also have crazy ones like "Exhausted parent" and other yummy flavors. You can sit in doors or out side. Very clean and extremely friendly and fun staff. It's worth the time and money. You have to check it out. read more

I travel back to Indianapolis once a month and sleep over near downtown Pendleton which is where the ice cream shop is located. Pendleton is small so unless you are nearby it would never be on your radar (yes, you'll be missing out). The name is a hit-Yummerful-what a great name for an ice cream shop! When you walk in the smell of the waffle cones immediately takes you over. I imagine there is a place in heaven that smells exactly like it. I think the samples are extremely important in an ice cream shop-they're a necessity; the employee was pleasant and generous with them. The ice cream is rich and creamy; it sticks together similarly to how melted marshmallows do. Once I learned it comes from a vendor in Madison, WI that seemed like an A-ha moment, as if it explained everything about how they get the rich creamy-ness. For how delicious it is, seriously a premium ice cream shop, the prices won't break the bank. We ordered a single scoop in a dish and a double scoop in a waffle cone-the servings were GENEROUS; probably the largest servings I've ever had from an ice cream shop and we only spent $8. We sampled at least 7 of the flavors and decided on Strawberry, Kitty Kitty Bang Bang, and Door Country Cherry. This will have to be my nephew and I's go to place for ice cream now. read more

Won't be back. It wasn't terrible, but it certainly wasn't good. The artificial flavorings overpowered what otherwise could have been decent ice cream. In our group of six, half of us through some of our ice cream away because it just wasn't good enough to eat it all. read more

With 32 flavors to choose from, you really can't go wrong! Great locally owned business that is just a hop, skip, and a jump off of I-69. We visited on their second day of business and were greeted with eager and friendly employees. After trying many samples, we settled on a scoop of Coconut almond chip, Kitty Kitty Bang Bang (delicious!!), and Mackinac Island Fudge. All were fantastic! You can definitely tell that they serve quality ice cream! The texture is so creamy and the choice of flavors cant be beat! I also noticed that they had some soy flavors as well. Prices are comparable with other ice cream shops. Definitely worth the stop if you are passing through... or even if you're not passing through, add it to your trip! read more