Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Restaurant At Second Mill

    3.3 (42 reviews)
    Closed 6:00 am - 9:00 pm

    Order Restaurant At Second Mill Takeout or Delivery

    Restaurant At Second Mill Photos

    Business Info

    RESTAURANT AT SECOND MILL ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Good for groups
    Good for kids
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Restaurant At Second Mill

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    E B.

    If you have any desire to eat tasty, seasoned southern food.....don't waste your time or money. I suggest keep on traveling till you find Southern Bistro. Spend your hard earned dollars wisely. From the terrible run down bathrooms to the overpriced canned food dumped into the feeding trough, to the small cramped dining area with the stained and disgusting fabric cover benches. This makes me hesitate to call myself Southern, what an embarrassment to Southern Cuisine.

    See all

    Photo of Pam N.
    0
    67
    10

    8 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 5
    Oh no 0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Restaurant At Second Mill

    Review Highlights - Restaurant At Second Mill

    Now the selling point of the whole experience is the banana pudding because this is where I got hooked on it.

    Mentioned in 3 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Willie Sue's - This is the ribs.

    Willie Sue's

    3.8(364 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    Food was amaz, especially the candied bacon. Service was…read morerather slow. Ambiance was great. You should open another location in Manning, SC

    To be fair here, I had been telling my family I "did NOT" want to come to this establishment the…read morewhole time I was in Sumter for this trip. I've been here multiple times and did not like it. This trip was no different. We had a large group of 16 and it started there. Was told a 2hr wait. If we split in to groups of 8 we'd be seated in 45. Took this option. Actually got seated in about 25 minutes seperately. (A table of 8 that was right next to us was vacant and NEVER got used for the entire 90 minutes or so that we stayed at the restaurant so why not accommodate our group? - strike one) Our waitress I'm told was very chippy with an attitude toward some party members. (I didnt get any attitude toward me) but heard a few people stating how she was answering people's requests and how unpleasant she was. - Strike two. The food. I ordered the meatloaf nachos (which were good). I also ordered the fried pork chops w/ side salad. Loading up on fake bacon bits (like 1000 pieces) doesnt make the salad better. This is a hint to their kitchen. The pork chops were dry and the "red skinned" mash potatoes" (which I do not remember the menu stating that they were red skinned potatoes which would mean SKIN would be present in the mash. Otherwise I would not have ordered this. ALSO, their baked beans.......this was the worst part of the meal. I am expecting some version of beans with a bbq base or similar...instead I got some sort of bean SOUP which was totally inedible in my opinion. Whole meal was trash. Strike three. My 83 year old father said at the end of the meal "worst meal I've ever had". Which I had him repeat to the table just in case anyone thought it was just me. $700 with tip for the quality is a bit much. I will never ever return no matter what my siblings say.

    Photos
    Willie Sue's
    Willie Sue's - Whole fried flounder with coleslaw.

    Whole fried flounder with coleslaw.

    Willie Sue's

    See all

    Palmetto Oyster House - Crab Cakes & New Orleans-style shrimp with hush puppies, fries, and cole slaw

    Palmetto Oyster House

    3.9(201 reviews)
    0.5 mi
    $$

    Prob more like 4.5, but all in all a really great experience…read more The interior is divey in a really fun way. Plenty of space. Fun decor. Server was really nice and on top of things. I ordered a steak, broccoli and salad. The steak was a perfectly medium rare, very nicely seasoned and delicious! Broccoli was just steamed broccoli, but was still nice and crisp. Salad was small and the dressing was pretty bad. Asked for a different one and it wasn't much better. Very clearly food service bottled stuff. But really, that was the only glitch. Would for sure come back here if I'm in Sumter again.

    So we were in town for the holidays, visiting family, and popped into Palmetto Oyster House for…read moredinner - and wow, were we surprised! First off, the crab cakes were loaded with fresh crab, perfectly seasoned, and had this amazing crispy outside. Seriously, some of the best crab cakes ever! The New Orleans shrimp were awesome too - that authentic spicy kick with great herbs and spices, every bite was perfect We also got the Mahi Mahi Club, and it was a solid choice. The fish was grilled just right, and with the fresh veggies, it was super filling Even the sides were great - the coleslaw had a nice tang, the fries were crispy (though a little salty), and the hushpuppies were sweet with real corn in them. Overall, Palmetto Oyster House was fantastic - great food, great quality, and that chill Southern vibe. Definitely check it out if you're craving some amazing seafood!

    Photos
    Palmetto Oyster House - Cute decorations.

    Cute decorations.

    Palmetto Oyster House - Mahi Mahi Club Sandwich with potato salad

    Mahi Mahi Club Sandwich with potato salad

    Palmetto Oyster House - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Outback Steakhouse

    Outback Steakhouse

    2.8(126 reviews)
    0.2 mi
    $$

    Got what I ordered, super nice waitress, they were running 30 minutes behind on pick up which left…read moreme sitting in a car waiting but at least the waitress was as nice as she could be about it. I waited but haven't went back

    Who knew a casual night at the bar could turn into such a great dining experience? We arrived 1…read morehour before closing on a Saturday and the restaurant was super packed. The hostess were friendly and accommodating. My husband and I decided to skip the wait for a table and grabbed seats at the bar, and honestly, it was the best choice we made all night. The bartender wasn't just pouring drinks, she was running the whole show with top-notch service, great conversation, and attention to detail that you don't always find in a chain restaurant. Our Margaritas were perfectly balanced. The Food orders were a little off but the kitchen corrected the issues right away. My husband was missing his rice for his shrimp skewer meal and his side dish. The food came out hot and it tasted good. What really stood out was how the bartender managed to make the bar feel like the friendliest spot in the house - checking in often, making us laugh, and keeping everything smooth even when things got busy. Outback is always reliable for steaks and comfort food, but when the service is this good, it makes the whole experience that much better. If you find yourself in Sumter, skip the wait for a table and grab a bar seat - you'll thank me later.

    Photos
    Outback Steakhouse
    Outback Steakhouse
    Outback Steakhouse

    See all

    Restaurant At Second Mill - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...