Incredibly small and unassuming restaurant in a pretty small town. Luckily, my parents aren't far and we're able to order often. This is one of my favorite pizza places. I love the cheese and the chicken bacon ranch. Their wings are pretty decent, too! The garlic and cheese bread need a marinara but aren't half bad without. Love the staff too! read more

See all

Great service, pizza was surprisingly good. We really liked the crust and it was over the top with the amount of cheese. Very busy with their local clientele. Little noisy, Will definitely be back! read more

The Best Pizza and Hoagies you will ever have. Try the burnt cheese!!! The staff is always attentive and pleasant.

Love Reily Pizza. We usually just get the pizza. I haven't tried anything else on the menu. The pizza is very good. The service can depend on the timing. It is a small place but gets busy. It is a nice place to go and relax and have good puzza read more

For a small town diner and pizza place it's has some very good food. And yes it can get really busy as was the day we were in. We had the pepperoni and sausage pizza and for a place where I don't believe they make their own dough it appears they invest in some of the best ingredients because we keep going back to enjoy the food. read more

This was our first time here. We live in Kentucky but were up this way to get something we needed, and decided to stop here for food as it was highly recommended. I have an autistic child and the loud environment was too much for her and she went into meltdown. No biggie, we are used to this. I got her noise canceling headphones from the car for her and put them on her. Our waitress noticed and immediately said she'd turn the music down. I wanted to cry happy tears, as to most people her meltdowns seem like tantrums. They also have SO many coloring books and a 200 count bucket of crayons and a pack of coloring pencils for kids to enjoy while waiting for food. Our food was very delicious!!! We ordered the Hawaiian with no onion and it was so flavorful with gooey cheese. This place is absolutely amazing and we will definitely make the long drive back out here. read more

I and my Granduaghter had our first lunch today From the minute we walked in the door we felt welcomed !! The service was amazing and super polite and very helpful on helping us make our food choices. The customer were super friendly. It's a small restaurant but very inviting and it was most definitely service with a smile . They have a few big TV's where you can watch the game and a bar for all your drink needs the pizza came to our table hot a bubbly. And no need for extra cheese because it's loaded !! I would most definitely eat there again !! I would like to say a special Thank You for the gentleman sitting at the bar that paid for I and my granddaughter lunch . It was greatly appreciated!! God Bless you . And I will most definitely be paying it forward!! Wonderful 1st time experience at Reily Pizza!! read more

I love Reily Pizza. Great staff, great drinks, excellent food. If you've never been, get a pizza. You won't be disappointed. Hoagies are amazing too. Say hi to Daphne. read more

Reily Pizza - Steak hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Reily, Ohio

Great pizza. They dont short on the cheese or toppings. Service is always good and they are always polite. Has a good small town atmosphere, and is a great place to stop and grab when on cruise, or when showing someone from out of town where are the good mom and pops local resturants are. Worth the drive and if you go the right way you might see zebras in a guys back yard! read more

Great pizza, especially if you like cheese (sooo much cheese). Hoagies with pizza and mushroom sauce are also awesome. Would have been 5 stars but the service was seriously lacking. They need a better system to keep track of orders and to get the right food to the right table. Has the atmosphere of a bar not a restaurant, or they have carry out. read more

See all

I've been going to this place for years. Especially when I lived in Hanover township. The best pizza in the area. They go heavy on the cheese. Plenty of topping choices, good sauce etc. I like the way the cheese is burnt on the edge of the pizza all the way around it. It's delicious. They also have a full bar and 3-4 beers on tap served in frosty mugs. The only down part is that parking is very limited and it gets busy. Especially on the weekends. Def a must stop if you are in the area and love great pizza. read more

I love this place! Don't be surprised if you wait an hour or more ft your food. The place is tiny and loud but the good and ambiance are awesome. While you wait for your food can indulge in dollar beers on Monday nights. I will definitely be a repeat customer! read more

Reily Pizza is a great hole in the wall small town pizza place. We love their pizza, hoagies & burnt cheese. Portions are generous & so are the toppings. It's a small place & parking is lacking, so we usually get it to go. I've been going there probably 30 years but only dined inside 3 or 4 times. They have a great outside area during the summer. If you can get a table it's a great spot to hangout, enjoy a beer & some delicious food. Service is always good. The staff knows what they're doing & do it well. I'll take Reily Pizza over any of the shiny trendy places. There's a reason it's been around so long. read more

They're pizza is so good! Their bartenders are amazing and work so hard. I really enjoyed the evening spent here with my husband, listening to music, eating pizza, and just hanging out! read more

I've heard from so many people that Reily Pizza is some of the best around. It's definitely true. The toppings are so generous and it's not super greasy. I would try the steak hoagie as well, and the wings look great. This place has been around a very long time and has a lot of character, with its original wood and ovens. Good for a casual hang out and cheap beer. Smoking is still allowed inside but it's not overwhelming. This is an ideal escape from the expensive, noisy Oxford establishments. read more

Best pizza in town! Great atmosphere. Not built for the uptight white collar folk. Great service, great people! Nothing better than going out to Reilly's, phoning in a pick up order and enjoying a cold beer while waiting for the best darn pizza in the land. To those who only gave it one try, please go back and give it another go around. You won't be disappointed at all! read more

Ordered a pizza for carryout. The wait time on the middle of a Saturday afternoon was 35 minutes. The pizza tastes like it's made with run of the mill food service ingredients--the crust is especially forgettable. The real claim to fame here is the massive amount of cheese, meaning basically that any pizza you buy is comparable to at least a double cheese anywhere else. Some of it runs off the edges of the crust, browns and crisps, another plus if you like that kind of thing. The 16 inch pizza with two toppings was $23, which is pretty pricy for what it is. I wouldn't buy pizza here regularly but it's fine for a change of pace once in a while. read more

I arrived at 12:20, internet and website states open until 1:00 am, states they have "turned off their ovens" and can not serve us! I will not be back to this establishment. If your website states that you are open until 1:00am, then you should be able to serve your customers until 1:00 am. read more

I live in Georgia, and am from Ohio. The one thing they don't have here in Georgia are steak hoagies, I am told they do, but have yet to come upon any. Anytime I was in Ohio, I would make sure and go to Ival's in Ross, but then they closed (?) and my niece introduced me to this place. We always get steak hoagies when we are there, and then stop on our way back to Georgia and order at LEAST 4 more to freeze to take home to eat at a later date. My husband, whom has lived his whole life in Georgia, had never heard of a steak hoagie, now that he has, he asks, where have these been all my life. If you want a good steak hoagie, this is the place to go. Dang it, now I am craving a steak hoagie, and don't have any trips to Ohio planned anytime soon. read more

This pizza was REALLY good! I would like to try extra sauce next time because I felt like with how much cheese they use (totally not complaining...yum!), it could use more sauce. The dough is not my favorite but not the worst either. It reminded me of a flaky biscuit. read more

Friendly staff, awesome food. If you like country music this is a place for you. Good for family night or going out with friends.

Used to go here all the time and we loved the food, but something has changed. It's just not as good, we've been disappointed the last couple times we've been there. Have talked to others who agree. read more

We love the BBQ chicken pizza from here and drive over an hour to get some but last time were were there it tasted a bit different. Still good but not the same. You get a lot of food for your money. read more

Hands down, the BEST steak hoagie in the United States. Pizza is exceptional also. Of you like cheesy pizza, this is the place to go.

Great rural dive atmosphere. Sauce and toppings are above average quality. Pizza is cooked in 30 year old oven. They should Buy one level up on crust, or better yet make their own crust and charge $1 more per pizza and the rank goes to 4+ stars. Oh and on Mondays dollar domestic cans. Other days $2. Make the drive. Worth the adventure read more

They have Red Dog beer!!! And the best pizza if you like good cheesy cheesy pizza they pile about 3" of cheese on it after they put the toppings on. You will not leave hungry but you will get hungry when you get home and smell the cheese and smoke on your clothes. And it's a sweet drive to get there. read more

The pizza is VERY good! Lots of toppings, worth the time it took to cook--seemed like FOREVER. The reason for the low rating is because he patrons there are outwardly racist, inconsiderate to others with their yelling, swearing, and racial comments during a football game. Small place, need to keep the loudmouths in check. Also, there are no craft beers at all, only cheap domestics. We'll get the pizza to go from now on! It's the best around. read more

This place just stinks! From the service to the ciggy smoke they still allow! Heck, the people making the pizzas were smoking! I had heard so many good things about the place I had to check it out. I took my wife and three kids there last Mother's Day. When we got there the place had about three other people in the place. I had a beer and ordered one large and one small pizza. After an hour of waiting a large group from Indiana came in. Their pizzas came right out hot and straight to their tables. Apparently they called their order in. I waited a total of one hour and forty five minutes for two pizzas! I sent my family to the car right before our pizzas came out. After the bill came, which they offered to take nothing off the bill, I politely asked the man that rang me up if I could speak to him outside. After I got him and his mother outside I began to explain how I had heard great things about their place and had to try it out. I explained that I had to wait 1 hour and 45 minutes for two pizzas. They explained the large group phoned their order in just prior to my arrival. I told them I understand, but a mention of that when I ordered my pizza would have been nice, as I would have left had I known I was gonna have to wait almost 2 hours for pizza. I then explained that they could have comp'ed me at least some appetizers as we waited! The guy then told me that it was Mothers Day and they were short staffed, and kept making excuses for the unacceptable service. I let them know I wouldn't be back, and then they finally offered to make it up to me by giving me a pizza "next time"! Sorry there won't be a "next time" for this family! Don't bother wasting your time on this place! read more

Call & order ahead if you're worried about the wait! Or, go thirsty and enjoy some cold pitchers while your pizza bakes!

OK Riley pizzas is not fast a food restaurant so have a beer or two while you wait.y If you're in a hurry or just plain rude or inpatient you may want to go somewhere else.This one of the best places you could ever get a pizza or a steak hoagie its considered one of the best hole in the walls in Butler County.... read more

Hear a great deal about the place and since its next to Indian Ridge, thought we'd try the pizza people were talking about. The service was alright, greeted right away, but the pizza did take about an hour to make and get. The pizza oven is small , so they can only handle a couple at a time. Nothing spectacular about the pizza, the longer it sat, the soggier the crust. Not what I expected after all the talk I heard......... read more