I came to this location since it was close to Target. It is conveniently located in a strip mall so there is a ton of parking. The place was very clean. I got vanilla frozen yogurt with brownie bites and chocolate chips as toppings. It came to a little over $9. The cashier was friendly; greeted me as I entered through the door and had a smile on her face the whole time. I would definitely come back to this location. read more

6/11/25 The machines were all in service and the consistency was back to normal. Taro is truly the best flavor. One negative is that some toppings were stale. This is unacceptable given their price point. read more

Red Mango in shopping center New Hyde Park NY, has Nathaly. Give the girl a raise- she sells the product with energy and smiles. Taro a special flavor not always there. She showed me a picture of the Corm . (root) She gave me a taste cup. I found it quite delicious. Something new I hadn't known of or tried. I also added a fresh juice called sweet kale immunity, made with kale apple carrot, lemon and orange. Thing is I was able to taste each flavor in the mix. They do have an order on line as well. ( see pix) items were a bit costly but tasted really good. read more

See all

Red Mango is my thing. I prefer a yogurt over an ice cream. You have the option to taste before you commit. They have about 14 flavors of self pour options that you can combine to your taste. Flavors range from an original with a hint of sweet and tart (my fave), coconut, mango, pomegranate, chocolate, coffee...there's something for your palette. Toppings range from granola, oats, brown sugar options , fresh fruits like mangos, strawberries, raspberry...as well as shredded coconuts and candy options such as Twix, Kit Kat etc. At the counter, your completed the design is weighed. Since all cups are the same size, the difference will be on how much you added. For (2) half cups the price ranges about $11-$13. Enjoy read more

See all

Great clean environment. Huge selection of flavors and toppings. Quick service all the way.

I like to take my kids there for healthy snacks. The parking in the Plaza is very convenient. The place is kids friendly and the staff are always nice read more

The toppings was not fresh. Some of the toppings were stale. For the costs I would appreciate better quality.

I love to come here whenever I'm shopping at lake success. They have several different flavors of frozen yogurt available but I tend to be boring and stick to what I know and I love the original flavor. The interior is quite cozy and I love the new sandwich options they have here as well. Also if you want bananas in your fro-yo just ask the cashier and they'll cut it up for you fresh. The only thing that needs to be improved are the couches. They had a giant piece of fabric laid out to cover up the couch which seemed a bit weird, so I'm hoping it's just temporary. Other than that I really love coming here and I'm always greeted by someone whenever I enter. Will be back! read more

Red Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Wow sooooo I did NOT know that you could get soft serve froyo and that you could do the toppings yourself. So I was pleasantly surprised when I walked in in Sunday with my two teenagers. One of them was like hell no. The other was like BOBA!! You can't please em all I guess. They won me over. Clean with hand sanitizer everywhere. Crazy flavors from cereal to fruits I think like 6 different froyo flavors and maybe like 40/50 toppings. Weight your order (this kid got his go the top and it was only like $5). Boom. That's a good deal. Other folks were like RED MANGO!! I was like I know right. read more

Red Mango - Kiwi boba - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

I had a wonderful experience at this Red Mango store..First off I wasn't rushed liked in some other stores to choose my flavor..Employees Alex & Jen were excellent in customer service and even gave some toppings suggestions. The store was quite busy however every single customer there never felt ignored. Alex and Jen really make a great team and I'm very happy with all my different flavor Frozen Yogurt with the many toppings.. I will certainly patronize this Red Mango store above some other stores that lack in the way the staff deals with their customers... read more

See all

cleanest store I drive from far away just for this particular one. The guy that works there is very nice to always met with a smile.

My daughter loves Red Mango so we go sometimes. The only issue today was that they didn't have my favorite flavor which is honey. My daughter mixed chocolate and Nutty potion which has Nutella in it. She goes for the sweeter toppings and I try to keep it healthier with fruit but whatever your preference, they have a good Variety of both kinds. Don't forget to ask for honey on top and be ready to dig deep into your wallet. It cost $17.00 for 2 yogurts. read more

Red Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

the desert is great! but its covid actions are a bit weird. All the condiments are open and anyone can access it like a buffet and the spoons are not individually packaged. We always just ordered to go and use our own spoon. i would expect this place to follow other yogurt place where all the flavors can only be access in the back by the staff along with the condiments and each spoon is individually plastic wrapped. read more

If I could put negative stars I would, this place is legal robbery, 45 dollars for 3 cups of frozen yogurt. Not even organic or good tasting. read more

This place is pretty good. Love the spacious seating area and their frozen yogurt is always fresh and delicious. They usually have a flavor of the month. I love the refreshing peach flavor. It is always so much fun that is self serve and you get to put your own toppings on. Me and my daughter love the gummy bear toppings!!! Just be careful with your portions because everything adds up quick and I have been surprised at the price one or twice when the yogurt was weighed! They could probably do a better job at wiping down the tables. It is nice that they have a flat screen TV to watch while you sit to enjoy your treat. They also have two tables outside for outdoor seating during the warmer weather. read more

Red Mango - November 2014 - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

See all

Probably the best Red Mango and fro-yo place, in general, in the area. They a have clean, roomy store and on nice days like today they have seating out on the sidewalk in front of the store as well. They also have one of the largest selections of flavors from which to choose. In addition, they have plenty of additional toppings that you can add. If you are not in the mood for frozen yogurt, there are other things that you can munch on as well, including their much ballyhooed smoothies. I'm a fan of sweet and creamy fro-yo flavors and they have at least a handful of those from which you can choose. They also have several other refreshing fruity flavors and rotate in anywhere from 2 to 3 different/new/imited time only flavors, so you don't have to get the same thing each time. My family and I are hoping that the nice, warm weather sticks around for awhile longer so that we can make any excuse to come back to this Red Mango a few more times before winter comes roaring back. read more

Love this place so much. workers here are so kind and nice. this location is always so sweaky clean

Clean establishment but I had a weird experience with the cashier. When I went to pay for my yogurt using my American Express card, the cashier asked me if I had a different card to use .. o said no And asked her if the business didn't accept Amex She never responded to me, she took my card in the card went through! My question is what was the point of asking me to use a different card if the business accepted American Express? That was a weird question in a little bit of a awkward experience read more

I had a craving for something fruity after I finished my workout at LA Fitness which is just across the street. There was only one person working, so I had a short wait. But, he did acknowledge me as I waited at the register as he finished other orders. My order was later taken without issue, and made perfectly to my liking. Service was friendly. Will return again to get my Red Mango fix! read more

Waited one hour for my order, only to find out They were too lazy to update Grubhub menu, then was told they never received the grub hub order which is hard to believe because they canceled the order. If you can cancel it , clearly they received the order. Absurd. NEVER AGAIN read more

This red mango was the worst I've ever been to. the yogurt was icy and the manager said it was because the pipes are frozen. they are concerned with covid procedures and don't let you sample the yogurt. however, there is no toilet paper and no soap in their bathrooms. The employees had a horror movie on the rv and had murders being committed playing with customers there. Horrible. read more

Great yogurt spot to go to. Love their chai bowls but holyshit they're expensive $11 bucks for a bowl! Staff seems to be on point and help out. BUT FOR GODS SAKE PEOPLE STOP COUGHING ON THE ADD ONS!!!!!! Nasty people . And don't forget to give them your rewards number because they don't ask you for it! read more

Red Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Froyo place in lake success that's self serve, and has some good options for flavors. I'm a fan of the dark chocolate sorbetto and taro froyo personally. The smoothie menu and the sandwich menu is also convenient to have. The froyo here isn't anything crazy good but it's tasty enough for a chain. A nice place to get a less guilt inducing and healthier treat. Decent amount of toppings too, they have fruit, boba, and of course chocolates and crushed up candy bars. Downside is that it's pretty pricey for a few ounces... which is why I don't make a habit out of coming here. Clean store though, and I like that it's self serve. read more

Red Mango - Taro, strawberry sorbet, and dark chocolate sorbetto (highly recommend) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Great location especially since I work in the shopping center. It's bigger than the ones on Bell and Fresh Meadows with a lot of seats so that's a plus. I love that there is a large variety of flavors but they don't have Irish cream =( The employees are the reason why I didn't give this place a full 5 stars because they are rude. I ordered a mango smoothie and the employee looked mad and was very unfriendly...when she was finished making my smoothie it was overflowing from the lid and she just left it behind the register counter and left...wtf? I had to reach over and get it. Huge turn off... And that's the most that they do there is to make a smoothie considering that it's self serve like seriously. A few other times that I've been there they weren't very friendly as well and were just talking. read more

Red Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Red Mango has changed a lot since I've last gone to one of their establishments. They offer a variety of fresh fruit juices and smoothies, frozen yogurt with your choice of toppings, açaí bowls, and soups and sandwiches. I tried the Berry Protein Smoothie Bowl. It was really good and included frozen yogurt, peanut butter, granola, strawberries, and bananas. It was also supposed to have blueberries, but for some reason mine didn't have any and I didn't notice before I left. Anyway... the smoothie bowl was not only tasty, but also quite filling. I would definitely have it again or try another bowl. I'm also interested in trying their detox juices... If you don't mind paying the $11, try it out! read more

Red Mango - Berry Protein Smoothie Bowl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Love Red Mango. It's delicious and you feel you are eating healthy clean eats. They have a wide variety of flavors and toppings. One of my favorite flavors is Taro. The topping area is always clean and organized. There is only one size cup and pricing is based on weight so be careful how much you fill the cup and how many toppings you put in because it adds up in the end!! Love the fresh juice bar! Juices are always nice and cold. The space is bright with a lot of natural light from the windows. Nice small tables to enjoy your treat. Staff is professional. This location is set in a strip mall so you can get some shopping done as well. read more

Red Mango - Yummy!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Greek mango, strawberry and pomegranate soooooo good! The staff is amazing as well and it's clean. You just can't go wrong in here. read more

Red Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Always good and refreshing yogurt. The quality of yogurt you get is very good. The ingredients were all neatly placed in their containers. The place is well lit up and not dirty at all. The staff wasn't that friendly maybe tired. No smiles no hellos no nothings. read more

See all

I have been frequenting this Red Mango location for at least 3 years. Since the start or 2020 this location has been going downhill. It is always absolutely filthy. The "original" flavor tastes different every time I visit. It used to be my favorite flavor. Tonight it just tasted like glue. It was completely inedible. The entire floor was so sticky with visible stains and I couldn't even walk. The employees were not cleaning. He was busy chasing his girlfriend, running in the store, and lifting her up in his arms, in front of the customer. Not to mention this location is almost always empty, and I visit at different times. Please try to keep it clean and please check and see if the "original" flavor is being made and stored properly. read more

Love frozen yogurt but it was my first time trying their sandwiches. The Mediterranean one is really good. It could use a few more vegetables but it's very tasty. read more

Not sure what happened to this place. It's a shame because I used to come here all the time when it first opened, and I've always felt very satisfied with my frozen yogurt experience. However, I've noticed this Red Mango recently becoming very unsanitary. The couch is ripped and some cheap cloth has been placed over it to cover the rips up. The floor is always a mess- it's sticky everywhere, and the garbage is overflowing. Makes me wonder if anyone's even cleaning up and taking care of the place. It could really use a makeover. Quality of the frozen yogurt has declined as well, and I never see the same employees working here. Overall I wasn't left very impressed, and I don't feel I can say for sure that I'll come back. read more

I ordered two smoothies from yelp to go. The store opens at 11 and I arrived at 11:30. The store was not open so I waited 30 minutes, I went to Macy's and came back. Finally the store was open , however no one was in the front at the register. Finally after waiting about 5 mins someone came , they didn't even make my smoothie yet. Second of all he made my smoothie with the wrong ingredients. read more

Absolutely horrible customer service - the assistant manager has no idea on how to work in a retail environment. Being a patron of this location for the last year I've always found the quality of the product to be consistent and have never had an issue. However, on my last visit 1 of the flavors I ordered didn't taste right. When I went to the counter to exchange the manager could only offered me a 10% discount on my next purchase. Since I wanted yogurt now I was forced to re-purchase the yogurt again. Yup, paying twice for 1 serving. When trying to discuss how absurd I thought this was the manager said "since you're so cheap I will give you the $8 out of my own pocket". Obviously I didn't take it and obviously this manager has absolutely no real customer service experience. I run a retail store and I would never think or allow my self or employees to talk to a customer like that. I understand we all have a bad day from time to time but unfortunately when working in retail we always have to be polite, friendly and accommodating. If the franchisee or corporate office would like more detail on this experience please don't hesitate to contact me. read more

Went at 815pm to get a smoothie. Sign says they close @10pm. Guy behind the counter says ' no more smoothies.' He didn't want to clean the blender again. read more

4 months ago I left a one star review for this joint. Since then the manager has continued to harass me saying that I got the wrong place and that my review isn't correct. Now he threatens to sue me. *le sigh* If he didn't call me a liar and kindly asked me to take it down , I would have. He really need to relax and understand that establishments will sometimes get bad reviews. Well my old review has been taken down since I'm undating the review. So please stop bothering me!!! BEWARE. for your sake if you don't plan on giving a good review don't leave any at all because the manager will most likely harass you until you take it off. read more

Growing up in Bellerose, I've been visiting this Red Mango since it first opened for my frequent froyo cravings! Located right in the middle of Lake Success shopping center, it's a popular stop for people in between stores. Since my office is right around the corner, I recently popped in during my lunch break to redeem a $5 coupon I received through e-mail. They don't just serve dessert items anymore - this location has expanded their menu to include some savory sandwiches! The BBQ Chicken Flatbread is actually pretty tasty. read more

I love their tropical mango smoothie but the outcome of my smoothie was outrageous. Worker refused to change my order after confronting her of my issue with my smoothie read more

Red Mango - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

Order was cancelled due to the fact that the store was closed even though it says it was open online. Very disappointed.

I used to LOVE this place. Now I get knots in my stomach every time I come. PRO - self serve, tons of flavors/toppings, in a shopping center so plenty of parking. Ample seating with tvs. CONS - barely there staff (writing this review while I sit in RM). At the moment there is one person working here. Staff usually has an attitude. You used to have all the self serve cups on the counter to try flavors. Now, they have to get them for you and give you a tiny drop in the cup. I know people abused the freebies but I gotta tell ya, back then this place was busier. The ambiance just doesn't feel welcoming. I believe there are new owners now and maybe that's why the policies and environment has changed? Not sure but I don't come here as often as I used to. read more

Red Mango - View from my seat. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - New Hyde Park, New York

The place is completely run down. The couch is ripped and has some kind of drop cloth on it. Go to Ikea and get some furniture. Your staff is very friendly and your product is delicious but unfortunately running out of forks and spoons,( having staff 1/2 nearby restaurant to borrow some) dirty floor and ripped broken Furniture is doing you a huge disservice. read more