One of the best delis in the area, can't believe I've never been before yesterday and I live down…read morethe street! The staff is so friendly & welcoming literally everyone says hello. The food is so fresh & delish I can't wait to try more of the menu ! I had a turkey blt & it was the best one I think I ever had lol. Fresh baked goods & hot meals to go as well. Super clean and newly renovated I was impressed

Went there on my way home from work and wanted a sandwich I…read moreused to go a lot but stopped for some reason but glad i went Back I got the 6 inch chicken cutlet with fresh mozzarella and roasted red peppers I think I got more then 6 inches but so good I am not complaining It was fresh warm and delicious the place is cool and you can eat inside if you want The service is great and I will be Back

Old school italian deli. Cash only. Got eggplant parm. On a long roll…read more Had to be one of the best eggplant parm. I ever had besides my mother's. Crispy bread,eggplant packed in. $10.50. Excellent friendly staff, great prices,and good food. Definitely will be back.

They didn't have what I was looking for - roast beef club - so they did their best to approximate…read moreit, and here's the kicker: this was $11. Look at the pictures. These days you can't open your front door and take a deep breath without it costing you more than $11. Look at the size of this sandwich! I don't know how they do it, but this place is absolutely recommended. Talk about bang for your buck, and GOOD! Please go and enjoy.

As a long standing Customer of "Garruttos" since closed which was originally in Newark moved to…read moreNutley, I never found myself searching for a replacement. Stopped in this past Saturday for our Tailgate Sausage & Meats and boy was I shocked! Small little storefront, free parking in back makes this easy on a street with limited access to parking. Old style Butcher specializing in pork products with prepared foods, dry & canned Italian products as well as olive oils etc. Very nice couple I assume were husband & wife handled my order which included Hot & Sweet Sausage, skinny sausage wheels with parsley & Cheese as well as some other stuff for our tailgate as well. Store is clean and everything in the case looks fresh. The sausage itself was by far some of the best we have ever had & better than any other butcher shop around that we have tried. I look forward to trying out some of their other products in the future.

Local staple. My go-to Italian deli for a nice chicken cutlet, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella w…read more Balsamic sandwich. Owner is nice, ambiance is deli vibes

Was craving an Italian sub, so I ordered one from this place on Uber Eats and had it delivered…read more This sandwich did not disappoint. Ham, cappicola, salami, prosciuttini, provolone piled high with lettuce, tomato, oil and vinegar, and oregano. Wow, this sandwich was huge and it was just a half. I will be ordering from here in the future without a doubt. I think I just found my new favorite sandwich shop.

Got the Larry David (pastrami), was a bit suspicious that a pastrami sandwich came with cheese…read more... Full hero for$24+tax tip (inflation and tariffs suck), sliced cold then warmed pastrami over cheese in hero. Not what I was expecting, will go to a real pastrami place next time. Otherwise a standard hero place, looked like they had decent hero/sandwich choices. Maybe I got the wrong sandwich, but it was just ok.

Absolutely delicious food; big fan of their breakfast/omelette platters, and one of my favorite…read moreorders is the pepperoni & egg sandwich on a roll with cheddar and salt, pepper, ketchup added. Very much worth a try.

First and foremost, I love local deli's. They can be the heart of the community. This place is…read morepretty decent. I've been ordering breakfast meals from here over the last several weeks and I haven't had a bad experience at all. The food has been good and freshly prepared. The service has been good, fast, and professional. Some of the prices on the snakes are a bit pricey, but of course a snack is optional and not necessarily needed.

Amazing bread, amazing meat, amazing deli. Must try the cappy's American or the cappy's Italian…read more Quick and reasonably priced if you are in the area and craving a sub.

They make the best sandwiches. Most places are cheap with the deli meat, and I am always amazed…read moreabout how full I am after eating. Sadly, they are selling the business, but I will recommend trying it before they do. I'm honestly scared. It's gonna turn into something else.. I hope whoever decides to buy this business keeps it the same. It's right at the end of KEARNY and such a welcoming place. The owners are always kind to my kiddos and very family friendly. It has an old school vibe, but it is perfectly clean! I highly recommend you give this place a try you won't be disappointed I promise.

Came across this deli when I was in need of a SANDWHICH. this did not disappoint I got the terrayki…read moresandwich and it was so fresh and really good. 10/10 recommend

A hidden gem in my opinion. I first got introduce to this location back when I was in middle…read moreschool. Now a college student who has moved from Belleville, I still find myself making the drive down here for the chicken cutlet and fries. The gentleman who works the counter is always happy to be there and greets everyone like family. I still introduce everyone to this location. I normally take out but they have plenty of tables to sit down with an amazing selection of drinks.

Petraccos is quickly becoming a go-to for me in town…read more I've tried their eggplant rolatini which was made fresh and deliciously. It came with bread and a nice sized salad. It was great, good sauce and a generous portion. Their sandwiches are fantastic too. Bread is really good and they stock pile the ingredients. I got a turkey and provolone with everything and on it and it was delicious. Also a great portion. Staff is friendly and helpful and I'll definitely be back to try more menu items.

Excellent neighborhood Italian deli in Nutley. Feels like you're stepping back in time. Great…read morefood and neighborhood friendly service. Hot and cold sandwiches, hot meals or cold ones you can reheat. Italian cold cuts and salads. Plenty of drinks, sweets, and chips for lunch time. They also cater which looks very good as well. Nutley specializes in Italian Deli's and this is a good one. They have newspapers too which isn't a guarantee anymore. If you need lunch or a pre made or hot meal this is a great place.

I spend my Saturday mornings collecting delicious ingredients for the week ahead. This week, I…read morefound Mastriano's on Yelp and decided to give it a try. Very cool "old school" butcher and sandwich shop! Staff were pleasant and professional. I purchased Berkshire pork chops, prime New York strip steaks, and a rack of pork ribs. All of it looks great! The sandwich list was too good to pass up, so I got a chicken cutlet, mortadella, broccoli rabe, and fresh mozzarella wrap. All of the ingredients were top notch and the flavors came together really well! Will gladly return to Mastriano's!

Excellent small deli, but a huge menu compared to its size. Really, well run…read more It's not cheap, but nothing is these day, and the pricing is absolutely fair.