Glad I'm the first to review this spot, I met Anthony (owner) when I first moved to City Island,…read morethis was previously a discount store which I thought he did a fabulous job of running. He had told my husband and I about his plan to turn it into what is now "A taste of Italy" and we couldn't wait. It is officially opened now and is exactly what city island needed. Again, this is a new spot so the shelves weren't fully stocked but totally understandable. I had an Italian hero with salami, ham & fresh mozzarella and it was delicious! Major kudos to Anthony again for making this happen and bringing a taste of Italy to city island!! We'll definitely be back for more amazing sandwiches and fresh mozzarella very soon since it is walking distance from our house!

Amazing pizza. My kids love picking up a slice or a sandwich on the way back home and sit outside…read more Very friendly staff and great Mozzarella cheese..... oooohh don't forget to try the rice balls yum .

sandwiches always good, people always friendly :)…read more great place for six foot party subs

Be careful when ordering special request. Nobody reviews the…read moreorder. I asked for extra meat, cheese, fried peppers on a chicken parm, I got ugotz . And charged for nothing. That's good business. Beware

Vito's is very delicious and just down the street! Wish they kept better hours but will be back!read more

I really like this place and the service is great. The owners super nice. They sell sandwiches,…read moredesserts, hot food and meats. I've gotten the ground pork in the past and it tasted super fresh. Recently I've fallen for the chicken alla vodka and the chocolate chip cookies. I've gotten ice cream there during the summer too. I like that there's a place like this in the neighborhood. If you haven't tried I'd recommend visiting. I hear the Mac and cheese is pretty good too.

My go to deli, they make the best sandwiches here. Everyone is always so friendly and service is…read morequick. My husband usually orders the hot chicken cutlet on a roll, lettuce, tomato, mayo with muenster cheese or the hot roast beef on a roll, lettuce tomato, mayo, and swiss cheese. I love the chicken and beef sandwiches too, but I usually order their chopped cheese on a roll with everything on it. Can't go wrong here. Such a great spot!

I realize I might be an oddball in this respect, but sometimes, a single individual can really and…read moretruly make my day. We made an emergency stop on a Monday evening -- not for food or drink, but because Progeny 1 had an urgent request for a bathroom. (Parents, you know the kind: where you have 1 minute lead time before the Apocalypse takes place.) The gas station we'd mapped to nearby did not appear to have one, so grasping at straws, we ran to the very civilized- / clean-looking Midland Fresh Market next door. The wonderful clerk at the register saw the look upon our faces, interrupted a transaction to hand us a key, and waved us to the bathroom at the back immediately, no questions asked. Afterwards, we purchased something of course. There's a beautiful, spotlessly clean deli counter to one side offering pristinely fresh salads, either prepackaged or made to order; subs and other sandwiches; wraps; burgers; gyros; wings; quesadillas, etc... all at reasonable prices. Per the store's website (http://www.midlandfreshmarket.com/Midland-Fresh-Market-Menu.html), they open at 5:30 a.m. have breakfast sandwiches, pancakes, French toast, coffee, etc... on the menu then. There's a neatly organized grocery section, including a fresh produce section, dairy section, plenty of dry goods, and posher packaged bakery items (e.g. black and white cookies, pastries). We picked up drinks and snacks for a bit less than we would've at a gas station. The cashier was a saint and dealt with some difficult customers ahead of me with patience and unflappable kindness, all while somehow keeping tabs on Progeny 1, who was cold and (with permission) had slipped out the door and back to the car. He mentioned that he had two young children, as well, hence his well developed spidey senses for the whereabouts of minors! What a great human! Borrowing my Yelp friend, Hannah's, review system: + LOVELY HUMANS WORK HERE (at least one at the registers on July 21, 2025 at 8 p.m.) + Very fresh salad ingredients with an option for build-your-own salads + Great place to stop for a quick, reasonably priced meal in transit + Healthy, reasonably priced snacks and drinks on offer The Pardner bookmarked the place for a return visit.

I simply cannot believe how good this place is! I need to go here every week for the rest of my…read morelife! Everything this counter-service deli serves is simply mind blowing!! I know it's a trek, but if you ever get up to north Bronx, do yourself a favor and cross right over into southern Westchester County to pick up some Italian amazingness from this place. You can't go wrong with anything here, but my favorites include the stuffed mushroom, rice balls, and Italian Stromboli (like an Italian sub stuffed in the most tasty bread crust you will ever eat)! The rice balls and Stromboli should be eaten with marinara, by the way... but that should be a given! I LOVE THIS PLACE!

This is a small authentic Italian delicatessen located on a very busy road on the border between…read moreYonkers and the Bronx. Our Italian-American family comes here specifically for the handmade fresh mozzarella, which didn't disappoint, until recently. My parents had a bad experience about a month ago. They ordered, had the guy behind the counter bag it, paid and left. When they got home, anticipating that fresh and mouth watering mozzarella taste, they realized it was definitely NOT fresh. Maybe a fluke. Because they have been churning out fresh mozz for years! My wife enjoys the seafood salad behind the glass at the Deli counter. She claims it's the best in Yonkers. One can also buy Italian pantry goods here like, dry pasta, canned Italian imports and glassed Italian imports. Also frozen raviolis/meat/cheese/lobster/mushroom flavored are in the fridge. It's a busy deli especially around the holidays, so I suggest planning ahead; think Christmas/Easter. It's not cheap! But it's mostly good and authentic Italian based deli. I ordered and Italian Combo and brought it home for our teenaged son (13) and he DEVOURED IT!! You will pay high prices. But you will receive good customer service and high quality prepared Italian deli specialities. Buon Apetito!

I Order Sal's Hero the best roast beef white american cheese they…read more Put my tomatoes on the side.Sal John they all know me I recommend you will not be DISAPPOINTED

Very nice Italian deli here. Stopped in a couple times. Very clean and friendly atmosphere. Ordered…read morea couple Italian combo heroes and they were packed nicely with mozzarella and roasted peppers. Another time ordered a couple chicken parm heroes and they were REALLY good! Nice job guys! Well done. They have a nice selection here and the service is good. Really good food with very fair prices. I stop in when I can. The outdoor seating is a nice touch...and you can relax and eat your lunch.

Stopped in for the first time today with my boyfriend. And i must say we are truely satisfied.. I…read moregot a bacon cheeseburger with fries and he got pernil with rice and beans.. Both were amazing I was not in the mood for cooked food so i got a burger but man do i wish i got the same as him. We were given a great amount of food and are total stuffed and full. The man and lady inside are very nice and friendly and prices are great. We definitely be back to try everything else really soon PS: finished our food before I found this Update:went back today for more

Gerry pizza is great I can't stop going there for the souperbowl we order a sausage pizza it was…read moregood it did not take long we took the pizza home enjoy it

I ordered a To Good To Go order from 3 Guidos and it was delicious. Chicken Parm with very tender…read morethin cutlets, fresh mozzarella. They also included a tortellini vodka with sausage that had some kick. Two hard rolls complimented the order. All very tasty. This is a very local spot for me. Very friendly counter guy, quick service. Very clean inside. Good specials, all look fresh! Boars head products. I will buy more from this deli. Patronize this local business! They are all disappearing and this one is old school Yonkers like you remember: IYKYK.

Unreal value at $10 per sandwich, I couldn't believe the quality and the amount of food I got for…read moretwenty bucks. Italian combo was a work of art, delicious: cappicola, mortadella, and sopresetta with provolone cheese... the menu says to choose your own meats and cheese... i would change that immediately and promote the one they make if you leave it up to them like I did, but that's for them to decide.. tuna sub was good but not great... more lettuce than tuna. Next time I'll try the cutlets. Overall I thought the bread was great (seeded and fresh) Italian combo 9/10, if they loaded it up a little more it would be 10/10... tuna I wouldn't get again but overall I was a big fan.