Mastered what they have to offer, just wish they would change it up and not play it as safe.

Prohibition River has gone so far down. Paid 100.00 for 2 drinks, a burger, and the worst kale salad I've ever had.

I really liked this place!! We went after a hike near Nyack so we were STARVED. The service was quick and waiter was so nice! The food was BOMBBBB. You must get the wings and the short rib quesadilla- note it has horseradish so that threw me off a bit but it was sooooo tasty. The prohibition burger was delish as well! I had the fried chicken sandwich but I prob wouldn't recommend cause I just feel like they did the other items better! read more

See all

This place is awesome!! I live in Philly but every visit to Nyack deserves a stop at PR! great people!! read more

Came here for a quick pick me up aka a beer. Loved that they had different variations of beer. Had some wings. Frank some beer. Had awesome conversations. It was a good day to be at prohibition River read more

It's ok place, bartender ( mid age man) is great. Food is so so. Drinks were amazing read more

Prohibition River - Negroni and Margarita - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

Amazing vibes and service. In the heart of Nyack and located central to everything. The bar is fully packed and the ambiance is cool and casual. Only downside is they do not have a lot of gluten free options, but I was able to get a tasty Beet and Apple salad that was to die for! Get the red sangria pitcher too! $28 and my boyfriend and I got about 3.5 glasses each read more

Prohibition River - Sangria pitcher - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

I stumbled upon this bar/restaurant thanks to Yelp while bar hopping in Nyack and I'm glad I did. This place has a cool, classy vibe. Think speak easy with a touch of Great Gatsby. Kind of hipster, but in a good way. They have these cool and intimate booths that would be great for dinner for a date or to celebrate a special occasion. I sat at the bar, it was early in the night so it wasn't busy yet. They have an extensive wine and beer menu and unique specialty drinks. The drinks were well made and strong. The Mac & Cheese was excellent (see photo). Simple but yet so good. The best thing I ordered was the Prohibition burger. This was not your regular ole burger. It was so flavorful and juicy. I highly recommend it. You better believe I will be back to try the "Grilled cheese shots". read more

See all

Top notch! Great options, check that menu out!! I got the Brussels sprouts, which were delightful. Also got the grilled cheese shots, which was two sandwiches (four half slices), sitting in a shot glass with tomato soup filling the glass :0 My entree was the largest pork belly I've ever had. Quite fatty, which I guess is to be expected from pork belly. Ask for extra BBQ sauce. Got the giant pitcher of Sangria, which was a great money deal! Tastes fresh and not over-sweet. Definitely recommend. Waiter was great, place was clean, sound level was good, ambiance was great! Definitely the place to visit if living there or just driving g through. read more

Prohibition River - Delightful appetizers! Brussel sprouts and grilled cheese shots - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

Stopped by on a chilly Saturday afternoon for lunch before heading back to Connecticut. Very cool vibe inside with window seating, which I was lucky enough to snag a seat by. Service was comfortably slow, and despite the little waits it gave you time to soak in the coming's and going's of Nyack. Food and drinks were delicious! My husband ordered a beer, and myself the Sparkling White Cosmo. I'm not a big vodka drinker, but something about this drink caught my eye, and I'm so glad I tried it. For lunch, my husband ordered the Steak Frites and was raving about how good it was. I ordered the 82 Main Grilled Chicken Sandwich, which was good, but the lettuce got soggy quickly. The chicken could have used more seasoning as well. For dessert we ordered the Apple Pie Eggrolls, which were pretty good. A little burnt and the apples needed more cinnamon sugar, but still yummy. Next time I'm in Nyack, this will definitely be a place I would consider coming back to! read more

See all

a solid gastropub with a variety of options. the star of our meal were the prime rib empanadas stuffed with tender meat and balsamic onion jam. the jam was beyond: sweet and savory! sandwiches were good...I tried the oyster mushroom sandwich (note that there are no oysters!) and the delicate mushrooms were lightly breaded and perfectly fried. plenty of outdoor seating and dog friendly! read more

Prohibition River - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

Food is good, vibe is nice, drinks are okay- slightly watered down. But there aren't many amazing places in Nyack downtown for American food. read more

Prohibition Burger offers the best reward after a great day of hiking at Harriman State Park! It's one of those menus that you just stare at and keep saying "oh my god" to you table mates. Luckily we snagged the last of the special egg rolls, Short Rib with Mac n' Cheese. They come with a home made ranch dressing which was amazing. Then I had the Prohibition Burger, which was cooked perfectly. The beer cheese wasn't as flavorful as I was hoping, but the homemade seasoned pickles were a nice touch and I'm obsessed with onion jam!! My boyfriend had the Belly Buster Burger, and I snagged a bite...also freaking amazing! The only thing I was disappointed by was their fries. They just weren't great and didn't have much flavor or seasoning. But the ketchup did have a nice flavor to it. To finish things off I had a Pumpking IPA, which I've had before, but the cinnamon sugar rim really added a new depth and flavor to it. Definitely stop by if you're in (or near) Nyack!! Super cool small town vibe with really nice staff. read more

See all

after a 5 mile hike with the family we were ready to show off our hard by eating lol. So we had to make sure our choice for brunch was the right one. Our first choice only served for pick up which led us to Prohibition. And honestly I'm glad that happened because this spot definitely was the best choice. Great service, cool environment with a night life feel but still kid friendly. They were great with making sure everyone was comfortable with safety precautions for Covid. Me and the lady had the Shrimp Po Boy and the kids had the Chicken Sandwich's. All served in great time, great temperature with a picture worthy decor (the french fries were perfect). I highly recommend this spot for brunch and I look forward to putting the kids to bed one night and seeing what the after hour vibes are like. read more

Prohibition River - Classic Grilled Chicken Sandwich Hand Cut Fries - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

Had high hopes but the food while decent isn't worth raving about and the service we had definitely left us unimpressed. Quick to take drink orders and apps to be brought out, but not a very attentive server, long time for them to come back to take the main course orders, so accordingly long wait. Our neighborhood table did seem to have a better service so perhaps bad luck for us... read more

We were the only ones in there on a late Wednesday afternoon. Very nice ambiance. BUT what bothered me is the bartender charged $20 for a shot of Widow Jane 10 year bourbon that costs $40 for a whole bottle. That is a rip off in my opinion. $12-$15 would have been maybe ok, but $20 for Widow Jane 10 year??!! When I asked him why, he just shrugged his shoulders. I was treating the other 3 folks so did not want to make a big stink..... read more

It seems insane that this was the first time I've ever eaten at Prohibition River. I'm in Nyack EVERY DAY and I've heard great things about the food. But, I had just never pulled the trigger on going there. We decided to go for dinner last night and I'm really glad we did. It was delicious. I started with a cocktail called The 82 Main - bourbon, aperol, vermouth and bitters - it was great but I would have liked a splash of citrus, maybe grapefruit. Hands down, the highlight of the meal was the buffalo cauliflower bite appetizer. They had all the heat and zing of wings but with cauliflower that still had a little crunch to it. And the way the blue cheese just sorta melted on top was divine. The fish sandwich "aka Hook, Line and the Kitchen Sink" was fried to perfection with light breading and quite a nice size piece of fish. I appreciate the fact that the bun was even "scooped out" a little to make room for all the sandwich insides and to cut down on the bread. Overall, quite a good meal and I would definitely return to try the cauliflower steak entree. read more

See all

Spent yesterday afternoon wandering around Nyack and became a bit hungry. Spotted Prohibition River and decided to stop in. Well, not exactly the restaurant, it was more like a table that we liked. The front is open and the table was located inside but close enough to the sidewalk where we could look out but be isolated from the commotion. For us, this was enough. I had no expectations of the food or drink and was thrilled just finding a cool location to chill out. The restaurant itself is beautiful. Kind of like an upscale Irish Pub with a bit more refinement. Dark paneling, vintage Guinness posters and large leather upholstered booths abound with a spacious bar area and tables close to the street. Again, no expectations. Friendly waiter brought the menus and I was mildly surprised that I could order brunch mid afternoon. For $15 had what was probably the best bacon, sausage & cheddar omelet I have ever eaten with potatoes that were, for lack of a better work, spectacular and a free Bloody Mary that I would have gladly paid for because it too was excellent. Our waiter mentioned that we missed the mark because he thought the short rib hash was even better than what we ordered and what we ordered was amazing. I have not had a go to place in Nyack for quite a while. That ended yesterday. I highly recommend Prohibition River and cannot wait to return there soon to try their hash. Great, great place. read more

We were a party of10 and 3 boys had the steak and fries at $36 to $38 a plate which was tasteless and was ordered medium rare but this thing was still alive and when I told the waitress we got no satisfaction the short rib was dry and covered in some thick gravy that was as thick as molasses We were not happy on our Saturday night read more

New ownership... terrible service. Stopped in on a particularly busy Sunday afternoon. The owner told us there would be a wait as they were backed up in the kitchen. We said we understood, he sat us at a table immediately and we placed our order. At first the water brought to our table was in a dirty carafe. We asked the owner if we could instead place an order for soda, he said we would have to wait for our server to ask for that. 45 minutes later and still no food. We asked the owner how much longer we could expect to wait. His only response was 'I told you it would be awhile'. After an hour of total wait time, and seeing several tables around us being served food who had been seated after us, we again approached the owner and asked for the status of our food. His only response again was 'I told you it would take awhile'. We were so hungry we decided to leave and on our way out the owner could only be bothered to shout after us 'please don't come back'. Don't worry, we won't. read more

Elevated pub food with good spirit selection, though I didn't try the cocktails, but it didn't seem like the bartender was a mixologist. The draft selection was limited. Sat at the bar and the service was good. Seemed like a nice spot to hang out, though I could also see it getting packed. read more

I obviously need to visit and explore Nyack more often. I only go down to Nyack for one reason and one reason only, 4th of July. However, today was a little more special because I was meeting with a friend and we randomly chose this restaurant. I won't beat around the bush. I will definitely be back here. I ordered the Half Roasted Chicken and it's EXACTLY what I wanted; very well done, juicy, just the right amount of seasoning and spices. Their macaroni and cheese was very delicious and our waitress was the sweetest. I really liked her baby blue nail polish. I'm definitely going back to try the steak and some of their drinks. Our waitress recommended that we come on a Friday or Saturday night.. So it's a date! Looks like I won't have to keep traveling to NYC to get a little f*cked up! Woohoo! read more

Prohibition River - Look at this amazing dish! - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

Staff was really nice. Drinks tasty. The food was awesome. The rib eye empanadas with au jus...yummy. love the wings!!!! Nice place to chill. read more

I took a trip to nyack not knowing what to expect. The list of small plates was unique. Me and my date ended up ordering a few small plates, a side and a entree. Everything was flavorful and the restaurant itself had a relaxing and inviting look. I would definitely recommend this place. It may be a bit pricy but well worth it. read more

Meh. I think our waiter was new but he was generally clueless. We were a party of 4 but two of us showed up first. He seated us and then started to tell us the whole schpeal about what they were out of (which included several veggie and non meat items, making ordering options very limited for half our party). I stopped him and asked him to wait until everyone had showed up. Then he only brought two waters instead of water for the whole table so when our party showed up they had to wait for him to wander back to ask him to bing for their waters. Appetizer came out wrong - asked for no bacon and it had bacon. They remade it but still a strike. Portions were fine but since they were out of cauliflower and salmon there were not a lot of non-meat options. read more

Solid place. Gotta love their take on classic pub food. I tried their mac and cheese, really good! The wings were great, and the prohibition burger is a show stopper. I was also eyeballing their Sunday brunch menu and there are a lot of tasty looking options that are really reasonably priced and even include one breakfast cocktail. Ill be back for that. I was also quite surprised that there was no wait for this place on Sunday like at 1:00. The service was good, food great, decent prices and the place looks nice inside as well read more

Prohibition River - Dry rub wings. Pretty good! - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

See all

Hreat atmosphere. Quiet on a Tuesday night. The food was on point, and the I wish I could remember our server's name, because she was awesome, knowledge and took care of us. read more

Prohibition River - Short Rib Mac n Cheese and Dry-rub wings! - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

Food very poor and bad my son get cheese burger as say mcd is better my wife a salad was greasy and I get a steak was well done I requested medium rare Nyack don't have any good restaurants all they suck read more

Prohibition River - Steak - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

So my husband and I stopped am here today after walking the street fair like we normally do and I have to say we were so disappointed. We go and understand it's super crowded but we sat and she took our drink order 30 minutes later didn't get any drinks walked by us a hand full of times and didn't even ask to take our order. We got up and left and my husband told her to cancel the order and didn't even flinch and told the bar tender to cancel. She apparently didn't give a ... so we left. So so disappointed Bc I was looking forward to there food. read more

Stopped in last minute on a Tuesday around 4. Was pretty much empty so we sat at the bar. Bartender was nice and we enjoyed the atmosphere. We ordered a Nyack gentleman (bar drink), short rib quesadilla and a tater tot appetizer. Food was good, we enjoyed both dishes. My drink unfortunately was for lack of a better word, terrible. It might be worth another shot, but I'd likely try some other options in the area first. read more

I would give this place more stars but there were flies bothering me and my date during our meal. Took a while to get our beer/wine, and for our food to arrive. The food is alright, it's home made and that literally means a lot. Prob won't be back, but I'm happy I went! read more

See all

Rating on service not food - I literally had a drink here and the bartender was friendly. Ambiance was great unfortunately I got here too late and the kitchen closed read more

Prohibition River - Double makers served neat - Gastropubs Near Me - Nyack, New York

This place is sooo good! The food is incredible. Burgers was one of these best I've ever had. Very friendly staff. oh and the bourbon selection is off the charts. My new favorite spot in Nyack! read more

It's always happy hour here in prohibition river. Since I had to go back to work, I settled for a cold glass of water instead of there $5 drafts or $6 mixed drinks. On Sundays they serve half off bottle of selected wines. I had the grilled chicken sandwich. This had grilled chicken, peaches, goat cheese and mixed greens with ranch dressing on a baguette. Chicken was grilled to perfect. The combination of sweetnees from peaches and bitterness from mixed greens is surprisingly very good. The golden fries were very good too. It waa fried to perfection; not oily. I mixed the overly sweet ketchup with siracha and it was amazing. My waitress was very sweet and attentive and made sure everything was going well. Definitely coming back for lunch or dinner. read more

See all

Service could be questionable but this place makes up for it with the food. The short rib egg rolls w beer cheese were insane good. I'm a burger snob and the Prohibition Burger was also grade A. Skip the Fried green tomatoes. Nobody's perfect. read more

This was a nice surprise. The food was great and the drinks were strong. The ambiance was very nice for a gastropub. We will be back to sample more menu items. read more

What a great night. We were at Prohibition River last night and the food was really good. We started with 3 appetizers for the table. Roasted Brussels Sprouts (without the bacon though), buffalo cauliflower bites and the shells and cheese. I honestly can say that I cannot recommend one over the other. They ALL really THAT good. I had the classic burger and it was very, very good. Everyone else had the southern fried chicken sandwich which they said was very good too. What made our visit to Prohibition River so good was that our waitress was excellent. Her recommendations were spot on from drinks to food to dessert. It's a cool place and you know you'll always get a good meal. I will definitely be back! read more

Delicious food, quick and friendly staff, indoor or outdoor seating options, average pricing. Would recommend and would go back. read more

See all

What a gem. Great space, friendly staff and great, interesting food. Located in a part of Nyack filled with restaurants, desert shops, music venues, etc. Bacon meatballs and Prohibition egg rolls were both outstanding. The duck breast hero was as delicious as it was unusual and unexpected. Definitely going back to check out the burgers and chicken sandwich. I strongly recommend that anyone looking for a restaurant in Nyack, check it out! read more

Wow! If you're looking for a casual place that has spectacular food with a great vibe you are going to feel very at home. We had the mac & cheese bacon egg rolls, the lollipops which was spicy sausage wrapped in bacon with a homemade dipping sauce, the short ribs (Fantastic) and the Prohibition burger. Everything was flavorful, fresh and hot, plus the food came out fast. We had a lot of driving to do so we didn't drink much but the beer selection is ample and creative and the one glass of Merlot certainly did the trick. Wow! read more