Prime 239 Let me start by saying this place was simply amazing in all aspects of our dining experience. The service, the food, the ambience are just simply amazing. Even the drinks were served in chilled glasses. We stopped by for our Anniversary dinner. This place was neat and clean and very elegant. Once we were seated Jay or server came over to bring us bread and get our drink orders. Our drinks were out fast, then Jay took our food order. I ordered the Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail for Appetizer to share. For our main course I got the 12oz Ny Strip med well with a Lobster Tail on top and the wife got the 6oz Filet Mignon med well with a Lobster Tail on top. For our sides we got the Baked Potato and Honey Buttered Baby Carrots. Now for the review starting with the Bread, it was warm, fresh and very good. The Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail was spectacular in size and served chilled. Our Lobster was done perfect and served with hot butter. The Steaks were done to perfection very good and tasty. The Baked Potato was served with Sour Cream Butter on the side. The Carrots were al dente and so tasty. All our food was hot and so flavorful. Jay, our server was right on point with service. This entire night was perfect thanks to Prime 239. I have reviewed over 187 places in the southwest Florida area, and this makes the top 5. If I could give this place 6 stars I would but I must give it a 5 plus. I can't wait to go back. + Gulf Coast Terry read more

See all

Finding genuinely good quality, great-tasting food in Cape Coral has been a three-year struggle for us--until now. We chose Prime 239 Steakhouse to celebrate our 26th Anniversary, and the entire experience was nothing short of extraordinary. I want to mention that our waitress, forgive us because we forgot your unique name, YOU WERE EXTRODINARY AND WE LOVED YOUR SERVICE! After three years of searching, we finally found genuinely great-tasting food in Cape Coral at Prime 239 Steakhouse. We celebrated our 26th Anniversary here, and the entire experience was nothing short of extraordinary. From the moment we walked in, the hospitality was rare and exceptional--they even had a handwritten "Happy Anniversary" card waiting at our table. Our server (forgive us for forgetting your unique name, but you were OUTSTANDING!) and the entire supporting staff delivered a masterclass in service: attentive, seamless, and genuinely warm. The ambiance is also perfect: comfortable, not too loud, and just right for a family gathering. My husband is the steak guy of our group. He said its a 10. He mentioned, "the lobster topper added to this steak, it pairs well and the steak is just juicy and perfect". Phenomenal and perfectly cooked, just as the reviews say, but the whole menu shines. Our party loved the delicate scallop dish, and even the hamburgers (consider offering shoe string fries or steak fries). We enjoyed the house seasonal specialty drinks and sampled the majority of the dessert menu -- creme Brulé' was spot on and the apply dessert is a definite must try). While we are a hard-to-please group and had a couple of minor personal notes, the overwhelming, unanimous vote is an enthusiastic FIVE STARS and a plan to return. If you want exceptional food paired with world-class service, this is the place. read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Excellent experience! Our server, Happy was great. We ordered a nice wine and actually had it served in lovely stemware! It seems like this is a rare thing these days, so we were pleasantly surprised. The wagyu filet was the best we have had and we have enjoyed many! Sides were all delicious especially the creamy spinach, Brussels sprouts, steak fries and buttery mashed potatoes. We'll definitely be back! read more

This review is for our meal a few months ago: We went here for our very first real date night since having our daughter. By real date night, I mean it was just my husband and I! Our daughter is 4 years old so yes, it's been a long time. Anyway, as former New Yorkers who used to love going to steak houses, we were excited to try Prime 239. It did not disappoint as far as Cape Coral! What a gem. Appetizers and drinks were delish. Steak was cooked perfectly, we got medium rare per usual.Only thing was they do not offer porter house for 2 which we always get so that was disappointing . Portions were huge. The cheesecake for dessert was so-so, I would try something else next time. Waiter was attentive and great. Nice ambiance. We will be back when we have another date night opportunity. read more

See all

Amazing restaurant with fantastic staff! They hosted our company Christmas party everything was Devine! read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

239 is a very enjoyable restaurant. I decided to make a reservation this time because the night before when I went to the steakhouse, it was packed. As I drove into the parking lot, the lot was completely full. After about ten minutes I was able to park. I still arrived 15 minutes early and they immediately got me in. This was a surprise! The friendly waitress immediately took my drink and appetizer order. After about 30 minutes or so, she took my food order. I did have to wait almost 45 minutes for my food order since it was busy. It was well worth the wait! I had ordered the Pork Tomahawk! It was very delicious, filling, and presentable! Great experience! read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Their signature gold emblem stamped into every table. - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Another wonderful experience at Prime 239. This has become our favorite special occasion restaurant. Special of the night was kangaroo. Everyone enjoyed their meal. Food and service were top notch! Our server was the best! We will be back! read more

See all

Decided to do an early Father's Day dinner since we are busy on Father's Day. We picked Prime 239 since hubby liked it from his visit about two months after they opened. Glad to see they are doing well. As always, hubby ordered a martini to start. When it came, I noticed no ice chips! Perfecto! The martini was made well! We really wanted to try the grilled artichoke but decided not to as we weren't sure it was done the way we liked. We opted for pork belly and beef tartare. Pork belly looked good, jt had the right color tone, however, even though I like salty food, this pork belly was a bit too salty for me. Alto, this was perhaps the most lean pork belly I ever had! It needed a little bit more fat! Beef tartare was good, just wished there was a couple more bread pieces, or less holes, so we could actually used the all tartare with bread. Really wishthere was a raw quail egg on beef tartare but most restaurants seem opted out of raw egg nowadays. Sad! For our entree I opted for lamb chop and hubby ordered the New York Strip with Foie gras on top! Both were a little over cooked. The Foie Gras though, it was a "wow" surprise, it was the seared foie gras we love so much but hard to find in many place! Wish they would put seared Foie Gras as appetizer on the menu, I would come back just for that! Service was attentive. Overall, we had a nice dinner, but next time if we want a great steak, either we grill at home or head to Capital Grill. read more

See all

The best meal I've had in Cape Coral! Yes it is expensive. Yes everything is a la carte. The sides are large so they can be shared. My New York strip was so tender and flavorful that I think it was worth every dime! Great wine selection too. read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Great special occasion dinner! - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Recently I patronized Prime 239 Steakhouse. I've harbored a desire to dine at 239 for some time now. I invited a friend to accompany me to satisfy my desire and share an evening of fine dining. I ordered a Steak , my friend ordered Salmon. My steak was delicious ! My friend responded with a ditto for the Salmon. I had a spicy "jalapeño corn" side dish that I thoroughly enjoyed. The ambiance was what I expected , nice , very nice. There was a lounging area near the bar to sit , relax and enjoy an after dinner adult beverage. The service was very courteous and attentive. There was only one minor complaint. I ordered a glass of water without ice. I took one drink and thought it was , excuse my French , toilet water. Uugghhh. Horrible. I then ordered a ginger ale. Sadly , the ginger ale was mixed with the same flavor of ... toilet water. Again , excuse my French. I would venture a return visit due to the ambiance and quality of cuisine. However , I will order bottled water on my next visit. If management stumbles across my review , please , please , address the issue of water quality. Better water quality would make my return visit so much more enjoyable. Due to the enjoyable ambience and terrific food I render 4 Stars. I subtracted one Star due to the water quality. Fine dining requires fine water. Nevertheless , 4 STARS !!!! I'll give them another chance. I'll be back ! read more

See all

Yucks and big bucks. Snooty server. Decent service though. Overpriced...oh and really overpriced.

Let me start by saying we have dined here many times and the food and service are always amazing. Unfortunately our last visit did not go as well. The lobster was mush and had to be replaced. The next one was better but very very salty. The filet was good but again it was loaded with salt. Hopefully it was just one of those off nights. read more

Ambiance, service very good. Food is 4 out of 5 stars because there is a lack of presentation on the plates read more

We finally got a chance to try prime 239 We were able to pick up of a special menu that they were offering this evening Everything was delicious. Service was outstanding. We will be back. read more

On a Friday night we met some friends for dinner 239 Prime was the choice for the night. We started with cocktails, the ladies ordered a decent Pinot and us guys had two different cocktails. I had a Vodka Martini dirty with blue cheese olives. Tasty but I prefer my martini is a traditional martini glass versus French Martini glass. We ordered two appetizers, Buffalo burrata cheese and artichokes. Both were decent in taste and in presentation. For the main course we had a couple of steaks and I went with the salmon. The Mrs ordered a filet medium rare and it was closer to medium. The other steak was a bone in ribeye and it was ordered medium and came out medium. I had the salmon and it was cooked very nicely at medium temp. The fish was good but the fennel and a liquid type of broth really didn't work for me. But the fish itself was ready good. Table sides were garlic spinach and jalapeño creamed corn. Spinach was the star of the sides based on the tables input. Service was good but lacked a bit for a $$$$ restaurant. Ambiance is average for a strip mall setting. read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Vodka Martini - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

One of my favorite places in Cape Coral! Owner, George and manager, Bob, along with their staff are always friendly and provide outstanding service and delicious food! A+! read more

Prime 239 has excellent steaks, excellent service, and some of the best bartenders in SW Florida. We always have a great experience when we go there to eat. We've been there many times and will continue going back! read more

Steaks were good. We were sat in a booth next to the door so we didn't get to see the restaurant. Our server Matt was nice and friendly! read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Steaks - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Everything I love in a restaurant. "Tucson casual" come as you are, but high end reasonably priced food. Awesome service by Freddie. Delicious steaks, great lobster and a free dessert for our first visit. This place is busy for a reason... it's amazing.... Absolutely perfect experience, thank you Freddie and staff at Prime 239 you are amazing... read more

See all

1. Some of the most awesome service of any place in this area. (Thank you, Gina--we love you) 2. Steaks that are incredible. 3. A pleasant, comfortable atmosphere Yeah, it's pricy, but it's worth every cent, and we'll be back for more, for sure. read more

The cook don't know how to cook a Steak med/ rare so he over cooks it's , we were a party of 8 at a Small table, no elbow room , two of us had Steaks over cooked , other six enjoyed theirs, Fries we're not anything to talk about Avg , read more

My boyfriend loves steak and I saw that a lot of people recommended this place so we decided to try it out. The place was lovely and service was amazing. We got started with some warm bread with their butter of the day, which was strawberry balsamic and it was delicious! We both got steak, I got a NY strip and he got a ribeye. They both had great flavor and cooked perfectly. The sides were amazing. We especially loved the jalapeno creamed corn. The asparagus with hollandaise sauce and the maple bacon brussel sprouts were great too! read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Steak, Jalapeno creamed corn, asparagus, and maple bacon Brussel sprouts - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Walking on the door we were greeted with a friendly welcoming hello. It was early so sitting at the bar was our preference. The bartender, Lea Lea was a perfect representative of the establishment. We ordered NY strip steaks cooked to perfection with sides of cheesy mashed potatoes and creamed spinach. All were excellent. The spinach was much better than your normal chain steakhouse. We added a wedge salad that was above the normal with a homemade dressing. read more

I love a good steak so I was really looking forward to the opening of this place. We finally made a reservation and had a nice meal with friends. The restaurant was kinda small, busy, but cute. The staff was very friendly, and the waiter was attentive enough. The food was good although I with there was a sauce that came with the steak with out an up charge of $6. The steak was cooked great though. The sides are family style, enough for two for sure. The mashed potatoes could have been smoother, I don't mind chunks of potatoes I just was expecting otherwise. The drinks were kinda weak for the price of them. I would try again and maybe get one of the specials as my friend got their bison special and he loved it! read more

See all

Amazing service and the quality of food was exceptional. This was by far one of the best meals I have had.

Excellent menu and service! They went out of their way to help us celebrate our son's 30th birthday with a birthday dessert for him. We had a wonderful time and highly recommend the restaurant for an enjoyable evening! read more

Second time here and it just gets better. The service from the front desk to biding the table, was impressive. The team work flowed all evening. We took friends and they loved it! Always the steak is cooked to perfection and let's talk about the specialty butter (pecan maple was a hit). And the corn, please do take that off the menu . Best thing that happened to Cape Coral! read more

Simply outstanding experience! Atmosphere was great! Service was excellent! Food was absolutely amazing! I can't wait for my next meal here! read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Wagyu Filet Crab Oscar style - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

This is a very pleasant restaurant to eat dinner and they really do have aged prime beef. The menu is a lot more interesting than most steakhouses because the appetizer list has some items that you could combine and make a late supper. If you didn't wish a full meal they have a great Bolognese Pappardelle ;they have Australian lamb chops, and the drink list is very broad. It was my birthday so they actually gave me a birthday card awarding a dessert. A special surf and turf for 40 bucks. It was too good to pass up. There was a cold water, lobster tail and a 6 ounce prime sirloin steak very thick perfectly cooked. The lobster tail was desperately overdone and tough . The steak had a lovely char, but if you're sensitive to too much salt. Tell the chef to hold back a bit. Both of us did not enjoy our bar drinks very much. I had a bourbon club soda, and the soda was flat, which is always a disappointment But par for the course at most bars that don't use bottled club soda. I then ordered a bottle of sparkling water, thinking I could fix the problem, but even the bottle of sparkling water was a bit flat .so there are a lot of good points about this restaurant and if you order carefully, it would be a very enjoyable evening. I recommend this restaurant with the caveats expressed above. read more

Our waitress was outstanding! Yes food is on the expensive end but worth it! I had the chicken and mash potatoes I can't remember what it's called on the menu. But it was the best potatoes I've ever had. Texture was amazing , taste of chicken outstanding! Would recommend read more

Had Amanda and Liz take care of my family and I the second we walked in the door! They made sure our food was great and the ambiance to the restaurant was met! Thank you ladies! read more

We love it , Best stack in town , Service can be better if no mistakes in the kitchen read more

OMG! Food is amazing. Add such a good steak in my life. The drinks were amazing. Green goddess was my favorite. You can't go wrong, inside or outside, is beautiful. Lead staff was so polite, even the manager came around to check on us. We come to Cape Coral at least once a year and I will definitely go back. read more

We went here on a date night and it was fancier than what we are used to in Cape Coral. The location is ideal but parking is tricky. We went on a Tuesday and it was packed. The staff was very friendly and we did have to wait but fortunately there is a welcoming bar area that we enjoyed while our table was ready. The food was great, it was a little too rich for my taste and the portions were healthy but overall we enjoyed our dinner. read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

Another birthday trip with my youngest daughter. Happy 13th! Did my research and came up with this place. Had the porterhouse, she had the ribeye, awesome. Perfectly cooked and very flavorful. We shared the broccolini and creamed corn and Alaskan King Crab Legs. Broccolini was great and the corn was best I ever had. It had jalapeño and cilantro in it. Legs were good but they didn't provide the appropriate tools to crack the shells so it took some work and time. For dessert we both had the apple crisp. That too was great. Emily was a sever and she was great. Gave some great advice on the local scene as we were out of towners. The only downside was the ambiance I was looking for Chicago style atmosphere but that's hard to find in SWF. None the less the food and service made up for it. Highly recommend. read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Porterhouse Alaskan King Crab Legs, Creamed Corn, Broccolini and Ribeye. - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Prime 239 does not disappoint as the only true "steak house" in Cape Coral. Difficult choice between the French Onion or Lobster Bisque. Neither decision is wrong. Steak cooked to perfection. read more

Best streak/filet 8oz in 10 years. Well done. Your staff is also very pleasant and attentive! We will be back! read more

Prime 239 Steakhouse - Bat area - Steakhouses Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

See all

One of the best steaks I have had. Cooked perfectly and so tender Service outstanding.

My husband and I were here for his birthday a few weeks ago. We enjoyed our experience thoroughly. They gave him a birthday card upon arrival and our apple crumble was free. They put a sparkler on it as well and sang happy birthday. Our server was nice and clearly enjoys his job. My husband really enjoyed his steak. He goes to Bern's every year in Tampa and he liked this steak more than Bern's. He said it was properly seasoned. My salmon was ok. I know ordering fish at a steakhouse is silly but I don't eat beef at all. We went for my husband and he was very satisfied. Highly recommend. I've seen some reviews about the noise and we didn't experience that, even as it got more crowded. Don't let that prevent you from going. read more

See all

Top 5 steaks that I have had. $$$$ but worth it. Service was great very happy. Not far from my Vrbo. Will go back next year. read more