Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Potsy’s On Broadway

    5.0 (2 reviews)
    Closed • Closed

    Order Potsy’s On Broadway Takeout or Delivery

    Potsy’s On Broadway Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Potsy’s On Broadway

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 months ago

    Excellent food but very small for eating in. I suggest taking out and enjoying at home with some vino!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Delis 1,123 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Basso Cucina Italiana - Shrimp 390

    Basso Cucina Italiana

    4.1(136 reviews)
    21.5 mi
    •$$

    Great food and service. The atmosphere is also very welcoming…read more Their bread, soups and salads are a great introduction to the tasty entree to the tasty main courses.

    Walking in the door the restaurant reminded me of an Italian family restaurant I used to work in…read morewhen I was in college. Initially it brought back some good memories and a hope that the food would be as good. As we walked in and were seated though, we were put in a narrow back room with no windows and an old noisy A/C unit. Somewhat claustrophobic. The table itself was sticky, and had a wire bread basket that had two small ramekins with pesto in one, and what we were told was a tomato bruschetta in the other. The tomatoes looked old from the refrigerator with a hazy gray sheen. When bread finally came, it was like a supermarket bread that was heated in the oven, but cold, so it seamed stale. Got up the nerve to try the bruschetta which was overpowered with parmesan. The pesto was overpowered with garlic and there was only one pignoli nut visible in the dish. The server was a very nice young woman. Polite, attentive. They had the policy of waiting until everyone was ready to place a full order with appetizers and mains which was fine, but it took about 45 minutes before the appetizers came out. The appetizers I tasted were good. A caprese salad with olive oil, pesto and a balsamic reduction. Fried Calamari cut in large pieces, but cooked tender. Then came the mains. My meat lasagna was dry on the inside with little or no sauce. It tasted as if it had been frozen previously, The ladle of sauce was not enough to freshen it up, and the cheese on top was burned. My younger son got gnocchi with pesto that arrived looking more like a pesto soup swimming with oil. I lived in NY for 60 years, worked ten years in restaurants through high school and college, and married into an italian family. I've never seen pesto like this. The gnocchi itself was dense and chewy. Not soft and pillowy like it should have been. My wife had abgel hair pasta with shrimp in a fresh tomato sauce. This they got somewhat right. The shrimp was actually cooked just right, the sauce was good, but still a little heavy on parmesan cheese, and some of the pasta was stuck together, so it didn't cook properly.. Overall, it was very disappointing and overpriced for what came out of the kitchen. Definitely will not be going back. As far as the 5 star reviews go, maybe we went on a night that was too busy for the kitchen, or maybe these were friends and family trying to help out and prop up a mediocre experience. Our local Pizzaria does better and for much less $$$.

    Photos
    Basso Cucina Italiana - The bar area

    The bar area

    Basso Cucina Italiana - SS Cassoulet

    SS Cassoulet

    Basso Cucina Italiana - Veal sorrentina

    See all

    Veal sorrentina

    Sette Luna - Salmon dinner and fettuccini with house marinara sauce.

    Sette Luna

    3.8(576 reviews)
    11.8 mi
    •$$$

    My girlfriends and I decided to order a bunch of dishes to share, and everything was so good that I…read morecompletely forgot to take pictures of most of the food! The Risotto Balls are a must-order. I've honestly never had anything like them before, and we finished every last bite. The gazpacho was so refreshing with a spicy, acidic kick. It didn't have much crab, but the flavor of the soup was amazing. The grilled polpo was cooked perfectly with a delicious char, but I do wish the portion was a little bigger. The Margherita pizza had the perfect thin crust with a beautiful wood-fired char on the bottom. The seafood pasta was one of our favorites and easily the best seafood pasta I've had. The creamy lemon sauce was incredible, the shrimp were beautifully grilled with just a little kick of spice, and the portion was huge. We also ordered the Agn Mozzarella, which was rich, flavorful, and another great pasta dish. The only thing we weren't crazy about was the chocolate mousse. It just wasn't sweet enough for our taste. The service was amazing. One of my friends has a shellfish allergy, and they were extremely careful to avoid any cross-contamination. Everyone was so friendly, the food came out quickly, and you could tell they genuinely cared. We went on a weekday without a reservation, and it was still pretty busy, so I'd definitely recommend making one. We'll definitely be back!

    We went to Sette Luna for dinner before our show at the State Theater. We were seated at a table…read morefor two which was quite tiny and uncomfortable but we survived. The waitress arrived with some water and asked if we wanted something else to drink so we placed a drink order and she asked us if we were ready to order food. We had just sat down and hadn't even looked at our menu yet, so we told her give us a minute. She came back a few minutes later even before she brought the drinks and asked again if we were ready to order. Kind of annoying. Finally got our drinks and I ordered an Arugula salad and a Margarita pizza for dinner. I also asked her for some bread to munch on while we waited for our food. The bread was good but they only dripped about a tablespoon of dipping oil on the plate for about 8 slices of bread. Not even sure why they bothered. The salad came and was very tasty with just the right amount of dressing and cheese. The pizza was delicious as well. Then the bill came and I saw that we were charged $3.50 for the bread and there was no mention of a charge for bread on the menu. Overall quite disappointing!

    Photos
    Sette Luna
    Sette Luna - Pepperoni pizza

    Pepperoni pizza

    Sette Luna - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Potsy’s On Broadway - delis - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...