Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Potato Po-ta-toe

    3.2 (5 reviews)

    Potato Po-ta-toe Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Potato Po-ta-toe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    4 years ago

    The best place in town for good food in a family atmosphere and the music makes you feel like you're home

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Potato Po-ta-toe

    You might also consider

    Oil Lamp Restaurant - Southern Comfort

    Oil Lamp Restaurant

    4.3(136 reviews)
    8.8 mi
    $

    SO GOOD! The description "old cafeteria style", while technically true, you never had food this…read moregood in any cafeteria! Driving North from Florida, we wanted dinner and preferred not fast food, but good food served efficiently. Well we hit that out of the park by ending up at The Oil Lamp. My friend had the chicken & mashed potatoes (these are the real deal!!). I had the beef tips on gravy over mashed potatoes. We shared sides of braised cabbage that had a fair amount of garlic - I will be thinking about it, yes thinking about cabbage - first time for everything. We also shared creamed corn and this is NOT from a can. The corn was so sweet and there was a crunch to it, which only fresh corn can give. Everything looked delicious. I eyed those desserts, but I'd finished my plate and just no more room. I live like 4 hours away, but I'm hoping to time my return trip to return to this gem. This isn't fancy, it's good food that has been cooked by chefs that know how to cook old school. Last note - generous portions.

    Prior to going, I'm not sure why I thought of this place as a "greasy spoon"...it was more of a…read morecafeteria. Much more updated and cleaner than anticipated. Upon entry, you go to the right to get in line and order. There is a sign with daily specials (you can also check out their Facebook page!). Up first are the trays and silverware and then the salad bar. After that are some entrees and sides they dish out for you. We ordered the rib-eye meal which comes with a side and bread but you can add whatever you want! I think it was $29, which at first seemed a little expensive, but my brother and friends assured me was definitely worth it! We also grabbed a drink and some dessert. All of the employees were very kind and welcoming. We went right at 5 on a Thursday evening so there was plenty of seating. The tables were big and there was room for all 10 of us (that's why we went early!) The food...was amazing! The steak was PERFECT. I asked for it medium and it was medium. So tender and flavorful! My brother wasn't lying when he said it was worth it. I also had the loaded mashed potatoes - excellent, biscuit-yummy, and the chocolate peanut butter pie- OH MY! I will definitely be returning to this establishment. We really enjoyed it.

    Photos
    Oil Lamp Restaurant - Options

    Options

    Oil Lamp Restaurant - Pie for everyone!!!

    Pie for everyone!!!

    Oil Lamp Restaurant - Outside

    See all

    Outside

    Pond  - 4 Grilled Shrimp, Spicy Cajun Pasta! Crab Cakes

    Pond

    3.7(172 reviews)
    3.0 mi

    This was our first time dining at Pond Restaurant, and overall it was a good first experience. The…read morecustomer service really stood out. The staff was friendly, attentive, and made us feel welcome from the moment we arrived. The food came out fresh and hot, and everything had good flavor. You can tell care was put into the preparation. It was a pleasant dining experience, and we'd consider coming back again.

    My husband & I tried this restaurant for the first time for a birthday dinner, hoping for a special…read moreevening. We unfortunately left disappointed. For cocktails, my husband ordered the Mango Sunshine & I ordered the Cucumber Mojito. Both were refreshing & tasted good overall, but did seem quite weak. For dinner, my husband ordered the braised short rib from the Specials menu & I ordered the lamb chops, one of my absolute favorite foods. I ordered the lamb chops medium rare & they were quite overdone, with the last one I tried to eat being well done. The brussels sprouts on the other hand were quite underdone, and were solid to the point that I couldn't even stick my fork through them. I asked for asparagus as a replacement, which ended up being underdone as well. My husband felt his mashed potatoes were too salty & that his broccoli was cooked into mush, but had no issues with the short rib. On a positive note, the staff was very friendly, & the complimentary biscuits were absolutely delicious. Overall, for the high prices they charge at this establishment, it is absolutely not worth it. I do not think we will be returning.

    Photos
    Pond
    Pond
    Pond

    See all

    Grits Cafe - BLT with Salmon and sweet potato fries.

    Grits Cafe

    4.6(302 reviews)
    37.0 mi
    $$

    Amazing food. Great ambiance. The special was delicious. Stopped by on our way to Florida.read more

    This was my 3rd time there as we are new to Monroe County and like to shop local. Sorry, but I will…read morenever go back there to eat! The first time we ate there it was ok. The home made soup was fantastic. Service was excellent. The second time the food was not so good. And last night it was a horrible experience ! However, great service and atmosphere but the so called fresh cooked Burger and fries with sautéed mushrooms. By the way, I specifically asked the waitress if it was freshly cooked to order because so many places keep pre-cooked Burgers in a warmer and quickly warm them up. A process easily identified by the dryness and inside temp of the meat. The small Salad was ok. The 2 lukewarm Biscuits were a little dry and undercooked. The sautéed Mushrooms were like shoe leather, dry and overcooked. The Fries were cold as was the dried up poor excuse of a Burger. Too bad there is no pride in the Kitchen! Hard to beat 5 Guy's for a good Burger. Having traveled just about everywhere in the USA. My review should be taken seriously. This place needs a Kitchen Manager that cares about all the food they put out. Not just the semi fancy gourmet that they try to produce there. If they got their Kitchen in order it could be a great destination restaurant !

    Photos
    Grits Cafe - Bar with Golf Channel

    Bar with Golf Channel

    Grits Cafe - Forsyth Taco Week

    Forsyth Taco Week

    Grits Cafe - Beautiful little place in the middle of Town. Old refurbished building. They did a great job.

    See all

    Beautiful little place in the middle of Town. Old refurbished building. They did a great job.

    Potato Po-ta-toe - newamerican - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...