When visiting the area, we were craving pizza. As I am gluten free we are always looking for good options. We decided to just drive over and dine in. The service was friendly, the atmosphere was not special in any way but was comfortable. The gluten free cauliflower crust however was amazing! It was buttery and a little crispy and absolutely delicious. Husband ordered a regular supreme and he really enjoyed his pizza as well. Highly recommend! read more

Please take in to consideration that I am a bit of a Pizza Snob. Crust was good. Rest of pizza was a bust. Sauce looked good but was lacking any real taste. Toppings were gas station fare and cheese was blah. I was pulling a trailer and parking was plentiful. I don't like leaving poor reviews but that's how it was. read more

Excellent thin crust pizza today. Perfect amount of sauce and cheese. The Italian sausage was delicious read more

Post Game Pizza - Large cheese and sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rogersville, Missouri

Super nice delivery service and I can finally find something decent to eat in Rogersville! Will probably be ordering in tonight!

Pizza is mediocre, wings are horrible. Service is meh. The only positive I have that influences me ordering here is that they deliver.

They have always delivered to us. This time a refusal. You have lost a loyal customer. Good day to you read more

We love Post Game Pizza! We have ate there twice & both our kids & my husband & I thought it was superb! We will definitely go back & possibly use their delivery service. read more

When they are good, they are very good... but they are very inconsistent. Also, always check your order! The last two times they got my toppings wrong, and they forgot the garlic butter on the garlic knots. Sometimes the garlic knots are wonderfully big and fluffy, sometimes they are tiny and very chewy. They have never offered discounts or replacements any time I have complained about messed up orders. If you are lucky, the thin crust pizza is amazing and the garlic knots are to die for. If you are unlucky, it's barely fit to eat. Right now my luck as been running about 50/50. read more

Super yummy pizza and as a person with celiac disease I was excited to see they had a cauliflower crust!! Not everyone has that and it was such a sigh of relief because traveling can be hard when your diet is limited. My only problem is the offer the cauliflower crust on the macaroni pizza and I'm not sure if the pasta is gluten free. Other than that this place was amazing and I will come back if I'm ever in town again!! read more

I ordered the 13 piece buffalo wings and they were TERRIBLE. There was more fat and cartilage then there was meat, i got them cold, and they were undercooked. I didnt realize this till i got home and i didnt wanna drive back. The cashier was super nice tho. read more

I think I may be their number one customer. Pizza is always yummy, subs are great, love the salads!

All of our experiences with Post Game have been great! Love being able to call in and get our order delivered! Good food and staff!

I had delivery from your new Ozark restaurant! Excellent customer service. Excellent pizza! Delicious fresh ingredients & the homemade crust is fabulous! I will now be a regular customer! read more

It's okay pizza, it's decent priced I love their garlic knots , very timely and nice staff!

Pizza, cheese sticks, and buffalo wings are yummy! So glad our town has this delivery option! Use the deals section online to save a few bucks. read more

If they were consistent they would have a higher rating. One time they were decent. Another they messed up our order, but did offer a credit which was nice. Third was horrific. Pizza was truly the worst I've ever had. Crust tasted stale and like cardboard. Cheese was over cooked. Pizza arrived freezing cold. Mozzarella sticks tasted awful and bland and were also cold. read more

One place in Rogersville, where you can get good food. I love ordering online and having it delivered. They are fast, friendly and food was hot and good. read more

This stupid place... I ordered to my school for a certain time and they were soooooooooooooooooo late omg like can you believe it. Broseph get it together read more

Carried out 3 extra large pizza's yesterday. When picking up about 6:00pm there were 10-15 employees in the building plus two customers. No one was wearing a mask. It's just average pizza and there are other options. I won't be back. The safety of my family is more important than $65 for average pizza. read more

Don't order it! You can get better pasta delivered from Domino's, for cheaper and it is way better than the dog food they delivered. Total rip off. Salad was decent. read more

Their pizza is okay for being the only delivery place in rogersville but I went into the restaurant the other day and ordered a Greek salad and the watched the man make my salad without gloves, and it took 15 minutes for my salad to even be made. So if you're looking for a nice salad, this might not be up your place. read more

This place would be 5 star but for one fatal flaw; they have no concept of sanitary food handling. Employees handle customer credit cards, ink pens, the telephone , and the cash register; and then your food without washing there hands! I noticed a guy kneading dough has black under his fingernails. GROSS! This place needs to be shut down before Rogersville has food-borne illness outbreak. read more

This is a relatively new restaurant in Rogersville. First: the food is absolutely wonderful. We have tried everything on the menu and haven't found any food lacking in taste, flavors and sizes. As a matter of fact, we generally have to leave with a doggy bag. Second: the atmosphere in the restaurant is nice for the area. The tables are always clean and the TV's are on for entertainment. Third: The staff are very effective in their jobs. One particular employee stands out above all of the others! His name is Jacob. Never in my life have I ever met a more respectful individual. He is not only pleasant, he goes above and beyond to make sure that your dining room experience is wonderful. He smiles anytime you look at him. He is the best employee I've ever seen working in the food service industry. He never sits down, if there is anything that needs to be done, Jacob is doing it. This young man will go places. He will be snatched up by another employer soon. He is too good to remain line staff. There is only one problem I have seen. There are two young men that work with the dough, one on day shift and one on the evening shift. Both of these young men will leave their station to go get a drink, talk to someone, take an order and then go right back to the dough that they had been working with. They have touched numerous items that have been touched by numerous people and go right back to making the dough without washing their hands. I have to give this restaurant 5 stars. We will see in a year how many stars they will receive. Enjoy! read more