Stopped at this place on my way back to Chicago and boy was it the right place to stop for a pizza. We ordered half supreme cheese half veggie pizza and it was honestly one of the best pizzas I have had! Go here and try their pizza. You won't regret it. Ignore that review from the one-star guy. He can go to Hawaii if he wants a tropical taste. read more

The pizza here is great! You can really taste the freshness of the dough. My kids love the garlic knots and the calzones. The pizza sauce is on point and the toppings are always fresh. We order here at least three times a month and the quality is pretty consistent. Great prices too. So glad to have these guys in town. read more

Staying nearby, and recommended by our hotel. We ordered 2 small pizzas, an order of buffalo wings, and boneless buffalo wings. They didn't serve beer, so we had sodas. The pizza was pretty good. My husband said his wings were fine. Not overly big, but fine. The boneless wings were so bad, I did not eat them. They were soft, and the outer coating had no texture. The flavor was totally bland. I would have been much happier with McDonalds nuggets. Service was incredibly slow, and they weren't busy. I definitely don't recommend. read more

Post Game Pizza - Boneless "Buffalo wings"?? - Pizza Near Me - Marshfield, Missouri

Love the thin crust cheeseburger pizza! Usually do delivery, wish they still served alcohol! read more

Darn good pizza. Driving cross country and needed a pizza off the highway. Homemade dough is great and they are working hard to sling pies at a hood price and keep the shop clean. read more

This is a great little local pizza shop. What makes a great pizza? Great crust, great toppings, great sauce...Post Game checks all the boxes. Better than the major brands in town, and I love supporting local small businesses. read more

Pepperoni thin was yum. Service was nice. Was quite as it was late but the place looks like a good local hangout.

I travel all over the country. So I eat pizza and other foods and always try local places. We love thin crust pizza. This was a excellent pizza definite quality. Will be here for about 3 months. Calling again real soon. read more

We ordered a large thin crust supreme. The pizza was really good. You can tell the ingredients were fresh. Appropriately priced and delivery was quick to our hotel room. Only issue was we didn't get chili peppers or sprinkle Parmesan for the pizza. read more

Absolutely love this place the food is amazing and delivery is always fast and fresh and I love supporting community small business... I definitely eat there once a week at least read more

Very happy with our decision to grab lunch here along our road trip. Will be our go to place when passing through this direction. Quality pizza made with care and love Friendly, attentive staff. Had the bacon cheeseburger pizza and it was delish. Don't think you could go wrong with any menu choice though read more

Good pizza. Great service. Nice clean premises. Only place in Marshfield with decent pizza

The pizza is usually delicious, but sometimes hit or miss with their doneness. They have unique pizza combinations

I ordered from them 3 times. Service is good I will give them that. The food is not what I expected. I had hoped for something that exceeds chain restaurants but unfortunately it seemed like a small town attempt with nothing special about it. Except the wings the wings are nasty. Wings - Always seem undercooked. They are rubbery on the outside to the point you can peel the chicken skin off. They weren't crispy like wings are supposed to be even if you ask them to overcook them. I am not sure what method they are using but they need to change it. Pizza - Sauce is not flavorful. Crust is not great either. We bought a rising crust pizza from the frozen food department at the grocery store for $5.99 and to be honest there was not enough of a difference to justify the cost. read more

Venture for the specialty pizzas that you've never tried before- you won't be disappointed!

Always great food and friendly staff, definitely recommend trying, great pizza and pasta.

The guys here at Post Game do a great job. You can order online or call in direct. I order from here at least three times a month. They also believe in helping this small town grow. They offer fundraising opportunities. They deliver and have always been prompt with my deliveries. My guests at Swan Song Inn order from here and they take great care of them. I honestly have only had the pizza and can't vouch for the rest of the menu, but they ROCK. read more

Pizza and cheesy bread have always been good. Service has been good as-well. Also delivery is awesome! However don't ever get the boneless wings.. worst "chicken" I have ever had. Honestly I think it is bagged frozen chicken from Walmart they warm up in the oven and poor BBQ sauce on.. take a look. read more

Post Game Pizza - BBQ boneless wings. - Pizza Near Me - Marshfield, Missouri

Once inside, this is a great little pizza place for Marshfield. Really nice sports theme atmosphere and friendly staff. All that wouldn't matter if the pizza wasn't amazing. Their supreme specialty pizza hand tossed is amazing! read more

Post Game Pizza - Supreme in the box! - Pizza Near Me - Marshfield, Missouri

Had to be the greasiest pizza I have ever eaten. Blotted the top as much As I could with paper towel and it was still greasy underneath. The toppings just slid off. I really wanted to like this because I prefer to support local business read more

The food tastes wonderful, both pizza and pasta. No issues with the staff at all. The place was clean enough when I went in person. The delivery was on time when I ordered. My only critique is that I wish the prices were a bit lower. read more

Best pizza place in town! We were so disgusted with pizza hut and we're thrilled when we found this place!

Their Buffalo Chicken pizza is the bomb. Pepperoni pizza is awesome. Service is top notch atomphshere is cool. Great small town pizza joint. My favorite read more

Post Game Pizza - The best pizza in town - Pizza Near Me - Marshfield, Missouri

Food is good but the customer service has ruined it for me. Myself and fellow staff members have ordered for delivery about once a week, since they've opened. We have had issue after issue and never once have they offered any sort of compensation for our wasted time and/or money. The online ordering website is a joke. Always having issues. They also have very unreasonable up-charges for small requests. An extra vegetable on a sandwich costs $1.00 per vegetable (and they will not tell you this if you place an order over the phone). I'm not typically one to complain but after so many unfortunate experiences, I will no longer be ordering from this business again. read more

Very disappointed with the pizza! Ordered the large 18" hand tossed Hawaiian and was expecting something as beautiful as the island. What I got was very bland, boring and not very many ingredients for the $20 . Needs to be a unique pizza that has a better value than what they have now for me to go back. Sorry but I have to give them a thumbs down. I might go back, probably not. read more

Quality seems to have slipped. The toppings on my last order (3 pizzas) were sparse and the onions burnt.

Being from NY we have never really found good pizza in the Midwest or south. We have been visiting Marshfield for several years and could never find good pizza until now. We stumbled upon a this relatively new pizza shop. Very, very good. Friendly people great pizza. The lady who waited on us had made brownies and gave a few just to be nice. They were maybe the best brownies we ever had. Thank you for that. We will definitely make this a stop every time we are in town. read more