As far as gas stations go, this one is a cut above. They have an extensive beverage selection, both alcoholic and non. Any snack you could want and the real winner is the perpetually kind staff. Considering this is virtually the only gas stop along the lakeshore between Holland and Grand Haven, we really lucked out.
Separate paragraph to highlight their PIZZA. It's actually so good. My grandparents don't live very far from here and it's quickly become our go-to spot. The thin crust is amazing, as is the cheesy bread, and the regular crust. The bonus of this stop doubling as a pizza joint is that it's open when other locales wouldn't be i.e. evenings before holidays. We always call ahead, as I would advise others to do. It doesn't take long and then it's obvi fresh. Port Sheldon Party Store is definitely what they call a hidden gem. read more