We LOVE this place!! This is a family owned and run restaurant. The pizza is fantastic. You must try the garlic knots with honey, it is addictive! read more

Rude miserable people They resent having to serve anybody I've been enough times now to know it wasn't just a bad night the other times The pizza isn't bad but their special demeanor ruins the visit. read more

Prices are high. Pizza is decent. They don't open till 4pm, so no lunch there. Must carry out, no dine in

Like many places around AF anvd RR, they are not following their listed hours (a pizza place closed on a Friday night). Ugh. Frustrating to find a place to eat. read more

Oh man where do I start? The pizza looks like a piece of art. It is literally top two or three I've ever had. 53 years old. Including New York, Chicago, anywhere California, etc. then there's the garlic knots, I won't even start, just yum! read more

Over priced for pizza that was not that good tbh service was GOD AWFUL asked what kind of sauce the wings get tossed in the guy proceeded to say a smoky kind of sauce (whatever that is ) so we asked for a side of it he then with an attitude talked down to us like we are stupid and said it comes already sauced and we couldn't get a side? Okay so it comes frozen pre made is what that sounds like to me I'll be back to angel fire for sure never again will this establishment get my money again oh and wtf is up with all the clutter? I love mom and pop shops but seriously find some organization and train your staff to pre bus cause no one wants to sit near that for 40 mins while trying to eat. read more

See all

We ordered to go. I think it's take out only right now. The pizza toppings were plentiful. The crust was very good (a little doughy underneath). I like a good, chewy crust. It was very good. It was a little pricy ($100), but 3 pizzas was enough for our family of 8 to have for two meals. The garlic knots were artery clogging, tasty goodness! Thank you pizza stop! Would be great after a day on the slopes. read more

Piss pore service and rude staff a year later. This is the only place to eat late night and close to the resort so they can be rude if you want food in Angel Fire. It's sad the owner has such a small ego. read more

Nice people great service from Cody A host of pizza to select from Small selection on menue read more

Good pizza but pricey for what you get. Service was fast. Nice little spot near the ski resort.

They had the greatest pizza. The dough was excellent. Maybe because I was there in the summer the service was a little slow.

Great pizza! Wish we could stay there and eat the pizza and have a beer. That would make it perfect

The pizza is awesome. Unique crust and tasty toppings. You can walk-in and take-out or call for take-out. Best pizza in town.

Food was very good! My family and I throughly enjoyed the whole experience. We had an XL pepperoni and mushrooms, battered mushrooms and a ham and cheese sandwich. The owner was friendly and kind. Over all the place had a comfortable, charming, small town feeling. read more

Pizza Stop - XL pepperoni and mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Head to head battle: Pizza Stop vs Angel Fired Pizza A panel of myself and 5 friends (all from Texas) have just performed an exhaustive side-by-side pizza comparison of Pizza Stop and Angel Fired Pizza. We ordered a large Canadian bacon, pineapple, and jalapeño pizza at each restaurant. Below will be the review for each restaurant. TLDR: Go to Pizza Stop, it's way better. Angel Fired Pizza Quality/taste- The sauce was very flavorful, the crust was a bit bland, the toppings were unevenly spread, and the cheese was decent. It was compared (negatively) to Cici's and Red Baron. Price- $19.13 for a large 3-topping pizza. Lower than Pizza Stop by $4. Location- Not very walkable from the resort area, but has a large parking lot, so parking is not an issue. Customer service- The staff were very friendly, although they did seem a bit preoccupied, despite the fact that the restaurant was less than half full. They were very helpful in offering Parmesan and red pepper flakes. Ambiance- Very cool second floor restaurant with a nice outside patio. Well lit, clean, and very welcoming. However, there are some weird paintings on the wall. I guess if you like art you may be interested. Additional comments- Really enjoyed the restaurant name being a pun. Conclusion: If you are looking to choose a pizza place not based on pizza, go here. If you want good pizza, go to Pizza Stop instead. Pizza Stop Quality/taste- Everything about this pizza tasted fresh and delicious. Ingredients were great, crust was nice and thick on the edges. So much flavor. Price- $23.95 for a large 3-topping pizza. Higher than Angel Fired Pizza by $4 but worth it. Location- In short walking distance from resort area. Limited parking directly out front at peak hours. Customer service- Extremely friendly and welcoming. They make you feel right at home here. Even threw in some extra garlic bread with our order! Ambiance- Feels like your typical casual ski town pizza joint. Conclusion- Best of the two pizza joints in town. You'll pay a bit more, but it's totally worth it. read more

Pizza Stop - Large Canadian bacon, pineapple, and jalapeño. Delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Last night at Angel Fire and we got a pizza and some garlic knots from here. We had an extra large, thin crust pizza with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, onion, bell pepper, and extra cheese. The pizza was damn good. The garlic knots were ok, but the pizza made the dinner. I was impressed with the food around the ski resort during our trip. read more

Just right off the main road, this place was a hidden gem to find. I could've sworn back in the day this place had red checkered tablecloths, but perhaps my memory serves me wrong. Pizza was fast, hot, and delicious and the biggest bang for your buck as far as size. We greatly enjoyed it. read more

Well this place is awesome! Trinny is so lovely. She took my order. We got a big cheese pizza to go and some garlic knots! She said 20 min so I came back and my pizza and knots were ready to go and OMG DELICIOUS!! My husband and I thought it was the best pizza and knots we'd ever had! I must if you're I. Angel Fire!!! Yummmmmmy!!! read more

Ordered take out... was ready on arrival, pizza and garlic knots were amazing. Friendly crew.... Great overall. 5 stars.

Food was out 20 minutes after ordering. Employees were really friendly and suggested some of their favorites. We ordered the bbq chicken pizza on thin crust and it was good for the area. However we were really annoyed that our appetizer of fried mushrooms only included what seemed like a handful for $7 (picture attached). They weren't tasty either. Seemed to be store bought and very doughy. read more

Pizza Stop - Fried mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Good pizza, bad service...took forever to get it...came out wayyyy wrong! The owner/waitress wrote off some of the tab but had attitude about it. Disappointed. read more

Take out only due to covid, but the pizza was very good. We ended up coming twice on our trip and both times were great.

This place has the best pizza and homemade ranch in Angel Fire! Service was great and staff was friendly. Would highly recommend. We have been here a week and have ate here four times. read more

Not sure what my kids look forward to more...skiing or eating at Pizza Stop! Definitely a highlight of our yearly trips to Angel Fire!! Whatever you guys are doing to make your pizza sooo delicious (maybe fairy dust?), keep doing it!! Thanks for making our 2023 Spring Break SO MUCH better!! read more

Great pizza! Friendly staff. Reasonably priced. New to Angel Fire and looking for a quick dinner. We had the three item thin crust and it was delicious. The dinner salad was fresh and the garlic knots were super yummy. Would definitely go back. Take out only. They do a great job for being short staffed. read more

Family enjoyed the pizza and loved the crust. Accommodated a dairy allergy for one of us. Sandwiches and wings were tasty too. Friendly staff even when they were super busy. Definitely our favorite restaurant we have found after a week of staying in Angel Fire. read more

Don't eat here on vacation unless you want to take turns blowing up the toilet with your whole family wreaking up the air bnb. Made us all throw up or diarrhea read more

We are here for dinner and although understaffed was pretty quick and provided great service. Quite a few restaurants in this area either close for summer or slow way down due to the winter being so popular but this Place is consistently good. We ordered the bbq pizza and wings and were very happy with both especially the pizza! read more

The pizza smelled fantastic when we picked it up, and my son ate a piece in the car because the garlicky fragrance had our mouths watering. It was just ok. Too much cheese, not enough sauce, which made it heavy without enough flavor. The crust was ok. I unrolled the outer crust and pulled out the extra dough. The crispy top layer of that was nice. Overall, average quality, extremely expensive pizza. Not too bad for a small ski town without many options. If I have to order here again, I'll try the thin crust. read more

The pizza is stupid good! Great beer selection as well. They've been making their homemade marinara sauce for 30 years. The dough is crazy delicious. read more

Pizza Stop - Pepperoni and jalapeño. Garlic knots on the side. Get them! - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

Rude Staff yelling at customers. When you're the only w$%re in the W- house it doesnt make you good just the only option. This place needs a reality check on the rude staff. But hey they can bc they can right? I wont spend money here again for sub par over priced pizza. read more

Pizza Stop is amazing and delicious! If you are spending time in Angel Fire, you need to check out Pizza Stop. Located just before entering the ski resort, it is nestled in a cute ski town. Pizza Stop is like walking into a home away from home, you are greeted by the family who owns and operates the restaurant. Make sure you saved up your appetite, their servings are large and menu is delicious. They offer a house salad with homemade salad dressings, garlic knots and thick crusted pizza that is delicious. Pizza stop has a small seating area up front but they do have an adjacent seating area that is comfy with TVs and there is no rush to leave. Great place for the family or if you want to grab a beer with friends. The owners were nice, service was great, clean and of course delicious pizza! If you want a traditional pizza place experience stop and eat at Pizza Stop! Quick tip: to get your NM fix, they recommend dipping your crust in the honey, sopapilla style..yum! read more

See all

Pizza Stop is the best pizza in town, hands down. And honestly some of the top pizza I've had. The owners come in super early and hand make everything. The ingredients are fresh, the seasonings are perfect, and the dough is amazing. The owners extremely sweet. If you haven't tried this pizza, go order some!! read more

This is by far the best pizza in town, you can get a thick or thin crust. What sets the pizzas apart from most is a tasty dough and generous toppings. I have tried most of the menu offerings and they are all good. Nice folks that run it add to the restaurant. The times listed here are wrong, they generally open at 4:30 pm and are closed on Tuesdays, call for current times. I'd rather pay extra for good quality and support a small family business than pay for chain or frozen cardboard pizza. read more

Absurd. Myself and a group of 4 purchased two of their XL pizzas, assuming this would easily fill us up. Two pizzas cost us $70. The pizzas literally are the size of your standard commercial large pizza (16in). WHAT?! We are paying $5 per slice and could only offer 3 per person. When purchasing an entire pizza, you would think you would get to pay less per slice. The kicker: They charged us a $1.50 take out charge. $1.50 to WALK OUT THE DOOR WITH PIZZA. RIDICULOUS. The pizza was decent, but my group was literally forced to eat all of the crust, in order to fill up. Five people paid $70 and couldn't even get full. For the same price, we could have gotten 10 medium pizzas at Domino's. Next time we want pizza, we will be trying Angel Fired Pizza for the more reasonable pricing. It would be cheaper to drive to Taos to get 8 medium pizzas from Domino's (as long you get better than 15mpg at gas prices of $2.50 per gallon). The crust is fancy in appearance, but difficult to chew and is flavorless. It would be better if there was less crust. Maybe they could lower their prices if they didn't braid the crust. Toppings were adequate, but not any better than toppings you could get at another restaurant. Staff was not particularly friendly, but we didn't have a bad experience with them either. Receipt for those interested: blob:http://imgur.com/45e251e2-7d7d-4fac-9dc3-e1fb895ae677 read more

Hole in the wall with some of the best braided pizza crust ever! Right amount of sauce and lovely service. The salad was also wonderful and fresh. If you're looking for an easy dinner that everyone will like, give it a try. read more

Awesome pizza with friendly service. We enjoy the thin crust pizza and our kids prefer the regular crust. Both are good options so you can't lose. read more

Awesome pizza and garlic rolls. The crust is so fluffy and delicious. I just wish we didn't have to ask for things like plates and they brought us one whopping plastic fork and knife to use for the entire table. I noticed a previous reviewer say that he didn't like seeing out of towners be rude to the locals, but we (the out of towners) didn't get a very nice reception when we walked in either. It goes both ways. read more

We loved this yummy place! We tried the other pizza place in town and were extremely disappointed! We got ours to go but I wish we could've eaten in the restaurant. It was cozy and warm and a cold beer with the pizza would've been great. I like the atmosphere! The staff was friendly and helpful. They were very informative on pizza size, crust style, etc. we chose an XL cheese and an XL pepperoni on the "thin crust" it was perfect! It's not cardboard thin as you may imagine. We also got a small "The Works" pizza on the regular crust (a bit thicker) and a dozen of the famous "garlic knots" and asked for marinara sauce for dipping. Soooo yummy. It was more than enough to feed our large family. Best pizza in town! read more

Pizza Stop - Yummy!!! - Pizza Near Me - Angel Fire, New Mexico

See all

The place is closed down. It's now a gift shop. No idea how the good was because they sell pottery now.