My favorite!! Of all the fantastic pizza places out there, Freddy wins the Blue Ribbon!…read moreNY style pizza with perfectly portioned cheese & toppings. This means the center of the pizza is not soggy but a great bite all through the generous slice. The sauce is excellent- not sweet or tangy - just perfect! And the crust - just enough crisp. The meat lovers was amazing - and just as good the next day too!

A great price given the quality of the pizza-wow!! We are solidly impressed by this spot and it was…read morenear our hotel. We got the online deal for 2 Large 2 topping pizzas, plus a Large cheese pizza, the philly sub+fries, and cannolis for just over $60. Its delicious, and they even called to check that we were coming/to notify that it was ready.

First rate in every way!…read more The restaurant has a pleasant, stylish decor. It's not great on the acoustics but was not overly loud despite being completely full. Our server was perfect. Friendly, attentive, got every part of our order correct. The food was delicious too. We ordered the burrata salad as an appetizer and loved it. We got a Margherita pizza and thought that it was tasty (a little chintzy with the toppings). We will definitely be back in the future!

Closer to 3.5, I got the burrata appetizer to go and it was solid. Just a lil pricey so probably…read morewould not order again. Feel like the tomatoes and other stuff could've been roasted/caramelized more. The cheese was fantastic and so was the bread. I ordered for pick up and it was ready within 30 mins. The inside looked very nice and Italian as it should. Will need to come back and try their pizza.

Had their Roman square pizza previously and loved it. The crust was earthy and slightly charred,…read morewith a focaccia-like consistency. The sauce was savory and cheese was soft. When we found out they had NY-style pizza we got takeaway to try out. The pizza was enormous and thin. The bottom of the crust had a slight charred. When the slices were picked up the pizza retained its shape instead of falling limp. The sauce was a simple but tangy crushed tomato base topped with rich mozzarella cheese. Shreds of fragrant basil rounded out the flavor profile. It was very yummy and will be back for more.

Service was great. Carlos is the man. Nice night to sit…read moreoutside on the patio... owner came by and was a nice guy. Bbq pork pizza (Roman) and mashed potato (Neapolitan) were both excellent. The Cesar salad was good. We'd go back for all of it, solid experience all around.

The food! Omg so good. I wish they had a few pasta options. But omg the food is legit.read more

Cannot leave enough of a good review! This place is amazing, the ambiance, the food, it all creates…read morean overwhelmingly good vibe. They have been receiving such good reviews recently so be warned on arriving early as they only make so much dough for the day, and there could potentially be a wait as well. Plan accordingly if you want to actually get a seat and enjoy their food. We've done a tasting with them as well, and it was VERY good. Highly recommend if you want a cute date night option or if you would like to do an anniversary option. It was very nice, and we got lucky and had seats right by the kitchen so could see them platting everything as well. That was a fun bonus!! Highly recommend just about everything. The staff is always so kind and you can tell they do their best to ensure everyone has an enjoyable experience. The photos are from the tasting we did, wonderfully delicious!!! I also attached a pic of the amazing pizzas we've had as well.

Delicious and cozy pizza, subs, and other goodies. Shop their market while you wait! I love old…read moreschool places like this that you can consistently count on to be good. Feels like you've stepped back to a simpler time pre Internet! -Italiano sub was perfectly balanced and didn't get soggy on their hard Italian bread. May be the best Italian sub I've ever had- the crusty bread was a first for me! -Tacchino sub was good but would be better with some type of pickle. Felt very rich. -two cannolis hand filled to order! The filling had chocolate chips in it. The pastry shell was perfect and not too fried. We've gotten their pizza before too- def recommend! Fantastic crunch and they make their own mozzarella. We also like to get their homemade pizza dough, pizza sauce, mozzarella, ravioli, and pasta for quick weeknight dinners. Their dried pasta selection is impressive and includes gluten free pasta. They are kind, warm, and knowledgeable- I feel very taken care of when I go! Call in your order bc they don't do online ordering. Don't sleep on this gem!

Saturday 1/24/26…read more It's been a little over 2 years since my last visit, and a re-visit was definitely due, so I'm here. I made a call in pick up order and got the chicken parm sub $11.75 and gemellis pepperoni special $24. Also, the service for ordering and picking up was quick and easy. - The chicken parm sub was solid, but the main problem was the lack of tomato sauce. - The pepperoni special was a miss for me, and that's unfortunate cause I remember it being way better last time. It's cheesy, but the lack of tomato sauce and the dough/bread being underwhelming/ weak really ruins the taste experience. Overall, it seems that Gemelli has definitely fallen off in terms of the quality & taste that I've enjoyed previously. Don't know if I'd be back, but I do know that their chicken parm and polpette subs are still worthy choices in my eyes.

Don't be fooled by this non-descript appearance. My family…read morehad a gathering at the historic cemetery near by and chose to have lunch here after. The food was OUTSTANDING. I was a skeptic. Having traveled and dined across the globe, I did not expect homemade pasta, fresh espresso, and Neapolitan style pizza to be in Rockville MD. If you live within an hour drive, just take the trip and have lunch or dinner here. Try the espresso martini! I shared a cheese pizza with my daughter, my mother had the chicken piccata, my cousin the gnocchi, my father the chicken parm, my cousin had a caprese salad and the further seats I couldn't see. We all shared a few orders of the calamari. EVERYONE raved about how delicious their food was. I agree. Probably the best piccata I've tasted. The pizza was excellent. The tiramisu great. The pistachio gelato was perfect. I sure wish they were closer to Florida!! So good.

Came for dinner for 3 at 6pm on a Friday and it wasn't yet busy, though it got busier after we…read morearrived. All in all a great meal, and I look forward to eating my way around the menu. The biggest hit for me was the suppli appetizer. These are absolutely delicious and vegetarian friendly! Similar to arancini but somehow even more delicious. These are a must-order. I had the pasta alla vongole and a bite of my husband's chicken parmigiana. Our friend had mushroom ravioli that she loved, but I didn't try as I don't care for mushrooms. I've been on a clams and garlic kick lately for some reason and the vongole comes with these and bonus bacon. I would have preferred the bacon a tad crispier, but that is personal preference. I'd give this dish 4* - I would get it again but after trying some others. From the one bite the chicken parmigiana was a 5*. Their marinara is very good and the linguine in both our dishes tastes freshly made. We all split the chocolate temptation dessert and I ate more of it than I expected to, it is chocolate mousse adjacent cake with ganache frosting, very light, perfectly sweet. Often I find chocolate desserts too much after a big meal but this one wasn't heavy at all. 5* My friend ordered sangria which she thought was more like a wine cooler; too sweet for her French oenophile sensibilities and a bit lighter than a sangria usually is, but I am a pleb who loves sweet drinks and I would order it. If you are a sangria purist you might not care for it. Hubs enjoyed his old fashioned but said it needed a dash more bitters to be perfect. I was driving so enjoyed a non-dirty Shirley. Prices to me are reasonable for quality and portion size; our tab ended up high because of the appetizer, drinks and dessert but if you just had pizza or pasta with soda it would be pretty affordable. I will be back to get more suppli and try other dishes!

If you're looking for takeout pizza, this is pretty close to a five-star place. The pizza itself…read moreis tasty NY style, fresh made to order. If you're looking for a dine-in experience, then my rating would drop to about three stars. There are only 5 cold metal hightop stools and a narrow counter to eat on. Cleanliness is not overy problematic but definitely not their strong suit. Service was efficient but more business-like than friendly. The place is fairly expensive too. Two cans of soda plus two slices of pizza came to roughly $17.

Great NY pizza, we live pretty far currently so hadn't made it over before since it is primarily…read moretakeout but we might be moving a bit closer soon (yay)! Good robust sauce, light and non-doughy crust, my only quibble is that I only like black olives and they gave me kalamata. I wish staff were trained on the difference so if someone requests black olives they can specify they don't have those. I had same issue at &pizza. So when I return I need to remember to not order olives. We ate the first slice onsite so we could fairly judge it hot, then drove home (currently over 30 minutes).

had an excellent experience at Coal Fire Pizza thanks to Yajaira. She was an outstanding…read moreserver--very attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable. She gave us some of the best food suggestions, and the pizza was delicious. I especially recommend trying the crab meat pizza--it was amazing! Her service truly made the visit memorable, and I'll definitely be coming back.

Non responsive management - trying for months to resolve an issue with 0 movement towards…read moreresolution or even a response.

I was really excited to try this place out with my husband. It's reservation only so make sure you…read morecall in first. I had the lobster ravioli with shrimp and he had gnocchi. We shared the burrata with strawberries and pomegranate. Everything tasted like it was from scratch and wasn't heavy and too salty like other Italian places. Each pasta dish had a lot of flavor and I honestly couldn't say one was better then the other, we enjoyed both of them so much. The waiter/owners son? Had some excellent recommendations on what to try and also the wine to pair it with. The complimentary bruschetta was nice I would recommend eating it with a knife and fork I managed to spill almost all of the tomatoes on myself :-D I want to try their pizza next, I've never had true authentic Italian pizza and it looks so tasty.

Check them out recently and got the meat lovers pizza, calamari, and cannoli for take out…read more Everything was great, with the standout being the pizza, which was thin, crispy, and flavorful. The cannoli needed another shell cause it was overfilled with ricotta cream I believe (and kinda pricey for just 1 shell). Tasted good, but yeah, probably won't get that one again. They seemed to have renovated the inside when I went to pick up which made it look much nicer and bigger. Definitely a good date spot. Also added some old pics from Valentine's Day dinner (February 2020). Seems like the calamari has changed from 6 years ago. The service back then was great, and I'm sure it's still good today.

I placed an order on their app for in-store pickup…read more There are plenty of free nearby parking garages as well as street parking that's almost always taken by other vehicles. I rated a 4 because you can't customize the order on the app beyond the sauce, cheese, and one topping. I wanted to add extra cheese and additional toppings, and the app didn't enable me to do so as either a free or paid option. The service was great. No wait to be assisted, and the pizzas were made fresh and exactly as ordered. Friendly and prompt. The restroom didn't need a key or code. It was clean but smelled horrible. I would definitely come back to this location.

I stopped going here long ago because they can't get the orders right. They gave me a free cinnamon…read moreknots for my birthday so I gave it a try...they forgot the icing cup, barely put any powdered sugar, and put an eye dropper amount of icing on the knots. Thanks for the box of pizza crust! The only icing in this cake is that their "review your order" page is 404 unfound can't make this stuff up. & pizza is ghetto.