I absolutely love pizza post. When we used to live next door it was our go to pizza spot. We would order it almost weekly. Recently, we did a pizza party birthday party there from 10am to 12pm. It was a huge hit! The owner, Matt, is an angel. Incredible at making pizzas but really good with people. They make you feel like family. 10/10. We no longer live by pizza post but will go out of my way for it! One of the best pizza spots in the area. Apparently he has a mobile pizza truck he does house parties as well! read more

I haven't been here since my Greenwich High School days in the 80's and the place is different than I remember. Thought they sold slices but only pies and the small pie cut in 8 slices goes for 8 dollars. Real good sauce and dough combo. read more

Pizza Post - Pizza Near Me - Greenwich, Connecticut

Have I really never reviewed Pizza Post? One of the top two pizza places in Greenwich without debate. Pizzas are outstanding as are the calzones. The only slight gripe is there is no way to get delivery via them or any other service, but they do explain that's to control quality and I get that. Great weekday lunch specials as well. read more

I LOVE this place. Such an awesome local spot and the pizza is delicious. There's an option to sit down or take out. The classic pie was delicious - absolutely recommend. Will be back here for sure! read more

Pizza Post - Pizza Near Me - Greenwich, Connecticut

I love this place and doubt i will ever go to another pizza place for a while. They do something great with their dough, i could eat it on its own with olive oil. You can tell all of the ingredients are fresh, especially the veggies and the cheese. It is not oily but very flavorful. I want to eat it slowly to savor it. Best of all, the service is quick but not hurried. The kids and adults behind the counter are sweet and friendly and make you want to eat in even when you are in a rush. It is a lovely spot and I am so glad to have found it. read more

Pizza Post - Margherita Specialty Pizza with spinach and ricotta - Pizza Near Me - Greenwich, Connecticut

I have been ordering from PP for a few years and I have added my $2 cents a few times...I am not HAPPY..!! Why would you ruin 2 $14 Milanos with 2 very STALE rolls .. I have been a patient customer but there is nothing worse to do yourself in then (2) stale rolls Throw the stale rolls out for the birds or your business is going to the birds. ... be consistent.. I spent over $ 60 tonight on take out.. you are expensive.. get it together.. please... read more

Delicious fuckin' pizza, I'd come by almost everyday during my lunch block. You couldn't possibly believe how many times my friends and I would walk over from GHS. There's plenty of seats for you and your friends to sit down and enjoy a good meal or just pick up a box and eat while you walk. Plus my best friend works there, he's great at the cash register. Say Hi to Vinny for me read more

Good pizza and good parking. Recommend for takeout. They do have tables if you want to eat there.

I usually love pizza post and have been going there for years and before the fire. Seems they are slipping in quality in the name of efficiency. I ordered a pizza and picked it up. I came 10 minutes before it was set to be ready to ensure it was hot. When i got there i was given a random pie that was sitting on top of the oven in the bottom of a pile of ready made pizzas. I live 3 minutes from the restaurant yet when i got home it was cold and not good. Disappointed. read more

I used to make the trip up the Northeast pretty frequently and on one occasion we gave Pizza Post a shot. My wife was very much into her spaghetti and meatballs but I thought it was nothing special. My Dante's Inferno pizza though (chicken with hot cherry peppers) I would definitely order again. A small pizza was appropriate for my meal (I have a big appetite but not too crazy). Each item was about $15 or so. With prices going crazy though who knows what it will be in the future. I'll keep Pizza Post in my back pocket for my next trip up to New England. read more

Stopped here along a drive South for gas/food etc...It was a hot hot day and Pizza Post was the only place in the area that looked like they might be open for lunch. I walked in, and settled on a chicken parm sub, and boy am I glad I did! After a short wait, I paid $6!!!! and went back to my car with the sub bag. Inside was a gigantic chicken parm, on a perfectly toasted roll, with excellent tomato sauce and tons of mozzarella! Fantastic lunch deal!!!! read more

Pizza Post - Colorful counter - Pizza Near Me - Greenwich, Connecticut

See all

We first tried Pizza Post the day we moved to Greenwich in November 1991. We've loyally eaten in and ordered out from here ever since. The people are all very nice and accommodating. The food is great and they offer far more than pizza, with delicious soups, salads, entrees and pasta. They also have catered for us several times and we've enjoyed it all. Very happy it's still in the family and we were all relieved when they came back from the fire - stronger than ever. Also happy that they still allow BYOB at a reasonable corkage, even though they've gotten a liquor license. read more

My family orders from here every Friday. We have been coming here for over 10 years. Some of our favorite menu items are shrimp francese, penne vodka, salad pizza, and margherita pizza. & The staff is absolutely amazing!! Also, I'd recommend their gluten-free pizza it's definitely the best gluten-free pizza in town! read more

Local pizza for 51 years. I've been buying there for 50 years. Friendly service. Nice thin crust pizzas. Good Greek salads. Take out or table service. read more

Always stopping by when I'm on the area! They have the best pizza and I'm loving the updated menu! So glad they opened up again! Definitely recommend! read more

I had been in Florida for over three months and I was in need of a real good cheese NY pizza that I would satisfy my pizza crave. Oh yea, I found on a street called "Hope"! All is now good with the pizza crave. read more

Pizza Post - Pizza Near Me - Greenwich, Connecticut

Was visiting from out of town and ordered out, food was decent, the Pizza was good, we'll be returning in the future to try another item on the menu. read more

I ordered a pepperoni and mushroom pizza one night when I was in the area with a pizza craving. I was greeted when I entered, and the staff was very friendly. It was small inside like other reviews had mentioned and it was packed (Friday night). I like that the pepperoni is under the cheese. Tastes good cold too. read more

I've supported Pizza Post for years - my family always goes, we always went before the fire now we want to go back and be supportive but hard to be supportive when the pizza is cold when you pick it up, no flavor whatsoever, and the salad is mediocre at best. What a disappointment. Don't rest on your laurels Pizza Post, pick up your game or people are going to go elsewhere! read more

Quick takeout service - great pizza and salads. Saw someone call this Greek style - definitely not! Thin crust. Flavorful. Got mine well done and it had a great char. Salad portions are generous. Would recommend! read more

Best pizza in Fairfield county hands down ! Nice staff. Friendly to my little one. Can't say enough good stuff about PP read more

Hello Pizza Post & Luca !!! I would like to thank you for the Pizza that was delivered to our office today ! CT Dermatology Group West Putnam Avenue Greenwich , CT. When Luca mentioned he'd like to treat us to pizza - we were delighted !! And Pizza Post - the best pizza in town !! thank you so much !! The pizza was delicious and we will be ordering from Pizza Post in the future !! read more

This place is awesome.. I ate here a couple times before they had the fire. But I'm so glad they're open now. Everything here does not miss. From their pizza, to pastas, or sandwiches. Try them with the garlic bread. Sooo good.. just stop in or order out. Great food and awesome staff. read more

Best pizza in the area! i've tried all the places in town for 22 years and have found this to be the lightest crust and the freshest ingredients and fast service. I have a hard time not eating a whole pizza margarita myself! read more

ALWAYS terrific, what more can I say? With the ice cream shop gopher next door for dessert, it's a home run all around!

ABSOLUTELY FABULOUS! The food is amazing and the owners are incredible. We had a surprise party for my mom's birthday and Pizza Post catered--Matt was awesome to work with, flexible and super accommodating to our needs. The selection and quality of the meals was exemplary. All the guests were raving about the food and had seconds. My family has been enjoying their fine food with Luca since 1972, and are thrilled that his amazing sons are doing such a great job continuing this family business!! THANK YOU!! read more

Cardboard box take home packaging means restaurants need to test their food in it and adapt accordingly. The meals cool down fast. And the meals need to be delivered with way more sauce. I picked it up and by the time I brought it home it was a blob. No sauce. And why do I have to ask for bread? Not that there's any sauce it to dip it in. read more

Don't answer their phone and ask to order online. But the online order is not available. Sunday 4pm.

I definitely recommend getting pizza pickup from here. My favorites are their pizza, calzone, and bread sticks.

This pizza place is awful. The service was crappy, and my chicken parm wedge was nearly inedible. The bread was stale and burnt, the sauce flavorless, the chicken cutlets bland and chewy and I'm not sure i tasted any cheese at all. Furthermore, the whole thing fell apart in my hands, so i had to eat this crummy sandwich with a knife and fork. Don't bother with this place. read more

I'm a regular customer with no relationship (or grudge). IMO this is one of the best Pizza places anywhere, including Frank Pepe's in New Haven and Grimaldi in NYC both of which I've enjoyed. The pizza is the perfect middle ground between too thin (Grimaldi) and too thick (most others), too chewy (Frank Pepe) and too crisp. Just right for me. Try for yourself. The atmosphere is very pizza joint: plastic wood tables, menu over the counter, drinks from the fridge or fountain and usually little kids making noise. I've had the salads and pasta and sandwiches, all of which are average. Go for the Pizza, skip the fancy stuff. Plain cheese. Get it to go if you want ambiance or TV and a beer. read more

@ Jim c: you should really stop trolling on Yelp and making statements about a place when you obviously know nothing about food. You are clearly a competitor trying to make a negative impression on this stellar place. I don't know ANYONE who would have such an isolated horrific experience without even a mention within this review of contacting the owners. I would have. Shame on you for stooping so low. Actual review: I've been coming for years, and the food is consistent, delicious and made in a timely fashion. The service is amazing and if you are looking for a place that serves traditional Italian with great deep flavors, the Post is the right spot! Ask for the meatball parm - I asked about them after I had one and they are one of the few, if not ONLY gig in town offering FRESHLY MADE meatballs! That's a major plus with me. Also, the pizza is light, crispy and flavorful. The new Sophia Loren pie is their traditional Margherita pie, made with fresh mozz and plum tomato. It's really quite bright, and light. Not your traditional heavy Margh. I have yet to get some of the dinners, but it is anything like the pies and the parms, I'm in! It's a Greenwich staple for 40 years. They are clearly doing something right. :) read more

Pizza post used to be the best pizza in Greenwich, but the quality has gone down considerably. Not sure what happened. The pizza tastes just average...not enough cheese or sauce and the toppings are nothing special. I used to really enjoy this place. read more

This is my families "go to" spot in Greenwich when we want real authentic Italian food at a reasonable price - I've lived in Greenwich and Stamford for over 45 years and it's simply the best - I've had almost everything on the menu over the years , but my/ our favorite is the pizza and the "Pizza Post" salad which is a magical blend of various greens with bacon, Gorgonzola, and fresh red onion (among other things )- The Fettuccine Alfredo is also ridiculously good as well as the meatball parm wedge(I like to tell them to bake the bread extra crispy) or it can come out a little soggy Oh and let me not forget to mention the Buffalo wings are perhaps the best around too with their homemade Blue cheese(ask for an extra container or 2) All in all you know what you're getting when you eat or order out from here, it's consistently good The one criticism I would have is that they don't deliver or have others deliver aka UberEats, but it's probably because they don't HAVE to- luckily I live 5 mins away or this could be an issue Keep up the good work guys ! Hp read more

Absolutely the best of the best. Favorite pizza spot in the NorthEast. Unassuming location, you might miss this gem if you didn't know, or if a friend hadn't raved about it to you. But to those of us who know, it's really the best. Very casual, traditional, pizza restaurant. It's small, but has a great vibe. The owners have been in the business for 40+ years, across several generations... How do I know this? Because they'll take your order, or sit down and talk with you (if you like, or leave you be). These guys are the real deal - the live and breath pizza and real, traditional Italian food. I've been eating from their family at several restaurants since I was a kid...and it never lets you down. There are plenty of larger, fancier, more expensive places these days. But we always make our way back to the Pizza Post in Greenwich every time we're passing through. Keep up the great work guys, you deserve this review. read more

Pizza Post. I had heard great things and gave you three tries...because I wanted to love you. Sadly, we just did not connect. I have only tried the pizza. My feedback is this. The dough is a bit too greasy for me, thus it gets a soggy, and as a result doesn't have the crispiness I need. The sauce is decent but they don't use enough...in fact they barely gloss your pie over with it. Toppings & cheese are adequate. I especially like the meatballs. Pizza post is adequate but I think there are several pie joints in Greenwich and the surrounding area that are far superior. read more

Great little hidden nook in cos cob shopping center. Small italian pizzeria with BYOB. Always is croweded with most people getting takout. They DONT deliver but are always busy. If you can get a table, everyone gets a pizza! its freshly made on the spot which means you do have to wait till its perfectly cooked but its always worth the wait. You can add any topics onto it and can get half or even quarter toppings here and there. I would love to come eat here more if it wasnt always crazy crowded. If you cant get a spot-get takeout they even do personal pizzas! Always hits the spot and freshly made can never go wrong! there very few good pizza places around like this read more

Okay, did you all know that to get a small, personal pizza, it's only 5 bucks? And the pizza tastes amazing too. Such crunchy yet chewy crust, soft stringy cheese, savory sauce. Very affordable food, very friendly staff. 10/10 would recommend. read more

I'm a fan purely for the pizza itself. Went here for a late dinner one night and was sadly disappointed by their meatball sub. There was no seasoning in the meat at all and I could have done with a sandwich roll about half the size of the one they gave me. The pizza on the other hand is really good. Thin crust and really great especially if you are there with a group of friends. read more

We have been here many times and we love it. Today we went in this restaurant at 9 pm. We just ordered a pizza and the brasilian waitress gave BAD SERVICE to us. She was very rude cleaning the floor at 9:15 pm while we were eating and after 2 min she brought to us the check while i was eating the second slice of the pizza. She rushed us but we check the time in advance seeing that the restaurant clase at 10 pm. This absolutely the worst exeperience ever. My friend didn t want to eat anymore, he was very sad. The service is Sucks. I wouldn t leave the tips. Take care of your costumers is the first thing. I won t come anymore when she will be there read more