Where to even start?! This place is incredible!!! A friend recommended it, and I am here to recommend it for the rest of the world. The buffet is very comprehensive! They had pizza of all the fun flavors, tons of different types of pasta with an assortment of sauces. My favorite was the salad bar! The staff showed pride in their work and cleaned up our plates quickly! I loved all the Idaho decor around the seating area! We will be back! read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Potato pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Ammon, Idaho

See all

It goes without saying, this is a pizza buffet, so I definitely temper my expectations. That said, they delivered on my visit. Pizza was good, salad bar was well tended. Pasta was really good. I'm not big on desserts, but I tried some and they were pretty good. Cashier was friendly and service collecting plates was outstanding. It started getting a bit crowded, but definitely a popular spot. Prices were also very good. Nice visit all around. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Salad - Pizza Near Me - Ammon, Idaho

Uhh oh...Toilet contents were shocking (from both ends). Hair found in pizza. Water was nice.

Pizza Pie Cafe was a great restaurant to work with! My students wanted to try their pizza (as part of a culinary experience they earned). The manager and employees were easy to communicate with over the phone. The manager even delivered the pizza to help our school out. The students loved the Oreo dessert pizza and cheese/pepperoni pizzas. Thank you Pizza Pie Cafe for great service, communication and great food! read more

I love the pasta... They have several types And 4 sauces - will accomidate anyone's taste Pizza always plentiful and delicious There also a salad bar Everything is all you can eat! Great value for your money read more

So disappointed tonight. We had reserved the party room for a birthday party.Five minutes maybe 10 into the party we were told we had to share the room. because they needed some of our tables. Really unbelievable the reason we reserved the room was because we have a special needs child and they are not comfortable in crowds. Of course our party came to an end. We will never return. read more

The pizza and the dessert pizzas were good. They were on top of making sure the pizza station was refilled constantly The Alfredo and carbonara sauces were curdled and lacked flavor. Liked the salad bar options. Over all it could have been cleaner as a whole and the beverage stations better stocked and taken care of on such a busy night. read more

Mane let me just tell you something : the employees who work there are very hard working and seem as though they want you to have the best possible experience. The place itself has plenty of room to sit a large quantity of people and the place is kept consistently clean . As for the pizza , have mercy on my soul ohhhh my I just love loading up my plate with some good quality slices of pie. My favorite part is getting to refill my drink and then when desert time comes around , I am truly blessed . I love it so much . My gah I just wow. Wit the bestest regards , yo favorite customer read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Just a special little pizza I asked them to make - Pizza Near Me - Ammon, Idaho

Fun place to take the kids so they can go wild and eat as much pizza as they want. Toppings are a little skimpy, and always out of Hawaiian pizza. That seems to be a crowd favorite. Please consider getting better, maybe texturized? Pizza serving utensils, the pizza slides right off of it and to the floor. read more

One of my favorite things about PPC is their pasta. Oh, my goodness is that wonderful. I mean, I know it's Barilla but the sauces that go with it are divine! Their pizza can be very hit or miss. The salad bar is your typical fare. It's good but nothing fancy. Hint, if you don't like to deal with the crowds like me go early. I suggest getting there right as they open. My only beef is that the pizzas usually aren't out until fifteen minutes after they open. Cleanliness is decent. I know it's hard to keep it clean when you get a large group of people, especially with children. I have seen it unkempt though when they first open. Make sure you get all your cleaning done before close guys. It's really important. read more

I hosted a birthday party at the Pizza Pie Cafe and it turned out very well. Oh my guests really enjoyed the different kinds of pizza, the dessert pizzas, pastas and the salad bar. So all in all it was a great success. read more

Excellent service and friendly staff. They seem to like their job and are treated well and it shows. Lots of options for pizza and pastas and an amazing salad bar. Don't forget the desert pizza as well! Well worth the price and great place to take a family! Thank you! read more

Pizza Pie Cafe has a great variety of pizzas with combinations I wouldn't typically get but loved to try! I don't have a big stomach but I definitely room for dessert pizza and it was worth it! Staff was friendly and the restaurant was constantly keeping sanitized with very specific instructions on how to handle your own food to keep regulations in check. Will definitely go again! read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Spud-O-Licious Pizza Firefighter Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Ammon, Idaho

Ordered thru Doordash, having never been here before. The pizza was like cardboard. Even my two youngest toddlers didn't want to eat the pizza, and they LOVE all types of pizzas! Personally, I think digiorno frozen pizzas taste 100% better The salad was huge, but after taking all the topping I requested NOT to be on there, there wasn't much actual salad which was a bummer. The garlic knots were warm and addicting. Overall, I probably wouldn't come back. But the pricing is fair for their taste. $33 on Door dash for 2 large pizzas, 1 salad and 1 order of garlic knots. read more

So disappointed in this place!!!! We had planned a 50th birthday party and reserved the party room. We had not been in there for 10 minutes when they came and told us they needed to put other people in the room because the restaurant was busy. We were absolutely shocked and devastated!!!! When I made the reservation they said we would have the room for 1 hour do we had planned activities around that timetable. We were not forewarned about other people coming in. If they had told me that, we would have made other arrangements. We have a member of our group that cannot be in loud environments or around a lot of people,which was yet another reason we booked that room. Weeks of planning destroyed in a matter of moments. The "manager" was not only unable to help us in anyway, he was actually rude. We have used the party room many times in the past but never again! None of us will ever go there again. read more

I don't see the fuss people give this place. Just as good as other locations I have been. Excellent food, price and service. Eat here you won't regret it read more

So disappointed. We love the Rexburg location. However I keep giving this location a chance and I don't know why. Clearly I keep hoping something will change. Two of our pizzas were undercooked and doughy. The third the dough was very thin the dough was weird tasting like it was left out a while before baking. The toppings on all pizzas were sparse. The only edible one was the cinnamon sticks. Even my kids who were super hungry barely at the pizza. read more

Friends took us here last week. $11 buffet not bad price. No Coke products for your $3, though. The Buffalo pizza was oddly sweet, stopped at one slice. Pepperoni pizza was OK. All crusts were a little doughy, needed more baking. Crust should just be thinner for the time in the oven, but being a buffet, they want you to fill up faster. I just stopped eating the crust after the first couple bites per slice. Took numerous trips to finally find a Hillbilly pizza available. The pasta bar was fine. A variety of noodle shapes and five sauce options. My friends rave about the Salad Bar, but I did not try it. Dessert choices were all pizza crust based. A similar pizza buffet (Cici's) serves the most delicious gooey cinnamon rolls. read more

I was bummed a few weeks ago when I found out from medical test results said I was seriously gluten intolerant. I contacted a few close friends who I knew deal with celiac disease every day. I found out from a great friend over a week ago that Pizza Pie Cafe also has some gluten free menu items besides their regular menu items. We went for lunch today. It was totally delicious. No upset tummy afterward. The service people was great & very helpful as well. read more

Pizza version of Home Town Buffet (not a compliment). Ate here during busy lunch. In spite of that, the pizzas all tasted like they had been sitting in the window for an hour or more (which they hadn't). Salad bar was ok, but just minimal on options. Lunch was 7.25 per adult. So many better options for the money. However if you want unlimited amounts of pizza, pasta and lettuce, this may be your place, that is if you don't care about what it tastes like. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza Near Me - Ammon, Idaho

Bull headed staff member was really unkind. Apparently if the tables touch it's a fire hazard. I was mostly turnned off by her attitude and terse nature. She was very unaccommodating and unpleasant. I haven't even tried the food yet, but I already don't like the place read more

Love it! Love the variety for the price. The salad bar is always fresh, the pasta isn't soggy, the sauces are homemade and delicious. The pizza is best when it comes out fresh. Good for families. read more

We love us some Pizza Pie Cafe! If you want great pizza in large quantities coupled with great service then this is the place to go!! Even when the lines are long they move quickly and the staff is on top of their game! Also we celebrated two birthdays and instead of serving 2 little Cookie Monsters for our group the guy who took our payment up front brought us a single large one that we couldn't finish! read more

Great value, great environment, great employees and some pretty good pizza. You can never expect pizza from a buffet to be amazing- much less at such a great low price, but they do some creative and fun things here. My favorite is the buffalo chicken pizza. When I was very first introduced to it, I was kind of let down because when you hear "buffalo" you are thinking of a delicious, tangy, vinegary bite. This one is not your traditional "buffalo" flavor. If you've been to Wingers, it's more like a Sticky Fingers pizza. Once those expectations are set and you're aware, its a delicious pizza and is reason alone to go. There's another one that's a spicy one with jalapeños and it's also very delicious. Their salad bar is hard to beat. Everything is much fresher than a lot of other salad bars you may have visited and questioned how long the lettuce has been sitting there. I start off with a huge, well composed salad to set the tone. The pasta is good, but in my opinion, between everything else, there's not much room for the pasta. But if you're a pasta guy/girl, they have a variety of pastas sauces, and the carbonara is pretty legit! The dessert pizzas are good, but I wish they undercooked it a little bit or something (If that's even legal). I just think it would be such a nice complement to all of the crunchy crusted pizzas to have a nice, soft dough for the dessert pizzas. They just seem a little too dry. Maybe they could throw on more toppings and that would solve it. However, they have like a pizza of the month or something, and they had a dessert pizza that was straight dynamite! It was like a nice soft sugar cookie, topped with deliciousness. Lastly, the staff. They always seem to have young, really upbeat and friendly employees. It's good to see people who appear to enjoy their job. read more

Beware anyone who is cilliac/gluten intolerant. Although they do sell gluten-free pizzas, they will charge extra every time you would like one, on top of the all you can eat buffet that is mostly unavailable to GF eaters. Your alternatives for gluten-free are a mediocre (on their best day) salad bar or GF pasta that takes 30 minutes and multiple reminders to ever show up. When you mention anything to management, they will then proceed to talk down to you like a little child and say they appreciate you coming in. The food quality and customer service is severely lacking at this location. You're better off going to Domino's or Lucy's. read more

Craigo's (now Pizza Pie Cafe) is probably one of the few restaurants I would miss when moving out of the eastern Idaho area. Having said that, the place is less than perfect. First, this place is usually very busy. Usually busy with a lot of kids too, which can get annoying very quickly. I suppose that's the nature of the beast of a buffet, but this place is especially bad in this area. Don't expect a nice, quiet evening here. It is likely not going to happen. Pricing is fair. About $8 per person for the whole buffet with a drink (that you do have to get yourself) is pretty cheap, and likely the cheapest buffet in town. The salad bar is the best part of the whole deal, with plenty of fresh ingredients every time I've bellied up to it. Very well maintained for sure. The pizza is so-so, and only a little bit better than Little Caesar's. At least there's plenty of variety with baked potato pizzas, barbecue pizzas and more. Even delicious dessert pizzas! The pasta is definitely not the reason to come here. While it's passable, it is literally just simple noodles and sauce. Expect nothing more. Why would I waste my appetite at a restaurant on something I could easily make at home? Perhaps the biggest problem with Craigo's is their hours. They close at 8PM. 10PM would be more appropriate, because this place definitely tends to satisfy my night cravings for a yummy salad. Overall, good salad, decent pizza but bad pasta and terrible environment do drag things down a bit. Definitely check it out, if you can get in before they refuse you (seriously, this does happen) because they're closing for the night. read more

We really, really miss the original college-town Craigo's in Rexburg. That place was amazing. Huge, delicious pizzas and the dessert pizza was amazing! I have no idea why someone thought it was a good idea to mix things up, but here we are. We do like this place, though it isn't perfect. I love that they have a gluten free pizza option, though it's expensive for what you get, and the wait is quite long -- my family will have all finished and my GF pizza will have just arrived. I also like their GF pasta option, though I do wish they had more GF sauces. The kids enjoy the all you can eat buffet, and the dessert pizzas are still very good. I quite like the salad bar WHEN it's tended. Sometimes the lettuce and spinach doesn't look very fresh, last time I had to pick through a lot of slimy Spinach pieces which was kind of gross. I do enjoy the fact that they have craisins, my favorite salad topping! And wish they'd offer some kidney beans for the lettuce as well, and chilled pasta (including GF). My husband says the pizza isn't like, award winning or anything, but it is a nice place to take the family. It can be expensive without a coupon, and it's often crowded, but I appreciate it for what it is, and hope they stick around. read more

Not very clean place however there food is amazing when I went to get my pasta the guy was kinda rude

For some reason this is my husband's favorite pizza place. But I think that's because it is buffet style. The pizza is very cheap. The pizza dough tastes like cardboard. But if you are in the mood for a lot of pizza for a cheap price then this is it. read more

I really love this place but the cashier was really rude. She has to change or else this place is getting no where with her running in the front. read more

Pizza Pie Cafe - Pizza and pasta buffet.. Couldn't ask for anything else... Besides beer - Pizza Near Me - Ammon, Idaho

This place has a good salad bar....... That's all I can say good though. On the few times I've come here I've paid nearly $15 each to come in and walk laps waiting for a table to be available. Then the pizza bar can't keep stocked for the people standing around waiting for tables and eating at tables. I won't be back. read more

The one star is not due to lack of service or food quality. Let's just say if you want to take a risk contracting covid-19, go to this location. There seems to be an almost complete disregard for the well-being of the public. No social distancing, no mask requirements, no sanitizing, and they are packing people around the buffet table like a bunch of sardines. It's disgraceful. The only protections they have is oversized plastic gloves and a black tray to put your dishes in. With the gloves, you're touching handles that have been touched by so many people. Some not wearing gloves. This is unacceptable and honestly disgusting. If you value your health and the health of those around you, do not go here. read more

Food was average. The employees were rude. Especially the guy that serves the pasta like can you please smile it won't kill you.

Visiting from out of town and got the gluten free buffet. The pizza was good, but the dessert pizza was a joke. I went to the pizza pie cafe in Boise and I was able to get the cinnamon pizza for dessert. But, in this one there were only two options of apple and raspberry available. I ordered the apple and my sister got the raspberry. When they came out my sister and I were shocked. It was literally an extremely thin amount of fruit spread on the crust and nothing else. No icing. Nothing. It was extremely disappointing. I truly don't understand why any company would think that was acceptable to give paying customers. Just because someone is gluten free doesn't mean they want the equivalent of toast and the dregs of a jam jar for dessert, while the "regular" options are plentiful and heaping with toppings. read more

While not the BEST pizza in town, the experience and the plethora of choices make this place a definitely "hit up". The pizza is by no means gross! Don't get me wrong! They have pastas as well, many choices and different sauces to choose from. All quite yummy. Their salad bar is usually pretty good. The main draw for me is the dessert pizzas. HOLY CRAP those things are tasted! read more

Wow! I hope this was just an off day! We waited forever to get the salad refilled, all the pizzas were old and even though we waited and waited and waited they only replaced one of them. There were 8 pans with three dried out pieces. And no raspberry desert pie despite asking repeatedly and being told it was three minutes out. We left 15 min later unhappy. So sad, we have teenage boys, this could have been a go to. Hope it was a fluke... at five o'clock in a Thursday! read more

Love this place! Family friendly, priced right, all you can pizza. If you have room for dessert get the cookie monster!

This place is funny. I enjoyed reading the history of their company that was literally written on all of their walls. None of the food is really that good. The pizza lacks some flavor and is a little doughy. The white sauces on the pastas taste like flour. But it's a family environment. That's why you came. The kids like picking out their own pizza. It's fast and friendly and pretty dang cheap. I suppose I recommend this. Just don't expect delicacies heaped upon your plates. read more

This pizza pie cafe is terrible. The food was ok... The selection sucks. They only make half the pizzas that the one in rexburg makes. The service was horrible as well. We asked for pizza that they said they would put in right away and 30 minutes later... No pizza. We even asked several times. Don't waste your time here. Go to the one in rexburg. read more

Great pizza, lots of variety! Pizza, salad, and pasta. Very friendly staff. Love the dessert pizzas! My kids love going here.