11/10, best pizza I've ever had! Way better than the big places. Definitely recommendread more

Very disappointed. Wings were cold and hard even though were just out of oven.Garlic bread was…read moregross.like a slice of cheese thrown on a stale bun and microwaved.First and last.Giorgios 100 times better and more friendly

I came to Stouffville to check out Saints Island pies as I heard that they were a Filipino fusion…read morecafé/restaurant. I was ideally looking for a great work environment that I can grab coffee and some food and I thought this place was a perfect in between!! The place does get quite busy throughout the morning to lunch hour. I have not come here in the evening. I can understand the hype as to why this place does get packed because they have so many different types of food to choose from as well as coffee, tea drinks, and specialty drinks. I was able to try two types of pizzas and share between friends. I was able to try the mushroom adobo pizza as well as spicy Laing pizza. Both were very good. The crust was very flavorful. It is a great infusion of Filipino flavors. I am Filipino myself, and I loved it. It definitely encompass everything I was looking for, and I thought it was quite unique as I've never thought about these flavors on top of the pizza!! I would highly recommend this place and definitely come back !!!

Renamed and rebranded to Saints on Main, which is open for breakfast as well, but will only mention…read moremy takeout pizza experience from there. Filipino-inspired pizzas were delicious! Crust had a great crispy texture and toppings for the 2 pizza options we got were tasty. The pizzas are small considering the cost (you could get a larger one elsewhere for the same fee), but it works so since their pizzas are pretty hearty. Ordering was easy - online through one of the food delivery apps. Was ready for pick-up at the indicated time. Would get their pizza again.

Yes this place is overhyped with all the latest influencers but I don't think it deserves the hate…read more As a local shop in Stouffville, it brings a good variety of things to the town. There is often a line during lunch hours so best to go a little earlier if possible. We tried the veal before and find that we prefer the meatball and we always add mushrooms! The portions are big and the bread is toasted so nice. Would come back!

My husband and I decided to try this place last weekend. We ordered chicken parm sandwiches and…read morecould not resist the pastries!! We had a small mix up with our order (which can happen anywhere) and contacted Sarah to let her know. Sarah is incredible! Not only did she reach out to me before the end of the day, she went above and beyond to rectify the situation. Honestly, she is the epitome of what customer service should look like!! She did everything but backflips to help us!! Food is great, Sarah is amazing, totally recommending to anyone who loves Italian food. Oh yeah, TRY THE CANNOLI!! My mouth is watering thinking about them!!

Good pizza, friendly staff and usually prompt service. Great specials as previously noted. One of…read moremy biggest pet peeves with pizza joints is when they don't properly or completely slice the pie. It happened on my last visit unfortunately... let's hope it doesn't become a habit

Good Pizza but avoid the Online ordering. Corporate Pizzaville ignores issues with their site. I…read morewas a regular customer but now will go elsewhere. Stouffville has a large choice of Pizza Joints.

The Works was ok. The spicy italian sausage was a bit muted (it's more flavourful at many other…read moreplaces). Philly Cheesesteak was decent. There was a lot cheese, though not much beef. The pizza crust here is pretty decent. If you get a good promo, it's pretty good value. I like that you get free garlic dipping sauce - it's alright, basically garlic oil (maybe my tubs were a bit old so the liquid was no longer homogenous)

Gave this place a second try. Ordered and paid online and my order was ready at the acknowledged…read morepick-up time. Kudos to them for that. I love the extra dipping sauce on the side and the piece of pepperoncini pepper per pizza. Gave it a decent touch which no other pizza chain in town does. However, I found that the taste was not there. A bit bland and not enough crisp at the base of each pizza. Keep trying boys and girls. I may be back for more!

A standalone, non-franchised pizza shop…read more The pizzas are quite unique. You won't see combination toppings like these at other places. Most of the other reviews I've read criticize the pricing and reluctantly I would have to agree. Great quality pies with lots of toppings but no other pizza place out there is charging almost $50 for one XL pie. 5 star pizza but 2 star pricing which brings my overall rating down to 4 stars. So far I've tried: Sweet italian Honey pork Gordon's favorite Will obviously return but this place is more for special occasions or potlucks imo.

LAZY stand out in…read morethe cold to order a simple pep and cheese large but actually pretty small pizza is 40 dollars lol Costco down the road sells the same pizza and bigger for 24 bucks. I know its a small place but you don't even have an entry point. I feel like a panhandler begging for food. Not even that its also not safe to be handling money through a window out in the open. 30 may have been reasonable but I wont be coming back. And nothing special either. The Costco one actually tastes a tad better. Whats the point.

We have been ordering pizzas from here for years. I'd say we have had at least fifty and after…read moreexperimenting with the toppings for about the first ten order, have settled on one combination for a large pizza. With the exception of one order which was slightly undercooked, every other was perfect, hot and delicious. When we have had friends join us for a slice the reaction has always been the same - the best ever tasted. The price is reasonable eve with delivery. It is local so I could pick it up and save about half the price, but most often I take advantage of the quick service. There's no 40 minutes or free offer, but delivery is never more than that, typically half an hour. It's great to have the best pizza so convenient. Online ordering is apparently on the way; for now it's in-store or by telephone.

This is the best pizza in town!! After being treated terribly and getting ripped off constantly at…read moredominos .. Decided to try a new pizza joint. Was told about this place and how good it is before... I had always looked past it based on the exterior but upon trying it, it quickly became our go to place. If I had one critique, it would be about the dipping sauces. I love dipping sauces and am not fond of the thick mayonnaise based ones- like they use here. But that's the only thing wrong I can think of so that's not so bad. I just buy my sauces elsewhere... The employees are lovely The dough/ crust is delicious The red sauce is divine The options are endless!! Overall just a great place to go for a pizza!!

My in-laws took my wife and to Fishbone by the Lake while visiting from the U.S. and had a lovely…read moreafternoon. The setting is absolutely gorgeous and the food was excellent!

4.5/5 I brought a friend here for birthday celebration, she loves the place. It's such a beautiful…read moreday, Musselman Lake looks absolutely gorgeous. We ordered Garden pizza, pull & tear bread and a steak tartare. I don't eat raw beef, but my friend said the steak tartare was delicious. The Garden pizza was fresh from oven with chewy pizza dough, arugula & other ingredients, we both loved it. Service was good too! This is always my favourite place to bring a friend.

The wings are $12/10 wings (I got 12) so they are probably the cheapest in the area unless a Sri…read moreLanka takeout place opens up. They get 3.5 stars. The wings are smaller than usual. There are few sauce choices. Medium was quite generic, mildly spicy BBQ. The interior was underseasoned. The wings were moist enough & not evenly tossed in the sauce. They were quite crispy, with breading that was more textured than usual.

Having just vistited Terroni in Toronto a week ago, I must say that my opinion of Cocelli Pizza ,…read moreafter 4 visits, exceeds that of the famous Terroni's. Coccelli's dough is delictible, soft and airy. They use just the perfect amount of tangy, and well seasoned sauce. Their cheese has a high-quality bitterness to it with an incredible stretch factor and the pepperoni always cups, curls and crisps to give you that perfect bacony savoury that we all pine for. I live in Georgina, and I swear I'd travel 40 minutes to Newmarket just for this excellent pizza, Thank you Cocelli!