Our little home town is so fortunate to have this pizza place! For 25 years we have ordered from…read moreSteve's pizza and only one time during these years have they accidentally had a whoopsie. They not only fixed the problem, but were so kind to go above and beyond by replacing our entire order (which honestly they didn't have to do that.) The only complaint in the time we have ordered here, is that we would love to see them open earlier. By the time they open, 2nd shifters miss out unless they wait around for the weekend. It would be amazing if they were open at least at 2pm

ordering online was easy, they had it prepared and delivered promptly…read more Over all the pizza was good, though they misread my 'special instructions" I feel. I requested 'extra crispy crust", and I got extra cheese instead.

Benny DiCarta's is the best NY style pizza we have eaten in years. It's a "2 paper plater!" That…read morecrunch tho! Served up quickly & piping hot- cooked to perfection. Located downtown, walk up order at the counter, cozy & seating inside to smash real quick and bounce. Be sure to give them a try if you like to fold your pizza! So yummy! We will definitely be back every time we visit Kalamazoo.

Stopped in at Benny D's for a slice and it was out of this world! Staff was friendly, food came…read moreout fast, slices were huge, and the whole place was super clean. We will be back soon!

We get pizza here regularly. Great quality food. Gets very busy at peak times…read more They bring your order out to your car if it's not ready when you arrive.

Just wasted $30 on a pizza and cheesy garlic bread. The pizza is underdone and a floppy mess, I…read morethink they forgot to put the cheese and garlic on the bread. Wishing I just got a frozen pizza!

Great sandwiches. Awesome service. Excellent prices…read more Onion rings could have been hotter. They were like warm to cold. Tater tots and French fries were good Id recommend this place

The pizza needed a little more cheese to hold everything in place. Otherwise it was good with…read moreplenty of meat. The cider on tap was delicious! Or young server was attentive and helpful. Would definitely return!

Don't be fooled by the gas station. Solid pizza and great service! Better than many of the "chain"…read moreestablishments.

I stopped in for lunch and self-served myself to 2 slices of Pizza. Paid a little over $6 at the…read moregas station counter. Pizza was hot and fresh. Quick and easy. Pizza was good.

Small town pizza joint with some big time pizza! My husband's been talking about Farmhouse Pizza…read moreand raving about their food. As a lover of all things pickle, I had to try their Pickle Pizza. It lives up to the hype! Made with white sauce, 2 types of cheese, pickles, smoked pulled pork and bbq sauce (on the side for us). Service is friendly and fast. Eat in or take out. They had a nice selection of beer, wine and seltzers if you want to grab those to-go with your food. Can't waIt to go back and try some of their other food!

Very disappointed and frustrated. We ordered two meat lasagna dinners on line with a pickup time…read moreof 6:13. I arrived at that time to find out they were just working on my order and it would be 5 more minutes. 15 minutes I'm still standing near the counter. They could have at least apologized and offer me a complimentary fountain drink and invite me to sit at a table in their nice dining area while waiting and bring my take out to me when it was ready. Very short on hospitality here. When we got back to the farm, the pieces of meat that they put on top of the lasagna were like hard pieces of charcoal. The garlic bread was missing the garlic and butter. Just toasted bread.

This place has the best pizza in Kalamazoo. My wife is a Chicago style expert. Their sandwiches are…read moreamazing. Service is great local and friendly would highly recommend deep dish. actually it's the best pizza in portage or Kalamazoo.

Great pizza for sure. We had the double crust pie and a hand tossed pizza. Great flavor in the…read moresauce, really good price for the amount and quality. If you're a Chicago deep dish fan, this comes real close. Even if it's not exact, it's damn good. We ordered online and chose the time, and it was timed to the minute. Plus walking in, everyone who greeted me seemed genuinely happy to welcome me and serve a customer. Definitely recommend!

Let me tell you a tale about my pizza-loving husband. This man lives for pizza--the good, the bad,…read morethe ugly. Now, I'll partake in the former any day of the week with him, but it's the latter that had me rolling my eyes *hard* one late afternoon on our drive from Chicago to our home in Michigan when he wanted to make a {45 minute} "detour" on this place he found for pizza. I was just ready to start our weekend and tired from the week. But boy oh boy am I glad I went limp & relented because I ate my words, in the form of some of the best pizza I've ever had. In fact, it quickly became a part of our regular routine and I haven't looked back. For context, I was raised in New York and have lived in Chicago over 10 years, also I'm thick as hell, so when I tell you I know pizza, you'll have to trust me and try for yourself. Patellie's has a fantastic crust, chewy, crispy, flavorful. They use the perfect amount and kind of sauce & cheese, and they locally source their veggies & meats. In fact, I usually always opt for whatever veggie pie they have that day (their chef is a mad genius), and it never disappoints. We don't make it up to Michigan as much anymore since selling our home, but I think about the pizza...and the other love of my life (their burrata) often & feel wistful. Check it out!

Got the penne alla vodka and it was really tasty. The sauce had a creamy texture with a little…read morespice, which I liked a lot. Pasta wasn't mushy, which is always a plus. It came with a side salad that was pretty fresh too. Our waitress was kind and checked on us a couple of times without being pushy. The restaurant was clean and had a nice chill atmosphere. Solid meal overall.

I am from michigan originally and was visiting from Florida and took my parents who still reside in…read moreMichigan to this distillery for a evening of fun and good food of which Gull Lake Distilling Co came through with flying colors!!! The bartender was awesome!!

Thanks for totally ignoring me when I came to the bar to order. 5 staff chatting with each other…read moreand didn't look at me at all. Instead walked away. Big mistake. I'm a big tipper for superior service.

To begin with, the guy at the front desk was very nice. Unlike some places, they warmly greeted me…read moreas I walked in and patiently waited for me to make up my mind and order. As I was waiting for my food, they engaged me in friendly small talk about sports and the weather. The pizza was finished rarely fast which I appreciated. And when I ate the pizza, it was delicious and flavorful. I would have loved for the crust to be a little thicker, but the taste is amazing. I definitely would be a returning customer.

The manager is the best and went above and beyond! Great service and we can't wait to support them…read moremore!