Patellie&#x27;s

0

38

21

2 years ago

Although the wait times can be extreme at times, the pizza has to be some of the best I've ever had, Anywhere. Our favorite is the HI. They will let you know right from the get go on the wait time so no complaint there. Their house salad is also great. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

D. T.

283

101

170

3 years ago

After being a customer here years and giving a 5 star review in the past, it hurts my heart to give this place 3 stars. But, when you act ignorantly, then you deserve fewer stars. After spending $67 for two pizzas, a Caesar's Salad and San Pellegrino, I would like to think that I would get a small little container of extra pizza sauce for free while my family was eating the warm pizza. But, I had to stand in line behind 3 people to pay 50 cents for the sauce. And the best part was that they gave me COLD TOMATO SAUCE that was obviously out of a can! They did not even heat it ! Seriously ??? Use some common sense !!!! I don't give a damn about the 50 cents !! I would pay you $5 for it. But seriously.....my pizza was getting cold while I waited in line to pay you 50 cents !!! After working in the restaurant industry for decades and giving customers free things regularly, I was completely shocked that Patellie's wanted my 50 cents ! I won't be back ! Thank you! You have NO RESTROOMS! I had to go across the street to use the bathroom at Froehlick's. But you got your 50 cents! Too bad you have no Business Sense! P. S. You charged me $1.00 for extra Basil on One Pizza and the other pizza had NO BASIL! read more

Patellie's - a person holding a receipt - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elliott P.

6

27

10

2 years ago

Best New York style in a long time! Great staff and awesome menu! Whenever we stay in New Buffalo, we will forever take a 40 minute round trip! We would visit more if we didn't live in Indianapolis! Keep it up! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Dan G.

699

976

2564

5 years ago

Very satisfied with our carryout feast from Patellie's. We got a few pies, meatballs and cheese and crackers for some holiday grazing. We enjoyed all of it. My sausage and Calabrian pepper pizza was excellent. I almost got giardiniera, but when I saw the the spicy Calabrians I decided to shake up the string of groundhog days and try a different combo. Sixteen inch pies, so you'll get eight proper slices. Pies had a good amount of cheese, a tasty sauce and perfect crust. Patellie's would be solid pizza anywhere. In Three Oaks it feels like a find, and where we'll be going in the future. read more

Patellie's - Spicy Fennel Sausage and Calabrian Chilis - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Patellie's - Veggie pizza, meatballs and cheese and crackers - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

See all

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 3

Oh no 0

Amanda W.

Elite 17

52

132

137

3 years ago

Let me tell you a tale about my pizza-loving husband. This man lives for pizza--the good, the bad, the ugly. Now, I'll partake in the former any day of the week with him, but it's the latter that had me rolling my eyes *hard* one late afternoon on our drive from Chicago to our home in Michigan when he wanted to make a {45 minute} "detour" on this place he found for pizza. I was just ready to start our weekend and tired from the week. But boy oh boy am I glad I went limp & relented because I ate my words, in the form of some of the best pizza I've ever had. In fact, it quickly became a part of our regular routine and I haven't looked back. For context, I was raised in New York and have lived in Chicago over 10 years, also I'm thick as hell, so when I tell you I know pizza, you'll have to trust me and try for yourself. Patellie's has a fantastic crust, chewy, crispy, flavorful. They use the perfect amount and kind of sauce & cheese, and they locally source their veggies & meats. In fact, I usually always opt for whatever veggie pie they have that day (their chef is a mad genius), and it never disappoints. We don't make it up to Michigan as much anymore since selling our home, but I think about the pizza...and the other love of my life (their burrata) often & feel wistful. Check it out! read more

Helpful 4

Thanks 1

Love this 2

Oh no 1

Ross G.

58

114

4

2 years ago

Visiting Three Oaks. Tried a pie. Loved it. Sort of NY style. The crust, toppings and taste were great. I will definitely make a return visit. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tyler B.

55

2

2 years ago

Probably the best NY style pizza in the area, but it is quite expensive. Definitely call ahead and order on the weekend, since it can be an hour wait. We ordered The Meat Pie for $25. This place is definitely worth a try, but for the price I wouldn't be a frequent customer. read more

Patellie's - The Meat Pie - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Michaela J.

73

98

28

2 years ago

Always easy and good! The staff is friendly and quick. Never a Michigan trip without a stop at Patellies.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jonathan M.

Elite 25

12

147

0

2 years ago

What more can I say. They have 5 stars for a reason. If you're lucky, you'll find out why. Don't hesitate to support this pizza joint and be happy they exist. Excellent, excellent, excellent. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jennifer M.

2

7

0

2 years ago

Got a carry out pizza order and it was delicious! Friendly staff and cute location too.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Lauren T.

3

24

17

4 years ago

We were visiting for our family beach trip to Lake Michigan and lucky enough to find this delicious pizza! We ordered a margarita for our family and received a glorious pizza. Called to confirm there was no egg in dough as our daughter has an egg allergy. Easy to order and pick up. We ate the entire pizza among our family of 4. Will definitely visit again next time we're in the area and try other items! read more

Patellie's - Our son enjoying the pizza - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Terra S.

25

0

3 years ago

Really good thin wood fired pizza. Unexpected excellent find in 3 Oaks! Order early on weekends! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John S.

2

48

22

4 years ago

Just for fun we did a taste test with Patellie's and another locally made pizza. I was still impressed by the outstanding taste profile, texture, and lightness of this pizza. It is far and away the best pizza in the area for me. The sweet chewy crust and the evenly distributed specialty toppings make this pie a standout among standouts. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Bernadette R.

278

22

36

7 years ago

A group of five friends and myself were on a trip and wandering around downtown Three Oaks, Michigan looking for a good lunch spot. We were planning on giving another place a try but that was a hot mess. We wanted a sit down restaurant that we could get a drink at, as well as some simple bar food. There was no such location to be found in the downtown area that didn't have a weird vibe so we decided to "settle" on Patellie's, which advertised slices of pizza. We are so happy we landed on this option!! The slices of pizza were each a quarter of a pizza. It was thin crust and they offered 4 options for slices. Between all of us in the group we tried the sausage, pepperoni and margarita slices. Everyone was extremely happy with their choice and agreed that this was the best option for lunch we could've found. They have chili sauce for dipping on the table which was a huge hit. No alcohol available but they do have fun craft sodas and soft drinks. read more

Patellie's - Cute inside - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Patellie's - This was one slice of the pepperoni (cut in half) - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rodney C.

1

5

2

4 years ago

I've had a lot of pizzas from many different places in Berrien County. Patellies is head and shoulders above the rest. Always ask about their specials, of the 7 or 8 different ones I've ordered I can only think of 1 that I didn't love, but it was still pretty good. Try their homemade crackers, cream cheese and jam appetizer. It's also phenomenal! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Shea M.

47

7

1

3 years ago

I'm so glad we gave this place a try. The menu is small and that makes things so much simpler. We got the standard 16" pie with pepperoni on all and half with onion, red pepper, and mushrooms. It was so delicious. The crust is my idea of perfect. Not too thick and not too thin. The sauce has the tiniest bit of kick to it. Just enough to let you know it's there. The cheese was tasty and the toppings were fresh. Can't wait to try other topping! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George G.

Elite 24

30

138

1

4 years ago

Hands down the best pizza for 50 miles! Good crust, good salads, drinks, some gelato/frozen desert options. Everything is great, employees are always nice and smiling like they enjoy what they're doing. It's an all around good environment that leaves me full and happy! My only complaint is that they aren't open more. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jeff D.

469

669

950

7 years ago

Being from Chicago, the bar is pretty high when it comes to quality pizza. Not so much deep dish pizza but pizza in general. So staying in Union Pier last weekend, we ordered in and opted for Patellie's. Of course I was skeptical but my skepticism proved me wrong - in a good way! We did a 16" thin sausage and mushroom. Next time I'll pass the mushroom but you can tell that sausage was fresh and probably homemade. The biggest surprise to me was the amount of cheese they put on this pie. It was an enormous amount but an enormous amount that was welcomed with open arms. This was a nice NY style type pie and deserves another go round next time I head back to Union Pier. read more

Patellie's - Box containing goodness inside - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Doug K.

1

8

4

5 years ago

My new favorite pizza spot in SW Mich. This place is for those that like thin crust and quality ingredients. Order and Pick-up windows on the outside of the building make for an easy transaction. I called and ordered on a Saturday in the summer at 5pm and the wait was 2.5 hours. Well worth the wait. read more

Patellie's - Sausage, Calabria Chili and onion - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

B D.

0

14

8

3 years ago

Hands down best pizza around! No joke. New York style, East Coast worthy pie right here in the Midwest. Never once been disappointed. There have been weeks where we have ordered three days in a row. I dare you to try this place there's no way you're not gonna like it. The staff is so friendly and the service is awesome. Enjoy your pie. We love Patellie's read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Gustavo L.

Elite 24

21

120

163

5 years ago

Tasty pizza. Great folks to do business with in TO. Their sandwiches are just as great. read more

Patellie's - Pizza and tequila. - Pizza Near Me - Three Oaks, Michigan

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daisy D.

0

20

0

4 years ago

The pizza here is not like others. Fresh ingredients + thin/delicious crust & kind staff = Our favorite takeout pizza!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rick R.

0

8

0

3 years ago

Last week, my wife and I and our two granddaughters had pizza at Patellie's. We each selected our own pizza and everyone agreed the pizza was exceptional. The service was also exceptional. A great little pizza joint. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Barbara H.

15

116

0

4 years ago

Never have had a bad meal here. And the service is always friendly, informative. Love this place! Just wish it was closer...

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily M.

1

20

2

6 years ago

Fantastic sausage pizza - everything you want in a thin crust pizza and nothing you don't. They only make one size pizza -16". We ordered a sausage, mushroom onion and a daily special salad - burrata and marinated tomatoes. The food was done a little earlier then they the time we were told it would be. We ordered at 6:25 on a Friday night and it was ready at 9:35 so ORDER EARLY! Delicious crust, homemade sausage and ice cold glass-bottle sodas to enjoy on their patio on a summer evening - perfect for a casual date after a day at the beach. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Marissa H.

0

13

0

3 years ago

This is by far the best pizza I have had in years. We got a margherita pizza to split, good portions for 2 people. The sauce was so fresh, it tasted like hand crushed fresh tomatoes. Food came out in 15 mins and we ate on the patio which was lovely! Overall 11/10 experience and would travel back here just for some more za. read more

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Emily K.

0

6

1

3 years ago

This place is honestly amazing! I've known about this place for a few years now and they've never failed to impress me each visit. Me and my boyfriend aren't big into pizza but there's is something I've always loved. Especially their margarita pizza. Ive wanted to show my boyfriend this place for awhile now, but it's a 30 minute drive so we never had the excuse to go till yesterday. Now I regret showing him because he wants to go again today! safe to say he LOVED it. Wouldn't stop talking about it on the way home! Pizza was delicious as always, we both got margarita slices and the amount you get is huge! It's practically 2 slices in one! Where I live you can't really find margarita pizza and if you do it isn't good. Their sauce is amazing, the crust is perfectly chewy but crunchy and thin, and the cheese has an amazing flavor as well. You can tell their ingredients are fresh. Customer service was amazing per usual, I loved the selection of drinks and the friendly atmosphere! You're immediately welcomed and greeted by every staff in that building. I loved it. Had a cute eating area outside and they were able to serve me my food through a window so I didn't have to walk back in! This place checks out in every area. They definitely deserve my 5 stars and a high rating in general. I appreciate this amazing business and their staffing. Definitely a customer for life! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Wallis Y.

4

27

2

6 years ago

Would be amazing in Chicago, even MORE amazing that it's here! When I saw one of the owners used to work at Blackbird (RIP) I knew it was going to be fire. Thank you Patellie's for existing and for bringing my favorite kinds of pizzas to the countryside. P.S. Try the meatballs read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Dave S.

1

28

0

3 years ago

Outstanding pizza. The crust is crispy and chewy, the toppings are delicious and the sauce is tangy and wonderful. I can't recommend their pizza enough. I can't wait to be in the area again to order from Patellie's. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Angela H.

0

3

0

2 years ago

the meatball sub was awful. what's up with using ricotta instead of mozzarella? when I asked for mozzarella they said it wouldn't melt properly. no onions or spices very bland. the worse part is that they didn't toast the bun and too much sauce so soggy n u could not possibly pick up and eat as a sandwich. the veggie pizza used to be good but somehow changed. again tasteless though I could taste the garlic from the jar. 42.00 seems high for these two items. save your money read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Bernard B.

0

3

0

5 years ago

Really good Neapolitan style pizza. Best pizza we've had in SW Michigan and we've had many.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aneta 7.

0

1

0

5 years ago

The best pizza ever!!!! Can't post any pictures because we ate it so fast Delicious, a must stop if you are in the area. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Jerry P.

14

16

0

4 years ago

This is some of the best pizza you'll find in Southwest Michigan. The sausage is phenomenal and the crust is amazing. Definitely the best anywhere south of Hagar Shore (pizza people know what's there). Good stuff!! Can't stop eating! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

S F.

1

100

1

8 years ago

The BEST pizza in the area! They do by the slice which was so filling and huge. You can also get a whole box. I was so happy since there aren't many restaurants in the area. It had a cozy atmosphere with minimal seating. I liked their drink selections as well. I will certainly be back. read more

Helpful 2

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 0

Traci S.

23

10

1

5 years ago

Patellie's - you rock! All the pizza in a 30mi square radius of Michiana area sucks... except Patellies. It's no Chicago pizza, but it's waayyyy better than anything else in the area. Yum yum yum read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Page 1 of 3

See more reviews

More info about Patellie's

28 N Elm St
Three Oaks, MI 49128
Directions
(269) 820-2066
Call Now
Visit Website
http://www.patellies.com

Full menu

Hours

What time does Patellie's open?

Patellie's opens at 3:00 PM on Monday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Patellie's opens at 12:00 PM on Sunday.

What time does Patellie's close?

Patellie's closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday.Patellie's is closed on Tuesday and Wednesday.Patellie's closes at 7:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon, Thu-Sat 3:00 PM - 9:00 PMTue-Wed ClosedSun 12:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Patellie's take credit cards?

Yes, Patellie's takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Patellie's have a happy hour?

No, Patellie's does not have a happy hour.

Does Patellie's serve alcohol?

No, Patellie's does not serve alcohol.

Indoor Amenities

Does Patellie's allow dogs?

Yes, Patellie's allows dogs.

Does Patellie's have TVs?

No, Patellie's does not have TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Patellie's have bike parking?

Yes, Patellie's has bike parking.

Does Patellie's have outdoor seating?

Yes, Patellie's has outdoor seating options.

Does Patellie's have parking?

Yes, Patellie's has parking options. Street Parking

Other Amenities

Is Patellie's wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Patellie's is wheelchair accessible.

Does Patellie's have free WiFi?

Yes, Patellie's has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

An honest approach to an old favorite responsibly sourced, high quality ingredients take out or dine in, there's a slice for everyone at Patellie's Pizza.

History

Established in 2017.

Patellie's is owned and operated by Pat & Ellie Mullins. After having LOCAL, a specialty grocery in New Buffalo for 6 1/2 years, P. & E. were ready for their next adventure. Pat and Ellie moved to Michigan via San Francisco in the Winter of 2010. While growing up between Belgium and Northern California, Ellie developed her love and respect for handcrafted artisanal meats and cheeses as well as straight from the farm produce. Pat, a native Chicagoan attended Chicago Cooking and Hospitality Institute and went on to work at Blackbird in Chicago, Hungry Cat in Santa Barbara and Pizzeria Delfina in San Francisco. Pat & Ellie met and fell in love while working together at the Hungry Cat in Santa Barbara.

Meet the Business Owner: Pat and Ellie M.

Patellie's is owned and operated by Pat & Ellie Mullins. After having LOCAL, a specialty grocery in New Buffalo for 6 1/2 years, P. & E. were ready for their next adventure. Pat and Ellie moved to Michigan via San Francisco in the Winter of 2010. While growing up between Belgium and Northern California, Ellie developed her love and respect for handcrafted artisanal meats and cheeses as well as straight from the farm produce. Pat, a native Chicagoan attended Chicago Cooking and Hospitality Institute and went on to work at Blackbird in Chicago, Hungry Cat in Santa Barbara and Pizzeria Delfina in San Francisco. Pat & Ellie met and fell in love while working together at the Hungry Cat in Santa Barbara.

You might also consider

Staymaker at Journeyman Distillery

3.9(262 reviews)

0.1 mi

My husband and I went for an early New Years dinner yesterday. Our server Gabe was outstanding !…read more He navigated us through the menu as we had not eaten there before. Gabe helped my husband with beer choices and had great suggestions for my cocktails. The food was delicious and the atmosphere very pleasant. We even had a visit to our table from the general manager. She was friendly and engaging. It was an enjoyable time all the way. We will definitely be going back My husband also found a whiskey he liked and purchased that too. It was a very positive way to end 2025. And no one paid me for this review . I'm writing this on behalf of my husband and me because having super food and super service needs to be recognized

Driving thru Michigan we kept seeing their billboards on the highway so we decided to stop for…read morelunch on a Monday. It was not very crowded and we're seating immediately. For some reason it was very cold inside so we asked to be moved onto their patio even tho is overlooks the back of their building and parking lot. My wife had their Southwest Salad which had a lot of BBQ Ranch dressing on it. Suggest it on the side! I had their Detroit Style pizza with sausage and pepperoni made with a Featherbone Bourbon crust. it was just ok as the sauce is basically on top and not evenly spread on the pizza. Their menu has some unique items but nothing really impressed us. The interior is very nice and if it wasn't so cold,it might have been a more enjoyable experience.

Peanut Butter Pie

See all

Mario's Pizza

4.2(104 reviews)

4.7 mi

•$

Great for takeout Or grab food at the table but I suggest…read moreyou call ahead and get the order started before you arrive

I like this little place. The bread they use for the sandwiches is really good. I got a special A…read more I do think it would be better to buy the bigger balls of mozzarella though and slice it. The flavor comes out better than in using the ciliegine mozz. Meatballs and marinara sauce were good. Mini cannoli was fine. Really nice owners. I thought about that bread all week and had to return. The chicken parm sandwich is really good. The tiramisu tastes like a nice cream cake but is light on the coffee flavor, fyi. I have also tried the #12 sub, the chicken alfredo, the brownie, the bread, and the salad. Salad is fresh and I love the homemade ranch and balsamic dressings. I came here once not too long ago and have not stopped thinking about it since, so I keep coming back.

See all

Villa Nova Pizzeria - New Buffalo

3.7(375 reviews)

6.8 mi

Michelle wasn't our server today but we were able to catch up. She's an awesome lady…read more Of course we had the baked goat cheese and cheese pizza. Both on point. The Sugar Cookie Martini was delicious. Solid tavern style pizza and always good service.

I stopped in recently for pizza, a Hawaiin and Margherita. It was good, thin crust. Not my favorite…read moretype of pizza, but it was different. The pasta was just ok. My friend did not like it at all. Meatballs were not good. Vodka sauce was ok but thin. The side of marinara was just ok for me. Ranch was good. Service is friendly. They carry Sprecher's root beer. I stopped in a while ago for dessert but did not care for it. Tiramisu was off tasting. Cannoli had cold shell and cream was not anything special. Would skip dessert next time.

Pizza line

Mozzarella sticks

See all

On the patio, it's cozy and warm in here with sausage pizza!

Stop 50 Wood Fired Pizzeria

4.3(258 reviews)

11.2 mi

Stop 50 is a cute little family-owned and operated pizza within the neighborhood. It's tucked away…read moreon a residential side street, and with that comes a much calmer and chill atmosphere than Michigan City or New Buffalo. There is patio seating outside on the deck, and plenty of seats inside that can accommodate small groups. Everything is hand made and cooked within a wood-fired oven, so have some patience if you place a large order (or one is ahead of yours). They also do carry out as seen from the bustling pick up counter. They also carry a limited selection of craft beers and wine. Food was delicious and our server was awesome and helpful with the menu as first timers. Will certainly be back to this hidden little gem!

Pizzas are great. Love the wood fire My wife had a salad…read moreand it was on point. Will be back

Sausage & pepperoni pizza with half green olives.

Firecracker - goat cheese, marinara, and bread sticks.

See all

Sausage pizza (minus a couple slices - oops)

Emma Hearth and Market

4.5(131 reviews)

10.0 mi

Wowww wow wow! I…read morewasnt sure what to expect when my friend suggested this place but I was thoroughly and pleasantly surprised. The "Detroit style" pizza really reminds me more of focaccia bread. It is SO fluffy and delightful. Unpopular opinion here but I typically don't consider pizza to be a "meal." It's something you eat when you don't have it in you to cook, and even if you get it in Chicago it's like...a last ditch effort at feeding yourself. BUT this feels like a meal. Like a treat. Like a schmancy lil indulgence you deserve. My friend is gluten free and I never in a million years would guess this is gluten free. I almost hope they didn't mistakenly put it on regular dough, for my friends sake. But if this is legitimately gluten free, I would gladly get it again even if I wasn't with a gluten intolerant friend. The artichoke pieces are massive, tender and tangy. The sausage is a bit strange, ground sausage instead of little lumps. And the mushrooms really top the "artesenal" feel. There's a cute little market with interesting delicacies and they have an incredibly diverse assortment of non-alcoholic beverages. The clerk did an amazing job of describing many of the options, took a lot of time making sure we knew what we were looking at. Definitely a connoisseur. Fabulous. A little pricey but, again, this is an indulgence. A meal. A quaint opportunity to relax and engulf yourself in fluffy, delectable fare that feels authentic and real. Not just ingredients tossed on a piece of dough for convenience sake. I look for to my next visit here!

This place is a real gem! I was shocked to find somewhere this good in small-town Michigan. I made…read moremy parents come here from Indiana and we're so glad we did. They've got a great selection of pizzas in several styles. We tried both the thin-crust Roman style and the thicker al taglio. Both were good but the al taglio was fantastic! The crust was the best part, for sure. We got vegan pizzas (with really good vegan cheese!), but they've got a ton of dairy/meat options as well. It's nice to go somewhere that can serve everyone! There's also a really good little market of Italian products and wines, so you can do a little shopping too while you're here. I didn't have a sandwich but they've looked really good too. There's a nice dog-friendly outdoor patio as well for warm days. Emma Hearth and Market is a must-visit if you're in the area and worth a drive too!

Market

Artichoke, Pesto, Broccoli, Marinated Tomatoes and Fresh Ovalini

See all

Capozio's

3.5(60 reviews)

4.8 mi

Food is OK, but service and attitude from staff and management are horrible. Seems to have a…read moreclientele that is part of some kind of a clique or cult.

We tried this for the first time last night. Exceptionally friendly staff makes you feel welcome…read more And the service was perfect. Being a vegetarian, I opted for Eggplant Parmesan and my husband had manicotti. All dishes appear to be homemade and the gravy (sauce) is very tasty. I also enjoyed a cannoli for dessert. My husband had the cheesecake but it was a small slice. The restaurant interior gives a homey feel and is able to accommodate large families. Great value for the price. We will be back.

Hand tossed pizza. Pepperoni with half spinach.

See all

Capozio's

Brewster's New Buffalo

4.0(526 reviews)

7.0 mi

Love their lavender lemonade. Burrata great. Lovely setting (nice outdoor patio), inside…read morecomfortable.

Love the updated reno at Brewsters! The ambiance is much brighter in the atrium and the new…read morefurniture is comfy. The food is always delicious and the homemade sauces, dressings and baked goods are greatly appreciated! Although we noticed the portion sizes are slightly smaller, our meals were outstanding and the service was great. Parking can be challenging; however, they do have a small parking lot and there is street parking in the neighborhood. A beautiful outdoor patio with vines and flowers is a perfect spot for lovely weather days and Brewster's is great for families, lunch/dinner with friends or date night!

So much natural light in their bar area.

Ricotta & Honeycomb

See all

Delicious Drinks

Roma Pizza Restaurant

3.0(66 reviews)

5.7 mi

Romas Pizza nailed it. Fresh ingredients, amazing homemade meatballs, and super friendly staff…read more Can't wait to come back!

Man its been a couple years since I've been there, but what happened???????? No servers, ordering…read moreat a counter, getting your own drinks...paper plates and silverware?? Now let's talk about the pizza....it used to have flavor...and you can definitely tell they have downgraded ingredients...no wonder why it wad completely empty and the phones werent ringing anymore. This place went from great to the ghetto.

The inside looks new.

See all

This is the place!

Miller Pizza By The Beach

4.0(106 reviews)

13.5 mi

Pizza was recommended by a patron at the Blue Chip Casino. They deliver right to your room. Arrived…read moreluke warm. We had gotten thin crust with sausage, pepperoni, bacon and mushrooms. The crust was not thin and crisp. Half of the pizza was overcooked. There was plenty of sauce. Plenty of pepperoni. Lots of mushroom. Very little sausage and bacon. Not a bad pizza, but not great either. Wouldn't bother ordering again. Maybe would try a pasta or something different.

I have been a long time resident in Michigan City but had never ordered from them before. I was…read morepleasantly surprised by an excellent, vegetarian pizza. Their phone service was good and delivery on time with an elderly, sweet man. The only complaint I have is their french fries. I got a decent amount, but it was tasteless. They need to put some kind of seasoning on it. I still think Rally's has the best, but have stopped eating theirs, because it has way too much salt and grease. I have to watch blood pressure.