Nice dinner spot off the highway. We were visiting…read moreGreenville and came here on a whim. We very happy with our selections. We started with some garlic breadsticks which were pretty good. I do not eat a lot of dairy, so I got a meat lovers pizza with no cheese. I loved the deep crust, very delicious. My partner got the chicken parm and said it was also very good. Service was great :) recommend this place if you are in the area for a sit-down dinner

This is delicious. It doesn't matter how many times I go. It's always so good. The service is great…read moreand always fast. I love the update and there's always plenty of seating. Expect it to be busy it's a great place and worth the 30 minute drive for me. I love the pear and Gorgonzola pasta. It's different but I can't say anything I have will ever compare. There's plenty to choose from on the menu so don't expect to go there and not love something you eat. I wish they were open on Saturday but this will always be a top spot to get a good salad, good past and yummy dessert. Do yourself a favor and try them

Be careful about placing your order online. Consider just paying at the store if you must do so…read more Today I placed an online order and realized 2 minutes after placing it that the pepperoni pizza would have Carolina reaper sauce. I suppose pizza isn't that fresh, because I called immediately and they claimed there could be no adjustment as it was already placed in the oven. How could a fresh large pizza be in the oven 120 seconds after an online order is placed? They would not adjust and the store worker did not budge to help us at all. Not sure I would return based on not just an inability to edit the order, but the way the concern was handled. It tasted pre-prepared.

Improve the food quality. Too many people working there, that just doesn't care. Needs better…read moremanagement.

Last week I placed a delivery order. it took over 45 minutes for the delivery after it made it to…read morethe point on the tracker saying it was out for delivery. I called after 30 minutes after the tracker said it was on it's way. (Note we only live approximately 15-20 minutes from the store) I have tried giving as exact directions to where we stay but they seem to be taking longer and longer to get to make the delivery. Today I ordered again, but, I ordered it 4 hours in advance. We are now looking at over an hour from when it was supposed to be delivered. It is currently still not here. What do we need to do to get the food delivered on time? I did call the store after it was 45 minutes late, "oh it it will be there in 15 minutes", I asked why it is being so late? "We're busy" is what I'm told. When it was delivered it was COLD!!! If I'd have answered the door I would have declined the order since it was so late.

Update. Call to order my pizza which I had credit for that wasn't cooked through (photos here)…read more Asked the lady on the phone multiple times "is it under my number????" And she said yes yes yes etc. This time I called them and a manager answered the phone of course, it wasn't under my phone number, so I asked if the manager if she could just be called really quick to verify they avoided my question and said that she was off work, etc. etc. and I asked again I said OK you don't have her phone number like you can't just call her real quick to verify? The guy hung up on me. So I placed another order through the app and I pay for it. They were rude to me so I was rude to them when I went to the window and refused to move up so that people could be served out of line which I always find crazy anyway. I get home and it's cold and there is HOT SAUCE on the lid. This was it. Never again! Highly recommend Pepperoni Express, the best pizza place in Lyman!!!

Great little hole in a wall. Next to the gas station. The…read moreteam here was sweet and got us taken care of. They should put napkins on all the tables, just a thought. Thank you tho for lunch!

UPDATED REVIEW!!…read more Never again. I gave them enough time to fix things snd establish themselves. This visit was just awful. It was so bad. All of the soda was completely flat. They brought out more, disgusting tasting, still flat from their machine that still doesn't work. My guest ordered chicken Parmesan. Here is what was wrong with hers: 1.) Chicken parm is not supposed to be served chopped up as it loses all the heat, you're supposed to cut and eat like a steak. It's part of the experience. 2.) Sauce - bland. 3.) Pasta was overcooked. 4.) Cheese just rips apart, clear they don't shred their own and there's anti clumping ingredients in it. 5.) The spaghetti was cut up like a child's meal. The cardinal rule. DO NOT break the pasta!! 6.) Never - EVER cut up chicken parmesan!! The are you doing!?!? It gets cold so quick after you let all that heat out and ruins the experience of the diner!! Would you like me to cut up a steak before serving it to you? NO!!! I had the pizza. I didn't feel any flour or semolina under it but okay let's pretend they still rolled it by hand... I ate one bite and my mouth is on fire - maybe I put too much red pepper flakes on. I try the second piece with just parm I believe but no flakes, a little cheese taste but extremely bland. I definitely had the third piece as is. All three pieces toppings literally falling off, just sliding, not from being hot but so many dry areas where there is no cheese holding anything together at all. All toppings and the pizza seemed....watery is the only word to describe it. It was even visual. I'll include picture for reference. Bland, bland, bland! How in the world is it so bland??? I'm sorry but this is in no way 15" pizza that is worth a whopping $18.99!!! Okay the food sucks but what about service and atmosphere? Service: Never told us their name. Was the most awkward experience because they were within' earshot from us the entire time but was attentive. At the end I asked for a box and was given a tiny thing not even one slice of pizza would fit into, I had several slides left too - this was obviously a give away that they had some form of ownership or stake in the restaurant because it was the cheapest option. I had to request a more suitable container then they finally give me an actual pizza box but like a kids one of something so I overlapped my pieces in it and left. The awkward part came due to the atmosphere which was: Atmosphere: NO MUSIC!! We had to sit there in DEAD silence. Are you kidding me? I started a show on my phone just to have something going. We felt like we couldn't talk about how bad things were till we left and it all came out after we came out. The menus are all altered in white out followed by price hikes on EVERYTHING. Are they smoking crack? Don't they have the original word documents that they made the menus on to begin with the furniture... Was absolutely falling apart I mean, literally my guest went to move one of the tables and the seats and the seat just came up looking around the entire restaurant you could just see cracked and chipped paint everywhere. They took zero pride on how everything looked. Also the bathrooms...I didn't use the bathrooms, but they even had a sign on them that said for guest use only. Completely rude!!! By posting signs like that you are saying to everyone that you think you are in business in a sleazy area and refuse to maintain cleanliness in the bathrooms. That's how it comes across. The entrance in, there are tacky hand drawn special taped ALL over the the door where you couldn't even see to the inside. I have to end it here, because I could keep going. Bottom line - I gave them one chance after opening - then another months later - never again. I would be 0/5 stars if I could. What keeps them in business and with decent ratings currently? To go orders, most don't go inside, and people have lower expectations when they get their food 20 minutes later already - a lot of senior folk in area and locals make it their go to because no other competition exists. That does not mean that it is good, that means they are too used to it in my opinion, which are all factual statements in my reviews. I hate leaving bad reviews but that's how restaurants learn and improve!

Drive through only after 5:30 and the service is awful. Drive through is just a standstill when I'm…read moreonly here to pick up

So to anyone that knows my reviews, you'll know I am very blunt and honest. It's a chain pizza…read morerestaurant. That being said, they withhold the average rating for most. Half the time you'll likely have your food messed up cause it's a race to get orders out. The papa sizes from what I've seen always get skimped on the toppings and cheese just right before the crust. Sometimes they're cut properly, sometimes not. The wings are too small and mediocre. But let's be honest people - it's Papa John's. No one really "loves" their pizza. They love eating it so that they can get straight down to eating that bowl of garlic butter with the crust. I do not have a picture of their newer "Papadias". HOWEVER - those are baller status. $6 is just right for the price, they are decently sized and come with dipping sauce. Those are awesome. Their breadsticks are just cook bread, don't recommend. Ever so often, you WILL get someone that cares when making pizza and end up with an above average pizza. I would have to say their best pizzas are their Tuscan six cheese and their Hawaiian BBQ. I'd rate them four stars each. Everything else is average. This particular location gets one less star due to all the orders that have been messed up or missing items, the company itself gets the average chain pizza place rating of three stars. The rundown- Jalapeño Poppers - 0/5 stars Non existent "cream cheese" filling. Not a fluke, ordered them twice and was told that is how they are "portioned". Garlic Parmesan Wings - 2/5 stars Too small, need more flavor. Tuscan Six Cheese & Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza- 4/5 stars Update: The Works 3/5 Stars The last few visits have been accurate orders, pizza made well and extremely friendly staff. Raising this particular location a star to three stars.

First time ordering from here since I was in the area and I'm always looking for authentic &…read moreItalian pizza! It was easy to call, order ahead, and pickup. The restaurant is small and with a standard theme, but it was neat and clean. The food was hot and fresh too. Right off the bat, I was excited to try the pizza. I'm tired of all the chain pizza places in the area, and Anthony's did not disappoint. The flavor was interesting, maybe an acquired taste with whatever ingredients they use, but I still enjoyed it! Especially the thin & crunchy crust, not doughy! The mozzarella sticks were also as expected. I have no complaints and would like to try an entree sometime.

Anthony's is a small pizza restaurant on Hwy 14. The service here was great. We did not have any…read moreproblems. The pepperoni pizza was delicious. We loved the cheese and the sauce. I did not have time to take any pictures because we were so hungry. We really enjoyed our meal! I will be going back soon to try other varieties of pizza.

Friday night here isn't optional, it's on the Reminders app right next to Henry's football practice…read moreschedule, and we check it off with the same relief every week. Henry gets the mini corn dogs, has for years, though we've now heard whispers that once they're out, they're gone for the rest of time, no substitutions, which has turned his order into something closer to a small bet. I get the same thing every time: the 10 inch personal pizza, pepperoni and onions, and two PBR liters. I've never once considered another combination. This is not indecision. This is a system that works, refined over years of Fridays, and I see no reason to disturb something that's already won.

Update 5/24/2026 - I'm not sure what's going on with the pizza appearance, taste, preparedness. The…read moreprices have gone up yet the quality isn't what we were used to getting when already spending a ridiculous amount for a pizza. Last night we had ordered a margarita pizza. It initially came with no basil, all the tomatoes were all in the center not scattered around, and the crust was burnt and hard. When I bit into the pizza, it crunched. Flatbreads aren't even cooked that much. We had to call in and get a new pizza. It had more tomatoes and this time it had basil, but the crust was still thin, overcooked and crunchy. Very disappointing. Refer to my video and of past photos. Whatever has changed, should be fixed sooner than later.