The pizza is not for me. The crust, sauce, and somehow the cheese, are all bland. However, the toppings are good quality, and as others have mentioned, the place is clean. I haven't tried menu items other than their pizza, so those could be good. read more

Great hometown Pizza joint! This is the kind of place where the owner knows you knows what you like and is always happy to help you pull off a birthday party, a pizza for a friend, or just a great pie to take with you. The owner does a lot for her community...donating to the schools, hiring kids for their first job, hosting pizza parties etc. And I have seen her deal with out of control customers with real professionalism. Why do people have to be jerks? read more

Great location with lots of parking. Nice building with lots of room and tables for big groups. Food....we've had numerous pizzas, wings, milkshakes ( so many flavors! ) pretty basic stuff. The pizza crust is not to our liking. Too thick,dense and tasteless. Maybe change it up abit and delivery would be a huge bonus !! read more

My 6 year old grandson loves his Hawaiian pizza from Pizza Girl. It his go to restaurant for lunch and dinner with grandpa. I like them too and everything else is great, especially burgers and shakes. read more

Still not the preferred pizza in our household. Great milkshakes and burgers. Lots of parking available and plenty of seating inside for a larger crowd. read more

Have been hearing about Pizza Girl from a friend for over a year. Finally broke down and ordered a combination with pineapple, 10 hot wings, a huckleberry shake and a chocolate mint shake. The pizza was great - crust was not soggy or greasy, toppings had the right amount of crunch (veggies) and the meat was tasty! Wings came with a side of ranch dressing and were just the right amount of spicy. Huckleberry shake was really good and the chocolate mint shake was a bit light on the mint, but also really good. Next time we go we are trying the burgers!! read more

Sandwiches and shakes are great. The service is good. The kids like the games they have. There always nice

The food was truly delicious. We had the cheese bread and it was hot and bubbly with just the right amount of cheese. We had several varieties of pizza. We all ordered the "personal" size and it was just right after the cheese bread. We had a Logger Bob which was beef, onion, green pepper and mushrooms. We also tried a Reuben which was just like the sandwich. We were mainly curious and it turned out to be a great decision! All of the pizzas were served hot and were the perfect size. There was enough for leftovers the next day and it was just as good warmed up.?Orders are placed at the counter and then delivered to your table. The young lady that brought our food was very pleasant. It is clearly a big supporter of all Onalaska athletics. It's a casual restaurant, well suited to families. Highly recommend! read more

Bought a pizza July 6, 2021. I'm not too sure what they put the toppings on. Calling it a pizza crust would be sacrilegious. The sauce was adequate at best. There's not much they could do to ruin the other toppings, but I think they're trying to figure a way. Bottom line...it was horrible. Revolting is another good description. If anyone reading this wants pizza, you're much better off going somewhere else, including a grocery store. read more

I have been going to Pizza Girl since the beginning. Very consistent, never disappointed. My family from out of town thinks she needs to expand to King County. I love the hot sandwiches, and my favorite pizza is the loggers supreme. I also like supporting a local business. read more

From out of town. Great pizza. Had a large chicken garlic and it was very large and very, very good. Best we've had in years.

Driving thru and decided to try it. Ordered a large pepperoni with a little extra sauce. Played some pinball while we waited. Pizza was great! Place was clean. Service was nice and speedy . Great small town feel. I will stop next time I'm in town. read more

Pizza Girl - a pepperoni pizza on a pan - Pizza Near Me - Onalaska, Washington

This place deserves a good, solid 4 out 5 stars. The bathroom was very clean and so was the entire restaurant. The employee that took my order and served me was friendly. I thought my Hawaiian pizza was very good. Yes, I was slightly bland, but I don't mind bland. I prefer it over an overly spiced pizza. The crust was crispy and not overdone. The toppings were generous. Give Pizza Girl a try. :) Prices were also not expensive. It's a nice little, local place to get some grub and play some arcade games. read more

See all

Visited Pizza Girl for the first time last night for a birthday party. The restaurant looked to be very clean, the pizza on the other hand was tasteless, crust was like cardboard, very bland sauce toppings were good. The owner was the rudest person I've ever dealt with. Will not be going back. read more

Great pizza! We ordered a large 'chew it' pizza. Flavorful meats and real cheese that stretched! The crust was just right, a little chewy and crisp on the bottom read more

Absolutely LOVE this gem we found, up in Onalaska! Went in to pick up our to-go order and, was greeted by the kindest couple of gals and the cleanest pizza place I've EVER seen!! The food was equally amazing and we decided that this is DEFINITELY our new "spot!" read more

I love this place. I come here about once a week. There are hardly any restaurants in the area, and of the few most are dirty and horrifying. Pizza Girl is clean and has solid offerings. The prices are also insanely cheap. Seriously, how is she making a living on these prices??? I like the burgers and fries. There are a million milkshake offerings (okay, more like thirty). For pizza the 'Hawaiian' is a good stand by and 'Keepin It Hot' is yummy too. No complaints from me. read more

Service with an attitude and terrible pizza We have tried this restaurant several times, hoping that perhaps it was just a "bad" day. However, every time we have been there the person/owner who takes your order is just shy of outright rude. Service is slow and the meal delivered with the same sour attitude. The pizza is terrible, very bland, really no flavor and toppings mediocre. You would do better to buy a frozen pizza from the grocery store. However, the hamburgers are decent as are the frys. read more

I used to like this place a lot, but it seems to always be going downhill with service and pizza quality. My mom and I ordered a pizza with just mushrooms and olives. We always make sure they specifically don't put green peppers on it because they make me and my father really sick. We ended up with the most bland pizza COVERED in green peppers and onions on top of the olives and mushrooms for some reason. I mean, it was just over an hour before closing, which I felt bad about, but it seems like pretty simple directions to follow. read more

They have several specials each month which is nice. And there seem to be team activities there too. I cannot eat quite a bit of what they servebecause of the high fat and white flour. Would love a better salad selection. :) read more

First of all, this is no longer called Gentiley's PIZZA, As you can see from the picture here, it is PIZZA GIRL. I don't know when they changed the name, but PIZZA GIRL is the pizza place located at 1772 State Rte 508, Onalaska, WA. Here is my review of PIZZA GIRL: This is the worst pizza restaurant I have ever gone to!!!!! I was so excited to try this pizza place as it is the only one in Onalaska. I like to patron local business' to give them a chance. THIS IS THE GROSSEST, DISGUSTING PIZZA I HAVE EVER ATE IN ALL MY YEARS. I honestly do not know how the woman who made the pizza can sell this with a straight face. It taste like year old frozen cardboard pizza. And it didn't even taste like real cheese. I bought it to go and when I served it to my family. They all (and I am not exagerrating) spit it out. It tasted like freezer burn. We had to throw the entire pizza away. It should have been a clue that when I went at 6:00 p.m. on a Saturday (which should be when a pizza joint is full) that there was not one other person in the entire establishment. Live and learn! I will NEVER go back to this place. The place has other food items on the menu, but if a pizza can be that bad, then why would anything else be good? When I read the reviews of anyone more than one star, I agree with another opinion below on these reviews, they must be friends, family or were paid because the pizza I purchased is literally in all my years the WORST PIZZA EVER! read more

I've gone here many times and the pizza is okay..., but the sauce is too sweet for pizza. I've tried many other items on the menu I still haven't found something great that I would go back for. The staff is always friendly and the place is clean but it's not my first choice for a local place. read more

Pizza gal is over-priced &usually burnt. If that's not enuff,... rude service. Not served w/ a smile, that's for sure.