Amazing food! I'm really picky about my pizza places and this one never fails to disappoint. Ive had the chicken marsala slice and hero, both amazing. Their calzones are great, and I can't wait to try other things. Really friendly staff and very homey / cozy to dine in. read more

Pizza Amore - Chicken Marsala Slice - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

Decent pies. They kind of jipped us on toppings and after we walked in and said 'hello' friendly- like; the 2 people working there were content to gab, turn up the music and ignore us totally. We made an effort to simply say the pie wasn't to be black.. nobody listened. The ingredients here are middle of the road. Sauce is tasty paste. Sausage and pepperoni not the best and the dough is okay. The employees here were happy to just laugh and animatedly talk to local drifters who came in and talked but never ordered. All in all it was worth a try if you are in Nanuet and coming back from an event on weekends. Or you could try them for catering.. they have the bright lights but don't listen at all to customers! Review: 4 read more

See all

Pizza amore hasn't disappointed yet!!! Went for a specialty pie at my sisters request. She's visiting from NC. The regular slice is delicious here too! read more

Pizza Amore - Half veggie/half penne vodka - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

Very good local pizza here, I always buy BBQ Chicken and White pizza pies are my favorites. Always fresh !!! Keeps me coming back. Tony..... read more

Quite pricey. Overly loud with a soccer games blaring. And they don't have a public restroom for "paying" customers.

Super thrilled that Pizza Amore had a Valentine's day special! We asked for a heart shaped pizza and were so happy to open the box to find this. Pizza is always a topic of conversation in our house - the right crust, enough sauce, the perfect amount of cheese. Somehow we found Pizza Amore and are so glad we now agree on a pizza place! read more

Pizza Amore - a heart shaped cheese pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Nanuet, New York

Everything is delicious the calzones, sandwiches you will not be disappointed. Good quality food at reasonable prices

Excellent margarita pizza. Most people would probably think it's a bad location but I think it's a great location because it has good food and it services two or 3000 condos in the area. read more

Great food doesn't have that commercial taste always never disappoints. From pizza to pasta to lunch everything taste good

Love Pizza Amoria their pasta dishes are fabulous. I eat there at least once a week I normally get the same thing sausage with Alfredo sauce over linguine if you haven't tried it give it a try you can't Go wrong for a $14 dinner read more

Charged an additional service fee to use my credit card. No signs anywhere about this except a small barely readable sign in the back of the register screen. Really ticked. Had I known I would have either paid cash or not ordered at all. Not cool. Also no gloves or mask in food prep guy. read more

Pizza was ok. Had a Stromboli or something like it. Tasted a little old. Price was the main factor for the reason I'll never go back or recommend it to anyone. 10.00$ for a small Stromboli and a slice of plain pizza. Then I notice a sign that says" 10.00$ minimum charge for credit card " I paid cash. But I see how the menu is geared to almost force you into spending 10.00$ if you want to or not. Not worth 10.00$ Go somewhere else. This place is a ripoff read more

During the height of the pandemic in NY, we had delivery from Pizza Amore. Tonight, we ordered a small pizza and 2 large salads for pick up. When we arrived, I was told the order was not ready yet so we waited in the car, parked right in front of the door. We could see clearly and directly inside. Imagine my shock when I realized the man handling and making the pizza was NOT wearing a mask. Needless to say, we told them to keep their food and left. read more

I stopped here to get two slices of pizza and some soup. I ordered two slices of veggie pizza and the Italian wedding soup. I have to say was truly disappointed in both. The pizza had no taste whatsoever and half of the vegetables on there I could not identify. Too many flavours too many vegetables. The Italian wedding soup, looks like something that came out of a can and tasted like it. I got two tiny meatballs if you can count them as meatballs. Definitely will not be back to order here again. read more

I live down the block and I rarely ever get a good slice of pizza from here. 4 times I've asked for delivery of a large plain extra cheese pizza pie. Every time, they charge more and the pie looks like a regular pie. The last time I ordered, I asked them to make sure there is extra cheese because every time I ordered, there isn't. He said, "what? Are you sizing the cheese?" I replied, "every time I ask for extra cheese there is no extra cheese" he said he will make sure it's on it. When I get it at my door, there was NO extra cheese. Needless to say, I would rather travel further to get better quality service and food. Even Costco has better pizza for half the price! read more

Bad attitude with $10 minimum credit card order, Was trying to push on me to get stuff that I don't need

Just called here and have ordered from here dozens of times and gave them very good service over the last couple of years and they do not except Credit Card payments over the phone! Who doesn't except that form of payment in 2018! So I find some cash and call back and their phone etiquette was awful! You would think you would try to retain the business even after I was inconvenienced but no, they had an attitude and could have cared less! Not how you run a successful business and thats why you have 2 stars! I will be going elsewhere from now on! read more

Nothing really special here- Sometimes you feel as if they are not that interested and seem to run through many different girls at the register. They pretty much live on convenience to the heavily populated area around them. Nobody wants to go anywhere near Spring Valley and they are on the safer tip of it. The best bet is to venture a bit farther to get your fix. read more

HORRIBLE place with incredibly slow service. Don't waste your time here when there are plenty of other places in the area that make better food and you don't have to wait 35 minutes for your food. This has happened to me many times there and I'd rather drive an extra five minutes to another place than give them my business. read more

blonde girl working the counter had an attitude. so did the man who rudely rushed me to pick a flavor ice. she got upset because i asked her to repeat flavors because i couldn't hear. read more

Pizza was decent. I just wish they would have a wider variety.

Marco and his staff are the best! They always accommodate our orders whether big or small. They are so friendly and are competitive. I look forward to continuing to order in the future. read more

Traveling through the area. It was one of the worst slices of pizza I've had. The crust was both greasy and dry. No place so close to the city and jersey should have such bad pizza. read more

I am always treated like family here. I love the friendly staff and the alternatives in cuisine. I am on a diet so I prefer the grilled chicken salads of all kinds. read more

Great pizza, pasta and service. All the things I expect to see in a local pizza place. I've been going here since I was younger and they never failed me or disappointed me in any way. Except for one time which is why I give them four stars. read more

Its just not the same anymore... previous owners sold it off, The new owners changed everything around. Used to be amazing, now its just meh... read more

Consistently a good pizza pie. Classic Wings, tried some meals a while ago, wasn't too impressed. But if you are looking for a good pie, and some wings it is a good find, at a reasonable price. It seems that anywhere you go for pizza these days that prices have gotten out of hand, they still are an affordable pie to fit a family budget. read more

We had the pizza, wings, garlic knots and salad tonight and thought it to be a marvelous priced and tasty treat! The delivery was fast and the food still hot. We have been customers for many years and will continue to patronize this fine restaurant. read more

Havent ate all day so i was like let me order some wings 6 hours later throwing up something isnt right

the pizza is good when you order a whole pie. i don't like the delivery kids -they are little snot nose cocky pricks that don't say thank you when you tip them..the old man who owns the place..is not very personable..and the $1 delivery charge to drive literally a half a mile to my house is ridiculous. read more