I was working in Churchville/Chili and at lunch we ran to the gas station for cold drinks. We saw Pizza 151 and thought we'd try it. I'm glad we did. Upon entering we noticed how unbelievably hot it was. Not only was it hot outside that day but the place was cooking. That being said the young men, and woman were upbeat, friendly and moving!!! The young men g man at the counter gave us the run down on the slices that were ready and we made our choices. Not only were they hot, and huge slices but an excellent proportion of cheese to sauce. Flavor was good and the sauce wasn't acidy ... which I have had on many a slice! It was good enough for a return trip today and I got the "sweet" slice. I would recommend that to anyone!! I can't explain why it works just that it does! If you're nearby stop in and try it , you will be pleased! Also they let us take a table and chair outside to eat read more

Ordered an XL with pepperoni, mushrooms and onions last night. Many pieces has no cheese, the remainder was barely covered, there was no layer of sauce, only a smear at best. The crust was incredibly thick and chewy. This was a horrible pizza. Will NEVER order there again. AVOID! read more

Got takeout and really like the full flavor of this pizza and sauce. The wings were a bit undercooked, but that is a personal preference. My mom really enjoys that they have a sweet sauce option. It is rare to find in this part of NY. read more

See all

The pizza I was served this evening was DISTGUSTING. The dough was literally raw (as in I could stretch it), even though I ordered the pizza well done. There was 3-4 times as much red sauce as there should ever be on a pizza, to the extent that my wife was scooping it off the top with a spoon because it was literally bursting up through the cheese. The best part? There was so much white sauce on the pizza that the entire box was saturated in it, and it leaked through the box and all over the rear seat of my wife's car. A fucking mess and food that wasn't edible is what we got for $60+. Obviously the recession hasn't hit your business yet because you can clearly afford to lose customers while letting these clearly incompetent, mush-brained teenagers run your business for you. Good for you on that. We will never order from you again, and I'll do nothing but talk Pizza 151 down as much as humanly possible from here on out. ,,I,, read more

Ordered chicken fingers dinner a couple weeks ago. They didn't start cooking it until I arrived. This happened to me before so they told me I'd get a free one next time. Tried to order a medium pizza today instead of the dinner ( both items cost the same- $15.99). They would not substitute. Seems to me if they wanted my business they'd make an adjustment. Won't be going back there anytime soon. Pizza 151 from now on. read more

The crust and sauce is now garbage. We don't need to ever spend $ there. Ever. We used to order the same thing every time because that's what we liked from them. Medium 'zza x tra cheese and 10 bone in wings. The pizza crust is like crackers. No raise and no fluff. Sauce is more like chunks of sour tomatoes. Never. No for $34 now for $5. read more

I ordered a large pizza with pepperoni banana peppers and black olives. There was hardly any cheese or pepperoni on it. Also an order of wings. There were supposed to be 10 wings but there were only 9. My bill was 45 bucks. Way too expensive and the quality wasn't there. Never again. read more

Ordered a baked sausage sub supposed to have sautéed peppers and onions. They were and horrible sausage was dry. I would not recommend at all. read more

Terrible experience...pizza was overbaked using old dough...salad was a joke....Never again....

Great pizza, thick crust or thin, cooked to your preference of regular or well done and solid customer service.

Spent $51.00 for medium pizza and 10 wings on Halloween night 2025 at about 8:15pm. We live in Spencerport delivery came about 9or 9:10 pm, we order almost every Friday night . Pizza and wings arrived below room temp , pepperoni was dry as hell , I think it was cooked separately and then thrown on top of the pizza because not one piece was stuck to pizza and it crumbled apart when you touched it. Ordered thin crust but got regular to thick crust, bottom was wet with heavy moisture. Now the chicken wings I ordered very well extra sauce. They were cold also and dry as hell !! No sauce on them when I asked for extra wing sauce. I have placed this similar order many times and we have liked it very much but the last two times no good !! I can understand this happening once but the last two orders totally says no one cares anymore!!! I am done buying this crap , they don't care about me I will bad mouth them as bad as I can from here on in !! Many many other pizza places around that will take my business !! read more

They do not deliver. Sent out flyers advertising they do with coupons. Food may or may not be good. Cant say as they wont deliver one town over. read more

They were extremely busy with probably 10 people working the counter and kitchen but I was waited on promptly and my order was ready on time. It looked great and was good but not as tasty as I had hoped. Crust was rather plain but toasted nicely, but I think the topping were a bit skimpy especially the onions. Highlight was definitely the garlic breadsticks. I enjoyed what I had but wouldn't go out of my way to visit again. read more

Pizza 151 - Garlic Breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

See all

2nd time getting pizza from here. The 1st was another person's order. This time, the driver left the pizza on my neighbor's porch after waiting over 3 hours. Horrible service for average pizza. read more

Always notice that no one has hats, or hair nets or even their hair pulled back. Food is good but the hair not being covered is making me think twice about this place. read more

First five orders of Sheet Pizza and 50 wings for $95 were very good and above average. Most recent order had wings that were a lot smaller and therefore severely over-cooked. The guys usually eat the entire order, but this time I had more than 30 wings left when everyone left. Pizza was average. I would comment on the Two Mountain Dew 2 liters included with the deal, but they didn't show up. read more

I have ordered from Pizza 151 once here in Chili, and another time previously in Batavia. The Batavia location really "delivered" on their Hawaiian pizza and pickle pizza; enough for me to make the trip to the Chili location with the hope for a repeat experience. I ordered on a Saturday at 11 am, because my spouse had to go into a B shift at work. I figured since it was during peak hours (no football games, etc.) the pies should be excellent. Upon pick up the counter staff was attentive and located my order quickly. I tipped and was on my way. The pizza was hot and fresh, but I didn't feel like the product was worth the price, and the toppings were skimpy on one of the pies. I would try it again but will stick to ordering from them if I am visiting my family in Batavia for now. read more

Pizza 151 - Meatlovers - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

See all

food took forever to be ready. got there and they were behind like almost 45 minutes. place is so small and nowhere to sit and so crowed all the time. So many orders back up. read more

I received a free large pizza coupon from a fundraising event at the Churchville-Chili high school, so I had to give this place a try. The pizza was overall pretty good and I personally enjoyed the flavor of the sauce more than anything. My only complaint was that the crust was a little chewy. Had it not of been, the pizza would have been perfect. Either way I'd come back here again. read more

Pizza 151 - Loved the flavor of the sauce but crust was a little chewy - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

I called and placed an order to be delivered in 1 1/2 hour. Food arrived pizza was ok. Crust a bit thick for my liking my 2 supersides mozzarella sticks of but the chicken fingers were dried out. The 12.09 special garlic and parm fries were cold. Very disappointing. Not only did I prepay for my oder I gave the driver more than 20% cash tip. I usually order from Marks but thought I would try out 151. I will not order again. read more

Hair in pizza absolutely disgusting If it could go wrong it did Girl put a star on box at pick up, then let them put the pizzas on top of the oven for 10 minutes During that time she checked her text messages Talk about terrible service - then to top off the night my wife spit out a bit of pizza - why - it had a hair in it. read more

Pizza 151 - Veggie Pizza with black hair - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

Saturday we decided to have pizza Si we placed an order for xlarge pizza and it came with two sides 1 2 liter bottle of soda As sides we got 1 cheese fries 1 boneless chicken wings The cheese fries were to die for I eat them in min I couldn't stop eating them My roommate had the chicken wings said they were great The xlarge pizza was OK lacked flavor but still good enough to eat The services was fantasic no complaints on that either . The only reason I gave them 4 stars was they didn't deliver to gates (the section of gates I live in) Would I eat their again yes read more

See all

Pretty decent pizza. I got a regular sauce pepperoni and a sweet sauce pepperoni slice. I really enjoyed the contrast between the two. If I only had sweet sauce, the sweetness would get a little overwhelming for me but I'm not a huge sweet food fan. The regular sauce has a really nice Italian seasoning flavor. Definitely worth trying, overall glad I tried this pizza but prob wouldn't be my go to weekly. The dough is pretty thick but has a nice flavor. One pepperoni slice is $3.50 but is pretty filling due to size and breadyness. read more

Pizza 151 - Pepperoni slice top with sweet sauce bottom with regular sauce - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

See all

Pizza 151 opened up in the old Mark's spot in North Chili. We really enjoy the pizza and wings we order from here! Have never had a problem with any of our food. Pizza is always crisp and has plenty of toppings. Boneless wings are great. Tried the hot wings this week... I'll go back to mild lol! Just personal preference. The staff is friendly and outgoing. If you order online they always have coupons available. I say give them a try! read more

The service is always friendly and the signature pizza 151 is great... do yourself a favor and ask them to add ricotta... so good!

If I could leave zero stars I would. Barely any toppings on the pizza, chicken fingers were the smallest I have ever seen, no celery with the dinner and way over-priced. The owner needs to take a trip to the Buffalo area and surrounding areas and learn how it's done right. I can go anywhere from Buffalo to the town of Evans and get great food for a great price. read more

Decent pizza not the best not the worst. The service depends on the time of day but 70% of the time they are adequate. Wait times seem to also vary on time of day of course, busier times around lunch and dinner other than that steady flow. read more

I'm updating this review because the consistency is spotty at best. We ordered the same thing (because it was so good the first time) tonight. Our pizza was extremely greasy (literally soggy) and the "cheesy bread" was a pizza folded up on itself with a sprinkle of cheese on it. Wtf. You can literally see it folded up in itself. Really. What happened? read more

Pizza 151 - New York Style Pizza Cheese Bread - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

See all

The first few times we had Pizza 151 it was great, but it consistently has not been great since. Today we ordered sweet sauce and it was definitely not sweet sauce (and hardly any sauce anyways - see picture). The time before today's, we ordered cheese on only half (we have lactose intolerance in our house), and it came with all cheese. We drive a far distance to come here and don't think we will much anymore. They've been responsive to refund, but helps to just get orders correct. read more

Pizza 151 - Supposed be crust lovers, but flat. Purposefully ordered w/o cheese (allergy), hardly any sauce - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

Your website and on-line ordering capabilities suck! Been trying for 10 minutes. No thanks!

Grabbed a quick slice while out Thrifting, I got the classic pepperoni and friend the Buffalo chicken. While we both prefer thin crust to thick, this crust and toppings were good. A little skimpy on the Buffalo sauce per my friend and I would have liked more cheese but for the price and the quickness of the pizza it was okay. Would go back if ever in the area read more

Pizza 151 - Buffalo Blue Cheese Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

See all

My family has been living in the Chili area for around 3 years now, and we have bounced around between 5-6 pizza places in the area (even going as far as Henrietta) trying to find the best. About a year ago we found 151 and our search is over! I've experienced consistent quality with the food, the service has always been great and reasonably quick, not to mention their recipes are really good. At this point we've ordered at least a dozen times and I feel that is a good indication for consistency. Not to mention they have great prices and run some really good deals. The pan pizza is my favorite but we also like their regular crust. You can tell that the dough is fresh made, and they have a good selection of topping options. I also appreciate that they have a few other options on the menu; for example when my picky step daughter decides she doesn't want pizza she can get pasta, which she almost always finishes, to my complete surprise! Especially for how much you get with the 1/2 pound portion of spaghetti and meatballs. read more

$25.00 for a one topping medium pizza (always overcooked) and a two liter bottle of pop? Really!

First two times the quality and prices were different. Third time the prices were back to a "higher" standpoint per slice, but the quality was spot on. I overheard them saying they were making adjustments to prices and doubling down on quality being top notch every time. Excellent pizza, a must try. read more

Pizza 151 - Buffalo Chicken - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

See all

Love their pizza, service, and prices! They always take great care of us. Try their wings, too!

It's just Marks 2.0. We ordered last night and had a delivery. I realized Pizza 151 was in the old Mark's location when I manually entered the 151 phone# into my cell and. "Mark's Pizza" came up as a labeled contact. The food arrived and this is just Marks Pizza made by someone else. The sauce is nearly identical. The crust appears to be the same. Even cooked on a Mark' pan as the crust has the 'speed bumps' on the bottom like Mark's did. Sauce, cheese and toppings are skimpy as Mark's used to do. Which is why we stopped ordering from them in the first place. We did have a few small issues with our order and was delivered 30min later than promised. That said, everyone was very helpful, very friendly. I would come back for the service. It's the Mark's pizza that would be a reason not to. It's lacking in flavor and too hum drum in my opinion. read more

Wings were over cooked with sub par blue cheese idk why there were rotted carrots but I wanted celery felt like I got ripped off.. read more

Pizza 151 - Pizza Near Me - North Chili, New York

Another Bad Pizzia place in the the Norrh Chili Area. Ordered a mushroom pepperoni 8 pcs of pep and 2 mushrooms on the pie., under done and doughy. Expect them to be OoB in 2 months. read more

2nd time ordering. 1st time was pretty mediocre, but a friend recommended it to us so we gave it another try. Most recently it was just a huge disappointment. The entire pizza was basically rubber. Almost had to cut with a knife to eat. It's getting pretty upsetting. Can't seem to find a good pizza in the area. read more

We have ordered several times past from this place. And seems that every time we order the worse it gets. (Worse, meaning flavor,size, quality) Ordered 2 mediums pizzas and 10 wings. Figuring it should be sufficient for 2 adults. Along with the salad and deserts we had made at home. Honestly used the on line $19.99 coupon. These 2 pizzas would barely feed 1 adult. They were not more than 10 inches in diameter. That should be called "personal size" or maybe "small" definitely not medium. Yes they could call it a 8 piece pizza. But the pieces can not be more than 3 small size bites. I don't normally take the time to write these reviews. But with difficult times ahead. We are trying to support local businesses. Sorry, but I will not be back. I will say that Salvatore's and even Marks does a better job. At least for me. read more