The pizza is pretty decent, and the lunch special is a good deal. I didn't love the area it was in, but overall id say it's worth a try.

Let me start with the ambiance and service. We walked in and we're immediately greeted by the entire front of house staff. They walked us through the menu, what their favorite toppings were and how their pizza was unique. The front of house man told us the history of the naming of the restaurant, and the why behind the story which was a very unique experience for us. The food was pretty good. It's made to order. We ordered the Bianca with sausage and it was pretty good. Very similar to 5 points pizza. The pizza was very very greasy but it wasn't overwhelmingly garlicky like most biancas. Will definitely return based upon the service alone, however the prices are very very high. Had to lower down to 3 stars because the cheesecake was abysmal. read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

First visit and really great spot for pie and good vibes. Owners are super cool and friendly. Pizza was made to perfection. I will say that if your worried about the portion size or if it will be enough food? Don't... Plenty of fresh ingredients and thoughtfully prepared with pride and skill. It was well worth skipping the usual in the 37206. I will make the trip out to collect this solid pizza made by a team of friends with passion for great food and service. I always appreciate local beer (Bear Walker 16oz) at a local restaurant on small business Saturday. Cheers boys you have a winner in my mind and thank you for being open for us to enjoy a awesome pizza after the turkey marathon... read more

See all

Delicious! This is pretty close to my Platonic ideal of pizza: big slices with enough inner crust stability not to flop over, chewy outer crust, a good amount of cheese, and (per the menu) "thick sliced extra large" pepperoni with hearty flavor. A full pie fed two of us and gave us a lot of leftovers for a second meal. We started with the focaccia served with whipped ricotta, and I'm glad we did because there was a bit of a wait for the pizza -- can't rush perfection! -- and my stomach was getting grumbly watching everyone else dive into their slices. I'd recommend ordering a starter or maybe calling ahead to place an order if you're worried about the wait. Thankfully, they've got a really extensive drinks menu (both alcoholic and non-alcoholic) to keep you occupied. I was especially excited to see several flavors of Austin East Ciders. The space is really cute, and there are several large picnic tables outside on the patio. Looking forward to coming back and trying the garlic knots, Porcetta pie, and cheesecake. read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

Great service, great pizza. Owner gave our boys supplies to make "Go Preds" signs before heading to the Preds game! read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

See all

Used to be the best pizza around but last few orders were pretty bad. The last order had almost no toppings, barely any sauce, & the dough was awful. read more

I just ordered and received the gluten free pizza with vegan pepperoni and it is literally baby size! Nowhere online dies it say that the pizza is ridiculously smaller than their regular pizza all for $40+ for delivery. Very disappointed. read more

The pizza was amazing! It had a thin crispy crust, with traditional or unusual toppings. The pickle pizza is awesome! What a local gem! Service was helpful and friendly: We ate out in the covered patio area. Very nice. read more

Hands down the best pizza you can get in the Nashville area. Service with a smile. My only note is they should change the name to "Olive Garden" because when you're here, you're family. read more

Most of the time the pizza is great. But sometimes the whole pizza comes out undercooked and chewy. They have creative flavors and I love that they sell by the slice. read more

The pizza was good but no indoor dining and 57 dollars for a pizza is ridiculous especially when your sitting outside at a picnic table

This is my neighborhood pizza spot. Mostly slide in for slices. Staff is the best. I love them all. Pizza is in the top pizza spots in Nashville. I know pizza is very personal to many people and everyone has such a vast array of what they "believe" is the best. This (to me) is closely comparable to NY style (my favorite). They have many pies that have crazy ingredients and if that's your thing this place has got to be the most creative when producing "themed" pies... but for myself I just stick to the "gold medal slice" the cheese. Side note: I love the new awning they put over the outdoor seating. Makes the outdoor ambiance much cooler and the vibes are nice. read more

See all

We heard about a pickle pizza and I have been on a pickle kick lately. My partner and I came here to try their Pickle Pizza pie and it was EVERYTHING I wanted. We also got the garlic bread, it was thick sourdough and absolutely drenched in garlic butter (yummmm) and served with fresh grated cheese and basil on top. Everyone was friendly, the inside counter was clean and well stocked with parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, and Italian seasonings. We each got a beer (er, cider and a sour) and enjoyed our time there. I saw another pizza I want to try (the Esmerelda) so we will be back soon! read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pickle Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

See all

The garlic and spinach pizza is one of the best pizzas in all of Nashville. Staff is nice, it's great to have NY style pizza in the area. Pizza is a bit overpriced for the area (probably for the best, if it cost less I would seriously get it three to four times a week). read more

It's so nice to have an elevated spot for food in Madison! The pink aesthetic is super cute, the food is delicious, and everyone who works here is so nice and helpful! They are also vegan/vegetarian friendly, my boyfriend loved the Be-Hive pepperoni. It's definitely on the pricy side for a pizza night, but the quality is worth it! read more

See all

Pizza was amazing! Just like New York City. It is pricey though compared to the national chains.

Wow! This is the best pizza on the planet!!! It's always just perfect. Please don't change a thing.

Best pizza in Nashville! The crust is outstanding! The touch of fresh basil on my pepperoni slice really hit the spot!

$7 for a small peppi slice. Ya'll have to be kidding me. I'm from NY and had high hopes on finally finding a good spot to grab a quick slice. I won't be making a return visit. read more

A fun pizza place located in Madison. Kind of in a spot that you wouldn't expect. Service was fast and the place was cute. Pizza options were totally unusual and delicious. Highly recommend! read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Spicy Pickle Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

See all

For my grandson's 18th birthday we went on an adventure, searching for his favorite slice of pepperoni. We went to three different pizza places and had a slice of pepperoni at each. Congrats Pinky Ring you were the winner for both of us! Great fold, giant delicious pepperoni, one of my favorite pizza crusts ever. Can't what to go back and try the rest! read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

Sourdough pizza! The patience this takes and also the ability to crank out pizzas at a high temp so they get out for everyone to enjoy is a labor of love and I appreciate it. I love that it's legit set up like a pop-in pizza joint. While the wait for a pie took a bit, it's great to see a new business thriving. Great beer selection, pizza by the slice, appetizers and salads as well. There's also decent amount of picnic tables to eat outside also and a stand up bar along the window to eat your slices. We'll be back but damn, the price of pizza have sure come a long way from what you grew up with. O_O read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

Ohhh this place is so good. Walkup or pickup. The hot honey and ranch for their delicious crust. Perfection! I live about 40 min away and I need this place once a week. read more

Visit Nashville to see my son and this place has been on my short list for quite some time and it didn't disappoint. This Madison hot spot has earned a top five spot in my favorite pizza restaurants, and quite possibly my favorite. The crust and sauce are undoubtedly the stars of the show, but the ingredients aren't lacking either. The oven does a perfect job of kissing the crust with the perfect amount of char without the char overpowering the bite. The ingredients play the supporting role perfectly without being loaded, but rather perfectly distributed and amazing quality. We had the supreme pizza and split between 5 people, 2 guys and 3 gals, perfect amount of to be full without stuffed. Sodas are in a can, would have liked a cup of ice to go with it, but didn't ask. Restaurant is minimal with only a few stools inside and majority of seats, picnic tables, outside. The hot summer sun didn't help the experience as it was very warm, so if i had one negative, I would prefer to sit inside. If simply judging the pizza it's absolutely perfect! read more

Grabbed a cheese pie and it was way better than I was expecting considering the reviews. Salads were fresh and the dressing was great. Money well spent, next time we'll try the New Haven! read more

This may be my favorite NY slice in the city. I am guaranteed to pay them another visit!

This was originally my favorite spot to indulge on a delicious slice of vegan pizza. I would come rain, snow or shine but after today that changed. I came in ready to tip and everything. Dude with the curly blonde hair, an absolute prick. He was extremely rude and dismissive. I simply walked out. I will never give them another dime of my money ever again. read more

BEST PIZZA in Nashville! This place is a hidden gem that we found to grab a quick bite before going to a local attraction. We got the Hot Mike's Pizza It was a pepperoni pizza with hot honey. read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

The pizza was great. They have a large selection of pizzas. Their outdoor seating is good and pets are allowed.

I am a bit of a pizza snob because I lived and NYC and know what true NYC style pizza should taste like... I have to say, they got pretty close here!!! We met the owner, Don, very nice and welcoming man as well of the rest of the staff. A really clean and cozy inside and lots of outdoor space available as well. read more

Best pizza in the greater Nashville area, and super friendly staff! I would highly recommend the chicken bacon ranch, however everything I've tried has been great! 10/10 read more

This pizza is fantastic! Adorable spot with a great patio. We also got the garlic bread, which is delicious but A LOT of food. read more

See all

Love the pizza! Great place to sit and enjoy outside. Staff is friendly. Watch out for the "Lunch Special," sounds like you are getting a "free" with 2 slices and save some money; but you are really just paying for a drink at normal prices. Not being able to order slices in advance causes me to wait every single time. I call and I'm told 30 seconds for any slices. Every time I come, I wait 15-20 minutes for new pizzas to be made for slices. read more

Amazing!!! Food & service was great... We will for sure stop again. The garlic bread was out of this world read more

Pinky Ring Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Madison, Tennessee

See all

Yummmmmmmm! Was a perfect day to grab a slice and sit on the patio! Toddler and I just finished having a blast at the library and love how close pinky ring is to stop by for an extra yummy lunch! I've been excited to try the pizza for a while, but honestly I've been more excited for this seasonal veggie caprese! It was excellent! Such delicious fresh mozzarella and zippy squash. But can't forget about the pizza! Excellent chew and crisp crust! We'll be back! read more

See all

Got one with extra cheese with sausage and bacon. Also the Bibb salad. Both were really good. Got some extra sauce for the crust and bingo much better experience. I almost always give places another try especially when they are new. Unless they are just really bad,. That was never the case here. I recommend the extra cheese. read more

Expensive but tasty. I'd go to satisfy the specialty pizza craving. I can say I do love a good pizza so I'll be back!

We stopped by last weekend, and thoroughly enjoyed the experience. Great pizza, friendly staff. And a shout-out for having a couple hard ciders available. The only downsides? We would have liked a little more indoor seating, since it was cool outside. And they are too far from West Nashville to visit regularly. But we'll try. read more

Big floppy delicious NYC style slices of pizza. Unfortunately for those of us who live in Nashville proper ... it's north in Madison and by the time you bring the pizza home it's cold. So eat there! read more

I just ate a pizza here called the rosa pizza. It was literally as if the gods appeared from the vast and empty seas when the pizza box was opened. It was truly a holy experience. read more